Uhm do not sleep on Turnpike Pizza!! I am such a fan and I'm so sad I didn't know about this place sooner. Everything is just so delicious made with quality ingredients! I got their chicken parm grinder and I could not get over how great this was all the way down to the roll itself which I read might be made in house. I also love their garlic knots. Their dough is so flavorful. I will totally be back to try more items- their menu is so vast that anyone can find something they'd like here I'm sure of it! read more

Another pizza spot in the books! We ordered the Napoleon, which had fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, drizzled hot honey with fresh basil. This is a very small restaurant, with a few tables. Take out is recommended. read more

See all

I grab food from here all the time. I'm working my way through the menu and so far everything has always been delicious. The pizza slices are huge and perfect for lunch. I got my whole family hooked on this place. Staff is friendly and take out is always easy. read more

See all

This review is based on two grinders I've had here recently, so I can't speak for the pizza. First off, the size of the grinders are GIGANTIC - I couldn't even finish half of the first one, which was the Milano. This grinder was SO good - the chicken and eggplant were nicely crispy and the balsamic glaze added a nice sweetness. The second grinder I ordered a couple of weeks later was the Tuna Fish. I forgot to take a picture, but the portion of the tuna was more than generous and the vinegar added a nice touch. I was honestly impressed with how good the sandwiches were that I already plan on ordering again! read more

Turnpike Pizza - Milano Grinder - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

I Called in an order over the phone on a busy Saturday night. Staff was friendly and polite. We ordered a large napoleon pizza. It was delicious. After taxes and fees it came to about 30$. Pizza was yummy and I would order here again. read more

See all

Flawless experience. The food is amazing! I wanted to try out the grinders because I always loved them at pizza shops. Inside is small and is mostly set up for take out. But the service was great! They were quick and let us know how much longer we had to wait. They gave extra sauces as well. The food was the best part though. I would recommend a calzone and Philly cheese steak for sure. Everything was hot and crispy and made to order and I will definitely be making another trip here! read more

Turnpike Pizza - Calzone and Philly Cheese Steak Grinder - Grinder - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

I am a return customer of this establishment, and this past Saturday I experienced some of the most dehumanizing treatment I've ever encountered while simply trying to pick up my order. I was given a wait time of 35 minutes, which I respected. I arrived on time, walked in, and approached the counter expecting a normal pickup. What followed was anything but normal. There were three men clearly running the operation. One appeared to be the head cook, while the other two--dressed in plain clothes--were assisting with orders. One thing that immediately stood out was the head cook wearing black rubber gloves while touching everything--door handles, the phone, the computer screen--without ever removing or sanitizing them, then continuing to handle food. That alone raised concerns about cleanliness. I stood at the register for about five minutes and was completely ignored. Not one acknowledgment. For context, the restaurant is very small, and I am a 6'4 man--it is impossible to miss me. Directly behind the register is a bread rack, and one of the men--the shortest of the three--kept coming within arm's reach of me, repeatedly ignoring my presence. I could have physically touched him, that's how close we were, yet I was treated as if I didn't exist. After being ignored, I sat at a nearby high-top table. The three men continued preparing orders without acknowledging me. A DoorDash order was called, and someone came in and was helped once their name was called. Shortly after, another man walked in and was immediately asked for his order name ahead of me. At this point, I had already waited about 15 minutes past the promised pickup time and watched multiple people be acknowledged before me. I stood up, went back to the register, and firmly stated my order name. I received a few looks but no real action. While this was happening, another customer came in saying he received the wrong pizza. I asked if it might be mine. I was told no, and the box was quickly moved out of sight. When the shorter man returned, the head cook tried to speak to him about my order, but they were speaking in their native language. I then saw the short man put his hand up toward me in a dismissive way, as if to say I could wait. Without even looking at me, he raised his voice and asked if I placed my order online or over the phone. I had to confirm he was speaking to me. After I answered, he disappeared briefly and came back with what looked like the same pizza box that had just been moved. Suddenly, his demeanor changed. He became overly friendly--calling me "bro" and acting like nothing happened. I responded with silence. I was honestly too stunned to speak. Before leaving, I checked my order to make sure everything was correct. As I got into my car, the same man ran after me with a 2-liter Coca-Cola, saying he could "see it in my face" and offering it as a gesture. That's when I spoke up. I told him how unacceptable and disrespectful his behavior was and reminded him I had just spent over $60 at his business. He admitted I was right and started offering me "anything I want." He brought out a slice of strawberry cheesecake, which turned into two slices and repeated apologies. But the damage was already done. I made it clear this wasn't about free food. It was about how I was treated--as a paying customer and as a person. I reminded him that his business depends on people like me, and that behavior like that is unacceptable. I do not give him credit for trying to fix it afterward. It felt reactive and weak compared to the disrespect I experienced. However, I am glad I spoke up and made sure he understood how badly he handled the situation. I share this because I walked away feeling hurt, dehumanized, and racially targeted. That is a lot to feel over picking up pizza. No one should ever be made to feel invisible or disrespected like that. So I'll say this for myself and anyone else who has experienced something similar: F*CK that. Do not let anyone feel that comfortable disrespecting you. Sometimes you have to stand your ground and make it clear--you do not have permission to treat me however you want. read more

3.50 stars. Basically, 4 stars for the pastas, 3 stars for the pizzas, and probably 3.5 stars for the price. No matter what you order at Turnpike, it's going to be a generous sized portion. This is especially notable in some of their pasta orders like their veal piccata or chicken scarpiello. Both orders were absolutely massive and lasted me a couple of days. The pizzas have also lasted a few days but alas for a different reason. I love the level of customization for the pizzas. There are so many flavor combinations that other places would be afraid to try. For example, fresh lemon is served on the side for their shrimp scampi pizza. But the pizza itself just isn't my favorite. I guess I like my thin pizzas crispy and what I've found is the pizzas here tend to have a more chewy consistency. Overall, however, Turnpike is worth exploring. I'll probably try one of their glorious grinders on a subsequent visit. read more

Turnpike Pizza is the sleeper in the neighborhood. Really good pizza and terrific calzones. Always polite and smooth service, definitely go and give them a try. read more

They use Slice for delivery. We ordered, received messages from slice that order is delayed. Called pizza shop and they didn't get the order. I paid $70 to slice and can't get through to them. As far as I'm concerned It's a BS process and someone took my cash. read more

New favorite pizza place in the area. We ordered first time for my son's birthday party last month. Everyone loved the food. Awesome wings too! Have been back twice already. read more

So whatever you may have previously thought of or heard about Turnpike Pizzeria, it's time for a fresh look. As of a few weeks ago, they have new leadership, new food talent and a new menu. I didn't connect with Turnpike when they first opened in Newington and I hadn't been in years, but the recent changes had me curious. I visited this week for lunch takeout, and I'm glad I did. I don't remember having a strong positive opinion of the atmosphere when I last visited under the previous management, but I immediately felt welcome when I walked in this week. They had cool music playing. I was warmly greeted, and the crew took the time to tell me about their new direction and their background. (They share some DNA with Pietro's in Hartford) They also gave me a better view of certain things for my pictures. You don't get much better service for takeout. Turnpike has one long table that could seat about 6 people, but it is more of a takeout or delivery place. They have a counter area with heated slices such as cheese, pepperoni, BBQ chicken and Buffalo chicken. You can order whole pizzas, sandwiches, apps, pasta dishes and entrees. The new entree menu has good looking options. I ordered Chicken Tortellini in Vodka Sauce, and it came with a Garlic Knot and salad. The food was all good. The vodka sauce and marinara that came with the garlic knot were both well executed and tasty. The grilled chicken was cut into long thin strips, and it had good texture and was juicy. The cheese tortellini were good. And the dish was well put together. The garlic knot was more like a garlic fist. It was huge, pillowy and garlic-buttery. Even the salad was a step or two up from what you expect. More vegetables. High quality ingredients. The creamy Italian dressing was good. With one very good experience under this new team, I'm putting Turnpike Pizzeria into my area takeout plans. I encourage people in Newington and neighboring towns to try it. 4.5 Stars based solely on my recent experience with the new team. read more

See all

Ordered Italian parm wings. Described as "cutlet style". I have never had a cutlet, chicken or otherwise, with bones in them. Was excited for chicken parm but got soggy Buffalo wings drenched in cheese and sauce. Threw them away. The lobster shrimp rigatoni was good. A little strange as they gave you ravioli and rigatoni, which is pasta with pasta. And there were only2 shrimp. Vodka sauce was good though. read more

I've heard so many great things about Turnpike Pizza so I decided to try them out. Turnpike Pizza is basically a take out pizza place but they do have a couple of seats in the establishment. As I walked in the establishment, it was very busy as there were many orders coming in for take out orders. I ordered a small pizza with half Pepperoni and I waited about twenty minutes. As soon as I got my pizza, I opened it up and took my first bite. The pizza was crispy but the sauce was messing some flavor. It had the right amount of cheese and the pepperoni was good but overall it was just missing flavor. read more

See all

Turnpike Pizza is surprisingly our new go-to place for pizza. I was originally skeptical but these people are the real deal. The fire-kissed caprese delight pizza (Hot Honey, Hot Oil, Fresh Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Fresh Mozzarella, Balsamic) is our favorite, and I don't usually go for "specialty" pizzas. All fresh high quality ingredients. Other pizzas are good too. And it's nice they have other foods like quesadillas. read more

Been dying for a pizza with salad on top... used to get one in South Carolina of all places and this was perfect! Balsamic was the best part! read more

Turnpike Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Was looking to grab a Greek salad, and Turnpike Pizza's Greek Salad Pizza came up as an option. OMG this is amazing. New favorite read more

Turnpike Pizza - Greek salad pizza with all the topping. - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Everything was great including the dough that many have complained about. No complaints here at all. Enjoy! read more

So, so, SO many great things to say about Turnpike Pizza. The owners are amazing, and always serving some traditional and innovative Italian food with a smile. Noting that they serve both traditional and new creations is important, because if you're looking to try something new, I'm sure they have it. Their menu is wide - inclusive of salads, sandwiches, pizza of course, pasta, pierogies, nachos and don't even get me started on the desserts whatever you are craving, they are able to satisfy. So happy that Turnpike pizza is a staple in our neighborhood read more

See all

Recommended to try Turnpike Pizza on my recent visit to Hartford to see my college student. It is a very welcoming place and the customer service we received was top-notch, 10 stars! I ordered their famous garlic knots, which did not disappoint. Fresh out the oven and large in size. You taste the Love! Oh, and the amazing homemade marinara sauce, I could eat all day. Just the right ingredients and nothing overbearingly strong. Kudos to Turnpike Pizza! I will be back! read more

Turnpike Pizza - Famous Garlic Knots! Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

We heard Turnpike Pizza was getting good reviews after a change in ownership, so we decided to visit! Luckily we were the only ones planning to dine in because there was only one table - definitely a take-out business, but they still plated everything very nicely for us. I had never visited under the old ownership, but you can tell they recently remodeled and it was nice in there. The owner is so sweet, and it felt good to support their new endeavor. If I lived closer, I would definitely order takeout from here often! Everything was delicious! read more

See all

We ordered delivery and the food was awful. First off, I've never seen a calzone not come with sauce on the side (never). The calzone followed the rule of "if you can't cook, just load it up with garlic"! It was stuffed to the hilt with garlic and mozzarella, very little ricotta. I rarely complain about local restaurants because I love to support local people but this was awful. read more

This was my first time going. I got the garlic knot chicken parm slider. It was out of this world. My husband got the Italian combo grinder. He loved it. Can't wait to go back. read more

Turnpike Pizza In Newington CT Is Under New Ownership And Has Really Caught Our Eye! Not Only Are They Dishing Out New York Style Pizzas Made With The Freshest Ingredients- They Have An Entire Menu To Chose From As Well! Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner- They Have You Covered! I HIGHLY Recommend The Turnpike Frutti Di Mare, The Tortellini Ala Vodka, & Diavola Pizza! Even A Regular Cheese Pizza Is A Must Try! And Save Room For Dessert, That Was Some Yummy Cheesecake & The Cannoli's Were Pure Heaven! read more

See all

I have ordered a few times here before but last night i ordered half turnpike special with hot honey on the left extra (2.50) and half margarita pizza, The hot honey wasn't as drizzled as if I were to order the Napoleon pizza. It's def overpriced for what i paid for 8 slices. $36 for a small is pricey. read more

My kids love this pizza spot! We usually come on weekends and always get the meat lovers and veggie combo. Great for family dinners.

Pizza is delicious and the garlic knots are huge. I would recommend eating. The sitting area is more of a waiting area not to sit and dine in. read more

I got the salmon steak and cheese. The bread was definitely fresh it tasted as if it was just baked. The salmon grinder was very flavorful and I added aioli and broccoli to it when I got home. I think it would be really good if spinach as well. It comes with onions snd peppers and they are delicious. I always try to add more veggies to my food when I order take out. It's more of a take out place but you could sit down. I think there were two small tables. read more

Amazing pizza! We always get it to go. Or delivered and great toppings their supreme version is great and crust done golden

DELICIOUS!!! Definitely will order more from this place. The food was warm and very tasty. Wonderful job! read more

Our first time trying this place out. When you walk in the first impression is clean and welcoming. Music is blasting(which I love) and you get greeted by the staff. If you order ahead your order will be ready on the shelf next to the register which makes for easy pick up. We got the chicken, bacon, ranch which was pretty good. We did find some bones from the chicken on the pizza but not a big deal, couldve been some more sauce and chicken but flavor was good and the crust was amazing. Plain cheese pizza was great. Great cover of cheese and not to much sauce just perfect for a plain cheese pizza. Mozzarella sticks were good. I really like the marinara sauce that had chunks of tomatoes which I like and it tasted homemade and fresh. Overall a great place. We will visit again read more

See all

Was very happy to finally check out Turnpike Pizza. One of the most unique menus I have seen in a good while. We went with the 3X chared pepperoni pizza and Italian special. Both crazy good. And can't say enough about the huge garlic knots. Wow! read more

See all

Often times I find myself and family to want both wings and pizza. All of the other places I've tried the wings are far from great, and you can tell they are using cheap product. The pizza here is certainly good and the wings exceeded my expectations. It also helps that they are always very friendly when we go in. read more

Turnpike Pizza - Wings and pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

The chicken parmigiana dinner was fantastic! The sauce is really phenomenal. The side salad wasn't your basic salad that comes with dinners. It had chopped up green peppers, tomatoes and onions. Very generous portions. Loved the garlic knot that came with the dinner. 5 stars! If you haven't tried this restaurant I highly recommend it. read more

The new & improved Turnpike Pizza lives up to the hype! The pizza is honestly perfect. It's NY style, with a rustic Italian vibe - soft, and slightly crispy around the edges. I tried a sample of their focaccia & noticed some similarities to the pizza dough. My theory is that their chef comes from a background in baking (they also make their own grinder rolls). For me, they have claimed the coveted "best pizza in Newington" crown. My only concern is that their menu is so incredibly expansive, I'm not sure how they will manage that much inventory while still achieving speed, quality, profit, etc. I'm not sure if they really need the bowls & wraps, given everything else available. Regardless, everything looks great especially the pizza. I look forward to trying their pasta dishes, paninis, & grinders. read more

Heard about this place on Facebook and decided to give it a try. One of the best pizzas I've had in a longgg time. Def order ahead as it does get busy. We got the meatball garlic knot sliders that we will be eating for a week, they are massive. And the pistachio blanco and it's amazing. For sure will be ordering from here again read more

Turnpike Pizza - Meatball garlic knot sliders - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

Very creative topping combinations! Not much space to eat inside, and no restroom. Great takeout place though!

We ordered a Caprese pizza and they gave us cheese. We were driving home from a trip and by the time we opened the box and saw the mistake we were too far down the road to turn back. We were very disappointed. read more

My usual pizza spot in Newington had a longer than usual wait, so I thought I'd give it a try. I was very surprised by how good it was. Amazing thin crust pizza, cooked perfectly. Dough, cheese and sauce were all fresh. The worker brought our pizza out to the car without even asking. Overall, I am very impressed and look forward to trying more toppings and items on the menu. Thank you for saving our night before the fireworks! read more

We came here for the Greek Salad Pizza and Garlic knots, and they were Slamming good. Love the Tziki and flavors inside the Greek Pizza. Garlic knots were super tasty with strong garlic taste. Turnpike Pizza I must say Is the best in the area. Nice crew and friendly workers. I will hurry up and come back for more. read more