Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Peppys Ice Cream

    4.5 (8 reviews)
    Closed 4:00 pm - 8:00 PM
    Updated 1 month ago

    Peppys Ice Cream Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Peppys Ice Cream

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Delicious twist. The small was huge; $4.50. The chocolate and vanilla were so flavorful, authentic, and creamy.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    I enjoyed my experience there - I ate lunch the first time and am planning on going back for ice cream tomorrow!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Marla C.
    178
    33
    49

    11 years ago

    this place has the creamiest, best tasting soft serve around! and they have crunch coat- the best topping ever!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Peppys Ice Cream

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 214 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Byrne Dairy Stores - Sign she decided to write rudely and stick in the window

    Byrne Dairy Stores

    2.9(8 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    Went to the store about 11:30 pm on 10/13/23. Young man at the front counter greeted me, I said how…read moreya doing. Walked over to the deli counter. Young lady was standing there writing something with her head down so I just waited. Without even looking up she slams her finger on the glass abd screamed "closed". I said but it's 24hours, she said well this one is closed slamming her finger on the glass again. I looked confused and said I'll just call corporate and see they have to say about the way you talk to customers. I left the store, I was out front looking up the number of email address.the young lady looked at me through the window, then decided to write a sign in pen saying "deli closed" and hangs it in the window. The fact that the deli might have been closed wasn't a big deal, but there's a way to explain that to customers without being extra rude.

    Great milk barn and gas in Waterloo NY…read more Byrne Dairy has almost anything you could want: yoghurt, milk, beer, sandwiches, nuts, cold cuts, scones, sweets, chips, lottery, candy bars, soda, drinks, coffee stations, juice, smokes and all else.. Byrne is half dairy stop and half gas station. They sell firewood, wind shield fluid and bottled water (for hots days) and outdoor items, umbrellas, freezer food, smoothies, energy drinks and tea. Super easy-going local chain. Clean, well-lit, happy colorful place to stretch your legs and get some snacks. 'Larysa' below complained about long lines: maybe it was your time of day. When I came, there were multiple cashiers, some even helping the elderly find items. Awesome ice cream flavors. All around great place for young and old! Review: 5+

    Connie's Diner - Wow!!

    Connie's Diner

    4.2(219 reviews)
    4.5 mi
    $$

    True Northern Hospitality! A warm welcome, "What can I get for you, Sugar" attitude…read more It's one of the most welcoming restaurants I've ever been to. The older woman who took care of us gave us the service you would expect from going to grandmas house. It was wonderful, I miss it! The food was what you would expect. Typical diner food, but with a home cooked feel. I remember getting pancakes and bacon. It taste like home.

    Pulling up to this diner, was like wow, really, I picked this place. But what a unique find…read more The inside has typical Diner flaire with booth seating and table as well as counter. The place was busy and when a table is available, you seat yourself. Service was very friendly and attentive. Reason for 4th star. Worth stopping when in the area and will return, next trip to the outlets. Just no lemonade or turkey dinner! Private parking, large lot. Milk shakes oh my. Unique menu, with interesting toppings. Vanilla milk shake was excellent. Stay away from their lemonade. Very disappointed. Pepsi machine and tasted poorly. TURKEY DINNER WAS JUST OK. SIDE Salad came with the dinner. Very fresh. Next trip getting their Julienne Salad. Looked amazing. Roast Turkey Dinner - Just like Thanksgiving, Not! Oven roasted turkey breast with our homemade stuffing (don't think it was) & gravy (so, so) over it all. Served with cranberry sauce 15.99. French Fries were very good. Fried Clams - Deep fried to perfection, on a bed of lettuce served with our cocktail or tartar sauce 16.9 Was large and very good. Chicken Caesar Salad - Chilled romaine tossed with caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, croutons and topped with grilled chicken 13.99 Was extra yummy.

    Photos
    Connie's Diner - Elvis corner

    Elvis corner

    Connie's Diner - Milkshake menu

    Milkshake menu

    Connie's Diner - Sign

    See all

    Sign

    Long Pier Ice Cream & Rentals

    Long Pier Ice Cream & Rentals

    3.2(25 reviews)
    2.4 mi
    $$

    The service was friendly But the wine ice cream didn't…read moretaste good The peach was very grainy and the raspberry didn't have much of a taste at all

    Ok! Where to begin here. Obviously the Finger Lakes is a…read moremajor tourist attraction in central New York. One lake is particular is Seneca Lake. How do I know that? Well, 1) if you've seen the area you know why lol and 2) I grew up in Geneva. Recently, I went home for a month. Got back July 9th. So not that long ago from the time I wrote this review. My friends from high school and I all got together a couple days before I left back for Idaho. I've known these girls for 30-35 years. So time with them is very special to me. My one friend has a boat. So our last outing before my holiday ended was...on her boat. We were out for a few hours and picked up her daughter and another friend at the long pier on Seneca Lake. It's a beautiful pier which means...lots of people flock there especially during summer months. We had been out for a few hours (as mentioned) and we wanted something to eat. There is an ice cream place right there at the entrance of the pier and it's called...Long Pier Ice Cream! I was pretty stoked to get ice cream bc we had been tubing and swimming and I was hungry, but didn't want full on dinner bc we were going back out. There were 8 of us on the boat. We all got ice cream. The place, again RIGHT on the pier, was obviously busy bc hello! Summer! It was legit 90° that day and humid. Naturally an ice cream stand would be busy and a great place to stop at. Which brings me to the staff. For the most part they were friendly. However, there was one girl and of course I didn't get names UGH! I think anyone on the staff will know EXACTLY who I'm talking about bc I guarantee this isn't her first time being an absolute ray of sunshine (insert sarcasm) She had long dark hair, glasses, short, and speaking of short, she was VERY short with every customer. EVERY! one. of. them. Now I ordered a "medium chocolate in a dish with rainbow sprinkles" It's the same thing I order at all these ice cream places. With THEEEE biggest attitude and taking snotty to another level, she lets out this lonnnng sigh and says "we DON'T HAVE medium! We have either regular! or large!" Followed by a semi-eye roll and another sigh. If y'all could have seen the look of shock and confusion on my face lol...bc I asked a simple question. To myself, I thought..weird and why is she being SO rude? So I asked, ok so what's the difference between the regular and the large? Again with the long siiiiiiiiiigh! "Ugh regular has like 6-7 swirls and a large ugh had 8-9!" I mean, if I could record how she was to me, it'd be better lol. Seriously, this girl HATES her job. So I ordered the regular. Now tell me this...WHYYYY would you EVER want to work at an ice cream shop ON. THE. LAKE! in the middle of summer, on a hot ass day like July 6th 2024! And have THEEE worst attitude to not just me! But to literally everyone I was with and everyone else in line. I watched her treat everyone with this unbelievable amount of disrespect. So again, WHY?! work at THAT particular ice cream or any for that matter...when you KNOW the place will always be busy? If you cannot handle a simple question as "what's the difference between a regular and a large?" then MAYBE...JUST....MAYBE! you should NOT be working with the public and ESPECIALLY with the public...at....you guessed it..:an ice cream shop..on a lake..in the middle of summer on one of the hottest days! Everyone in my party all had the same reaction to this girl and her sorry attitude. Now don't get me wrong, if any of us were being rude, I would gladly admit that or even better...I just wouldn't write a review. I do not like writing bad reviews for businesses UNLESS it is absolutely warranted. You can check my reviews to make sure. I take my reviews very seriously and write them exactly how my experience was. I know Google and Yelp can be abused by people, so I genuinely strive to NOT be one of those people who abuse the review game. So with my experience with her, this is why I am writing exactly it as I, as WE! ... experienced our time at your store. To top it off, the prices were..meh. I took into consideration tho that where we were and hello, it's NY. Things are just more expensive there. The prices were not even my concern tbh. It's just suggested on here we add info on prices. The ice cream is good enough. I come home often. I will always think before returning to this place. The ice cream is very tasty, that's what sucks haha! Like, if I'm on the lake and want ice cream...it's the only place. Not sure if this girl will always be there, but GOOD. LAWDY! Let's hope not because it's a very poor look on what is a good business and its location is brilliant. Right at the pier, next to a big ass hotel, next to a playground. Whoever decided this location has a bit of genius in them. However, they need to use that genius when hiring friendlier staff. Thanks, Yelperscoopers!!! Cheers!

    Photos
    Long Pier Ice Cream & Rentals
    Long Pier Ice Cream & Rentals - Store front

    Store front

    Long Pier Ice Cream & Rentals - Great selection

    See all

    Great selection

    Peppys Ice Cream - icecream - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...