I feeeeeeeeeeeeeel like this is a neighborhood staple for a reason and must be enjoyed fresh. We ordered from Uber (BOGO) and it's further away than anticipated. We also ordered during rush hour because we're a pair of idiots. Anywho, let's get to the pizza. Great crust, delicious sauce, tasty cheese. It's what you'd expect from a neighborhood pizzeria. We also ordered some spanakopita that had crushed garlic all over it. Not sure why but my friend loved it. Would I order again? Only if I were in DC. I would probably pick it up or dine-in. read more

Waited 1hour 15min, pizza never came. Got an email saying they cancelled the order. By then it was after 11 pm and everything was closed. Can't imagine customer service being any worse. read more

Love these folks, I get mushrooms anchovies and spinach large pizza and it never disappoints. Friendly, reliable, good people and good food.

Pizza is the best on this side of town, and always good with fresh vegetables and meat especially pepperoni. I do recommend trying it out you won't be disappointed. read more

Note: This is a delivery review only. I wasn't expecting too much because, well, it's a pizza delivery place. But Sicilian Pizza pleasantly surprised me. I ordered a custom calzone (I like that they offer those) with provolone, meatballs, and sun-dried tomatoes. The app gave an estimate of about 45 minutes delivery time, and the driver arrived five minutes early. The calzone was hot and clearly had just come out of the oven before being brought over. Already, that was earning them brownie points. I enjoyed the calzone itself, which was a nice size and wasn't too greasy--a common sin of cheap calzones (read: Sbarro's in any mall anywhere). The little marinara sauce was also good, although I had to ration the container since it was small. Next time, I'll have to do one of their select-a-topping pizzas! read more

Sicilian Pizza - Provolone and meatball calzone - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

The pizzas are well made, the fries are still crispy by the time I get them home, and the salads are decent. It's everything you need in a neighborhood pizza spot. read more

I really love Sicilian Pizza. The staff is wonderful and they definitely take pride in the quality and care of their food. Super quick but always on point. FYI it is a walk up to the counter establishment. read more

Every neighborhood deserves a solid pizza place, and this place certainly fits the bill. Consistently great thin crust pizza with a great sauce. Have also tried the house salad, chicken tenders, and manicotti and they have also always been on point. Wait times for pickup are minimal. Love this place. read more

I wanted to give sicilian pizza a high rating, due to their quick service on a Friday night. It took approximately 20 minutes for the delivery man to arrive in front of my apartment. The pizza came out piping hot (which is what I LOVE), so kudos! The pepperoni pizza was good. The only thing that I would make note of is the tomato sauce - it was a little too sweet for my savory tastebuds. However, for the price, you can't really beat it (since it seems like food is just generally expensive in DC). Would definitely call for delivery again when I have a hankering for some simple pizza! read more

Sicilian Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Cheese pizza was thin, definitely not what I was expecting based on the name. Cheese was good and spicy, but the sauce was mild. Mozzarella sticks were a rip off for how tiny and bad they were. It was fast enough for delivery tho read more

I have only had pizza from here but it is hands down the best. The sauce has so much flavor and the cheese blend is fantastic and plentiful. read more

Good quality ingredients with generous and smiling service. Great experience all around. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Pizza with olives and fresh basil - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

See all

I would like to provide an excellent review for Sicilian Pizza, located at 1004 Florida Avenue NE in Washington DC. (202-296-6000) Being of Sicilian heritage myself, I love the Supremo Pizza, which reminds me of my Grandmother's and Mother's pizza who both came to the USA from Palazzo Adriano in Sicily. The delivery is always on time, and everyone is extremely kind. In my opinion, this one of the BEST pizza locations I have found in DC, akin to Two Amis in NW. Mangia Bene!! Tony Romano read more

I order pizza from there as per recommendation of our friend. The selections on website were pretty interesting and fairly reasonable prices. I got spinach and artichoke one. Pizza arrived after 35 min or so, hot and looking delicious. On my 3rd slice I bit into something hard almost breaking my tooth. I was back closing of an earring!!! I love additional toppings in my pizza but not when they are metal and might cause some damage. I won't be coming back!! read more

Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Please put your money elsewhere for pizza. I have never had so bad of pizza in my life. It was bland, soft and gummy from being undercooked, was in desperate need of salt, desperate need of of more sauce. I put up a picture just to show how little sauce there was. Just don't waste your money. Their cheesecake was decent though. Idk how that happens. That's why they got 2 stars. I just want to point out that I have had government issued school lunch pizza that has been better than this. I was so angry at this pizza that I threw a slice at the wall. Just don't buy from here. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Terrible pizza. That's how little sauce there was on this pizza. I was undercooked under seasoned and under sauced. - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Great pizza close to home. I had the pizza and the spaghetti and I tell ya it was amazing. Generous with ingredients. The meatballs are authentic Italian. Very saucy but I like that. Not sure what the negative reviews are about because they were great in my experience and have ordered dozens of times now. Vastly better than dominos or papa johns. read more

Ordered from here for a Sunday afternoon pizza craving. Kind of selected this place at random and we got soooo lucky! The pizza was fantastic. I like pizza with a good amount of sauce and when I order extra cheese I am always disappointed at the amount of cheese, but not here! There was probably a half inch of cheese on this delicious pie and they didn't skimp on the sauce either. I ordered the cheese pizza and added ricotta, mozzarella and provolone extra. It was exactly what we were craving. We ordered mozzarella sticks also, which wasn't the greatest idea, because by the time they got to us they were not crispy at all, but I think that's just how it goes with delivery. Highly recommend the pizza! read more

I can eat an entire jar of pickled chitterlings with olives (YUCK) after consuming "Mary Jane". The first couple of time eating from this location was due to feeding "Mary Jane's" cravings to Eat! Eat! Eat!. This last experience was very sobering to say the least. I took one bite and thought to self how disgusting!! After other guests complained, I knew it wasn't just me. I am done with this place. The pizza is over priced and awful!!! Mary Jane or not!!! You have been warned!! I will take Ledos over this place moving forward. read more

I ordered a 10-piece buffalo wing and a order of Garlic Bread. I'm am currently vomiting and have a very bad case of diarrhea. Clearly something was wrong. The wings were ordered well done but they were rubbery so I could only eat 4. I will never order here again! read more

Sicilian pizza is one of the best pizza I had in DC for the following reasons: 1. Taste: We usually get the two topping pizza with extra cheese. According to my roommates when they first order from there, the quality of the pizza is tolerable but the more we order from there the quality increases by a million. It actually tastes amazing now. 2. Service: We never use their delivery service since we live right down the block. They often make the wrong order.....but if they do, they always make us a new one. So we end up with two pizzas with the price of one! Can't complain on that! read more

Sicilian Pizza - Half Pepperoni and half feta, spinach and bacon! - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

very bad service and the pizza was sucks don't wast your time gays and the fries was too much oil read more

Tough to pick a rating for Sicilian Pizza. On one hand, it's my neighborhood spot, always there for me when I want a panini in a pinch. I also recently learned that their cannoli rivals that of Isgro, which is no small feat. But... on the other hand, the panini can be inconsistent, the pizza sometimes rubbery, and the wings disappointing. It's not as wildly different as NY Pizza (Penn Ave SE), but it's just not always great. What it is good for is the pizza, and actually now that I think about it, the calzones are really good, too. The panini are okay, sometimes they are great (especially when you aren't feeling pizza), but sometimes they use different ingredients (like, dude, I know that prosciutto looks/tastes like... this is straight ham), which can make it inconsistent. Sometimes they throw in a free, individually-wrapped slice of cheese pizza. We haven't been able to figure out what the common factor is there, but it's always a welcome surprise. Definitely a worthwhile pizza spot in the area, better than the others near H St. Treat yourself and get the cannoli, too. It's even better with coffee the next morning! read more

Sicilian Pizza - One of the walls, featuring part of the menu and strategically placed hot pepper flakes and Parmeasean. - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

I work right next door at Gallaudet University and often order pizza here. Very tasty and crispy crust if you get "thin crust" and light on the cheese. Something like Bertucci's thin crust. Inexpensive and fast, too. I always pick up, and pizzas ready in 15 minutes. Friendly owner and staff. Lasagna also good. read more

This NY Pizza Snob's go to pizza when in DC. The Margherita pizza is absolutely delicious! Fresh tomato and mozzarella on good crust. Really really good. Takeout only. Small hole in the wall with difficult parking. Uber Eats does deliver from here. Wiseguys Pizza is also terrific in DC. read more

By far the best pizza/sub/wings shop I've ever had. I made the mistake of only eating their pizza for about a year when I decided to change it up. Wow. Had their paninis, amazing. Went vegan and had the whole wheat no cheese pizza, amazing. Quit vegan and ordered their wings, amazing. Haven't had the pasta but I bet it's...amazing. I'm working on my adjectives. It's. So. Good. read more

So I live in NoMa and stopped by the other day to check it out. This pizza was good, nothing spectacular but def good for a local spot. Grabbed a menu for the next time. Now heres where I have an issue, the menu has a list of coupons in it. I called to place an order and was told they don't honor their own coupons. I wasn't met wit an apology but yet annoyance as though me wanting to use the VALID COUPON THEY LISTED was a problem! The young lady on the phone said she told the manager however doesn't tell the customers. Nor did they remove the coupons. For me its the principle. They could've removed the coupons or jus honored it since it was their fault! It sucks because I wanted to support this spot but nope not now! read more

Let me start by saying I don't review things, ever. Let me put this in perspective. I had a $5 coupon through Slice from ordering from Pizzaiole, (which has been great), recently. I am a sucker for Salami and hot peppers and saw that Sicilian offered a Salami option. I opted for a one topping deal and got Salami only, knowing I had banana and jalepeno peppers at home. Including tip I luckily only paid $15. I received the box - luke warm as expected from most deliveries - and brought it inside to add the other toppings. When I opened the box it actually smelled rotten. The Salami was thick cut and baked into/under the cheese and was essentially chewy. I pulled a few pieces out and they were grayed and had a funky stench, which is what the photo shows. I managed to find a crisped piece that I tried, i couldn't have told you it was Salami if I hadn't ordered it. Despite the smell, (I'm hungry and paid $15 here guys), I removed visible Salami from a few slices and gave the pie a try only to taste nothing but the foul flavor of the smell now invading my house. The cheese was rubbery, the sauce was flat and the dough is that of a frozen pizza. Needless to say I can't believe the product coming out of a place with a 4.5+ rating on slice that dares to be named Sicilian. If you're a fan of this place at least do yourself a favor and don't ever venture for cured meats. A one rating to Sicilian simply because the delivery came only a few minutes outside of their estimated window. Hopefully I don't get sick. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Honestly, don't bother. Pizza was cold and undercooked. You're better off ordering from dominos.

We love the portobello mushroom and barbecue chicken pizzas. I love that Sicilian offers a whole wheat crust. Had the barbecue chicken last night. Delivery was fast, pizza was hot and so yummy! read more

We ordered a half and half extra large pizza and we devoured it at home. It was tasty, the dough had a crunch without being paper-thin, and the artichoke slices were generous as were all the toppings. While waiting for the pizza the manager/owner asked if we would like to see it being made. We looked at a very clean and well-organized kitchen from the door. Most places that are not open kitchen concept don't ever let you see the working conditions, cleanliness etc. Sad to say we ate the pizza without taking a picture. read more

Ordered the Gyro Pizza with Garlic and Buffalo wings. Garlic wings were a little dry but I've seen far worse. The pizza incorporated gyro meat, spinach and feta in a really creative way. Would get again. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Gyro Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

The night Sicilian Pizza DC saved Thanksgiving- ''Twas the night before Thanksgiving when.... OK, cut to the chase. I ordered online (very convenient w/Beyond Menu) but forgot to "save" toppings, so when a plain pizza arrived, I gave it back to the driver saying it was wrong. He was confused but said, "Ok, I'll be back in 20 mins with the right pizza." I called the store just to let them get started on making it and was told that the order they got was for a plain pizza- that's when I realized it must have been on me. With a houseful of family, I botched dinner! Sicilian Pizza called back- we're sending you a new pizza with the toppings you wanted, no charge (I'd already paid for the plain one), and 20 minutes later Thanksgiving is saved! And everyone, from 91 year-old grandma from Manhattan to 20 year-old daughter from LA said, "That's a REALLY good pizza!" Thank you to all at Sicilian Pizza DC. Forever my go-to DC pizza place! read more

This place isn't very good. It should be obvious: when a restaurant needs to advertise and offer "special deals" so much...they're trying to make up for something that's lacking. We ordered online which seemed like a nice convenience. Apparently they are linked to several other websites that you actually end up purchasing your meal through so the offer of getting free bread sticks with your order doesn't actually apply (despite the fact that there's no small print saying it only applies to their *official* website). When we got to the shop to pick up our order it was wrong. We had to wait for them to make it properly. Too bad with that extra time they couldn't have made a good tasting pizza. It was a very generic, cardboard-ish pizza, nothing memorable. They also ran our credit card again before we left despite the fact that we'd put in the info online. We were charged twice and had to point it out to them to be credited. Just one more hassle and who knows where into the interwebs and that other website our credit card info went. Two forgettable pizzas and a 2L of soda for $35 isn't a deal. Factor in the taste and the headache of the website and service and they should pay you for it. You can get better tasting and quality pizza from any of the major chains around here, not to mention good mom and pop places like Wise Guys. read more

I really wonder why would YELP remove my perfectly legitimate review about this little pizza shop without my consent? What is the point of your existence as a web site if you are going to remove people's reviews without verifying the legitimacy of the review. I usually go to Sicilian Pizza to get my cheese pizza. Those taste really good and always freshly made. The owner recently recommended the supremo pizza, when i told that i am having friends over. The supremo pizza was amazingly delicious and all my friends just loved it! The service was great and quick, and the owner was as always very welcoming and provided excellent customer service. I now only order supremo pizza and nothing else. Thank you Sicilian Pizza keep up the great service! read more

Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

This is the worst pizza I have ever eaten. And just to be clear, I mean that Sicilian Pizza's pizza is worse than pizza that comes from gas stations. At least shitty greaselump pizza tastes like something. This whole fucking pizza could have been made out of different textured tofus for all the flavor it had. The sauce seems to be nothing more than a tomato that someone squeezed above the crust. The meats were all unholy vacuums of non-flavor. How do they even find pepperoni that doesn't taste like anything?! THATS WEIRD. Nothing had any seasoning in it. We threw the whole thing out and are now contemplating whether or not eating a bag of pita chips is better than just skipping dinner. To add injury to insult, this shit is expensive. read more

This place is insane! I like to order a large pizza, half pepperoni and sausage, half feta, spinach, and bacon. (This isn't listed explicitly on their online menu, but they are happy to do it.) The wings are also amazing! Meaty, always served hot and perfectly cooked, great flavor. Be warned, they don't always answer the phone and delivery sometimes takes quite a while. However, when the pizza arrives you won't be disappointed. read more

As a major pizza snob who's spent weeks in Italy eating the best pizza in the world (sorry NY folks), I can say that the pizza is unremarkably average and not really distinguishable from any of the big chains. Pizza arrived hot, delivery was quick, and everything was fresh... but the sauce, toppings and crust are all completely flavorless. Anyone suggesting this is the best pizza in the city should get out more. I wouldn't even rank it in the top 20. Even in terms of neighborhood spots, this wouldn't even make the list. 2 stars for the pizza + 1 star for quick/hot delivery. read more

Sicilian Pizza has been our go-to pizza delivery for years: above-average pies, great Greek salad, decent prices and consistent service. Tonight when I glanced over at the slice on my two-year-old son's plate, I noticed a baked-in roofing nail sticking out of the crust. I called to report it, and received a perfunctory apology, an offer for a new pie (which I declined), then a "well, what do you want me to do?" An offer of a full refund would have gone a long ways towards making this situation better. It was not made. I won't be ordering from here again. read more

Sicilian Pizza - Nail in the pizza crust. - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Just ordered pizza for delivery tonight, via yelp's online ordering, and received my delivery within 45-50 minutes. Pizza came piping hot, toppings and extra sauce as requested. Not the best pizza ever but it was pretty damn good, so I'm not sure why people are hating on these nice people! The one thing I will say about pizza places is that, like the jumbo slice type joints, the late night pizza is NEVER good. But when you order pre-midnight drunkie pizza, it's going to be their true pizza quality and from the places I've ordered from, it's pretty decent. So please keep that in mind when you post or read reviews for my favorite food-if it was normal delivery/take out or if it was late night, we make it as fast as we can and therefore, quality goes down a bit, pizza. I'd definitely order from here again! read more

Sicilian Pizza - pepperoni and roasted red pepper. delish! - Pizza Near Me - Washington, DC, District of Columbia

Not completely sold yet, but being just 3 blocks from my new house, I'm sure I'll have some more taste-testing soon. I ordered online and went to pickup a bit after the 30 minutes they quoted. Unfortunately, the food still wasn't ready. After waiting another 20 minutes, it came out. Maybe they were just busy, but I really don't like waiting and much rather would have been told the realistic estimate and shown up then. We had two pizzas, both were the whole wheat crust. One had artichoke and feta, the other mushrooms and caramelized onions. The toppings were definitely good. But what was lacking was the solidity of the crust. It was just too soggy/ flimsy. After putting some in the fridge and eating the next day for lunch, the crust seemed to hold up better. Next time, I think I'll try the original crust, not the whole wheat and see if it makes a difference. I am curious about the large list of toppings and sauce combinations here. Definitely a step up from many of the corner pizza places across the city. read more