Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Peppys Ice Cream

    4.5 (10 reviews)
    Open • 4:00 pm - 8:00 PM

    Peppys Ice Cream Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Peppys Ice Cream

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Erica O.

    Nice outdoor ice cream stand with lots of shady areas to sit. The service was very good. They serve Hershey's ice cream and soft serve. My friend got the Twix Flurry special and I got the Blueberry Sundae special. She said the Flurry was excellent and my Blueberry Sundae was very good. I didn't care for the pieces of waffle cone in the layers, but everything else was great. The blueberry cheesecake ice cream, blueberry topping, whipped cream and fresh blueberries on top.

    Tropical orange soft serve
    Cassie C.

    I grabbed a cup of soft serve with friends. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The ice cream itself was tasty. I just wish there had been a sign that clearly stated they only accepted cash. Thankfully I scrounged up a few bucks!

    Front Entrance

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Delicious twist. The small was huge; $4.50. The chocolate and vanilla were so flavorful, authentic, and creamy.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    I enjoyed my experience there - I ate lunch the first time and am planning on going back for ice cream tomorrow!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Marla C.
    178
    33
    49

    11 years ago

    this place has the creamiest, best tasting soft serve around! and they have crunch coat- the best topping ever!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Peppys Ice Cream

    Review Highlights - Peppys Ice Cream

    “Good ice cream although it doesn't look like they make their own hard ice cream, there is a Hershey's sign.”

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 237 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Byrne Dairy Stores - Sign she decided to write rudely and stick in the window

    Byrne Dairy Stores

    2.9(8 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    •$$

    Went to the store about 11:30 pm on 10/13/23. Young man at the front counter greeted me, I said how…read moreya doing. Walked over to the deli counter. Young lady was standing there writing something with her head down so I just waited. Without even looking up she slams her finger on the glass abd screamed "closed". I said but it's 24hours, she said well this one is closed slamming her finger on the glass again. I looked confused and said I'll just call corporate and see they have to say about the way you talk to customers. I left the store, I was out front looking up the number of email address.the young lady looked at me through the window, then decided to write a sign in pen saying "deli closed" and hangs it in the window. The fact that the deli might have been closed wasn't a big deal, but there's a way to explain that to customers without being extra rude.

    Great milk barn and gas in Waterloo NY…read more Byrne Dairy has almost anything you could want: yoghurt, milk, beer, sandwiches, nuts, cold cuts, scones, sweets, chips, lottery, candy bars, soda, drinks, coffee stations, juice, smokes and all else.. Byrne is half dairy stop and half gas station. They sell firewood, wind shield fluid and bottled water (for hots days) and outdoor items, umbrellas, freezer food, smoothies, energy drinks and tea. Super easy-going local chain. Clean, well-lit, happy colorful place to stretch your legs and get some snacks. 'Larysa' below complained about long lines: maybe it was your time of day. When I came, there were multiple cashiers, some even helping the elderly find items. Awesome ice cream flavors. All around great place for young and old! Review: 5+

    Mr Twistee's - FIVE dollars for a small with sprinkles. I hate that I paid 5 for a small ice cream

    Mr Twistee's

    3.6(28 reviews)
    3.8 mi
    •$$$

    Sunday night final dessert while in FLX. Our dinner place didn't have much by way for dessert so I…read morewas able to snipe this places right around the corner. Reminds me of any other drive-in, small town ice cream stand - but this one had a drive-thru which was packed. The walk up was packed too. You know an ice cream place is good if the front lights are yellow. Ambiance of a small town place where locals entertain tourists like a melting pot. I ordered a chocolate shake. It was very good and flavorful.

    Ok, so I grew up on this place. It was the only pace to go when we were kids. Summers during high…read moreschool, we always went here for the amazing ice cream and always played mini golf there. They had the best miniature golf course. That's gone. And honestly, the magic of Twistees is as well. The took out the miniature golf course and put in a stupid playground that I legit have never seen any kids playing on. Not sure what happened to this place. I'm just assuming some lame a$$ bought it and changed everything fun about it. There used to be a small arcade too. Not sure if that's there, but pretty sure....it is not. Even tho arcade games have been replaced by the games that we have today... TRUST if the arcade was still there...it would absolutely still be used. Sure there was probably a period where it just sat, but I see arcades a lot more these days and people who actually love going to them. It's a connection to their past and their kids love them too. The ice cream is good but gotdayuuuum! Their prices are insane! I get things get more expensive over time but come on, what they charge for a small and what you actually get (in a dish) is absurd. Makes me very sad. I can honestly say, after this last visit that...that was probably my last visit to Twistees. I'll go again if my friends from high school wanna go when I'm back visiting bc we went all the time back in the day. Aside from that tho, yeah, pass. Most ice cream places are pricey, but it's sad to see how expensive Twistees is and the tiny portions you get for what they charge. Oh, I asked for rainbow sprinkles too. Been getting that ever since I was a tiny kid. She said "small chocolate with rainbow sprinkles!" They were red and green sprinkles. Christmas. Nothing rainbow about them. I didn't grab it bc it clearly was different than what I ordered. I know, small thing to complain about but it was weird. Then she shook the ice cream toward me and said ..: "small chocolate, rainbow sprinkles!" I said...those are rainbow? Looks like Christmas to me" Even the guy next to me was like...you know that's not rainbow, right? No response from her lol. Overall they are nice there but that was weird. Long Pier is pricey too, but they give you the portions you'd expect and the ice cream tastes better to me. That's the other one in Geneva that's not far far from Twistees. Anyway, people will always go here bc it's Twistees is a local legend, place is iconic, it's a Geneva staple. I just know a lot who skip over and go elsewhere. I'd never want it to close bc that would be a huge part of my childhood.. gone, but ugh at least bring back the miniature golf course!! Bring back some of the magic that made Twistees magical! Thanks, YelpeeTwistee'er's? If you go, enjoy! Ice cream is still ice cream and I love ice cream haha. Cheers!

    Photos
    Mr Twistee's - This used to be a miniature golf course. They should bring that back. I didn't even check to see if they still have the arcade...

    This used to be a miniature golf course. They should bring that back. I didn't even check to see if they still have the arcade...

    Mr Twistee's
    Mr Twistee's

    See all

    Sweet Acres Creamery

    Sweet Acres Creamery

    4.9(7 reviews)
    4.8 mi

    So I was headed to Buffalo by car from NYC and while visiting a rest area I noticed this pink…read moredrink, it was strawberry milk. I was like that's kinda odd, strawberry and chocolate milk in a stand alone fridge? I ended up buying the strawberry milk and Holy Moses, this was the easily the best strawberry milk I ever had. I also noticed it was pretty expensive, it was a small container for around $4.50 but I bought it anyway and wow was it worth a buy. It was so good, it was so good it actually made me make my way to their actual farm and take god their milk was cheaper at the farm. I also asked since I noticed the employees were wearing very distinct clothing if they were Amish? The employee said it was similar but they were Mennonites. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA&select=FJpVePPXalf0iGdM0UXSng The food: Strawberry Milk- This is a must get item. It was $5.75 for a half gallon. I loved the strawberry flavor of the milk and I love the creamy texture of the milk. Chocolate Milk- I think this was a great chocolate milk but not as distinctive as the strawberry milk. Strawberry Ice Cream- This very similar to the strawberry milk, but not as rich a creamy as the milk. I enjoyed this but the milk is my favorite item.

    Another lunch stop when I was out and about. I love the fall vibe when visiting. I ordered the…read moregrilled chicken panini and pumpkin spice latte. Unfortunately my visit wasn't as super as it has been in the past. My coffee cup's lid didn't fit, and my panini was soaked in whatever sauce they used so it was very soggy and messy. I don't think it deters me from visiting again, it was just a different experience this time.

    Photos
    Sweet Acres Creamery
    Sweet Acres Creamery
    Sweet Acres Creamery

    See all

    Connie's Diner - Summer salad with grilled chicken

    Connie's Diner

    4.2(225 reviews)
    4.5 mi
    •$$

    Pulling up to this diner, was like wow, really, I picked this place. But what a unique find…read more The inside has typical Diner flaire with booth seating and table as well as counter. The place was busy and when a table is available, you seat yourself. Service was very friendly and attentive. Reason for 4th star. Worth stopping when in the area and will return, next trip to the outlets. Just no lemonade or turkey dinner! Private parking, large lot. Milk shakes oh my. Unique menu, with interesting toppings. Vanilla milk shake was excellent. Stay away from their lemonade. Very disappointed. Pepsi machine and tasted poorly. TURKEY DINNER WAS JUST OK. SIDE Salad came with the dinner. Very fresh. Next trip getting their Julienne Salad. Looked amazing. Roast Turkey Dinner - Just like Thanksgiving, Not! Oven roasted turkey breast with our homemade stuffing (don't think it was) & gravy (so, so) over it all. Served with cranberry sauce 15.99. French Fries were very good. Fried Clams - Deep fried to perfection, on a bed of lettuce served with our cocktail or tartar sauce 16.9 Was large and very good. Chicken Caesar Salad - Chilled romaine tossed with caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, croutons and topped with grilled chicken 13.99 Was extra yummy.

    Service was quick and attentive. I had the hot turkey…read moresandwich with fries and it was delicious My friend had pancakes which are huge. Always friendly and busy diner with a 50's twist.

    Photos
    Connie's Diner - Elvis corner

    Elvis corner

    Connie's Diner - Wow!!

    Wow!!

    Connie's Diner - Sign

    See all

    Sign

    Ports Cafe - Ricotta gnocchi with ragout sauce and short ribs

    Ports Cafe

    4.3(474 reviews)
    5.1 mi
    •$$$

    We booked here because of the view of the lake. That was a misnomer, as there is a road and a…read morerailway line between the restaurant and the lake. However- the food was AMAZING!! I'll remember this experience for a long time.

    Came by for our anniversary dinner, overall had an OK experience but we'd had huge expectations for…read morethe place - which fell a bit flat somewhat. Let me start off with the positives: 1. The staff are excellent, we had a server who was super charming and checked in on us all evening. Easy process to book a table, helpful people all around. 2.The place itself is snazzy and upscale, but not excessively so; we enjoyed dressing up a bit for a nice dinner there, but didn't feel like the vibe was overly stuffy or anything. 3. The appetizer we split (mussels in a slightly spicy broth with focaccia on the side) was excellent. Easily the highlight of our meal, would order it again in a heartbeat. The downside, unfortunately, is that the main part of our meal was nothing to write home about. I'd found this spot online and booked a table for two specifically to really "wow" my wife and enjoy an excellent meal together, and was really looking forward to some good food after reading all the stellar reviews here on Yelp. It certainly has high-end prices for the FLX (spent over $250 for dinner for two, without a dessert or more than a glass of wine each), which in general I'm happy to pay - if the quality is there, that is. But our entrees were just unimpressive, and actually slow to arrive. Took them a solid 40-45 minutes to bring out our mains afterwe finished the appetizers, but worse was the fact that both dishes (rack of lamb for myself, and short rib gnocchi for her) were simply bland. Best part of my dish were the mashed potatoes honestly - the lamb itself was unseasoned, and the sauce was watery. My wife's gnocchi weren't terrible, but the sauce had an odd, almost burnt aftertaste that neither of us cared for. For a regular restaurant, with more regular prices and reviews, we wouldn't have minded honestly - but because this place is kinda marketed as one of the better restaurants in Geneva, and priced as such, having a bit of a mediocre meal left us fairly disappointed. Again, great service and fun spot just to be in, and _some_ of the items like the appetizers are pretty tasty (I'd happily come back for another taste of their mussels and focaccia). But we likely won't be coming back anytime soon, particularly as we live out of town. Hope it was just a fluke and that they bounce back.

    Photos
    Ports Cafe - Inside ports the front and bar

    Inside ports the front and bar

    Ports Cafe - Halibut with bucatini and foccacia

    Halibut with bucatini and foccacia

    Ports Cafe - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Peppys Ice Cream - icecream - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...