So disappointed in my meal today. I am an out of towner and have been here once before to celebrate my aunt's surprise birthday before she passed away in 2022. Unfortuneately I did not enjoy my experience. Prices were was overpriced for the quality of food. My fried shrimp had no seasoning and it was not even browned. Looked like someone just used a cheap cornmeal batter with no flavor. Baked potato was plain and dry. Salad was an iceberg style (no green leaf lettuce or spinach). No refills on drinks, not the best service, and just felt like we could have gotten more for our money elsewhere. Highly disappointed . Should have went elsewhere. read more

Jp's City Island - Iceberg lettuce- mixed green lettuce would be a better option. - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

There's something about a restaurant with a quiet kitchen, absent aromas and diners on a Saturday night in a popular area that made me leery. What made me leave aside from poor service? The absolutely INSANE prices!!!! My guy and I were handed menus that were written over in pen with the most ridiculous prices ever!!!!! no words needed. We looked at each other and got up and left. If they are going out of business, they need to just throw the towel in, because overcharging people, not having professional waitstaff on hand, and the mystery of the quiet kitchen (which happened to be in the middle of the place and semi-open) was effing weird. We drove a few blocks down to another establishment and looked at the prices and knew that we were not losing our minds at JP's. read more

*** 5,400th review *** My partner and I had a wonderful weekday lunch at JP's. We were some of the only people in the restaurant! We loved the water view, and they did a nice job warming up the restaurant despite the cold day. The lunch specials are a good deal, and you will definitely go home with leftovers. They certainly knock seafood out of the park, but I also had some delightful baby back ribs. Yes, the prices are higher than you might expect elsewhere, but I'm happy to pay the premium for the quality and exquisite, unique time. read more

See all

After lucking out on a rainy Father's Day fishing trip, we decided to get a consolation seafood meal. JP's photos look good so we went for it. We were the first customers through the door at 11am. Service was very friendly and we were seated with a nice view of the water. Being up at 4am we were starving so we went with the broiled combo for two. This came with lobster tails, fish, scallop, shrimp and baked clams. The clams were amazing. The set ran for 165$. It was a lot more food than anticipated. Food was great and the beer was cold, we would definitely return to try the other a la carte items. read more

Jp's City Island - Sonny's Broiled Combo for 2 - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

Service was good, Ambiance ok. I was very much disappointed with the food. For a place that boast about seafood authenticity, I was disappointed with my crab stuff flounder meal. While it was plentiful, the crab stuffing was approx. 99% bread stuffing. The crabmeat was non-existent. If you are going to charge such exorbitant prices, I do not mind paying as long as you are going to serve real seafood. The bill was hand written on a regular store numbered checkbook not even presented on a modern computerized print bill. The bill payment is all cash/zelle...go figure! I used the restroom and that had a sewer odor to it. Needless to say, I will not go back nor recommend this place! Folks you can spend less in city Island and get better or at least same type of food. read more

A Delightful Evening at JP's Restaurant From the moment our appetizers arrived, I knew we were in for a treat. The garlic bread was absolutely divine--each piece bursting with the aroma of fresh garlic and infused with a silky finish of premium olive oil. It's the kind of bread that sets the perfect tone for the meal to come. The star of the evening was undoubtedly the stuffed flounder. This beautifully prepared fillet showcased the chef's skill, generously filled with succulent crab meat that complemented the delicate, flaky fish perfectly. Every bite was a harmonious blend of flavors that melted on the palate. Accompanying the flounder was a baked potato that deserves its own praise. Tender, smooth, and perfectly seasoned, it had a wonderful buttery texture that paired beautifully with the main course. I also indulged in the fried shrimp, which arrived golden and crispy. The accompanying sauce elevated the dish to another level entirely--perfectly balanced and expertly crafted to enhance rather than overpower the natural sweetness of the shrimp. The french fries were equally impressive: crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. JP's has earned a loyal customer in me. Every element of this meal demonstrated care, quality, and culinary expertise. Highly recommended for anyone seeking exceptional seafood on City Island. The views from our table were delightful as well. read more

See all

So after many years of frequenting JP's Restaurant, I have to say that this afternoon was the last time. I had a birthday Luncheon for my spouse and the bill was over $1100. Fine. We ate and drank and enjoyed the meal. The waitress was informed earlier that some would pay via Zelle, and some cash, since this restaurant no longer accepts credit cards! Thats another issue entirely to itself. However, this waitress added meals onto the bill that were already paid through Zelle, and when we attempted to explain her mistake, her attitude and response was totally unacceptable. We paid the entire bill to the manager (JP) including the gratuity, and proceeded outside to the parking lot to say our goodbyes and take some group photos. Next thing we know, some other waitress comes running outside saying we owe more money! Whatttt! So it seems, this waitress of ours told the manager that we had underpaid and had not given any gratuity. That pissed me off! I personally walked back inside to straighten this out. It became a mini fiasco and to be honest, it truly hurt my feelings that JP did not even want to listen to what I was saying. This is the short version. It was obvious that this waitress was taking advantage of JP because he gave her another $100. He was too intoxicated to even see what she was doing....and he was not listening to me. I was patronizing this establishment when no one was coming there. The Lobster House always gets all the customers, but I stayed loyal. I've always "over tipped" the wait staff, but I guess being a loyal customer means nothing at this restaurant. Well they won't get another dime. I don't like how my guests and I were treated this afternoon. I'm never going there again. read more

This has been my Goto spot for many many years. I've always loved JP's. I went today for the first time since I moved out of the area a few years ago I was very disappointed. The food is just not the same. At least the prices are no lower. read more

JP'S!!!!! Y'all have lost your mind! 1st of all, take that tacky sign off of your door. I don't know who thought that was a good idea, but PLEASE. 2nd, your prices are insane. You do realize there are a thousand other seafood restaurants on the the island, right? Why would anyone eat somewhere, where you are charging $75 for shrimp scampy? $90+ for crab legs?!?! $25 for drinks? On City Island??? Guys, No. I left your restaurant after the 1st glance at the HAND WRITTEN, over priced food on the menu. I don't know what happened to you guys, but years ago this was a great establishment. I hope things get better soon. read more

My visit here happened early Dec 2025. Everyone should be sure and read the huge sign on the entrance door to the restaurant. It explains things clearly. And they did not lie. An entree could easily feed 2-3 hungry people with leftovers, if you add in the salad, bread and drinks before the meal. Maybe 4, so yeah, everybody needs to be good and starved out! It is pricey, but I felt my meal was worth it it. I had fried fish for a week afterwards. How many left-over fried fish sandwiches can a person eat? It was an early Saturday afternoon. no crowd no fuss, no muss. Service was excellent! No room for dessert. read more

Always a good time at JPs. A great quiet spot off the beaten path on City Island. It's been a favorite for many years - the food is consistently tasty. To start that warm garlic bread is yummy - today we shared the seasoned broiled whole lobster and fried Shrimp combo - paired with yellow rice- stuffed baked potato- Caesar & Italian salads - hot green teas - all was delicious! Service was terrific read more

Jp's City Island - Whole lobster - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

I arrived at JP's around 3PM on a Thursday, and it felt like I had the whole restaurant to myself--a peaceful pocket of old-school charm. My waitress Maureen greeted me right away with a bright smile and genuine warmth. She was not only friendly but very knowledgeable about the menu. I told her I wasn't in the mood for anything fried, and without hesitation, she recommended the flounder stuffed with fresh crab meat. She mentioned the stuffing was made in-house--and that sold me. I went with her suggestion, and let me tell you--I'm so glad I did. The dish arrived hot, fresh, and bursting with flavor. It took me nearly an hour to savor every bite, and when I finally finished, my plate was clean. Easily one of the best seafood dishes I've had in a long time. JP's is a true classic. You can feel the history in the décor--it's not your average restaurant. While you dine, you're treated to a soundtrack of timeless hits from the '60s and '70s, paired with a lovely view. The whole vibe is nostalgic, cozy, and unpretentious. Now yes--it's priced higher than most, but hear me clearly: you're paying for quality. This is flavor done right, not rushed. And honestly? Quality over quantity any day. And don't forget--tip your waitress. Folks like Maureen are what make places like JP's unforgettable. read more

Jp's City Island - Flounder Stuffed with Crabmeat Stuffing - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

First thing i have to say is wow just wow. the prices, through the ROOF! your telling me 75$ for a basic flounder and over 30$ for appetizers jeez(not big portions btw)! my grandmother asked for the check and she asked about how the food wasn't very good and could be better in a non violent tone. the owner then screams out saying "you don't know what good food taste like"embarrassing my family. the restaurant is not well kept, the restaurant only accepts cash, and has very blunt and just overall stupid signs for a restaurant. the signs were saying to look at menu before entering and how our food is better than everyone else's and if you don't like it then you can leave. service horrible. Whatever you do don't EVER go to this restaurant and if i could rate this place 0 stars i would! read more

I've been to this restaurant a few years back but wanted to check it out again on a Friday night. We were welcomed by the owner who was very attentive and nice. Our waitress came to us very quickly and took our drink order. The menu has a lot of options so you may need to time to order but the food was worth every penny. I just ate the rest today.. large portion and let me tell you my drink ?!!! Was amazing baby!! I felt a little buz buz! Definitely worth the $20. I had a blue margarita and my company had a Long Island! I enjoyed it and I just want to add.. Check out a place for yourself! I've been here twice and I don't have any complaints. read more

Jp's City Island - Stuffed shrimp and bake potatoe - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Consistent quality of food. I always get the broiled lobster- so full of flavor and fresh. I've been coming to JP's for many years with my family to celebrate birthdays, graduations or just to pass a relaxing Sunday. The view is the best of any City Island restaurant. The music is very laid back and relaxing. We always get a warm welcome from the owner who makes sure everyone is happy. Thank you JP's! read more

Had the pleasure of visiting this place again for my birthday today. Very very great food. I must say the food was great. I tried something new today which was the fried scallops and the fried lobster tail and the fried shrimp which came with yellow rice and a salad. My partner had flounder with linguine with red sauce. The food was wonderful. The waitress was great too. The lady name is Maddie. Mr. John the owner treated us very well and took great care of us. The ambiance is always amazing. Very nice decor and wonderful music. I love to come here for the king crab legs. Those are always wonderful also. I just like the food here...I look forward to visiting JP's again. Happy eating. Last but not least the red sangria is the bomb dot com. read more

See all

This has been my #1 spot on City Island since I was a kid. J, the owner, is always hospitable, and the food is fantastic. Whenever I'm on City Island, I always come here. You won't find another spot with fresh and delicious food on the island like JPs. read more

See all

Been coming there 4 years, take it the place need some serious decor updating, but that say nothing about the food & drink service are good!! We'll be coming back. read more

This is my go to spot when i want authentic seafood! This place never disappoints. The hot garlic free bread will have you coming back. The owner is so gracious and welcoming! I LOVE this place and visit every time I travel from Georgia to New York! read more

Having been there many years ago, I decided to go back. What a mistake! The restaurant smells moldy and looks old. My friends and I went in and one went to use the bathroom. while we perused the menu, we decided to leave as the prices were ridiculously overpriced. As we left, we got yelled at for using the bathroom and not ordering. NEVER GOING BACK!! SO RUDE, SOOOOEXPENSIVE! read more

Okay of all the years I've done City Island I have somehow missed this Gem which was on point the staff and owner John were super attentive (in part due to my friend being a regular). The portions were more than enuff and the cocktails were nice and strong. And sadly due to great convo a couple of drinks in didn't gets pics of my seafood platter shared with my girl pal. Sonny's Broiled Combo For 2 Shrimps, flounder, scallops, baked clams, and 2 large lobster tails served with a potato (for me) and rice (for my girl) 2 salads and peas (which the menu as a whole could do without). I will definitely be going back and get pics of my food . Sidenote: Even on a rainy day the views were sweet. read more

See all

Where do I begin? Let's start with the main reason for my couple of visits, the view. This is one of the few places with an outside seating area with close up water views. JP's has been around longer than some of us were even considered a thought and has a large customer following despite the prices. I'll get to the prices in a sec. When you walk in its like you're stepping back into time, as this place is stuck in a time warp. 50s music playing in the background, random oldey-type chotskies littered throughout the place. Their mantra should be, if it ain't broke don't fix it and if it is broke don't fix it. No modern day upgrades happening here. The food. Big thumbs up for their Garlic Bread. This and a cocktail just sitting outside watching the water and the crows nest is more than enough for me. Carbs + Alcohol + View for the win! But to get the Garlic Bread you have to order a main. There were no Crab Cakes on the menu, so I opted for the Fried Clam Belly app. You don't see Clam Bellies on a CI menu ever, so that seemed a decent choice, size and price wise. The bellies were a portion of 12, with a thick, tasty batter. Accompanying it was a good tasting Tartar Sauce and wedge of Lemon to cut the fat. All and all it was a satisfying app, but after several bites became redundant. Not totally disappointing but nothing to really squeal or should I say yelp about. :) The prices here are exorbitant. I balked from sticker shock, but the surrounding tables seemed on board with the prices. The orders that passed us were extremely large. Like take home and feed your family again until they're full large. I can see the appeal but can't comment on the flavors. Would I come back again? Most certainly! For the view, garlic bread, a drink and maybe 6 Clam Bellies instead of 12. Four Star Tip: Servers were swift, friendly and professional. read more

See all

Dirty wine glasses food not appetizing ,won't be back ..,...... I could go on and on and on and on and on. read more

All I got to say was that this place is expensive but worth it. The menu warns you that this aint no cheap thrill so be prepared to roll them dollars out. the staff is attentive, the restaurant is low maintenance so don't come expecting it to be a 5 star ambiance. IF you in city island, come here don't go nowhere else. Get anything on the menu and I can guarantee you it will be a grand slam. The view of orchard beach was pleasant while I dined on my seafood. I can't wait to make the 1hr fish trek from Brooklyn to read more

Jp's City Island - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

Did not eat here but from first impressions alone- I would never. Firstly, I get it that parking is solely for the patrons of the establishment- noted. My family and I however, did not initially know this, were undecided about where to eat and parked here. Not 5 seconds after I parked we were stopped and told by someone also parking: "my man's, if you're not eating here, you can't park here" and "I'm just giving you fair warning". This man was apparently "part owner of this establishment" so hey, understood but sir, if you read this, as the owner of the vehicle you stated would be towed the BETTER way to obtain business would be to say "hey, your car can be towed if you park here and you're not dining here BUT why don't you all come in and see our menu before heading out". THIS is how you gain and keep loyal customers. Telling you we're undecided on where to eat, you could have easily made $$ with this attitude as we were a very large party. From his attitude and negative stance alone, I quickly drove my car out and looked for somewhere else to eat. Sad and hopefully a lesson learned. I can see why the parking lot was empty. read more

JP's is the best restaurant on city island hands down. The service is great and the food is delicious.

I visited this restaurant years ago and wasn't impressed with the food and/or prices. LOL. Granted I am not a seafood eater so I cant comment on their specialty. Some coworkers and I recently visited this spot to celebrate a colleagues retirement and we had a a great time. The staff were amazing and went above and beyond to accommodate our large group. I was very pleased with how attentive the staff was towards our loud azz group. The restaurant could definitely use some tender love and care in the overall appearance especially in the back area going towards the bathroom. The water pressure in the bathrooms wasn't the greatest. However, since we're still in COVID life, you have to be mindful that a lot of restaurants took some big losses and continue to support. The views are still beautiful and we saw people jet skiing and canoeing while we ate. Now to the food, I was much more satisfied with my meal that had some flavor and I enjoyed my leftovers even more at home that night. LOL I ordered the chicken parmigiana with linguine. No one in our party complained about their food and there were several dishes. We were given complimentary stuffed clams and oysters that everyone loved. I tried both and surprisingly liked the clams. Honestly, I think our group enjoyed the expensive azz drinks here more than anything else because everyone got louder, laughed more and we couldn't even take advantage of the complimentary bottles of champagne they offered. The majority of the group had rounds of Hennessy coladas and that killer strong island iced tea. Honey, I took a sip of a friends colada and immediately went back to my virgin daiquiri and water. Our freaking bill was half towards food and half towards drinks. LOL I would definitely recommend this restaurant for a large group dinner, it would've been nicer if the area for big groups was enclosed because we were getting stares from the other patrons due to the drunken laughter, LOL. Thanks again to the amazing staff! read more

See all

A friend recommended it and I never heard of it on city island, owner John recommended dishes and it was great . Melissa beautiful server read more

See all

My favorite City Island dining View. Wonderful sitting outside in all kinds of weather. Great portions.

When you go to JP's you get personalized attention by the owner who coordinates with the staff to provide the best service for his patrons. You don't see this kind of service anymore. The food is excelente. I had the crabmeat stuffed flounder. It's to die for. They give good portions. The frozen drinks are the best. There's private parking. You have choice of indoor or outdoor seating. Great view of the water. JP's is a hidden gem! read more

I understand & know that seafood is expensive but my husband and I came here for a nightcap and with the idea of getting a few appetizers to share, before we walked in there was a sign saying to look at the menu first and now I understand why.... The prices are insane. Again, quality seafood costs money and I have no problem paying for it but the cheapest appetizer on the menu were mozzarella sticks and they were $18 dollars......... what is the reason for that.... It's not seafood. Every other appetizer was the same price as the entrees.... Make it make sense!?? I'll give it to them that the portions are very big but an appetizer shouldn't be the same size as an entree therefore it shouldn't be the same price either... The lights are so dim, you have to use flash to see the menu which isn't for me. The best thing about this experience was the complimentary garlic bread. It was delicious. Our waitress was also very sweet but I will never come back here. The menu has a quote on there that says "real quality seafood costs real money" something like that, which I think is super tacky too. I don't think anyone would mind paying for quality seafood but the calamari weren't even quality... they lacked seasoning big time. read more

Jp's City Island - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

It gets no stars- my mother and I went to the wrong restaurant. You could tell something was off by the greeting from a guy in a dirty oiled stain shirt to the only ones in the restaurant. We thought, maybe he was a cook and had a long day, until.... We asked him about a special- he returned with a penny saver and all I could notice was his dirty long fingernails not to mention the fact he rubbed his genitalia before walking away. We got bad vibes and stated to the waitress that we were in the wrong place, it was then confirmed how much of a wack job this guy was. He started saying that the shrimp we are eating is poison and just started talking about dog food and fake food at the neighboring restaurant, the one we were supposed to be at. Rethink your choices when in City Island- go in there with care and ALOT of sanitizer. read more

Hard to know where to start.... Loved my Pina Colada and garlic bread, this isn't just good bread, it's special. Stuffed flounder, little clams with bacon bits, scallops, pasta calamari, jumbo shrimp, lobster tails, oysters, and on and on, it was a feast. It all comes quickly too. Sat outside and enjoyed the view. It's places like this NYC hides away but the locals know the deal! John is a great owner / host, will def be back to darken his doorstep again! read more

Jp's City Island - JPs view outside - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

All I can say is my food was good. I'd been to every restaurant in City Island and Jp's is still one of my favs. It reminds me of one of those type of hole-in-the-wall restaurants with banging food and drinks. My Mai Tai was really good and made well. Jp's is similar to some of the seafood restaurants you find in Long Island but closer to home. read more

Jp's City Island - Seafood Near Me - Bronx, New York

See all

JP recently had a delightful special last month. When I tell you the amount and quality of the food JP put on my plate was enough to feed 4 people. The chicken parmigiana was delicious! The fried shrimp wasn't mine but someone packed it up and when we opened the dish we did the happy dance! Sorry to my friend that never received his order of shrimp with fries! Yummy!!! Next time I will treat! read more

JP's is one of my favorites on City Island. John the owner always makes me feel welcome and takes care of me and my guests when I come. The portions of food are very plentiful. I love the sangria. Only sangria that comes close as being as good as mine. Lol! I know people complain about the prices. Yes the food does cost but the amount you get is enough for 2 in 1 meal. People also complain the decor is dated. Looks dirty. I agree they should invest and upgrade/change some things but the ambiance is just a damn good time. Every time I come it's a blast. And the old school music is right up my alley. I love it read more

See all

JP's food is fresh and delicious. I came here for my birthday it was a nice cool day so we decided to take a table outside. The waitress and the bus boy were excellent. Excellent service to go along with fresh tasty seafood. I ordered the whole lobster and the fried shrimp and I received exactly what I was expecting. The lobster was broiled , seasoned and cooked perfectly (not rubbery) For my drink I ordered the Mai Tai everyone can't make a Mai Tai but JP's Mai Tai was a perfect blend. I can't wait to come back again. read more

See all

The owner and waitress super friendly. Went at 1 pm on a Monday. The place was empty and stayed that way for hours. Right before I left, two more couples came. The salad was stale and the crab stuffing for my lobster had no crab. All breading. And the place was filthy. From the seats, floor and even the windows. It's time to renovate the place from top to bottom. Until then, I won't be back. read more

I love coming here! JP is extremely personable and makes sure we are happy. Last time we came we got free shirts which was awesome. Honestly, I've ditched many of the other restaurants because of this excellent customer service and fresh food! Ohhh and the drinks are awesome!!! read more

See all

they have a sign that basically tell you if u have no money dont buy because there are cheaper places on city island, service was horrible, over priced, servers dont clean the table after your done, the restaurant smelled like a port a potty once you walk inside, food was horrible. i highly do not and i mean do notttttt recommend read more