Great pizza at a really good price. Friendly staff, they just gave me a free slice to try along with what I had ordered. Highly recommend!

My husband came home with his house special and it's the best place that I've tasted in a long time What a delightful surprise read more

Not quite my kind of pizza -- some of the photos on their website made it seem more New Haven style than it is. Wondering if they used stock photos?? The staff at pick up were so friendly though and gave us a slice of pizza bread to try. Pizza was fine. Hard to find New Haven style in the area (as a girl from New Haven). read more

Great pizza, a real good local pizza place to go when you need to feed a crowd and don't want to spend ridiculous prices. I love the staff as well, good to have peruvian representation in the pizza game! read more

This is my 2nd time ordering my GF pizza from here and its very very good. GF pizza can be a hit or miss but this one was perfect, its just cheesy and full of flavor. yup. I ate it all!! I ordered a grinder for my dad , his grinder had nice piece of chicken cutlet in there with ham, lettuce, tomato and sauce . He was satisfied with it and also enjoyed the complimentary slice of buffalo chicken pizza. it has the perfect amount of toppings on the pizza also. For Mondays, cant beat the Monday deals by the way. The. slices are huge and I heard those garlic knots are addicting!! Family/ owner that works at the pizzeria are all so friendly and nice! Also, they offer apps, wraps, grinders, salads, pizza, Stromboli's, wings , and calzones. phoenix Pizza is a great place to order take out from and get good slice of pizza! read more

See all

This spot has been a rotating pizza place since we moved to Newington and we're glad that they've moved in! Some great NY style pizza with huge slices and delicious pizzas. This is our go to spot and their service is great. Everything is priced well. The crust is thin and crispy with a lot of different combinations of toppings. Margherita (classic) - Everything you're looking for in the classic pizza. Gooey cheese with the classic flavors. Phonenix Special (onions, peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, hamburger) - A fantastic variety of vegetables and meat. Together, the combo works well but the hamburger was unseasoned by itself. Melanzana (White pizza with eggplant, spinach, ricotta) - Crispy breaded thin eggplant slices. (One of my favorites). Bacon Mashed Potatoes - had lots of great bite sized bacon pieces, I personally would pass on the mashed potatoes (too mushy for me to put on pizza). Tomato Basil (Basil tomatoes, garlic, shredded mozzarella, olive oil) - similar to the margherita but less saucy and more tomato! read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Bacon mashed potatoes and tomato basil slices - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Always super delicious!!! Love picking up pies for home. Love that the pizza is cut New Haven style. Never greasy

Great Pizza In a very lowkey area, this right here is a hidden Gem ! New haven style my coworker would not stop talking about this place so i figured i have to try it & wasnt dissapointerd one bit ! read more

So here I am, reviewing a new pizza place, in the Center of Newington, next to the Starbucks. Bobby D. is one of the first reviewers. Doesn't feel familiar at all. Wink emoji. Phoenix Pizzeria opened about two weeks ago. The immediate prior pizza place didn't last very long there at all. Pizza is dead. Long live pizza, I guess. I'm always curious about the new pizza places that open in this space and I have to say that I think Phoenix is one of the more promising ones. I visited to give Phoenix my slice test, and they had numerous pizzas by the slice that included Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Ranch, Thick Sicilian with just sauce and cheese, Meat Lovers and what I ordered -- the House Special. I was impressed with the House Special with sliced sausage, spinach, mozzarella and the star of the show for me, a very spicy pizza sauce. The sauce had an arrabbiata vibe and I thought it was great. I couldn't tell if the sausage was also hot, but I liked the overall flavor. The crust was thin and well managed. I know that's welcome news for the people always searching for area thin crust spots. Service was friendly. When I said it was my first time, the person who seemed like an owner offered two tasty garlic knots. I can't remember giving a pizza place Five Stars based on a slice, but I'm doing it for Phoenix. It was an original take on a sausage and spinach slice and I'm looking forward to trying more. read more

See all

Seriously just go get some pizza from Phoenix. My wife and I shared the Fresh Mozzarella pizza (with some bacon added to half) and chicken wings. Both were delicious! We recently moved nearby and couldn't be happier with this unassuming gem. It's family owned and it feels like home! We had a nice conversation with the owner who was very sweet, and gave us some tips on the area. The person who took our order was also very nice. A definite regular go to... We will be back! read more

We got the meat lovers pizza and the small bruschetta. Everyone in the house loved it. The bruschetta was nice and crispy crust and fresh flavorful toppings. Was greeted by a very nice man who had my food hot and ready along with a sample . Place was nice and clean. We will be ordering from there again. read more

Very nice people here! I love their Sicilian style pizza!! We've ordered several times and we'll be back.

We stopped by chance as we went to Starbucks next door and we were really hungry. Picked up an order of garlic knots and didn't even have to wait. Very nice folks crew working there and yummy knots. read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Delicious Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Picture perfect and the taste to match. High quality ingredients and an expert pizza maker equates to a perfect balance of sauce and cheese atop an outstanding crust. Nicely crisp and flop free. I've already been 4 times and I'm not done yet read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Small cheese pie well done - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Newington has had many pizza places over decades, mainly Greek style. This New Haven style pizza is the best in Newington now! Also offer slices! read more

Great pizza! Delicious thin crust and tasty sauce. Toppings have always been fresh and the slices are huge! My favorites are the buffalo chicken, chicken bacon ranch, and Sicilian. Definitely will be going back a lot for slices and full pies! read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Chicken bacon ranch. - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Love the huge slices of pizza here. After eating two slices, I was stuffed for the entire day. Each slice was around $3 or $4 each. I loved the creativity and variety offered with each pizza. Hope this place sticks around, it tends to change its name and shut down a lot.. read more

See all

Very good pizza always consistent Nice and considerate people I will return and recommend read more

Phoenix pizza is amazing with flavor, has a great crunch and an excellent yum factor! The ordering is super easy and was ready on arrival for pick up. Very nice place easily located with a clean and presentable atmosphere. Will definitely return read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Delicious wings - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

First go was a success! Loved seeing this place was so close! We ordered some wangs, knots and half and half pie.. all were very good.. the crust was a tiny bit thick and chewy and it worked well! The flavor was spot on! I love the menu options and had a hard time making a choice which is always a good problem lol.. I'm eager to try again and work my way through the menu! read more

See all

They never disappoint. Always kind and always family friendly. My order always has an extra sample or is just correct! They are our families' go to. read more

Great pizza. Friendly service. A little pricey but they do have specials during the week

In the mood for pizza and decided to try this new place. We ordered a sausage mushroom onion and a pepperoni mushroom plus some garlic knots. The pizza was a thin crust with tasty toppings and a nice crust. I do wish there was some more sauce but otherwise we really loved it. The garlic knots were perfect and we enjoyed them all weekend especially with some homemade soup, there were plenty to go around. This is a great pizza spot the employees are very friendly and accommodating. I got the sense it was a family run business and we love supporting these kind of spots. Give a try you won't be disappointed! read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

First, my review is not on taste! The pizza was very good ! My 3 stars was based on sticker shock. The online menu prices are def wrong . My pizza was suppose to be 22? When they rang me up , it was almost 28! I don't like surprises, I wouldn't have ordered it if I knew the price. When I questioned the price difference , she said costs went up . Yes, we know prices went up . I'm all about small local businesses but it's going to hard for them to compete with 27 (and change) dollar pizzas and deceptive pricing . read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

In my opinion the best spicy Buffalo chicken pizza around (5/10 spice wise). I also recommend the steak and cheese pizza and basically everything else on the menu. Always a wide variety of random slices. Very friendly and good specials throughout the week. read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Spicy Buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

Its delicious. My slice was crispy and flavorful, and quite large. Garlic knots weren't in a Knot shape, but were absolutely everything else you could want from them. I've also tried a couple of salads from there. They we're chopped style and delicious. I haven't tried dine-in yet, but there is seating available. best pizza I've had in the area read more

Delicious pizza, and the restaurant is spotlessly clean. Stopped on a whim and happy I did.

GREAT white pizza!! Haven't had a fresh red pie yet, but had a couple slices and they were really good as well. Definitely my new favorite pizza in town. read more

Phoenix pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Great pizza. Nice service too, ambiance is good. Busy parking lot, will definitely return

Food was good and was done fast! Ordered a small pizza which feeds 2. U can add toppings for extra charge and do half and half sides!

Pizza was delivered BLAZIN hot with fresh toppings and a nice crisp crust. My new favorite pizza spot in newington. We had the house special. read more

Great pizza! Big slices! Give it a try! For those in the Newington area, you know this location has had multiple different pizza places throughout the years, none of which has survived. The primary reason was not location but quality of food. Phoenix Pizzeria is the newest to give it a go and I think they can make it for a few reasons: 1. Their pizza is very good and it is different than the other places nearby. It is a thinner crust with the right amount of toppings. You can hold the slice vertically and nothing falls off. The crust is the right level of crispy and the toppings are delicious. I've tried the chicken bacon ranch, Philly cheesesteak, Buffalo chicken, pepperoni, and Mediterranean. NOTE: they also have a thicker Sicilian slice which looked good but i did not try. 2. They sell slices. The other places nearby don't do slices, so this idea sets them apart. Their slices are big too! So if stopping by Starbucks next door or just need a quick bite, you can grab a slice or two and a Fleri k and be on your way in 5 mins or less. 3. They have garlic knots and they are great! 4. The owners are very nice and eager to do well. Overall there are a lot of pizza places nearby but Phoenix is a new place worth trying because you will like it. It a little different in style of pizza and being able to get a slice vs a whole pizza is a great thing too. read more

This place has changed over many times. However I have been here three times this holiday break. The pizza is just so delicious. The crust is thin and crispy. The pizza has flavor and staff is very nice. Highly recommend this place! I drive from Wethersfield just to pick up a pie. Worth the drive. read more

this pizzeria is so good!! i wasn't on planning on getting lunch but the idea of pizza (and trying the new place in town!) sounded good, so my partner and I popped in. The employees are lovely and the pizza is so good! I got a mozz and basil slice and it was so delicious- the dough has a very good crunch but was very doughy inside! They also gave us small slices of their tomato basil pizza to try, and that was also fantastic. I hope they're able to stick around!! I would definitely recommend it :-) read more

Pizza was delicious, I bought a large buffalo pizza. The person cooking greeted me right away and was pleasant to talk too. They have lunch specials too read more

They do not deserve 1 star! Disgusting!!! I bought the "Phoenix Pizza" white pizza with olive oil , tomato, pesto, and chicken. I ended up having food poisoning from their food! ABSOLUTELY DO NOT EAT HERE! Unsanitary people! read more

Friendly staff and delicious and generous slices. Highly recommend. Slices are always available every time I've gone there.

The pizza dough seems to be fresh, but they are using pans instead of freeform, and the bottoms of the pizza crust get a bit too cardboard- like for my liking. The sauce is nice, and they do not skimp on the toppings. All in all, pretty decent pizza. I've been to this location under all of its former iterations many times, and all of them offered garlic knots, which were amazing. These looked fantastic, but they were way too chewy, and had absolutely no garlic whatsoever. They were bread knots, to be sure, but were bland, chewy, and frankly disappointing. read more

Phoenix Pizzeria is a newly opened family owned pizza restaurant in the starbucks plaza on mainstreet. They sell full pizzas or pizza slices which when you go in for a slice you're in and out within 5 minutes. there are a variety of slices to choose from and the slices are fairly large but thin. i'm very pleased with my pizza because ever since stretches closed, none of the places have met my expectations but this place sure did. not to mention they through in a few garlic knots to try and they were very good. food was flavorful and delicious! i recommend! read more

We tried their pizza today. Great thin crust pizza!!! The House Special is the best pizza we've had in CT without a doubt. Please try it. You will be amazed with the flavor. This will be the only spot we will be ordering pizza from in Newington. read more