My friend and I were walking in downtown Eureka exploring the shops. It was hot and we were carrying our refillable water bottles. We decided to stop in for lunch at Sarah's. They told us we had to take our water bottles out of the store and then come back in, in order to be served. I am still scratching my head at this nonsense. Will not be returning or recommending. read more

Impromptu date night done right! Cute place for breakfast, coffee, lunch, dinner or dessert and wine. Husband and I went and got tacos for taco Thursday ($3each) which were all yummy -- veggie may been favorite. We also tried bacon and goat cheese flat bread and the goat cheese appetizer. So much food and was delicious. Our waitress was super friend as well. I'll be back! Would love for a friend date read more

See all

Superb food but limited menu. Probably the correct menu for this location. Very small with lots of high top tables. Bigger menu means a bigger inventory and more employees and expense. Just don't go there if you want variety. read more

My wife always wants me to run in on like a Sunday morning/afternoon and get her a breakfast sandwich. They're fast, nice, and attentive. Typically I'll wait no more than a few minutes when they're busy but multiple employees will check in on me during that time. My little girl has gotten to love the Breakfast Biscuit Sammy (I think was the name) also now, which is a lot for a little one but she puts it away somehow! Tastes good, great service! read more

don't bother if you have more then 4 people. Waited and stared at empty tables of 4 and they would not pull up a chair. They let 5 people come in and take over the bar area for breakfast, then they seated people at empty tables instead of pulling them together. The clueless staff just started with "deer in the headlights " look. Totally ridulous, no common sense what so ever at this place. Went across the street and got seated immediately read more

I love avocado toast and was very excited to see it on the breakfast menu. When I got the toast it was probably the most unappealing looking avocado toast I have ever seen. The avocado was a grayish color and was a paste-like consistency. I tend to prefer chunky avocado toast. The toast tasted ok but it wasn't much for the price and definitely didn't look very appetizing. read more

I visited Sarah's. I ordered the veggie rice bowl. I was impressed by the portion size. I actually had 3 more meals, after eating at Sarah's place. It was well worth the price. I would recommend Sarah's. Oh yeah, the deserts are yummy too(-: read more

If you go here get your stuff to go. Absolute worst service and poorly run restaurant I have been to in a long time. We ordered at the counter, sat down, and then waited 25 min for the FIRST of three items to come out. 7 min later I go to the front to ask what is going on and they said they have a full house, as if to excuse their disorganization, and will look into it. It's Mother's Day AND they advertised a special menu by the way so it's not like they didn't know what was coming. After another 5 min they came to tell me that there was another person who ordered the same thing I ordered and he got my food and that mine would be coming soon. At this point we just asked for our money back and left. FYI the mix up explains my order but my wife ordered something completely different so it did not explain why her food was never served. Shame that our Mothers Day breakfast was ruined by this s*** show of a "restaurant" Just a tip to Sarah's. Go Google how to run a restaurant and get your stuff together. Better yet go somewhere that has good reviews for service and just copy what they do. It's not that hard. read more

Attempted to order online which seemed like a convenient system. Arrived at the scheduled pickup time and no one had even started the order or noticed the ticket. Five minutes later found out some of the items on my order were not available. At that point I asked to refund the order which they were unable to process. I suppose we'll see if the refund goes through after the owner processes it as promised or if I have to dispute the charge. I'm not holding my breath. read more

Lovely little spot in Old Towne Eureka for a Nibble. The bakery items are not to be missed, and the people who work here are as sweet as the cakes. They serve lunch, and dinner too !! read more

Super cute atmosphere, friendly staff and delicious! Assortment of yummy bakery items.

So many delicious confectionary treats! The shrimp and grits is delicious. Great cocktails and atmosphere

The red velvet cupcakes were so to die for that I ordered an entire cake for my daughter's first birthday. I should have stuck with the cupcakes because the cake was so dense, it wasn't too enjoyable. But overall, every other sweet we've tried has been delicious. Placing my order was incredibly easy and I was happy to support local. read more

All of Sarah's food is AMAZING!!! Sweets, breakfast, and even dinner food is absolutely delicious. I highly recommend this hidden gem!

Absolutely the best. Food is fresh, authentic, and delicious. Manager and bartender Stephanie is the best there is. Drinks and bakery items are absolute perfection as well. It's our favorite place in Eureka! read more

Food looked great staff was friendly, but it took 35 minutes for us to finally ask about the only two things we had ordered, only to find out we'd have to wait another 10 minutes. Staff handled it great and they didn't charge my card, much appreciated but if you are in a hurry do not go here read more

I love supporting small biz but I just visited this shop in Eureka and was told nobody could write happy birthday on a cake for my mom today. I bought the cake but was told a "decorator" was not in because it was too late in the day. Anyone can attempt to write happy birthday on a cake but oh well. Disappointed. I still wish you guys the best. Take care. read more

My favorite place for brunch with a friend! Great coffee, great food, great atmosphere! I love the healthier menu items.... and my kids love the glitter bites! Lol! read more

Enjoyed Taco Thursday at Sarah's today. My dad lives in Eureka and had been before, but this was my first visit. Ambience, service, food quality, and prices were all exceptional. Not sure why they don't offer tacos for lunch every day, but it seems they're only available for lunch on Thursdays. Definitely worth stopping in when you're in town. I'll be back next time I'm in town too. read more

I love this cozy cafe for food, coffee, or desserts. I'm always thrilled to find they keep a couple gluten free goodies available. The staff is particularly pleasant and attentive. read more

I had to order 7 dozen different cupcakes for an event. They were all amazing. Love the salted caramel, wedding cake and Smore's! The store is cute too! read more

See all

Great food but very laid back. As in make sure you are going to sit back and relax. Service is slow but the staff are nice and the treats at the counter are amazing. read more

Staff is a little incongruous with the sweet atmosphere. Some focus here would really shift the vibe and improve this gem of a spot.

I love their food and bakery treats. Unfortunately, they raised their prices considerably. My coworkers and I love coming here for lunch but we were there recently and I got a black bean burger with a side salad and an iced tea and it was $20. That is very high for a lunch in my opinion. We are all very disappointed because this place was our go-to. read more

the food was good but we had issues with the manager. Our waitress was really sweet but she forgot to put my mother in laws order in and it was 20 minutes late. It already took us an hour to get our food when it wasn't that busy. My chips were stale and by the time we got our food it was cold. We asked if her meal could be taken off and they gave us trouble. The manager at lunch time was very rude, she was rolling her eyes out us and ended up talking bad about us where we could see her to our waitress. read more

This place is absolutely amazing! The staff is wonderful too! They make the best food hands down, I've never gotten a bad item off their menu! They never disappoint. The bakery items are so delicious and it's such a treat for the entire family! read more

My mother and I went into the bakery yesterday and the workers were extremely sweet and friendly ... but we bought a dozen cupcakes and a cookie and were greatly disappointed... The aesthetic was there but the flavor wasn't ... the cakes weren't moist or flavorful... all we could taste was the icing ... we wasted $40 on cupcakes there for 1 dozen .... save your money go to a real gourmet shop.... we honestly preferred Walmart's cake over there's . But service was very friendly read more

Love the atmosphere and breakfast. I always get the skinny Sammy. Yum! The lavender flavor for coffee is different and delicious. Wish they opened earlier though so we could go on the way to work. read more

A number of problems: line to order was so long, they never informed us that they had switched from breakfast to lunch. The chai was sickeningly sweet, tasted like it came out of a gas station machine. Coffee was weak. Prices were high, for a small town. Not a great experience, but only one a few options if you're seeking to avoid fast food. read more

First impressions is important. My wife and I stopped in for lunch after church and they were out of chocolate cream pie that was a special. Out of potatoes for breakfast, plain chips and the ice dispenser was out of ice. The BLT sandwich was good. It appeared the chicken salad sandwich was made with dark chicken and we found a bone and did not have any grapes. Potato salad was dry. The sweets were very good. read more

While in St. Louis, one food item to try is the Gooey Butter Cake. It's hard to describe. It's kind of custard based, like cheesecake. Sweet but not too much. Perfect with coffee. The shop is a dessert bakery that's also a cafe. Friendly staff and a nice small town feel where everyone knows each other and they make you feel like you are part of that. read more

This place was absolutely amazing. The workers were very pleasant and accommodating. The decor was cute and made you just want to chill with a cup of coffee and relax. They have a wide variety of food and I was not disappointed in any of it! I had the turkey panini with the side of the week which was a tomato and cucumber pasta salad. They had several different desserts and even gluten free options. I tried the macaroons, they are DELICIOUS! Beautifully decorated and had amazing flavor. My boyfriend ate a cinnamon roll and it was the perfect texture crunchy on the outside a bit gooey in the middle and full of cinnamon! They even have a selection of coffees each unique with flavors. Definitely not disappointed in this place and will definitely return! read more

Had a fantastic lunch with incredible desserts. Very friendly staff in a quaint setting. Cake pops are extremely moist, we will be getting a bunch to take home. read more

Sarah's on Central - Warm brownie sundae with vanilla ice cream - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eureka, Missouri

See all

Sarahs was very good. We love the downtown Eureka scene especially this time of year with all the fun and creative scarecrows everywhere during the scarecrow festival. All the same delicious baked goods you would expect from Sarahs but a full menu that has sandwiches and salads and I hear a Tapas menu on certain nights as well. read more

We searched on yelp for breakfast this morning and were not disappointed. We jumped off the freeway and even bought a birthday cake! We will definitely be back in the future. We came from Ohio and I loved that the biscuits had cornmeal in it. read more

Sarah's burgers are amazing! They have so many delicious options on the menu that the whole family can find something they like.

Wife and I just got done with dinner at Sarah's, awesome. Great food and cocktails. Never had a disappointing meal there. Awesome staff.

It took 45 minutes to get a basic breakfast. Nobody their working seemed to care as I stood by the cash register at the 30 minutes mark to ask about food and workers just kept walking right by me. During that 45 minute wait we had to ask for our orange juice three times to get it. After the long wait for the food my biscuits and gravy were stone cold, breakfast sandwich was cold, wife's pancakes came out no syrup and had to ask for that twice, and her danish did not come out and had to ask to bring that to us. Lastly it's self service coffee but most of the coffee containers were empty so could not really get a refill though I paid for a "bottomless" cup. For my first visit to Sarah's, it was also my last. On the way out I heard another customer state "why do I have to f$&cking wait 45 minutes just to get a breakfast burrito". Clearly it's not just me having this bad experience. read more

The Central Muffin is delicious!! The Crooey is a little bit of heaven! So glad we found this place today - will definitely be back!

Food was awesome. All the employees are very nice and helpful. If you love breakfast this is the place for you. Very pleased with my experience. read more