It's kinda like a cafeteria setting so I wouldn't bring a first date here. BUT...it's a good place…read moreto go, when you're hanging out with family and/or friends. My buddies and I usually go every other week during the summer months. The best time is on Fridays...around lunch time and/or before 5pm. Only because the traffic getting into City Island can be a pain; PLUS Johnny's gets packed during that time as well.

I loved every minute!! From the riding through the cute…read moretown- to the free parking at Johnny Reefs. The service is quick but sufficient. The place is on the water and has nice fresh air. Food was fresh and underrated. Very very good food. Pina colada is a MUST!!!! Without alcohol is nice and smooth, but I found with alcohol was a bit too harsh lol I was only sad about seeing a new menu design. I was excited about seeing the old yellow sign lol

Food is amazing! Service was great and attentive…read moreAmbiance was very relaxing since I think we came after the morning rush. Early is better to find street parking. Cozy place so get a reservation. I look forward to going back.

Archie's Tap & Table is operating on an entirely different level from the typical City Island…read morerestaurant scene. This is not your standard seafood shack or casual neighborhood spot. The chef comes from the world of high-end NYC dining, and you can feel that experience in every detail of the food. There's a level of creativity, precision, and thoughtfulness here that honestly feels Michelin-worthy. This makes sense, because the restaurant has earned that recognition. Beyond the food, Archie's also has one of the best Scotch and whiskey (bourbon and rye included) selections anywhere in the area. It feels curated by people who genuinely care about food and drink, not just running another restaurant. We eat there often, especially for brunch, which is spectacular and consistently better than it has any right to be for a neighborhood spot on City Island. The best example of the attention to detail was the chopped cheese sandwich special. When it arrived, my first thought was: "How is anyone supposed to eat this giant thing?" But then you take a bite and realize the bread was custom made specifically for the sandwich. Somehow it completely melts in your mouth along with the meat and cheese, making this enormous sandwich unexpectedly delicate and perfectly balanced. It's the kind of detail most restaurants would never even think about. Archie's is a true hidden gem and proof that truly exceptional food can exist in places you wouldn't expect.

want to thank them for helping celebrate my Moms birthday they were great. Our waitress was…read moreamazing. they have a great lunch special. comes with soup or salad a main course and coffee with cake. Food was good. great portions. my lobster was very tiny but for the amount we got i'll let it go. they have a parking lot. prices are reasonable.

Everything was great! We had a big party of 20 people and as soon as we arrived there was a host…read moreready to seat us. What really made everything go smoothly was the waiter Fernando. Omg, he did an absolute amazing job. He brought out the food and nothing was missing. He was nice , sweet and funny. Kudos to him! The food was good and the prices were even better. We did go at around lunch time, so the prices were a tad lower. Definitely recommend this place! Stephanie

As you enter you order from the menu board- I ordered the $18.00 Whiting fish and French fries…read morew/pickle (under my fries- I was looking for it lol). You get one large Whiting and a bunch of fries - no complaints. I ordered a passion daiquiris $10 - was pretty good too. In Seafood City - cash only -you order and wait for your number to be called - service was quick. The place is a ranch style atmosphere with red - school lunchroom tables inside and on the outside. They also have a variety of other food options. It's definitely a family style restaurant with reasonable prices. I would recommend this place.

I felt like I was at the jersey shore with a twist. Seafood city is such a sweet spot in the heart…read moreof city island.. fast paced, out door seating, for families and friends just having a good time. I definitely recommend.

A Delightful Evening at JP's Restaurant From the moment our…read moreappetizers arrived, I knew we were in for a treat. The garlic bread was absolutely divine--each piece bursting with the aroma of fresh garlic and infused with a silky finish of premium olive oil. It's the kind of bread that sets the perfect tone for the meal to come. The star of the evening was undoubtedly the stuffed flounder. This beautifully prepared fillet showcased the chef's skill, generously filled with succulent crab meat that complemented the delicate, flaky fish perfectly. Every bite was a harmonious blend of flavors that melted on the palate. Accompanying the flounder was a baked potato that deserves its own praise. Tender, smooth, and perfectly seasoned, it had a wonderful buttery texture that paired beautifully with the main course. I also indulged in the fried shrimp, which arrived golden and crispy. The accompanying sauce elevated the dish to another level entirely--perfectly balanced and expertly crafted to enhance rather than overpower the natural sweetness of the shrimp. The french fries were equally impressive: crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. JP's has earned a loyal customer in me. Every element of this meal demonstrated care, quality, and culinary expertise. Highly recommended for anyone seeking exceptional seafood on City Island. The views from our table were delightful as well.

So disappointed in my meal today. I am an out of towner and have been here once before to celebrate…read moremy aunt's surprise birthday before she passed away in 2022. Unfortuneately I did not enjoy my experience. Prices were was overpriced for the quality of food. My fried shrimp had no seasoning and it was not even browned. Looked like someone just used a cheap cornmeal batter with no flavor. Baked potato was plain and dry. Salad was an iceberg style (no green leaf lettuce or spinach). No refills on drinks, not the best service, and just felt like we could have gotten more for our money elsewhere. Highly disappointed . Should have went elsewhere.

The food and service are excellent! I always love the ambiance! Loved the crab cakes and apple pie…read moredesert!! Yum!

This has become one of my favorite spots. It is a trek up to City Island, but more than worth it!…read more I love their pan seared tuna especially with the seasonal veggies. It is always fresh and juicy. Combined with a glass of cold prosecco This last time I got the meatloaf, which was delicious. More of a Hungarian dish, which you can't get everywhere. The ambience inside and out is hip and for me nostalgic. My friend who's from Europe, couldn't get over how friendly Bronxites are! The owner and the other guests, were charming As I said there's more to New York City than Manhattan!!

I came with some friends last week, it was our first time exploring the area, and we left this…read moreplace impressed. We came without a reservation; they made us cross the whole (huge) restaurant, probably three rooms, and then we were given a great, beautiful table that faced the water. We ordered a few plates to share, together with a few drinks. We had a BLAST!! Lobster tails, crab legs, pasta, mussels, shrimps. And the drinks were delicious! Our server was super attentive and available to help us out with anything. Pretty fast service too, given what we had ordered. And it might be the fact that we shared everything for the table, but it came out somewhat of a convenient price per person, too.

Warranted update. Summer 2026…read more In this day and age, it's difficult to know what type of service you're going to receive while dining out, it's such a gamble. On our group's recent birthday lunch, service and food were seriously lacking. -------------------------------------- A snippet of my conversation with the server. Me: "I will have the Lobster Bisque, please" Server: "Manhattan Clam Chowder?" Me: "No, Lobster Bisque" Server: "The white one? New England Clam Chowder?' Me: Oy vey! "No, Lobster Bisque" Server: "Okay, Lobster Bisque" Now that I think of it, maybe he was trying to warn me? As my "Lobster" Bisque was full on Tomato Soup. WTAF! Sea Shore doesn't serve Tomato Soup, so why is it in my bowl? I had two spoonfuls and asked for it to go. Mind you, I enjoy a good bowl of tomato soup, but I was looking forward to Lobster Bisque. After some thought, I threw the soup away. It wasn't worth my efforts to redeem. As for the rest of our orders, the consensus was the same, food lacking seasoning. Just a heavy dousing of flavorless Paprika for show. Your ordered meal should be prepared properly, especially at these exorbitant prices. The bill for 5.5 of us was just shy of $700.00, and 1.5 of us didn't have an alcoholic beverage. I'm fully aware of CI's prices, but generally we'll receive a more than decent meal to match. Poor service, mixed up orders, filet of sole sitting in a pool of water. I'm done! If the choice is Sea Shore for next year's first week of July birthday celebration, l will not be attending. And, I'll make my own Lobster Bisque. Thank you.

I always come to Tony's for a chill vibe and good seafood. Very fast service and cash only.read more

Food is not as good as I remember it being 10+ years ago. Just kinda average now. And I'm sorry,…read morebut no restaurant has any good reason (other than tax evasion), to still be cash only in 2026. It's ridiculous, especially at places like this where everything is pricey. Also, I can't believe they don't have any bike racks in the massive and ugly parking lot that blocks views of the river.