Was visiting my daughter at St Mary's hospital and heading back to Winder saw this and had to go. My son and I have t been to one in years and couldn't wait! Drive through was empty so picked up a turkey and a Rueben (rye), I wanted that famous sour dough. Took a bit to get home so opened up and dug in and these were fantastic!!! The turkey had a lb of meat or close, great bread and soo good, Rueben was not as big but spot on. We only at half and had to stop and will eat more later but we got fast service, good food, happy camper !! Recommend!!! read more

Schlotzsky's - Turkey and a Ruben on rye! These were huge and just what I wanted - Sandwiches Near Me - Athens, Georgia

The woman who took our order tonight was incredibly kind and welcoming and interacted well with my kids while we were ordering. Her service will have us coming back again ! read more

My husband and had an early supper here May 2025. The service was prompt and courteous. We both had the original combo which came out quickly. The bread was perfect and the meat and veggies were fresh and plentiful! There was no one dining in but us and we thought the atmosphere was relaxing and welcoming. We are both glad we visited and we will be back. read more

I've visited this location several times. The drive through lady was rude I'm not sure what her issue is but she's not friendly at all and very unprofessional. She couldn't hear my order due to laughing in the microphone while taking my order. 1490 Baxter Street host: term 5am cashier: term 4am DT-513 read more

Came through for lunch today and the lady working the drive through was incredibly friendly. She took my order quickly and my food was fresh and tasty! I ordered the Turkey Bacon Club and added avocado! I didn't go inside so can't really speak to nature of the inside of the restaurant! read more

The worst Schlotzsky's I've ever been to and I've been to at least a dozen locations. I'm an Athens local, I was so excited to move near a one, but my gosh it's so so bad!!! From being ignored by employees for 20 min at the counter, to the quality of the sandwiches, to the upkeep, and cleanliness inside the dining room. It's all horrible and it makes me sad cause I truly love their food! Today I decided to go because I had a $5 off coupon, placed my order online, showed up, they couldn't locate my online order, which I ordered at their location. So canceled the order and this truly is the last time I'll have a horrible experience with them because I'm never going back. Corporate needs to step in here to get new management cause their current "system" most definitely isn't working. read more

Schlotzsky's - Sandwiches Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Ordered the Turkey sandwich and a MiniBon Roll through Door Dash. It took over an hour despite scheduling the order in the morning with the hopes that it would arrive after the lunch rush.. but I get it, folks are busy. The sandwich was okay but the cinnamon roll was inedible. It was as hard as a rock and ice cold. Not sure if it was days old or served frozen, but regardless, this ain't it. I don't see myself ordering from here again. read more

Schlotzsky's - MiniBon Roll - Served stale and rock solid. - Sandwiches Near Me - Athens, Georgia

Ordered a small Original and a small drink. Sandwich was great. The bread was toasted. The ingredients were fresh. Interior is messy though. Customer service was good. Wait time was shorter than expected. It was a bit pricey but I guess it's worth it for good sandwiches like that. read more

Love this place. It's always delicious! The staff is friendly, and they have great options for kids.

I got the original sandwich, which was very good. However the restaurant in Athens, Georgia, was very dirty. I tried to find one clean table, and there were none. I finally found a big booth, and then noticed ketchup on the seat and fries scattered on the floor. There was a lot of trash on the floor in the entire restaurant. The staff was also detached. place. Disappointed, to say the least. read more

Why are there not more Schlotzsky's?! I have not seen this restaurant since I moved from Louisville three years ago. I spotted one in Athens, GA and knew I had to stop! It was just as good as I remembered! I ordered the Fresh Veggie, medium size, sandwich. Hubs got the Avocado Smokecheesy. Both were good, but I was envious of hubs' sandwich. Why? Well, because of the avocado--duh! Also, because it was hot and mine was cold. Next time I'm near a Schlotzsky's I'll be getting that or trying one of the pizzas, which looked absolutely delish on their menu pictures! read more

See all

The food at this location is inedible. The bread was stale and the sandwich was missing half of the ordered ingredients. To top it off, I ordered ahead and selected curbside service. When I called at pick up, I was asked to come inside instead. Talk about a bait and switch for a service chosen for ADA accessibility. read more

I can not pronounce the name well, but I can without a doubt devour their delicious food, lol. The atmosphere is very nice and relaxing. The wait time is not so bad. In my book its one of the best eateries in town. read more

We tried to plan a dinner with the family since the sign says dining room open. But wrong it closes at 3pm.

I come in to get lunch from time to time and upper management is there a lot. The team is always working very hard and is always very attentive, but the upper management is very rude to them and doesn't treat them very well and it shows. I wish better for them! read more

I've liked Schlotzsky's since I lived in Austin in the '80's. The original sandwich hasn't changed too much over the years but I think it was bigger and decidedly unhealthier back then. Still good. I like this franchise. Nice space. read more

Schlotzsky's - Original - Sandwiches Near Me - Athens, Georgia

God bless these workers. I came in like 20-30 minutes before close and ordered a crap ton as an emergency for family coming in who were delayed by a traffic accident in Atlanta. The guy at the front counter was super nice and although I could tell the girl in the back was disgruntled (which I get lol I came in super late that's my bad) she still made sure the orders were made perfectly and made sure to supply us with spoons and was friendly to me in person. My family was very happy with the food. Give these kids a raise. read more

I eat here about 3 times a month and usually get the original deluxe sandwich. Which I love. I eat in and the sandwich is at my table almost before I sit down. The staff is courteous and professional. I love onions. My visits will continue!! read more

On line ordered 12 sandwiches at 1030 no a Wednesday They immediately called back and said the order was to large

I went here April 9th between 220pm-240pm and not only did my "pizza" not get put on a pizza crust (someone decided that I should have a flatbread instead)when I specifically asked about pizzaa and their ability to make their sandwiches into pizzas. My sweet tea had no sugar and I was told it's because they moved the tea urns around. Now I could forgive this if when I was trying to get assistance the girl with this weird green hair and eye makeup could have bothered to answer the drive through window instead of handing it over to another individual. Because she was too busy refilling lids and straws.... And the pizza looks like it was just thrown together.... I am sorry you made a mistake and thought I wasn't going to get what I paid for. read more

They have amazing sandwiches. They're closed in Virginia Beach where I live at, So I had to get it again while I was here in Georgia. It made me remember what I was missing. My favorite is the deli chicken sandwich. read more

The first time I tried Schlotzsky's was in Austin many years ago. When I saw that we had one here, I began eating one every now and then. I like the "Original" and it is always to my liking. I hear others say they have gotten poor service. But this has not been my observation. I love Schotzsky's. read more

Sandwich tasted weird so I looked down and found multiple wirey black hairs embedded in the bread of my sandwich. Mistakes happen but yeesh.

I have never had such a horrible experience at an eatery. After waiting 30 minutes in the drive thru line as the only car in line, I received my French dip sandwich without the roast beef. Only onions and melted cheese on a bun. Disappointing. So I called in on my way back to the restaurant, and instead of being greeted with apology and compensation, the workers simply laughed at their mistake and thought it was so funny. Then another 30 minutes pass by as I stand in the restaurant waiting for my correct order. Safe to say, I will never be giving Schlotzsky's my business again. Schlotzsky's Lotz Worse read more

The Schlotsky's Team went above and beyond for me tonight. I am a vegetarian and had accidentally ordered the wrong sandwich (one with meat) on the app and realized it when i went for pickup, I told them about this and they made me a new one no problem. Thank you Schlotskys! read more

I usually love this place. Ordered two sliders tonight. You must get the same flavor and they do not sell them individually. Wow it was $6 for two small sliders that were not even adequately stuffed with meat. So disappointed. read more

This is the nicest, cleanest Schlotzsky's I've ever seen, with chill, multi-colored light fixtures; horseshoe-shaped booths; and an overall coffeehouse feel. Plus, a row of stools lines a counter with up-to-date computers providing Internet access. I just dropped in for a snack: a surprisingly delicious piece of cheesecake with a classic foundation, chocolate sprinkles and a hunk of creamy caramel at the tip. If only the entire piece of cheesecake had been dipped in the caramel... read more

I was here about a year and half ago, and I witnessed something very unsettling. After finishing my food (which was actually quite delicious), I went to the restroom to wash my hands, when I saw an employee (I believe he was a cook, for I didn't see him at the cash register) walk out of a stall and exit the restroom WITHOUT WASHING HIS HANDS. Needless to say, I will not be returning to this place ever again. read more

We occasionally stop for drive up sandwiches. Have been pretty good for years. Today - 2 not-good, dry sandwiches. Called asked for manager - after talking with some lady, same guy who answered said he was the manager. Described our concern with the not-good sandwiches - he was not concerned! Didn't know why they weren't good - not a new person. Didn't really care. Said he didn't know what was different. Ugh. May try once more. Maybe. read more

I was pleasantly surprised with how nice and clean this Schlotzskys was. They even have Mac computers to keep kids or older kids entertained while waiting. The food was good but nothing that really stood out. I had the buffalo chicken which really had no zing and was rather blah. What was delish was the cinnamon roll - supper gooey and oh so yummy! I'd give this place another try but will try something different. read more

I always go to Schlotzsky's in Athens, GA whenever I go back home. It is always a good clean restaurant with good food and plenty of space to sit and eat with friends. I tried to get them to make a Schlotzsky sandwich to go but they can't figure it out... They are just not that good when they are not straight off the oven. I'm a long time fan of Schlotzsky's since the late 1970's and wish they were closer to home for me. It is currently about 250 miles to the nearest Schlotzsky restaurant. read more

I was surprised when Schlotzsky's came to Athens because I've only known them to be up north and I'd only been to the one in Ann Arbor. I try to refrain from chains but I have to talk about this Schlotzsky's. It's super. It's very clean and the décor is beautiful with little hidden rooms where people study or just group together. They have a very good healthy personal size pizza and it's less than $6.00 so this place is quite affordable. They have wifi and the staff is always great ! read more

I like the fact that the ?manager is actually reading the reviews and following up/taking action. It shows that he really cares and is interested in the feedback. read more

Terrible visit. Took 15 minutes to get a simple sandwich. When it was delivered it had nothing in it but meat. Nothing else. When we returned it the staff was totally apathetic. Wouldn't return all the money either. Will never go to the Athens store again read more

Food was a 4. Seating a 2. A good deal of the seating requires that you squeeze between tables and place you butt in someones face.

I've adored Schlotzsky's ever since I first tasted it. I normally get the Combination Special pizza, 86 the black olives. I've tried their sandwiches, and though I love the bread, I think I'll stick with the pizza. Also, of the many locations I've seen, this one is the most uniquely built and elicits a dimly lit coffeehouse feel when visited in the evening. My only complaint is their ostensible inability to deal with gift cards. I was double charged THREE consecutive times, and one staff member seemed particularly unapologetic about the whole matter. Right now, I'm slightly miffed at the service, but I'm not sure how long I can stay away from that delicious pizza. read more

Horrible customer service!!! I have eaten at Schlotzsky's at least once a month since it first opened in Athens many, many years ago and have never had such horrible service as I did today when I ordered at the drive-thru. I ordered 3 chicken avocado flatbreads and confirmed the order, as always, and paid at the window. When I got my order it was 3 sandwiches. I sat at the window until the female working the window saw me and asked what. I told her my order was wrong and that I had ordered 3 avocado chicken flatbreads and she said no you didn't and took the bag back and said "here we go again!" This made me think my order isn't the only one she didn't get right today. A moment later a young man came to the window and asked what the problem was and I told him and said I would like to speak with a manager because I'm a years-long customer and didn't need attitude from his employee who didn't get my order right. He asked if I wanted a refund and I told him no, I want the food that I ordered and no more attitude. He said well the problem is she repeated it back to you and you said yes to the sandwich order. I asked him why would I confirm an incorrect order and especially one for 3 sandwiches when I clearly told her AND confirmed 3 chicken avocado flatbreads. Needless to say I checked my order before leaving. Of course I wasn't given a receipt and neither one of them provided their name. I was at the Athens Schlotzsky's on Baxter Street at approximately 4:15 pm today (May 25, 2020). If anyone else had the same horrible service as I did, please write about it. If enough customers - who are the ones paying the salaries of restaurant workers - share their dissatisfactory experience maybe a regional manager will step up and provide training to employees so no other customer has to get attitude when the drive-thru worker gets your order wrong. The only reason I'm giving a 1-star rating is because I couldn't post my review until I chose a rating! read more

On the plus side, if you like Schlotzky's, you will enjoy this location. It is very clean and nice, with good service. The patio is lovely, and for you nerds who can't stand to be away from a computer long enough to eat a sandwich there are Macs to play games and such on. The seating is set up kind of dumb though. When it is busy it can get very claustrophobic and you will end up with strangers' butts in your face and on either side of you. The main negative is that, well, it's Schlotsky's and the food is terrible. They don't use real turkey..it is similar to what you would get in one of those 99 cent Carl Budding packs. No telling what kind of mechanically separated garbage it is. This is unacceptable, especially considering the price. Slap that between two spongy, tasteless discs..the trademark Schlotsky's "bread"..yum. read more

I really like this place because the food is great and the place is clean! I've gone to other Schlotzky's and they have been kinda dirty and gross. But this one is nice and has great service! read more

The food is pretty good. I got a turkey sandwich and it was good. However, this restaurant was unbearably hot and uncomfortable. Especially the bathrooms. If you're looking for a place to cool off from the summer heat, don't come here unless you want a heat stroke. read more