Sal's continues to be my " go to" locally for great pizza. It's as close to the NY / NJ pizza I grew up with around. Slices in the restaurant are THE best because the crust gets extra crispy when reheated ! They've been in town for many years and never a surprise - just consistently delicious pizza, grinders and paninis!! If you order pizza for take out ask for it well done. THAT is my little secret. read more

See all

Best local Pizza around. nothing fancy, but flavorful with generous toppings. It's our local spot when pizza is what's for dinner! read more

Pretty good pizza. NY style. Good sauce and cheese. Crust was a little rough, but overall, it was a good pizza after a day of sightseeing. People were friendly and its one of those mom-and-pop shops that you're happy to go to. read more

See all

Went for second time. Had an amazing Grinder and great dinner, and the breadstick order was superb. Sal's is the best in my opinion just so good. read more

Always lovin this local Italian mom & pop VERY affordable restaurant! They are SO good to us every time we stop in! It's a great satisfying homestyle meal, or get a slice. Sal's always here manning the ovens himself. Perfection every time! Tonight I got a personal Sicilian pizza for only $8! Check out my pics for the deets. It's all good here! Thank for reading me & happy healthy yelping! read more

See all

Loved their pizza. Just had the eggplant grinder. Not good. So sad - I was so looking forward to it.

Great pizza! I love the mannicott dinner. The sauce is perfect. They also have grinders on fresh bread. Yummy and definitely Italian!

Amazing service! The workers there were extremely friendly, the pizza was amazing! 10/10 would 100% recommend for anyone planning to have a group of people eat at the same time read more

I live right up the street from Sals. Fantastic soups, great pizza, nice dinners, beautiful salads. I've never been disappointed . Fair prices. Very clean read more

I am sitting here at Sal's looking for my prior review and strange though it be, it appears I have never reviewed it. How can that be? Great thin crust AND Sicilian pizza, fresh salads, perfectly cooked pasta, and the best home style parmesans around. Sal cooks it all himself and looks like he was born to be in a kitchen. 5 booths and a few tables, usually filled with families. Many regulars since Sal seems to know them all. A little over a dozen "gourmet" pizzas or build your own. Delicious fresh salads, stuffed bread, paninis, calzones, subs, and "homemade dinners." I've sampled much of the menu and loved it all. They do seem to do a lot of take out but amazing service. Love this place. Over and over again. read more

See all

I can't speak for the pizza but I can speak for the service and dinners. I had the eggplant parm and my son the chicken parm. They were both delicious and included a house salad and bread. The sauce that was served with the meals was so good. It was nice and fresh tasting. Service was friendly and attentive. I would go back. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

I took out a small Sal's house special with anchovies. I am having anchovy after 14 years, I forgot the fact that I never liked anchovy. But apart from that it was a nice pizza. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sal's house special with anchovies - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

Great every-time. We love the pizza and the salads. Would highly recommend sals as a go to place

I ordered Sal's Pizza last evening to satisfy the unstopped hunger I had been receiving. This pizza certainly satisfied these unruly cravings of mine, but I have some comments and concerns that I wish to address in this review: 1. Over the phone; they told me I can put bacon on "virtually anything", and then preceded to hang up the phone when I requested it be put on the soda I had ordered. Later, we got the bacon problems sorted, but I was still unsatisfied. 2. when the pizza was finally delivered, I consumed it in record pace, but the meat left more to be desired; it was flaky, overly sweet, and tasted like if someone drowned a baby in olive oil. My 3rd and final issue with this pizza is that it gave me an aura that I can only describe as despicable. The pizza was subpar and I felt insulted when consuming it, but all in all I would recommend it to those who want subpar pizza. 3/5 Would recommend. - Loe Granola read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

Great Pizza place. We were traveling to Boston from NYC and needed lunch. So we Yelped and got off the road. Sal's is wonderful. Nice establishment and good food. And all at great prices. I had an antipasto salad (medium) which was big. Had lots of salad, veggies, meat and more. I also had to have a slice of pizza to go with it it. Excellent choice. We also had a Chicken Parm sandwich (yummy) and a Chicken Pannini. Wonderful. The food is really good. The staff a delight. I wish this was closer to me I would go at least a few times a month. read more

See all

I appreciate generosity, but when I ask for mushrooms, I don't mean I want an entire mushroom farm dumped on there. I couldn't see the cheese through the mushrooms, which were stacked on other mushrooms. Other than that, their pizza seems pretty good. read more

My three year old review still stands. I guess Sals is just five minutes too far away from me to go back on a regular basis or something? Gonna have to change that. Went back for the revisit and it was still quite good. Hmm, theres baked ziti here... puts it on my to do list. read more

We stopped in after grocery shopping. The food was really good. We got the veggie pizza and kids pasta. Service was quick and pizza did not disappoint. Cleared my cravings! Pricing overall was not bad either. But it's not much of a sit down place. If you want to eat there it'll be fast and delicious but it's set up for takeout. Nonetheless will be back for sure. read more

First time ordering from Sals.Ordered a medium cheese pizza,new York style and it was outstanding, one of the best pizzas I've ever had, service was also excellent . They have a new customer read more

Connecticut is know for their New Haven style pizza. But being from NY, at times i crave NY style pizza without the drive. Sal's is a hidden gem i stumbled upon. Inside is the feel of an old school NY pizzeria. Eating a piping hot slice of cheese pizza on a cold december night hit the spot so well. This is a solid spot for NY pizza; dont bother with frill toppings like Hawaiian or BBQ. Keep it simple with cheese, garlic, or pepperoni. read more

Sal's is an oasis in the pizza desert known as northern ct. I've been totally enjoying the pizza at Sal's for over ten years. If you're jonesing for an authentic NYC pizza, this is the place. Remember one topping only you know the rules. I look forward to reading your comments. Now go eat! read more

I love Sal's pizza. The dough is amazing and chewy with a nice golden crust. The texture is thin but not too thin. I love the little bubbles that rise up in the oven and lightly browned. The sauce is my favorite no one else makes a delicious sauce like Sal. I have been going there for years and I used to get the slices for lunch but then I decided I wanted leftovers for dinner or another day. The slices are really a good size and filling but now I just take my time and enjoy eating every single bite. The garlic knots are a good appetizer and the salad can be adjusted for the items you want on your salad. I have had the pizza with roasted red peppers and occasionally other veggies but I really prefer to enjoy the pizza flavor which is the best just as it is delicious. I have also had the cannolis which are very tasty and fresh. Aa read more

Still searching for the best pizza around. After seeing a local post of this being a local favorite we had to give it a try. Garlic knots were good, but nothing to go crazy for. Not very garlicky, which was a miss for my family. More like dough knots with a drizzle of garlic oil. Pizza was ok. Crisp crust, but very doughy and chewy, not thin and crispy like NY style as it's claimed. Not enough sauce, nicely seasoned though, just wished there was more. Very cheesy, but something was missing. Like I said, not a bad pie, just not "the one" for us. The search continues. read more

NY style pizza is Perfection. Grew up there and it's the best I've had since leaving 20+ years ago. He's also a sweet man! read more

The pizza by the slice sign brought me in. They have booths up front and tables in the back. I ordered 2 plain, but they had other options. The slices were a good size and very tasty. The menu had a nice variety. Everything from Antipasto to Manicotti and even something called pizza pops. I did see a gluten free pizza option for those that need. It really seems like a nice place. Most that came in addressed Sal the owner and pizza maker by name. I would definitely recommend. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

This is an older time favorite, haven't been here in forever. The pizza is still good, Sal is a craftsman who works in the art of pizza. He uses Bread, cheese and sauce and makes edible masterpieces. I got the grilled chicken pizza, definitely worth the trip. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Small Grilled chicken pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

I've lived in South Windsor for nearly a decade and I'm ashamed that I'm just discovering Sal's Pizzeria. You ever find a great pizza place and get a little bored, but refuse to try somewhere else because you fear getting a bland pie? I suffer that affliction. I'm terrified to try somewhere new because it might suck. I'm glad my wife latterly dragged me here. It was a great experience. We dined in and order a bunch of stuff from the menu; pizza, antipasto, pasta and meatballs. I liked my serving of antipasto, though my friend would have liked more flavor. My daughter told me the meatballs reminded her of my homemade ones and I take that as a compliment. We ordered a large pepperoni pie and it came out screaming hot. One nice touch they had was refrigerated grated cheese. Clearly it was not the pencil shavings of other places. The pizza was very thin with a crisp crust. The sauce had a tang and there was just enough cheese. This is one of the best in the region. The dine in experience could have been better. It was very warm and clearly Sal's focuses mostly on take out, though our server was very friendly. We did have regular silverware but everything else is paper. We are lucky in South Windsor to have multiple amazing pizzerias. I'll be back here and we will have to do some pizza rotation. read more

I love Pizza by the Slice places, and Sal's is definitely a great place for that. Most places try to just pump out as many slices as they can, to have a high turnover rate, but Sal's takes time with their slices, and you can tell by the way it tastes. I got a pepperoni slice, and a cheese slice. My OCD immediately kicked in, because the slices weren't cut in the shape that we're all accustomed to. (You will see what I mean). The bread is definitely the star of the show at Sal's Pizza. The pizza overall tastes good, but the bread is just so fluffy, and delicious. Definitely give this place a try! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

Sal's was fantastic. I have to say they have the best 10" Calzone I've eaten anywhere in the US. Everything was fresh and the service good. Lots of leftovers for dinner so don't let your eyes take you to the 12" calzone, lol! It was a bit warm due to the outside temp and the ovens inside so would suggest turning up the AC. Thanks Sal for a great lunch! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Counter area - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

Best pizza I've had in CT. Frank Pepe's is so overrated and Sal's is real traditional NY pizza. Makes me feel like I'm back in NY. 10/10 read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Onions, Peppers, Pepperoni - Sals pizza is the best and just as good if not better then any NY pizza - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

See all

I came here to try the famous Sicilian and I wasn't disappointed. The pizza was so tasty and delicious. I ordered the personal size to dine in and another order to go. The place was clean, quiet and spacious. The girl taking the orders was very friendly and helpful. I will definitely try this place again! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sal's Sicilian! - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

See all

Hands down the BEST New York style pie you'll find! I've been going to Sals for 20 years. Go there for the pizza, try the other menu items, you won't be disappointed- especially when you're treated with kindness and warmth read more

Got a large cheese pizza to go, I had wished we didn't.... Cheese was very soupy and just made a mess. Pizza is very floppy, doughy and chewy. Comparable to big y pizza. First and last time trying sals for me read more

Are you frikin kidding me?? I've had wings over 24 years, from Boston to LA and NEVER had wings as good, juicy and full of meat as these. I've also worked as a bouncer in a high end establishment. These wings beat them all hands down! I took a chance and got 36 my first time. What a win! Boooo, frikin ya! Try em. I guarantee you will be impressed and have a new spot for your partaaays. read more

Had a chance encounter with Sal the other night as hubby and I were leaving the neighboring sushi place next door. There was a power outage that affected most of the shopping area except for the corner where Sal's and the sushi place are located. It was late - closing time, and Sal was standing in his doorway. He called out to us, commenting on what a lovely evening it was, an evening for lovers. How romantic! About that same time a group of young folk drove up and asked Sal if he was still open and if he had some slices. "I was just thinking about closing, but sure, come on it." (Imagine this all said with a fabulous Italian accent - charming and perfect!) I said to myself right then and there, I must come back and try a slice from Sal. Yesterday we were out exploring our new town (just moved here a week ago from the NW) and I had a grumble in my tummy saying "FEED ME"! Patience, dear tummy. I will stop at Sal's soon to satiate the inner beast that is my belly. Arrived mid afternoon at Sal's and was greeted by a friendly woman (Sal's daughter? wife? cousin?); Sal was in the kitchen manning the oven. I ordered 2 slices, just cheese. Simple. A couple minutes later two large slices arrived at our table, piping hot and on a paper plate. A little sprinkle of oregano, a dash of pepper flakes, and a healthy dose of garlic powder - delish! The crust was thin and crisp on the bottom, the sauce was pure tomato (maybe a tad sweet for my personal taste, but the garlic and oregano compensated for that), and there was a generous topping of cheese. Nom, nom, nom! Only took about 20 minutes to make my belly happy, and (with tax) was less than $5.50 to feed two. Service was excellent and supper friendly. On a side note, there was a grandmother and her grandson also dining while we were there. The kid LOVED their pizza. This place is a most for families. You're kids will be part of the clean-plate club. I look forward to my next visit! Thanks, Sal, for the good pizza slice-a! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Slice of cheese. - Pizza Near Me - South WIndsor, Connecticut

we hadn't ordered from here in some time but aftervreading mostly positive reviews figured we'd try again. Ordered cheese pizza and wings. Both underwhelming. Pizza was not crisp, cheese melted but pale and not enough sauce. Wings were ok. read more

Ok but the garlic knots.....didnt know I was missing these garlic knots in my life but I was and so happy I have found them. If you trying Sal's for the first time, get the garlic knots. You won't regret it. Also all of the food I have tried so far has been great. Pizza, pasta, stuffed shells, cannolis, all amazing. But, the garlic knots....I am ADDICTED read more

Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon and had a side salad and a personal sicilian cheese pizza. Salad was average with fresh iceburg lettuce , cherry tomatoes, cukes, green peppers,red onions. Italian dressing tasted homemade, very mild dressing. Pizza was one of the best I have ever had, probably in top three. Sauce was outstanding as was the cheese and crust. There is about ten booths inside and is very clean. I will definitely be back here again. Service was friendly and cook was also. read more

See all

The other reviews were spot on, except I screwed up and forgot to order garlic knots! It is a simple little place but the subtle details...a tasty, beautifully textured crust, nice mushrooms...just well done. First time, but I feel confident this is business as usual. Quality place. read more

Listen, Sal's is the closes I can get to new york pizza. It's fresh, saucy, cheesy, cripy thin and just hits the spot. I often like to drop by for a slice for a couple of bucks. Good folks that run the shop. A hidden gem that needs to be recognized more. Just check it out read more