Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sammys Fish Box

    3.1 (1.1k reviews)
    PriceySeafood
    Open 11:00 am - 1:00 AM (Next day)
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Order Sammys Fish Box Takeout or Delivery

    Sammys Fish Box Photos

    SAMMYS FISH BOX ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Happy hour specials

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sammys Fish Box

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Donna L.

    Went to City Island and ate at Sammy's Fish Box. The food was good and the service was great. The only down side was it was crowded so the service was a little slow. But outside of that I would consider it a complaint just a observation. Our server made up for the slowness in performance and personality. I wouldn't expect anything else given the popularity of this place. Look at the portions they were well with it.

    Cesar Q.

    I haven't been to City Island since I was a wee lad and wifey had asked me about going up there and checking it out. First off, check out the wiki on it, it has a very storied history and interesting facts that go back before the American Revolution. Sammy Fish Box is about a 5 minute drive after the bridge going into City Island, there is a parking lot so do not fret. It's a huge joint inside with plenty of seating, host was very friendly. The place looks very sea-foody, super cool IMO. The menu is huuuge, so many different seafood combos with shrimp, lobster, calamari, fish and more. The waiter was very friendly and attentive. No complaints on service. I had a seafood combo with all types of shellfish, the shrimp were super meaty and good. I would for sure come back and try the different stuff on the menu. Bathroom was clean, was able to change my baby's diaper, no problem. If you never been to the boogie down Bronx and are a seafood fan like myself please check it out. Good luck if you're taking public transport as it is a mission, we drove a car. I know that has nothing to with the establishment but just know before you think about going!! Cheers!

    Roasted Whole Mediterranean Branzino
    Djinou J.

    The food here is massive. You'll get a plate of bread, garlic bread, cornbread, butter, veggies, and cheese to share. The actual seafood is just okay though imo. It looks better than it tastes. It was fresh and large but it didn't really have any flavor. I got scampi style shrimp and salmon. The fried jumbo shrimp was great. But the salmon was lacking flavor. The rice and pasta are both bland. I asked for peri peri sauce on the side and that helped a lot. If you like deep flavor and very spicy food, get it peri peri style. I came with a large group for a birthday. Everyone else agreed on the food. It was edible for sure, but nothing memorable. Very bland. The service is quick and friendly.

    Ebony M.

    Sammy's Fish Box is a treasure on City Island. The service and atmosphere is great. You cannot ask for a better, dining experience. The seafood portions are large, definitely great value for your meal. During my last visit, I had been away from the U.S. traveling in Countries wherein the seafood is freshly caught, and cooked the same day from icy, Nordic waters, so my tastebuds were very picky. I was not impressed by the taste of my seafood. Most likely due to growing up on seafood in New England you acquire a certain taste. My friends enjoyed their seafood, and were happy, they live in the Bronx and that's what their tastebuds are accustomed to. With that being said, give it try, you never know, you may enjoy.

    King Crab Legs & Jumbo Fried Shrimp combo
    Javone B.

    I meeeeean it's Sammy's. Bring cash because they don't take credit cards nor debit cards. The crab legs were incredible; seasoned to perfection. And shrimp were amazing. The portions are ok, they could be bigger. We sat outside and enjoyed the sun over the water, amazing views. I'm definitely going back next summer. But in all honesty, I could go in the winter but the vibes wouldn't be the same.

    Seafood paella

    We have been wanting to try this place for a very long time and made it out there today. We were so excited to try the seafood paella. When it arrived we were blown away by the size of it. It says it feeds two but it would be enough for a family! However, the dish was overall boring and flavorless. It didn't have any unique flavors and the seafood was a bit dry. For how excited we were, it was a huge letdown. Despite the food being disappointing, our server, Jeff, made up for the whole thing. He was friendly, attentive, and so kind to our whole family including our kids. He made us feel welcomed, and valued. I'm not sure if we'd make it back here. We wouldn't get that same dish, but would heavily consider returning because of the stellar service.

    Seafood Skewer
    LeeLee S.

    Went with a group, 2 of us had been to City Island before, for the rest of us it was our first time. First off, I just want to say, City Island is really cool, doesn't feel like you're still in New York. Sammy must be doing pretty well for himself, there are multiple Sammy's restaurants at that end of the island and they have five parking lots. I am not a seafood eater but the rest of the group is. They feasted. They all loved their meals. The amount of seafood on their plates was crazy. I had the cheeseburger which was ok, I think it might have been microwaved. I feel like restaurants like this don't really exist anymore. There is so much to look at on the walls, neon signs everywhere, big booths, old school Tiffany (inspired?) lamps hanging above each booth, balloons at the entrance which I assume they give to kids either coming or going. The drinks were pretty strong and on a Friday night, I appreciated that. I had two lemon drops which were tasty and did the trick. The rest of the group started with pina coladas and then switched to beer. Our waiter, I didn't catch his name was great. You could tell he has been doing this for a long time. We all had a really fun dinner there.

    Joey T.

    Wow, we were not prepared for the portions! Decent place, decent service, very good pina coladas. Ambiance is kinda tacky but cute.

    King Crab Legs & Jumbo Fried Shrimp

    I have been coming here since I was 6 years old and I am highly disappointed on how bad this place has become. To charge MKP ($160) for 6 shrimp and chopped up crab legs is Ridiculous!!! Prior visits they gave at least 8 whole Alaskan king crab legs with the fried shrimp and the price was less. When did this become a trend to chop up 3 crab legs, pass it off as if they are giving you more and damn near double the prior price!! Will NOT return here . Sad to see an establishment go down hill like this!!

    Melissa K.

    The service was excellent!! Jeff, our waiter catered to our every need. Every single staff was welcoming and friendly. My family took me for a graduation dinner and the staff gave me a balloons and a flower necklace to make me feel special. They went above and beyond to make sure I felt special.

    Bernie's birthday dessert.

    The food was great and the service was superb! We were celebrating my husband's birthday. The owner brought over balloons and at dessert they sang happy birthday with us. There were several other parties celebrating birthdays and it was a wonderfully warm atmosphere. I would just suggest that the cucumber salad be called pickled, because it didn't look like a salad. Everything else was delicious!

    Piri piri whole red snapper
    Jinn A.

    A feast! We enjoyed everything, from the complimentary bread, cheese and pickled veggies to the seafood which was fresh and delicious. Service was efficient and our head waiter, Nacho was considerate and attentive. Restaurant was busy but there was no wait and plenty of lot parking on an early Saturday evening in August. The Focus is on the food because there is no ambiance. Sammy's has primarily indoor seating and has limited views of the water. Outdoor seating can only accommodate small parties. Indoor Decor is dated and kitschy. They crammed in as much seating as possible so it feels tight. Vibe is family feast not romantic dinner. Enjoy!

    Baked Potato

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of A M.
    2
    25
    69

    2 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    2 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 4
    Love this 5
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 30
    Thanks 10
    Love this 19
    Oh no 6

    5 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    28 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    20 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    4 months ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 2

    2 months ago

    The food the ambiance it's #1 in city island , now i understand , very well , usually one pays for what one gets..sammys fish box is #1..

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Melanie K.
    103
    53
    10

    3 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jinn A.
    86
    62
    20

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Eric W.
    2657
    833
    3540

    2 years ago

    Helpful 8
    Thanks 0
    Love this 11
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tamika G.
    45
    86
    657

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    The food is Absolutely Excellent; But, a bit on the Expensive Side! The Service is Quick and Attentive. The ambiance is Cozy and Inviting.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    The place and food is average. Gets very busy so plan ahead to wait. Kind of expensive for average food.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 2
    Love this 7
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 9
    Thanks 6
    Love this 0
    Oh no 5
    Photo of Erik T.
    100
    193
    476

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Zuri D.
    0
    16
    21

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 2

    Page 1 of 29

    Ask the Community - Sammys Fish Box

    What Covid health precautions are in place?

    The employees were wearing masks and the tables were not seated on top of each other.

    Why time do they close on Thursdays for take-out?

    I believe around 1-2am. I would call to be sure

    Does all Takeout Orders come with the complimentary bread platter and salad?

    yes

    Where is the parking area?

    Parking lot is adjacent to the restaurant. Parking is free with validation from waitress.

    Do they accept Amex?

    yes

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 22,101 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Johnny's Reef Restaurant - Fried Smelt

    Johnny's Reef Restaurant

    3.9(752 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    Honestly, I miss the old owners of this restaurant. Since the people have changed, they've changed…read morethe recipe for the batter on the seafood, they also have changed the fries , and worst of all THEY CHANGED THE TARTER SAUCE RECIPE! It tastes like mayonaise now, and that broke my heart. I just want the good food spots in the Bronx to remain that way. The food is definitely not as good as it used to be.

    The only reason I came out this far was for this. City Island and Johnny's Reef. This is not a spot…read moreyou just happen to go to, it takes planning, preparation, saving and probably some fasting. I go all out when I come here becuase it's fast seafood at it's best, steamed, raw or fried. You order at the counter for things you want, so plan your order with friends so you can get what you want all at once. Send one to get the fried's, one to get the steamed, raw, etc. It looks like any seasonal shack on the eastern seaboard, but just a tad busier and a tad nicer. Service is good becuase it's far enough away from the NYC grind that people aint tryna bring that vibe. They're trying to have a different experience. It's got great views. Cash only of course. Seating is cafeteria style. I usually have to go for a walk afterwards to help digest everything. Prices are high if you indulge or come with your whole family, but it's kinda in line if your tryna splurge and go big. My usual order is steamed snow crab legs, fried calamari, fried clam strips, steamed cherry's and little necks (or raw if it's daytime or late summer) and a steamed whole snapper if I'm with more than 1 person. It's a feast, but worth a gout attack. It's fresh seafood that's well prepared and simple. You can't go wrong on the cocktail sauces, butter, lemon on most items.

    Photos
    Johnny's Reef Restaurant - Johnnys Reef

    Johnnys Reef

    Johnny's Reef Restaurant - Piña colada

    Piña colada

    Johnny's Reef Restaurant - Close up of the fried fish

    See all

    Close up of the fried fish

    City Island Lobster House - Raw clams

    City Island Lobster House

    3.7(882 reviews)
    1.3 miCity Island
    $$$

    It's been years since I've been here. I'd forgotten how great the food is and service is…read moreimpeccable. Friends took me here for my birthday and we had reservations at another place, but they "lost" them? All of us have been here before so we decided why not, and see what happens. The place was incredibly busy, we had about a 20 minute wait but it was worth it! Our server Robert was top notch. Professional and cordial. He Immediately came over with glasses of water, garlic bread, cheese and olive tapas, a house salad, and napkins. Tried the broiled fisherman's combo: shrimp, scallops, fish fillet, mussels, stuffed clams, lobster tail, and a side, I opted for linguini with garlic aioli. Everything was cooked very well and the presentation amazing and beautiful. Now here's something you don't see every day; an actual stuffed clam where the clam is still partially attached to the shell! None of that surimi crap! Finished the meal with a double espresso, shared a tartufo and cheese cake. I don't know if the digestif was complementary, but it was a nice touch. I don't know how the kitchen keeps up with the orders. The waitstaff must put a few miles on their feet a day and a cardio workout carrying the trays overflowing with food. Amazing! Everything in the restaurant is kept neat, clean, and organized. The music is not overwhelming. You can hear each other at the table. When the weather is a little nicer, they have beautiful outdoor seating with views of Long Island sound. It is very romantic, when the sun is setting, you can imagine yourself being somewhere exotic and far away. As the song goes; "Sometimes you don't know what you got till it's gone."

    I was here many years ago, and I wasn't impressed then but decided to give it another go…read more.. Some friends wanted to meet up for dinner last night, so my wife and I went to meet them. At 6:30, it wasn't busy, probably because there was a snowstorm the night before? We'd ordered The Seafood broil and a side of New England Clam Chowder. Yes, they brought out a (very generic) salad for the table, garlic bread (good - best part of what was served, honestly), and a (mediocre) 'antipasto'. The Clam Chowder comes, its tepid and so thick that the spoon is standing up in the bowl. Tasted it ("Has this been sitting since yesterday?"), and hard pass. Sent it back. They apologized, came back in 7 minutes with replacement bowls "we made it fresh". In seven minutes? It was warmer and thinner, but the damage was already done to my palate and phyche. "No thank you" *not even for free Of course, the plates come as that soup arrives - there's no room on the table, anyway. The main course was as disappointing as everything else: If you like alot of seasoning, a ton of breadcrumbs and grease - by all means, order that seafood broil! The two and a half inch lobster tail was the highlight, the shrimp wasn't bad - but the scallops, clams and all the rest were absolutely smothered in breadcrumbs, old bay and grease. We were looking for a replacement for (the now closed) Artie's. This ain't it. I'll spend the time and money to drive to Jordan's Lobster Farm in Island Park when I want quality seafood, I guess. I wish I'd taken photos to accompany this review, but I kept trying to salvage the evening and enjoy the company of friends I hadn't seen in awhile. Overrated diner with valet parking. Do better.

    Photos
    City Island Lobster House - Nautical Stop

    Nautical Stop

    City Island Lobster House - Lobster clam baked special

    Lobster clam baked special

    City Island Lobster House - View behind restaurant

    See all

    View behind restaurant

    The Original Crab Shanty Restaurant - Broiled scrod

    The Original Crab Shanty Restaurant

    3.6(943 reviews)
    0.7 miCity Island
    $$$

    The Original Crab Shanty on City Island is doing brisk business and most everyone in the restaurant…read moreis there for the Lobster Special, which, according to my friend who recommended the Crab Shanty, had disappeared from the official menu. My friend says he and his wife come here all the time and get the same thing. I brought someone here and we liked it very much and at $38, it's a good value. We walked in the nautically themed Crab Shanty and were seated quickly. Even though the Lobster Special had disappeared from the official menu, I understand it was always possible to order it and it was inevitable they had to bring it back out on the official menu. It comes first with garlic bread that you will devour. Next you have the choice of a salad or clam chowder and that clam chowder hits with the garlic bread. Then comes the main event with the whole lobster split lengthwise, two baked clams and a broiled or steamed shrimp. On the side you can choose fries, rice pilaf or baked potato. The fries were good, the clams and shrimp better and the lobster was great. The lobster is buttered and seasoned well. These are not jumbo lobster, but adequate for the price point. No one goes home hungry and the Crab Shanty goes easy on the wallet so you can return anytime. Service is good too. Four stars!

    Had an amazing time at The Crab Shanty today (4/12/26)! The food was on point as always--hot,…read morefresh, and consistently delicious. My sister went all in with the stuffed lobster loaded with clams and shrimp, plus a baked potato and New England clam chowder. I had the Mediterranean Baltimore-style crabs in garlic sauce with clam chowder and broccoli--absolutely . If you love whole crabs like I do, this is the spot. The drinks? Top tier. My sister had a Bloody Mary and Hennessy coladas, and I had an 1800 margarita--bartender definitely knows what they're doing! Only downside was the wait--about 45 minutes--but it was restaurant week on City Island, so expected. Honestly though, the "deal" wasn't much (just a free virgin piña colada or soft drink), so don't go expecting big specials. Overall, still my go-to every time. Great vibes, great food, and always worth it. I'll definitely be back!

    Photos
    The Original Crab Shanty Restaurant
    The Original Crab Shanty Restaurant - Broiled crab stuffed lobster, broiled snow crab legs/shrimp

    Broiled crab stuffed lobster, broiled snow crab legs/shrimp

    The Original Crab Shanty Restaurant

    See all

    The Black Whale

    The Black Whale

    3.9(228 reviews)
    0.5 miCity Island
    $$

    This has become one of my favorite spots. It is a trek up to City Island, but more than worth it!…read more I love their pan seared tuna especially with the seasonal veggies. It is always fresh and juicy. Combined with a glass of cold prosecco This last time I got the meatloaf, which was delicious. More of a Hungarian dish, which you can't get everywhere. The ambience inside and out is hip and for me nostalgic. My friend who's from Europe, couldn't get over how friendly Bronxites are! The owner and the other guests, were charming As I said there's more to New York City than Manhattan!!

    I stepped foot on the Black Whale for the first time to experience dining in the heart of City…read moreIsland- when I pass by, I have always being intrigued by it's charming and quaint look which makes the place have a pleasant and unique feel. Once you step in it you don't feel like you are in The Bronx. I chose to sit outdoors since it was a nice breezy afternoon and I felt enchanted by all the garden furniture surrounded by plants under trees. I ordered the pan seared sesame tuna salad and a passion fruit margarita and they were both very good. I also ordered a tiramisu for dessert which was also delicious. De-the server was very friendly, attentive and helpful at the time of ordering- I communicated that it was my first time at the restaurant and she made a few suggestions to assist with my choices. It is definitely a place worth trying.

    Photos
    The Black Whale - Interior

    Interior

    The Black Whale - Meatloaf

    Meatloaf

    The Black Whale - Passion fruit Margarita

    See all

    Passion fruit Margarita

    Jp's City Island - Salad

    Jp's City Island

    3.3(280 reviews)
    1.3 mi
    $$$

    A Delightful Evening at JP's Restaurant From the moment our…read moreappetizers arrived, I knew we were in for a treat. The garlic bread was absolutely divine--each piece bursting with the aroma of fresh garlic and infused with a silky finish of premium olive oil. It's the kind of bread that sets the perfect tone for the meal to come. The star of the evening was undoubtedly the stuffed flounder. This beautifully prepared fillet showcased the chef's skill, generously filled with succulent crab meat that complemented the delicate, flaky fish perfectly. Every bite was a harmonious blend of flavors that melted on the palate. Accompanying the flounder was a baked potato that deserves its own praise. Tender, smooth, and perfectly seasoned, it had a wonderful buttery texture that paired beautifully with the main course. I also indulged in the fried shrimp, which arrived golden and crispy. The accompanying sauce elevated the dish to another level entirely--perfectly balanced and expertly crafted to enhance rather than overpower the natural sweetness of the shrimp. The french fries were equally impressive: crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. JP's has earned a loyal customer in me. Every element of this meal demonstrated care, quality, and culinary expertise. Highly recommended for anyone seeking exceptional seafood on City Island. The views from our table were delightful as well.

    There's something about a restaurant with a quiet kitchen, absent aromas and diners on a Saturday…read morenight in a popular area that made me leery. What made me leave aside from poor service? The absolutely INSANE prices!!!! My guy and I were handed menus that were written over in pen with the most ridiculous prices ever!!!!! no words needed. We looked at each other and got up and left. If they are going out of business, they need to just throw the towel in, because overcharging people, not having professional waitstaff on hand, and the mystery of the quiet kitchen (which happened to be in the middle of the place and semi-open) was effing weird. We drove a few blocks down to another establishment and looked at the prices and knew that we were not losing our minds at JP's.

    Photos
    Jp's City Island
    Jp's City Island - This is very unhealthy with the amount of oil on it

    This is very unhealthy with the amount of oil on it

    Jp's City Island

    See all

    Sammys Fish Box - seafood - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...