Sunday night final dessert while in FLX. Our dinner place didn't have much by way for dessert so I was able to snipe this places right around the corner. Reminds me of any other drive-in, small town ice cream stand - but this one had a drive-thru which was packed. The walk up was packed too. You know an ice cream place is good if the front lights are yellow. Ambiance of a small town place where locals entertain tourists like a melting pot. I ordered a chocolate shake. It was very good and flavorful. read more

Mr Twistee's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

I went there for the first time after moving to town. They have a large selection of ice cream, shakes, sundaes and toppings. I got their sampler pack with four flavors. Their menu features a lot of different flavors. The flavors were interesting because they aren't the general flavors you would get from a store. The staff were absolutely superb as well. I will definitely will return once the weather gets warmer. read more

Mr Twistee's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

I came here to get some Dole whip and to my surprise they had gluten free waffles cones! Not a lot of places have gluten free cones so that was nice. All of the food is labeled really well for anyone who has dietary restrictions. My server was nice and I enjoyed the seating area; I wasn't expecting there to be arcade games and a playground! read more

Mr Twistee's - Pineapple and strawberry dole whip cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

See all

This was the worst ice cream cone I've ever had! I ordered a medium cone with cherry dip top. I asked the worker to put it upside down into a cup. She gave me a medium size paper cup and the ice cream barely came to the middle of it. There was about 1/2 cup of ice cream. Inside the cup, the dip top was all liquid and nothing stuck to the ice cream. It's suppose to harden into a shell. The ice cream was really melted, almost liquid. My sister got the same thing in a small and barely got a kiddie serving. The cost was over $11. I can do better getting ice cream from a grocery store. What a disapointment! read more

I was just looking for a quick hit of soft serve ice cream while in Geneva and stopped by Mr. Twistees. The person in front of us got their cone which looked too much so i asked "what size is that?" "This is literally a small" read more

Mr Twistee's - (small) soft serve bavarian vanilla on a wafer cone with crunch coat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

An absolute essential in Geneva. A drive through, play ground and plenty of rotating flavors. It's open seasonally as many ice cream stands in the area are. They do take credit cards which is nice for a small operation. I really appreciate that they have many flavors of dole whip for my daughter who is allergic to eggs. My older daughter loves their dip cones with candy eyes. A wonderful spot for a local or anyone looking for a a little taste of nostalgia. read more

Closed. Seasonal I am sure. But they should update their hours. We went because the hours said open till 10a. This place rolls its sidewalks up by 7. And off season even earlier. This is just an example. read more

This was a super delicious ice cream cone on a warm day. I got the blueberry cheesecake yogurt which was a very good hard serve yogurt. It was full of large cheesecake chunks and in true small town ice cream shoppes, the sizes are huge for what you pay! read more

Mr Twistee's - Blueberry Cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

This place has so many options! Great for the whole family. They even have a drive through. There's a playground for the little ones. Very tasty read more

Terrific drive thru ice cream spot! We got a dipped cone, a butterfinger flurry, and a puppy sundae. Lots of outdoor seating, too. Special flavors every day for Dole Whip, Frostline, and other specialty brands. We're here on vacation and wish there was a Mr Twistee's at home! read more

Mr. Twistee's lost a very loyal customer today. Literally, every year during their open season I am there almost every week to have some of their new frostlines. The older lady, I believe the owner was so rude to my grandmother for absolutely no reason. She talked to her with such disgust that it really took everything in me to smile and say "that's okay" so as not to ruin the day we were having. I will never go there again. Such a sadness and disappointment. read more

First time here and I absolutely love it. Definitely coming back soon. The workers were very friendly and the ice cream was delicious

Lots of "options" however most of the flavors are watery and more like popcicles than ice cream. For a similar price you can drive 25 min west to the Cheshire Creamery and get rich, thick ice cream. read more

On a nice day this is the place to get your ice cream. Our favorite is the oatmeal but it isn't served daily. However there are other options like black raspberry or black cherry. You get a good amount of ice cream in either a cone or dish. I get the dish because I feel I would drop the ice cream out of the cone. They do have outdoor seating but not being used because of covid; everyone eats in there cars or takes it to go. read more

AMAZING MENU!! Such great options as well as the service ! The brownie batter ice cream was great and they have so many dips !

Mr. Twistee's is the best local ice cream spot in Geneva. They have great hard and soft ice cream, and feature several special favors all the time. My favorite is the hard scoop "outrageous oatmeal cookie" flavor. Order a kiddie cone, and get a special ice cream cone with sugar disks to look like eyes. It's nice when you're ice cream looks back at you. read more

Mr Twistee's - The kiddie cone, flavor: outrageous oatmeal cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

Great service. Delicious ice cream. The small was huge. Loved the playground for the kids. I was able to sit and finish my ice cream while they played. Great experience. read more

Way too expensive for their small servings! Check out the photo I posted of the small Flurrie for $6,25! read more

Mr Twistee's - $6.25 for that small cup of a butterfinger Flurrie! I'd never return here with their outrageous prices. Bring on the DAIRY QUEEN! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

Love the drive thru convenience. The kid size was so cute with little candy eyes. The pecan praline was Amazing!!!!

So disappointed. First, we paid $5.15 for a medium with sprinkles. I figured ok...it's been expensive in past years, I guess I forgot how expensive Twistee's got. Next, the ice cream quality has gone down hill! I got Bavarian Vanilla, which used to be my favorite...not anymore. It is like they watered down the mix, making it like ice milk! We won't be back. read more

I'll go to Mr. Twistee's but only when Peppy's isn't open. They have good ice cream and all but it is way to overpriced, especially with the small portions you get. A small cookie dough flurry costs $6.25 and they're tiny! If you are willing to make the 7-10 min drive go to Peppy's in Border City!! read more

Mr Twistee's - Small flurry $6.25 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Geneva, New York

We drove from Watkins to Dresden with a carload of kids, if this was not bad enough, when we pulled in it was closed, online it says you're open till 10, but your sign out front said 9; to make matters worse we pulled in at 9:05; you could have cared less, now I'm driving the same boatload of kids back to Watkins; but now they're all crying... thanks a lot Mr. Twisted indeed. read more

Decent Ice Cream.. but prices are way to high for the small portions you get.. People say Twistee's is the best, but they are sadly confused... Go to Peppy's instead!!! read more

This is a nice place for ice-creams if you're in the area for wine tasting, and need to have something to offset your alcohol intake! Both the hard and soft ice creams are good. I especially liked the moose-track flavor. They also have dog-friendly ice-creams if you need some for your furry friend! read more

This is the ice cream stand I love to go to. It's got good selections of hard and soft ice creams. Good portion for the kids and best of all a nice play ground for the kids to run freely. I got a two scoop in a waffle bowl; chocolate pretzel and peanut butter cookie dough. The wife got two scoop in a waffle bowl cappuccino chocolate and the chocolate caramel pretzel. The waffle bowls were fresh and crunchy and the flavors delicious. I love that they take credit card as well. read more

I have been coming to Twistees for over 30 years.. every time I am in Geneva visiting family I make it a point to go at least once.. sometimes once a day:) read more

First of all, their prices are outrageous. Way too expensive for the quality and quantity. They have a pretty good selection of flavors, although I feel like there are always too many peanut butter options. The hard ice cream usually tastes great, but for some reason it melts really quickly...as in, it's usually already dripping down my arm (yes, past my hand) when they hand it to me! It's frustrating! The playground is fun for my kids, which is probably the main reason why we keep coming back, despite the steep prices. read more