Back in the day this spot was a music store, not like Area Records where CDs, tapes, vinyl were sold, but instruments. Not even sure when they closed to be honest. Kind of sad to see it gone after seeing it my entire life. There is a bakery there now. It's basically strictly...order and pick it up type of place. They sell cookies and other pastries at the front. It's a "help yourself" and you scan a QR code to pay. So! Ok, I do love the new technology where you can eat out and scan a QR code and pay that way. Or using a QR code for so many other things. I don't however like this set up. I think it's really weird. Cash is also an option here. I wanted to originally pay cash. I got 2 cookies and a brownie. Says "ring bell if you need change" I press the little button 3x and I can see people in the back. Not one person came out after I hit the button. That's booooo! It's like, why have it if you're going to ignore it?! Just close the doors to the public and have it strictly as an online business. I love love trying bakeries like this vs buying anything store bought. When I'm home, I look for places like this, Amish farms, Mennonite farms..any place that sells fresh baked cookies. In Idaho we don't have many great bakeries and if they are around...they are miles away and driving in Boise traffic these days is SO NOT worth the hassle for a cookie lol Also, if really don't eat many cookies and stuff but shoooot when I'm here in NY visiting and I'm close to Amish and Mennonite farms where they make INCREDIBLE baked goods...I definitely indulge lol. The cookies here and brownies were... ya know, good, but would I write home to mama about them? Nah. Hell, I'm staying at my moms and I didn't even tell her about them after I ate them. The cookies were pipe $2 a piece, I think, small brownie was $3. Honestly, cookies should be .75 and brownies... $1.00 There was really no variation in tastes between the two. They use something in their baked goods that made each one taste exactly the same...except you obviously could taste the chocolate on top of whatever they use, in the brownie. Would I recommend? I mean, maybe? If someone asked, I'd be like "there's a bakery in downtown Geneva, buuuut..." and then shrug my shoulders and give that crooked mouth look like... meh Now, maybe their cakes and whatever else they make are bomb af. I'll never know bc 1) I won't be going back lol and 2) I don't see myself ever buying a cake. Again, I see bakeries like this, it's a small business, I love supporting small businesses especially in a town where I grew up, went to high school in, etc...I see them and have to try. I tried it and now... I'm good: I can't say anything about the staff, because they ignored me lol, the place is small, it's clean. It's a bakery haha! Thanks for reading. Cheers, YelperSweets! read more

See all

Amazing cakes & super accommodating. We got the Chocolate Chocolate cake and it was smooth, rich, & not too sweet. I'm not a big cake gal but I would love to get that cake again. read more

Simple Sweets Bakery - Chocolate Chocolate cake - Desserts Near Me - Geneva, New York

Simple Sweets Bakery is located on Castle St in Geneva, NY. They have a wonderful display of sweets. We ordered two cronuts that was delivered by Amazing Grains to the bakery. They have some items that are baked on site and some items from local vendors. The cronuts were great. We put them in the oven for a little bit to warm them up and it was very soft. I also ordered an Iced chai tea for $3.50. For me, it was too much chai and wasn't a good balance. read more

See all

Some nice gluten-free offerings on this lovely little bakery. Nice drink specials as well.

Very clean good variety reasonable priced great service Friendly and attentive to request read more

Stopped in just before closing time for an afternoon treat. Greeted in a friendly manner. Got a chocolate peanut butter brownie and a banana chocolate chip bread pudding. Also picked up a coconut cream pie to take home. The brownie was really good, had a hint of cinnamon and not over baked. The bread pudding was balanced and just the right level of not being too sweet. The pie was super creamy and flavorful. We are still enjoying it! read more

Delish! I got all mini vanilla cake and it was so fresh and full of vanilla flavor. The cute tea selection was also a nice touch. Staff was super sweet. Will be back! read more

Marina and Rosana are amazing! Brownies, cookies, wedding cake! Gluten free, dairy free, vegan options all delicious! They will work with you on every part of what you may need. Definitely 100% best bakery experience! My guests absolutely loved the our cake and cookie selection. read more

Simple Sweets Bakery - Dessert spread: cake! Blackberry thumbprints, vegan chocolate crinkles, macarons, and vegan snickerdoodles - Desserts Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

This is an adorable little bakery that my fiancée and I found after having lunch with a friend. Their baked goods are quality and their servings are large. I also must say, they're pretty inexpensive for what you get, which is always a huge plus. When we arrived, we were offered free samples of their protein brownie, which was so good that I had to get one. Protein baked goods, I personally find to often be big misses so to find one that was this delicious was revolutionary to me. Beyond that, my fiancée and I both got tiramisu and flavored lattes and our friend ordered a large hot chocolate, a cronut (croissant doughnut) and some cookies for later. Our total came to only about $30 for all of us. The lattes were really delicious and although I couldn't taste the peppermint in mine (which I've been finding happens often recently, some places do it better than others) the latte itself was so good that I didn't mind the lack of the added flavor. The lattes were also really good sizes and I feel like I could have opted for a small next time. The tiramisu was nice and light while delicately balanced with slight espresso flavor. The cake was moist and soft which was a perfect compliment to the fluffy cloud of mascarpone. Our friend's hot chocolate was, again, enormous almost to the point of being comically large. She ended up really enjoying it, but taking most of it in a to-go cup. We all tried a bit of her cronut as well because it's been a long time since I'd had one and neither of them had ever had it. It was so yummy! It reminded me a lot of fried dough taste wise, but way better. The outside was a little crispy, almost like a churro, but the inside was layered like a flaky croissant. Whatever it reminded me of, it was extremely good and I'm totally getting it next time I'm there! Overall, this is a great little cafe to sit down with the company of friends and have a nice treat and a chat. The baked goods are delicious, largely portioned, and a great value. I'd highly recommend checking this place out. read more

Personally one of my favorite cafes in Geneva, they have amazing sweets, and decent lunch, the lady that is always there (i'm assuming she is the owner) is such a sweet lady and always makes you feel so welcome :) read more

I had the chicken pesto sandwich and Mac salad. It was delicious. If you're looking for a quick and tasty lunch this is a great spot.

Baked goods were Ok, but poor customer service made this an unpleasant experience. We were disappointed.

Amazing service, EXTREMELY FRIENDLY service and spotless interior. good coffee and delicious vegan and non vegan desserts. always a gluten free option! good prices and nice variety of treats homemade. definately will be returning! read more

Had lunch from Simple Sweets that included 3 small sandwiches cut in perfect proportions and no crust (cucumber, egg salad and pesto turkey) along with a piece of ham/cheddar quiche. So delicious and the perfect size and packaged to take with me. Highly recommend! (Also, the Tiramisu is scrumptious!). read more

We're using Simple Sweets for our wedding welcome reception! 25 dozen macaroons for a very reasonable price. Macaroons pictured for our tasting will have colors etc for actual event. Really delish! read more

Simple Sweets Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

I had an event, and spent at least 200 plus dollars. The cake was very dry! The cookies were not even cooked all the way. It was a very poor experience especially when giving over 2 months notice. The cookies were also very small.. I would not recommend wasting your money here. read more

I bought a dozen cupcakes and they have the best frosting I have ever had. The cupcakes were a HUGE hit

This place is amazing! The owner really knows what she's doing. She makes incredible cookies, cakes, brownies, etc. If you ever have a question about anything, just ask and she knows what she's talking about. Some of the things she does may seem crazy but she does all the pro tricks and the results are insanely good. You can take her cookies onto the plane. Get it read more