Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Silver Coach

    3.5 (48 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Silver Coach Photos

    Business Info

    SILVER COACH ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Classy
    Moderate noise
    Dressy
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Silver Coach

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Inside one of the private dining spaces looking out to main area.
    Kate E.

    I really was hopeful and eager to give four stars but I just couldn't do it. Not that anything was wrong or bad about the place but the food just wasn't stand out enough. However I must say the walleye special was cooked to PERFECTION. Delicious and massive cut of fish, flaked perfectly and flavorful. I just didn't love the "potato crusted" part which turned out to be hash browns all over it. For an upscale restaurant the hash browns felt way too bar-foody to me. Love the out of the box thinking but just wasn't quite a home run in this application. In addition, the price was too high in my opinion. Speaking of price, we felt the appetizer was way overpriced too. We got the bourbon shrimp which was quite good (if you like spicier stuff!) but it's just four shrimp and a blob of rice....for $15.50! We're not talking gourmet or jumbo shrimp here either. That being said though, I can't go without saying that this place provides a wonderful unique experience. We reserved a private dining room and it was lovely and very private since it's teeny and no one else is in there with you. We enjoyed looking around at the historic decor of the train car while also feeling the awesome fall breeze with the open windows. Only downside with that was lots of traffic noise. Given the price points of the menu, aka what is advertised as an upscale restaurant, I'd say a suggestion we have is that they have a better drink list. Only wine is listed and given to you at your table and the waitress brought us what she called an "old drink (cocktail) list." A full spirits list would be really helpful and classy for people like my husband who look forward to seeing what the bar has on hand. We're from out of town so I don't think we'll be back but in general it was a neat evening and different experience. It's just a big bummer they seem to be a little off on their execution vs price point.

    Very cute bar seating
    Austin R.

    Such a cute restaurant with thematic decorations. Attentive service. There were many food options that I'd have loved to also try. I had chose the specials for both dinner and dessert, but all of their regular menu items sounded wonderful.

    Private dining room
    Anna P.

    Our group of 8 thoroughly enjoyed our experience at this supper club. The food was delicious, and our server paid attention to all the details. Meal began with unique drink offerings and bread service. All patrons in our party enjoyed the various meals (salmon, jumbalaya, shrimp Miguel, Caesar salad, roasted garlic bulb). The ambience is that of a tradition WI supper club, but unique in that half of the restaurant is literally an old train car with two private dining areas, perfect for a date night. We were a little shocked that the prices online were not as shown on the menu in the restaurant, but we understand that this is a representation of the current times and changes in consumerism.

    The private dining room is perfect for a romantic dinner.
    Tara P.

    Stopped to have dinner with my boyfriend and the food was outstanding! So fresh and absolutely amazing. The service was great and right on target. The Pomagranite Mule was delicious and Allan had the Old Fashion which was very stiff. The steak was tender and full of flavor while the ribs were juicy and fell off the bone. At first we only ordered the half rack but ended up ordering the other half because it was so good. I would highly recommend visiting The Silver Coach restaurant.

    A Fave!!
    Nat C.

    What a fabulous place to eat and have a cocktails. Very charming, unique and clean. The service is amazing. One of my fave places!!

    Blackened salmon dinner.
    Troy J.

    Silver Coach offers a contemporary menu and an intimate setting. During a recent visit, we enjoyed the blackened Salmon in garlic sauce and a shrimp & scallop special over pasta. Entrees were great. However, The crawfish ball appetizer on special wasn't so special after all. The texture was funky and the mustard sauce masked the crawfish flavor I was craving. The best seats in the house are the private dining rooms in the Pullman railway car. They seat 2-4. Avoid dining outside. It's nothing special. We ate outside during a recent visit and won't make that mistake again. The patio is unremarkable and patio service was less attentive than indoor dining. It's a great place for a date. Not a great place to bring the whole family -- especially if you have young kids. I plan to come back to try their Peri Peri entrees -- which are very spicy.

    Our Valentines dinner, at the Silver coach. Very exceptional.
    Melissa L.

    My husband and I are new to the area and wanted to go some where more than just a casual place, for our Valentines dinner. The Silver Coach seemed like the place. It was intimate as advertised. Was disappointed about the dress attire. I felt out of place, it was more casual then dressy. Our dinner was outstanding, five stars for that and our service was just as great. It is a little a pricey as advertised but we were ok with that. Their martins were also wonderful, a great variety. Five stars for that. The food was cooked perfectly. Very impressed! So over all five stars, I rarely give a place five stars. Being from Illinois and eating at very upscale restaurants in Chicago, this is right up there with their cuisine. My only suggestion would be more strict about dress code. This was a outstanding restaurant! I know we will be back! Great job!! Melissa

    In the private dining room
    Laura L.

    Delightful atmosphere (absolutely request the private room), delicious food, superb service. Our new anniversary tradition!

    Trapper steak done medium rare...delicious
    Betty R.

    Dined here on a busy Saturday- the day before Valentine's Day - but the service was still great. They have an awesome martini menu. I had the pink lemonade martini and for dessert had their special chocolate strawberry martini. For starters a must try are their crabfish balls in a great roumalade sauce. They have a great menu with 3 or 4 specials. Always hard to choose. This place is a very nice up-scale supper club.

    SIlver Coach Supper Club Hwy 66 just off Hwy 51 Exit 158 Stevens Point WI - private dining - sleeper car

    See all

    Photo of Bob G.
    35
    5
    0

    12 years ago

    good food, local produce. bonus is you like trains

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Delicious! Wow! Excellent ! Best bruschetta we've ever tasted. Very good service. We will be back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kim B.
    0
    11
    0

    12 years ago

    Just a great place to enjoy a quiet evening with a special someone with wonderful food. Meals are fairly priced and cooked to perfection.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Silver Coach

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Hilltop Pub and Grill - The cod

    Hilltop Pub and Grill

    3.8(224 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    $$

    We were looking for a Packer game stop on the way from Minocqua to MKE, and we were so pleased with…read moreHilltop. The food and waitstaff was great- congrats to the Browns-fab-waitress on her team's win. She was so helpful, and fun! They did not have the volume up on the game, which probably kept me from yelling as much as usual. We enjoyed the large cocktail menu, specials and number of TVs. Also, the entrance is an actual giant beer barrel - super cool. Plenty of parking, mostly bar fare.

    We were in town and someone suggested going here, so we headed over for Saturday dinner…read more Unfortunately, if I'm being completely honest, it was just not great. When you consider the food prices, the credit card fee, and the taste of the food itself, it's hard to even give this place 3 out of 5 stars and call it "average." I hate giving lower reviews, especially to smaller businesses, but this place needs some work. I'm going to write the kind of honest review I wish I would have seen before going here. To start, the prices are quite high. For what they're charging, I expected much better food. On top of that, they also charge a credit card fee, which means they are passing that cost onto the customer in addition to the high menu prices. That alone is an immediate negative for me. The ambience of the place itself isn't bad. It's a larger restaurant, and the curved door and circular shape are actually kind of cool. It's also cool having TVs all around. We were there on a Saturday night, and it was pretty slow. That said, if the locals have been here before, I can understand why it was slow, given the food quality and prices. I got the 1/2 Tequila BBQ Burger, and it was pretty boring. I can make much better burgers at home. It needed better seasoning, or really just any seasoning at all. The tequila bbq sauce was fine, but it mostly tasted like very sweet barbecue sauce. I got waffle fries with my order, and they were also just fine. Someone else at our table got the beer-battered fries, and those were much better. I do want to give them credit there. The beer-battered fries were actually quite good. I asked my wife and sister what they thought of their meals, and both of them were incredibly disappointed. My wife got a salad with chicken, and it was very boring. Again, it was something we could make better at home for cheaper. My sister got the salmon, and she was not impressed at all. I read through some of the other reviews, and I think a lot of them may be from locals, whereas I was just visiting town. But I agree with many of the negative points people have made, and I've already said it here: the food just isn't good, especially considering the prices they're charging. I'd recommend looking for a different restaurant in the area. If management happens to read this review, I think they could improve things by reviewing the quality of the food they're serving and working to improve the overall taste. Otherwise, they should consider lowering prices to better match the quality of the food. The portion sizes were good, and that is another thing I do want to give them credit for. At the end of the day, maybe we just didn't order the right things, but no one at our table enjoyed their meal enough to want to go back. This place needs a lot of work, and I hope they have better success in the future. Next time we are in town, though, we will be going somewhere else.

    Photos
    Hilltop Pub and Grill
    Hilltop Pub and Grill - Chicken sandwich w/fries and bbq sauce

    Chicken sandwich w/fries and bbq sauce

    Hilltop Pub and Grill

    See all

    Olympia Family Restaurant - Steak

    Olympia Family Restaurant

    2.9(47 reviews)
    1.6 mi
    $

    We were in town for the weekend and my sister wanted to see if the tuna melt was as good as she…read moreremembered it. She was not disappointed. My brother had the perch fish fry and I had the bluegill special. We were happy with the coating, taste and temperature of the fish--no fishy flavor. Both came with soup or salad, coleslaw, bread and cracker basket, choice of potato, and dessert. Spumoni ice cream was a choice and what a treat. Rarely see that as an option. Other dessert options were bread pudding, tapioca pudding and vanilla ice cream with the option of chocolate sauce and whipped cream. Service was prompt and friendly. The coffee was nothing special, but the refills kept coming without us having to ask. Back in the day, we used to come here if we wanted leftovers for another meal. Happy to say that still holds true. A favorite of the locals for decades, this family restaurant provides generous portions in a comfortable, relaxed atmosphere. The closest thing to a Greek restaurant there is in the area. A good place to relax and unwind, but if you're looking for a fancy, upscale place with creative, gourmet cooking, go elsewhere.

    We have eaten here many times in the past and were happy with the food and service. Lately though…read morethe place has gone downhill. A few months ago we went for dinner and I had the Caesar Salad with chicken which was always delicious. Not that time. Instead of romaine lettuce, the Caesar (which is supposed to be ROMAINE) was made with horrible iceberg lettuce, and it was all limp and soggy before the dressing was even added. Last night I ordered the Turkey dinner which was one of their Sunday specials, only to be told they were out. We were not told when seated that the Turkey dinner was out, or I would have looked at the menu and chose something else. The waitress did not inform us until others at our table had already ordered. I took a chance and ordered the Caesar Salad with chicken and mentioned to the waitress that the last time it was not made with Romaine, and she said she'd make sure it was. Well, the salad did have Romaine, but that was all that was correct for the salad. There were NO cucumbers (which I love about their salad), croutons or parmesan cheese (which are also a standard for this salad) and the tomatoes were horrible! The few tomato slices were yellow and white, totally inedible. As I was eating I discovered that they had the gall to add green peppers to a Caesar Salad. OMG. I hate green peppers! I took them all off and gave them to my husband. We told the waitress but she said they were apparently out of cucumbers and cheese. You would think they could have offered to comp the salad considering so much was wrong with it. Nope. If a restaurant is out of an ingredient that is essential for a recipe, the customer should be told ahead of time, instead of just exchanging it with something else that the customer might not like. My husband had the Spinach Blue Wrap which is supposed to smothered in Bleu Cheese. There was no Bleu cheese in the wrap but swiss used instead. We were so disappointed!!!!

    Photos
    Olympia Family Restaurant - Gyro Platter

    Gyro Platter

    Olympia Family Restaurant - Raw steak

    Raw steak

    Olympia Family Restaurant - Raw

    See all

    Raw

    Silver Coach - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...