Y'all. Backstory: I can't cook. And if I could cook I wouldn't be able to cook seafood. Yesterday was my husband's birthday and he was looking for a frozen seafood boil to have when his 2nd shift job was over for the day. I couldn't let frozen seafood happen on his birthday-he LOVES seafood. Here come's a recommendation for Tiff's Love Butta. Ordered from their website (could've ordered from DD & saved $5 but I'd rather order from a local business directly than give my money to DD). The website was SO easy to use, and setting up delivery was equally as easy. Even better that I was able to pick a time almost 12 hours later in the day so it would be hot & fresh right when he got home. I ordered him the *(1 lb) Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters, 1/2 lb Shrimp, 1/2 lb Sausage, Smothered Potatoes, 1 Corn* and he LOVED it. He only ate half of it before succumbing to a food coma, and then he woke up in the middle of the night to even eat more. I cannot thank y'all enough for making my husband's birthday so special. And y'all have lamb too? He's gonna be so happy, he loves lamb. I can't wait to surprise him again with another beautiful meal from this place. read more

Tiff's Love Butta - (1 lb) Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters, 1/2 lb Shrimp, 1/2 lb Sausage, Smothered Potatoes, 1 Corn - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great spot for some seasoned seafood!! The butter was phenomenal and the shrimp and crab legs were great! read more

Tiff's Love Butta - (1 lb) Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters, 1/2 lb Shrimp, 1/2 lb Sausage, Smothered Potatoes, 1 Corn - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good Lawd this place is ahmazing.. no kidding. Dont cook , let Tiff do it. It's stupid good

Tiff's Love Butta was amazing! The crab cake was my absolute favorite! It had so much flavor. The corn was delicious, and the shrimp and sausage were packed with great taste too. David was awesome and made the whole experience super personal. I'll definitely be back if I'm ever in the area again, and I'll be ordering the butter to have it shipped. It really is THAT good! Such a cool and unique concept. Circle City Eats is nothing like I've seen before. I even spoke with the owner, Tiffany, over the phone, she was super friendly and you can tell she really loves what she does. Highly recommend! read more

Tiff's Love Butta - Was so hungry, I forgot to take pictures of my food! - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

So I found this place on Uber eats. Took a look through the pictures and was intrigued. The reviews commented. I have a surprisingly flavor for the food was. And now it's a bit pricey, but you get your moneys worth. I had the lamb chops with Gooey potatoes and corn, shrimp, and a side of beef sausage, and let me say it was excellent! Food had a ton of flavor, them lamb chops were so soft and tender and juicy!!! The food was well seasoned as well. I'm glad I spoiled myself! read more

Tiff's Love Butta - BIG DEN DEN Love Chop Special (2 Lamb Chops, 6 Shrimp, 2 Scoops Smothered Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg) 1/2 lb beef sausage - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The signature garlic butter is what makes this place special. I won't order the butter on its own for fear what all I'll use it for all the time. It's so good. Tonight was the first time I had the crab cake which was amazing. This is the third time I've been. I have had something different every time and it's been amazing every time. read more

Tiff's Love Butta - 1/2 lb Sausage,Smothered Potatoes, 1 Corn 2 Corns - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This place exceeded our expectations. my husband and I stumbled across it. We ordered the lamb chops and salmon dinner. It was amazing! Smothered corn and potatoes ! Love Butta make you wanna slap ya mama. Chef David introduced himself and treated us like family while giving us some history about the restaurant. My husband and I will definitely be returning Thank you chef David!! read more

Tiff's Love Butta - Salmon , smothered potatoes and corn - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is a carryout or delivery joint only. They do not have a dining room. The best they got is picnic tables out front, but they are not too desirable in the winter. They serve seafood (and some non-seafood) boils that would make the most cajun New Orleanian proud. It is in a shared kitchen building with other chef's. I found this place a little hard to find, but it is in Circle City Eats. The restaurant has a small banner up top on the front of the building, but it is among a bunch of other restaurants banners that occupy the building. There is a adequate sized parking lot where you can park and go in and pick up your food. I was able to place my order online and it was pretty simple. I will admit that it is a bit pricey, but seafood is not cheap. I ordered a lobster boil and a no seafood, sausage boil. All total, it came to around $65. I was ready for pickup at the time I requested. When you go to pick up your food, it is a bit conplicated for a novice such as myself. You are supposed to hold your phone with a code that you were given, up to a tablet on the wall and then it will tell you what locker your food is in. I was having difficulty so the woman that was working then helped me out and just found my food and gave it to me. I was very appreciative, because I would have been there all night. The food tasted as good as it looked. My mom, who had the lobster, kept raving about it and asking when she could go back. I am not a seafood eater, so the sausage was all mine. The sausage, the potatoes, and the corn were delicious. They were perfectly seasoned and full of flavor. I got the pound of sausage and it was more than enough food. I always love the opportunity to support a local restaurant. It is always nice when it has good food. I will definitely be back very soon and highly recommend that you check them out. I guarantee that you will not be disappointed. read more

See all

Our food was easy to pick up! We sat outside and ate the picnic table! Forgot to bring our own snow crab utensils but other than that food was great! read more

Best wings I've ever had! The buffalo sauce flavor wasn't too overwhelming, and the meat was so tender but not overcooked.

If you have not tried Tiff's Love Butta, please stop what you're doing and order right now! You will thank me very soon! I'll wait. Order submitted? Great! Now prepare yourself for a celebration of flavor. An explosion of taste. If you will be enjoying your food with others, get your conversations out of the way now! Because there will not be any conversation after the first bite! Just eating! Lastly, I made the error of agreeing to share some of my food. After tasting my food, I betrayed my promise. There was no way I was sharing anything- not even the egg! Like Lord of the Rings: "It came to me! The Ring is MINE!" Tiff has changed the game! Things will never be the same again! To that end, I need to get going and order more! read more

DELICIOUS ... and the price was comparable to other restaurants with similar cuisine.

Delicious food! This place is take out only. You order at the iPad and wait for it in a small room. Loved the crab legs - I just wish they were a little pre-cracked so that they could marinate in the butter/seasoning and also be easier to open! The shrimp was also amazing. Reasonably priced! Would come back. read more

Overpriced and underwhelming. Aesthetically the food looked amazing but unfortunately I didn't love it. It was just ok. I ordered through Uber eats so my total came out to be about $70 something dollars. I also ordered a large side of the butter and was not impressed. I had high expectations because the place is named after the butter but personally I wasn't a fan. read more

OH MY GOSH!!!! TIFF KNOWS WHAT SHES DOING. Seafood- super fresh. Flavor- outstanding! Seafood, corn, and potatoes all loaded with flavor. Got a side of luv Butta too, Amazing!! We tried crab legs, shrimp, sausage, again all OUTSTANDING! This was such a fun at home date night too!! Will be returning!!! Food was ready on time and the pick up lockers are super accessible. I recommend ordering online and picking up! read more

Oh My..... The food was amazing and we had plenty of it! My grandson just had to have a seafood boil for dinner. So we went out on a search on YELP! After reading the reviews we settled on Tiff's Love Butta. What a great find! We ordered 3 meals to share amongst the 5 of us (Seafood Bake, Shrimp/Salmon, and Lamb) and had plenty left over (lamb. potatoes, and corn). We emptied all the seafood onto the middle of the table and endulfhed until I found the pick up service to be easy enough (a couple of user errors). Chef had to come to my rescue! She was very polite and friendly! The 'cloud' kitchen was clean and convenient! Actually tight across the street from the 10th and Meridian Landmark Bldg. Since this turns out to be my office building... I will be ordering carry out for a Friday dinner! read more

I had heard good things about this restaurant but hadn't tried it. I don't eat seafood boils and only like fried seafood. When I stopped in the very nice young lady at the window took her time to explain everything to me. Since they didn't have fried fish I opted for the tilapia well done (crispy) if possible. The process took a little longer than I was told...But when I tell you it was worth the wait!! I got home my food was still hot. One taste and all I can say is that the person who prepared this food knew the assignment. The fish is simply delicious along with the bed of potatoes and corn. I am kicking myself for not trying this place sooner. I know it's a much better option than fried and it taste darn good. read more

I am so glad we tried this place! My husband and I were on a modified fast with no beef and pork. So he suggested we do a seafood boil. We normally go to one of the major chains, but he was telling me about a new place he wanted to try. He couldn't remember the name of it so I went on a search and immediately pops up Tiff's Love Butta among some other restaurants. It caught my eye because it is keto friendly, low carb, and gluten free. This normally would turn a lot of people away because it can sometimes cut from the flavor, but that was not the case in this situation. We had crab legs, shrimp, turkey sausage, corn, eggs, and potatoes in our meal. The food was marinated in the butter, but not so oversoaked that all you tasted was butter. There was a very good ratio of butter to seasoning. The potatoes were cut smaller and not just in half so you could enjoy the flavor with every bite. We loved the fact that we could choose from pork, beef, or turkey sausage. The portion sizes were great! We had some left over and still managed to get full. My husband had to stop me from eating it because it was so good. You know how sometimes you're full but you keep eating because the food is delicious? That was me last night. By the way this was not the spot my husband was referring to, but he forgot all about the other place once we started eating. He was reluctant to try it at first because he likes to go and dine in, but he tried it since I had been excited about it. When I looked at her website I remember seeing a few features about her in the news and it turns out she also had a recent food feature nomination for food small businesses because of the quality of her food. Sometimes I take pictures of our food, but it had such an enticing aroma that we immediately dug in. By the time we were finished there was little left. That would not be due diligence to this incredible place. There are many other pictures on Yelp that will suffice. I am not a fan of Tilapia, but I look forward to trying it at this place with Tiff's recipe next time. The catfish and lamb seem appetizing from the pictures as well. I hope you try Tiff's Love Butta. You will not be disappointed. read more

We did a pick up order. Very easy and convenient and the food was so flavorful and good! I'll definitely be going back 10/10 read more

Tiff's Love Butta - Salmon, Potatoes, 1 Corn, 1 Egg - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Amazing food. I thought it was a restaurant. The owner was super cool. This is one of the best Crab I have had. So much food. read more

Tiff's Love Butta - Amazing. It was finger licking good. The owner is super nice - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

When we arrived, we were unsure how to navigate the space. We rang the bell and Tiff came to the front and gave us more info regarding the space and her food. We were still unsure how the whole process worked. It took about 30 minutes from the time I placed my order, and had we not gone inside we wouldn't have know that our food was ready and that we needed a code to retrieve it from the locker. I was too hungry to take pics, but my food was really good! I did add my own seasoning once I got home as it needed a little more salt for my taste. Overall I enjoyed my food and now that I know how it works I would return! read more

I've had takeout from here and it is so delicious! I bought the crab cracker kit, but it wasn't needed for the crab legs as they are already cracked. Everything is drenched in Tiff's Love Butta. It is finger licking good!!!!!! read more

See all

Wow! Amazing platter. So I ordered thee Salmon 1/2 shrimp with potatoes and corn. It was really good and the taste was very on point ... I should have ordered more lemon but overall it was really good. My food was ordered through doordash and arrived one hour later and was still hot and tasty. read more

See all

We split this huge order of crab legs and were plenty full. The crab.....the butta....the potatoes! Drool! So so good. We will be back soon. At this price, not something we can eat every weekend but worth every penny for our landlocked state we live in. Thanks Tiff the sticker didn't lie. read more

Tiff's Love Butta - Packaginf - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

If you love your seafood baked, this is the place to go. I had ordered a small portion just to try it and boy did I make a mistake. I needed more as soon as I was finished. It was so good and especially when you get some of that extra butta. Baby let me tell you, it's the truth. My mouth is watering just thinking about it. The eggs that I had with my crab legs was sealed with flavor and wasn't all hard or soggy. It was easy to tear into those legs and eat Roth up. It was nice that there is an option to order yourself a cracking kit. I was at work on my lunch and was needing those tools. Bottom line is, stop stalling and go get you some of her food! read more

Talk about passion. My wife and I ordered a boil for ourselves (we love the concept, but we've got a 9 month old and can't get out much, so this option is perfect for us.) Tiffany puts a lot of care and love into her food. The quality is great, the price is right, and if you're in the downtown Indy area, the location is super convenient. All of the seafood was cooked well, and plentiful. The sides (potatoes, boiled eggs, sausage, and corn) were also very well done and complimented the star dishes well. Our suggestion is to get extra seasoning and extra Love Butta because both are VERY good, and you'll wish you had more. We will be back. read more

I was craving seafood today. And I immediately had to call Tiffs love Butta for a side of snow crab legs. I always love the platters that I get with either salmon or crab legs. I was so glad that I can just order crab legs to get my seafood fix. Order whatever you like from the menu. I promise it will be delicious!!! read more

Tiff's Love Butta - A side of delicious crab legs!! - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Tiff's Love Butta is liquid gold. We tried the shrimp and crab and both were delicious. I love that our food was cooked to order. Everything was full of flavor and cooked to perfection. I can't wait to try it again. read more

Tiff's Love Butta - 1Lb Love Butta Baked Snow Crab Clusters, 1/2 lb Delicious Love Butta Baked Shrimp, w/ Potatoes, Corn, and Boiled Egg. - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

the food and service is the best Ive from a online seafood place the butter I can kill for

The food was amazing!!!! Well seasoned and hot!... customer service was very helpful. I would recommend this this place to anybody any day of the week!!!! 5 stars!!!! read more

The food is SOOOOOO good yall. Just trust me. Ordered on the website and food was ready within 20 mins. Nice and hot by the time i got it back home. Amazing portions and real seafood boil in Indy?? Sign me up! Appreciate you so much! read more

Food tasted amazing, just wish prices were a little lower but doesn't take away from the taste.

Yummy yummy in my tummy! Food was awesome! I can't wait to come back! Service was great!

Wonderful food and she even splits the legs. The potatoes are outrageously delicious... it is a must!

Omg! Heaven on a plate! You have to try this place! Its fabulous seafood and more served with an incredible garlic butter sauce. She even sells the butter!! I had the crab boil complete with a generous portion of potatoes corn on the cob and hard boiled egg for $22! You pick it up to go which is a win-win!! Reasonable prices for what you get! Been twice! One of a kind for Indy! Definitely a repeat customer! read more

I just had Tiff's Love Butta today for the first time and I must say I was blown away.. I had the 1lb crab leg with the potatoes, egg,sausage and it was delicious. It was a tad bit salty but the flavor was amazing. This will be my new go to spot frequently. Def a must try! The service was quick and I received my delivery order earlier than expected. read more

Amazing taste and flavor! Would 10 out of 10 recommend giving Tiff's Love Butta a try for all your seafood feast needs!

What a great find!!! My wife wanted seafood but we had been working in the yard and she didn't want to get fixed up. I had recently read an article about a new test kitchen in Indy and Tiff's Luv Butta was one of the focus restaurants. This is a great find. We brought our own bottle of white wine to partner with the snow crab legs, shrimp and sausage. The side of luv potatoes and corn on the cob where also amazing. Just good food. They do have two picnic tables out front for those who don't want to wait to get home to eat. read more

It was ok. Food needed a little more seasoning. Other than that it was good................

Food was so rich and delicious, crab and shrimp were excellent. Will definitely be going back and getting more of that butta. read more

Tiff's Love Butta - 1/2 lb Snow Crab Cluster 8oz Lobster Tail , 1/2 lb Shrimp, Potatoes and 1 corn - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana