Excellent food and service! We were quickly greeted and whisked away to a booth. Our waitress, Sheri W. was extremely attentive. My husband and I told her it was our first visit to JG and she was delighted to help us with any questions or concerns. The menu is huge and it offers something for everybody! I decided to start with the apple salad, which was huge! It was crispy, crunchy, and had just the right mix of ingredients. My husband ordered a small (12in) cheese pizza, and I decided to go with a small (12in) vodka pizza. I love vodka sauce but had never tried it on a pie before, man was it delicious!- Chef's kiss! My husband really enjoyed his traditional cheese pizza as well! It was great to find a new haven style pizza joint further into the state. They also serve Detroit style pizza which I'd be interested in trying next time. The only downside was not having room to try the italian ricotta donuts that look and sound amazing (which JG doesn't start serving till 5pm). I guess that means we'll just have to go back! 10 out of 10 for JG, we shall return! read more

See all

A nostalgic stop during a recent trip and otherwise not remarkable. Ordered meatball side, pizza with broccoli rabe and sausage and the Sicilian orange and blue cheese walnut salads - all of which were perfectly fine yet somehow not as we remember dining years ago. Perhaps it was the take-away part that made things just ok and not comfort food on the go style satisfying. read more

First time my wife & I have been disappointed with this restaurant. My wife got a caprese wrap that had way too much dressing and made a mess. I go the chicken parm, not enough sauce, smaller Portion. What happened? read more

Food and service were excellent. We were seated in a booth in the bar area by choice. Spenser is an excellent bar tender as well waiting on the tables in that area. He is very attentive and is on top of drinks and food before your glass is running low. Thank you Spencer for being 100% attentive at what you do to keep customers happy. If you are wondering if I/we know him. No we do not. I always ask the name of the person serving us. I find it to be a more pleasant experience knowing the name of the person who is serving us. As for the food my Apple walnut cranberry something salad lol was amazing. I ordered it with Only romaine lettuce, no onions and extra dressing. Amazing!! My husband ordered a cheeseburger with fries that he really enjoyed. 10/10 on food and service but if you plan to sit in the bar area it can get really loud if it is full house. read more

Joey Garlic's - Cheeseburger with fries and Apple walnut cranberry salad. - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

As always stellar meal at one of our favorite and most frequented restaurants. The food, service and atmosphere are always stellar. We had mussels and cheesy garlic bread Anthony's Al Capo ( pork cutlets) Chicken Parm Chicken Joey Baked fish Cobb salad Apothic Red and Guiness Ricotta donuts ( ask for a some raspberry sauce on the side. Mix it with the vanilla custard. Omg) Caramel brownie read more

We had the Buffalo Cauliflower Bites for an appetizer along with salmon dinners. The Cauliflower tasted old and was too greasy and also had a bitter taste! We informed the waiter ( he seemed kind of new at the job) and he said that he would inform the chef about it. Nothing was done, when he brought the salmon out, he removed the uneaten cauliflower, not even asking why it wasn't touched! The salmon was good but we both had issues with our stomachs after the cauliflower. I'm surprised the manager was never to be seen because the waiter needed more training read more

I've been here a few times now and overall its delicious. This time we got the Philly cheesesteak eggrolls which were really good. Then I got the Crazy Alfredo pasta which was delicious and a HUGE portion. I had left overs for 3 more meals. My partner got the Detroit Motor City pizza which was so flavorful and also a whole pizza so he had that for 2 meals. There is plenty of parking here as its in a plaza. They do also have a bit of outdoor seating for the warmer months. I never had a wait when I come here either as its a pretty big place. read more

See all

We were seated immediately even though it was busy. Unfortunately our table was a booth by the bar right under the air conditioner. Our only solace was that it was right next to the door to go outside, so it was constantly being open and closed and we would get a warm breeze... Started out with the onion straws, and the eggplant fries... The small was huge and that's an understatement but very tasty . Our server, Shari, brought us some ranch dressing. I think she read my mind because the onion straw tasted delicious with ranch. Because we ordered pasta, we had salads coming, which were pretty good, but nothing extra extraordinary . We both ordered the penne à la vodka, one with sausage and one with shrimp blackened... Highly recommend the blackened shrimp. It gave the pasta a little bit of a spice and it was tasty :-) It was this Sherri could read our minds because as soon as we were done with the appetizers, she came by with boxes for the leftovers and then as soon as we were done with our last bite of pasta, it seemed like she was right there with containers to go and brought us a bag so we could carry everything out, which was very thoughtful. Overall, a chill experience inside, but I'm sure other tables would be fine... Our server out shined everything else, she was great! Thank you Sheri! read more

See all

The food is amazing, the portion sizing is incredible you will definitely have leftovers. From a date night to large groups. The staff is incredible and knowledgeable and help to make food suggestions. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. My only complaint is that I don't love their beverages, they have off brand drinks. read more

Joey Garlic's - Vodka Pasta, Cutlet and Lasagna. - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

We had not been here in many years and thought it's a good time to go back! It was a god decision, the food is good and like the name suggests, full of garlic! We had the Chicken Joey which was so flavorful. The risotto was outstanding, so creamy and delicious. And the broccoli was tasty, covered in chopped garlic. We also had their new promotion of chicken cutlet meals - Brooklyn chicken which was a mild impression of Parmesan, but less sauce, and fresh mozzarella on top. And, a very strong taste of garlic, to be expected. The atmosphere is pleasant and we had a friendly and attentive wait staff. read more

Joey Garlic's - Chicken Joey **New** - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

We had a group of 6 of us for dinner. We were a bit behind schedule but they were able to accommodate us. Our server was efficient, getting us all set. The room was a bit tight with another party but it was not overwhelming. Once we placed our order, the food came out at a nice pace with appetizers and salads followed by our entrees. Everyone enjoyed their meal. read more

One of my coworkers was retiring. I reserved for a larger group. They were well prepared to take on a party of 18 people with separate checks during lunch hour. The food was delicious and came out quickly. The meatball sub was enough for 2 meals! They even let us use their utensils & knife for cutting a cake. Such an efficient service team too! I'll definitely use them again for work lunches for groups! read more

Ordered delivery meatball grinder and requested extra sauce and it hardly had any sauce, couldn't even eat it. Won't order here again.

I have a new favorite pizza, The Kitchen Sink minus mushrooms. Outstanding flavor, great topping and thin crust. Don't not get the garlic on it because you will miss a treat read more

Joey Garlic's - The kitchen sink - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Love the eggplant fries, they are always amazing! And so was our waitress Heather. We had so much food left over we had a meal the next day! Atmosphere is just the best no matter what time of day. read more

We were visiting the area and someone recommended this place to us. We called to place an order for pick up. There was an area you can park and they will bring it out to you, that was what we gathered. After waiting the amount of time they mentioned on the phone, we drove there and parked at the designated spot and messaged them through the text message chain they sent us, letting them know we were there. After 15 minutes, we messaged them again to confirm; someone responded "ok". After another 15 minutes, we decided to just go inside to pick up our food since no one was coming out. It ended up being around an hour overall wait time; it was a Saturday evening, so it was busy and we get it. Aside from the wait, the food was really good. I had the small Hot Honey Pepperoni Bronx pizza; it was on a thin crust, mozzarella, pepperoni, hot peppers, and honey. That was so so so good! Unfortunately, I didn't get to take pics. The next one I want to try is their mashed potato pizza. My family enjoyed our meals and would definitely go back. read more

See all

Great selection of shellfish and well-seasoned pasta and salads. Quiet and easy parking. Our server, Sheri,was delightful and just the right degree of attentive. We will definitely return. read more

I haven't been to a Joey Garlic's in at least 12 years. At that time they primarily offered pizzas. Today their menu is expanded to pasta, salads, wings and more. Today we were a party of five, when we arrived for dinner. It was super busy, after around 15 minute wait we were brought to our table. We got eggplant fries as an appetizer to share. These were pretty good, and a nice alternative to traditional fries. For my cocktail I got the Pistachio Martini. I didn't expect this drink to be green, but it makes sense. It tasted like pistachio ice cream in a cocktail. For my meal I got the Clam Chowder and the Apple Salad. This clam chowder was not on the menu. The waitress told us about it. Just because it was a special, yet we aren't anywhere near the water, I expected it to be well, like clam chowder. It was super, super salty, inedibly salty. In my experience it is difficult to mess up a salad, and of course, there are minimal carbs, so it's typically a healthier option. The Apple Salad arrived in a bowl. It looked fresh with thin sliced apples, over what seemed like a whole bag of greens. There were also walnuts, cranberries and gorgonzola cheese. This was a massive salad, the quantity is there for sure. Not so much the quality, the zest, the flavor or the star of the show. I didn't even have a quarter of this salad. I brought the rest home with me, not because it was amazing but simply because I already had it. Others got the Kitchen Sink pizza, this is with pepperoni, sausage, bacon and meatball. This was very meaty, not my personal pick, but very good with thin crust and rich toppings. We concluded with the Chocolate Lava Cake. This was pretty tasty, the warm, melty, gooey chocolate paired with vanilla ice cream. If I were to return to Joey Garlic's I would stick to their pizzas. read more

See all

My family and i drive 40 minutes just to come here, we love this restaurant! Never had a bad meal, and the portions are HUGE. You'll easily have 3 full meals from one entree. Cons- The Service can sometimes be slow, and I think it's pretty dark inside depending where you're seated. read more

I just want to give Joey Garlic some honest feedback. Although I have eaten at the restaurant often, yesterday I was with a large group. Your food was excellent and plentiful. The staff were excellent. I plan on going there again. I need to say that I have a hearing impairment and we were seated in a small side room. normally I hear even with my hearing impairment in noisy places. Then another large group was seated close to us. They were extremely loud. This close proximity of two large groups made it difficult to hear and have a conversation. This is not the first time that I ate an otherwise delicious meal in the presence of two large groups. Many restaurants seem to follow this practice. Therefore, I would like to suggest that they separate two or more groups rather than seat them near each other. This practice spoiled an otherwise wonderful experience. Thank you for your attention. read more

Always a great spot to go when you aren't entirely sure what you want for dinner. It's usually busy any given night but never are we left waiting around for long. I've mostly checked out the pasta, which has been delicious on numerous occasions and the big piece of garlic bread is one of my favorite parts. The portions are rather large and can definitely be taken home for a second or third meal. It's clean inside and nicely decorated with plenty of space from other tables to enjoy private conversations. The ricotta doughnuts are absolutely delicious - a must try! read more

There is no shortage of Italian restaurants around here, but this is the only one I know of with eggplant fries. If you only come to Joey Garlic's for apps and drinks, or these gimmicky fries, it'll still be a fulfilling experience. Outside of the apps, pasta classics, pizza, Detroit pizza, and wraps make this an impossible to choose menu. The kids menu includes the staple burgers and fries and chicken tenders. The Alfredo was a different recipe but very tasty meal, and the Al Capo was colorful and fun. Half of your pasta will go home because those plates are huge! The waiter was pleasant for our group of 7, and attentive without being pushy. read more

Joey Garlic's - Huge plate of eggplant fries. - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Italians would describe Joey garlic, Italian American fair as it mezza mezza or just so so. Joey's is reasonably priced for pretty average fare. The meatball appetizer comes with three large meatballs, although given the density of these meatballs, it's very likely industrially made as hand made meatballs tend to be a lot less dense. The grilled bread that comes with it wasn't really toasted and tasted burnt from the grill marks. It made me think their grill needed to be cleaned more. The pizza is solid. Good mix of cheese and crushed tomatoes. Pepperoni could've used a little char, but had a nice spicy finish. read more

Joey Garlic's - Meatball - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

I have to start by saying service here is absolutely phenomenal. Upon sitting at the bar (about 50% capacity) we were immediately greeted by Shannon who introduced herself and genuinely made us feel very welcome. We ordered a round of manhattan's but my friend chose a bourbon that didn't taste all that great. When the other bartender noticed we didn't touch much of our drinks she quickly offered to replace them with a different bourbon and it did taste better. However, the ambiance at the bar wasn't very good. It was bright and once we got settled in I realized the vibes were not good. We honestly felt out of place. Seems like mostly locals that weren't the friendliest. I realize you're there to eat / drink but when seated at a bar you'd expect a more inviting atmosphere. The food was nothing to write home about either. The garlic bread was just "eh". Wasn't a huge fan of the sauce either. The house salad was a good size for the price (small) but it looked like someone walked along a salad bar and dropped every single item on the plate except for the lettuce. Ate maybe half and just didn't have any interest to continue which is unusual for me. My buddy felt the same about his large salad with chicken which he said did not taste very good. Maybe we ordered the wrong things, maybe we came on the wrong night, maybe our experience would be better in the dining area but I have no plans of returning and if it wasn't for the exceptional friendliness and service from the entire staff this would have been a two star rating. read more

Joey Garlic's - Manhattan - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

love eggplant fries but ....something changed....last order had more batter than eggplant and no taste.....not the same.....peeled off the batter and found such a skinny piece of eggplant......do not think I will buy these again Pizza was good read more

We've been here many many times. Fantastic grinders! Chicken parmigiana, Philly cheesesteak or pork cutlet with broccoli raab are my go to's. I'd be really hard pressed to name one better in our area Service is always spot on. We rarely have to wait for a seat. There are plenty of staff on hand all the time and the place is always clean and comfortable. I had my favorite chicken parmigiana grinder and it was perfect! Highly recommend to anyone looking for great food in a casual setting. read more

Ok so I have had the eggplant grinder a few times. I have always loved it. They eggplant breading has always been so flavorful and cooked properly. I ordered the eggplant parm dinner for the first time and it was inedible! There was a ton of a plant cutlets, very thick and undercooked. No flavor very little sauce. I could purely chew it. I removed it all, and I was only able to eat the little pasta that was underneath it. I was extremely disappointing because it's costly and how could their eggplant cutlets be so delicious on there grinder but not in a meal? I also ordered avocado salad. I've had it in person and it was big and delicious. However, I ordered it to go. It is smaller and it only came with a half avocado. It was mostly lettuce. I'm not sure if this is the norm now or it was just a really bad night.? read more

Joey Garlic's - Eggplant Parm - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Went here for dinner with a friend. I will say our waitress was very patient with us. Because one of our party didn't arrive until 45 minutes later. We did get appetizers while we waited. For the appetizers we got the garlic bread and mild wings. Sorry guys I was too hungry by the time the food came out. The garlic bread was delicious had just enough garlic in it. It wasn't soggy either. The wing, we could have gotten them a bit spicier. But, that was ok. It was still good not greasy or soggy. Glut had the perfect crispness to the wings. When, the rest of our party came. We didn't even look at the menu. Our waitress bless her heart stayed patient. Said to us when we are ready just throw a hand up. She'll be watching. I got the pasta bolognese it was very meaty and full of flavor. Holy cow was the plate huge. It was enough for three more nights. My husband got the shrimp scampi. He said it was good. But needed more acidity in it. Not enough lemon was squeezed. My friend got the eggplant Parmesan with penne noodles. Everything was good. Will go back to try other dishes. read more

See all

Solid place. Good food, huge portions. Nice relaxed vibe. Gluten free offered as well which is a life saver for many. Cheers JG'S

My husband and I recently voided for his birthday dinner. We have not visiting in quite a long time and we were looking forward to our meal. Unfortunately, we were very disappointed. We ordered the Philly egg rolls for an appetizer and they had no flavor and were very greasy. My husband ordered a pizza that was undercooked and when he picked a piece up off the tray, oil was dripping off of it. I ordered the avocado salad with grilled chicken and like the egg rolls the chicken lacked any flavor. The service was good but sadly the disappointing food would not propel us to come back any time soon. read more

Recently ordered delivery for a night in with a large group! Because it was a large group, we were able to order quite a few different things to try! Here's our breakdown: * The cheese pizza has a bit of a kick to it! I'm guessing there is some red pepper in the sauce? * The chicken bacon ranch was a little underwhelming. It didn't have a lot of flavor. * The hot honey pepperoni was a party favorite. It was a sweet, spicy, and savory combination that worked well. * The eggplant fries were very, very fried. * The homemade meatballs were delicious and served with a giant scoop of ricotta. * The Cesar salad was as expected. * The avocado salad was great. However, we asked for dressing on the side. The actual dressing did come on the side, but the balsamic glaze was put on the salad so we were unable to save leftovers. * The gluten free pizza crust was disappointing - but it's very hard to make an impressive gluten free crust. We ordered delivery so I have no comments on service or atmosphere. read more

Joey Garlic's - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

I absolutely love Joey Garlic's! The food and portion sizes are definitely worth the money spent. I've also catered from there a few times, and the food has always been great. I've interacted with the manager, Michael, while placing orders several times, and he was kind, patient, and very professional in explaining the options. I love everything about this place; it's my go-to spot! My go-to spot read more

Chelsea M. was absolutely great! this woman deserves a raise! the food was absolutely amazing and her service was immaculate. The whole place was clean and it was amazing. make sure this girl gets a raise! read more

We ordered for pick up and the process was seamless. My husband and I got a couple large pizzas for a party and they were decently sized. The pepperoni and cheese was awesome, crust was perfect, and we wish we got more! Also great customer service and the pick up was super quick in the parking lot. Definitely recommend if you're around the area. read more

Stopped in on the way home from a graduation. Had the shrimp scampi. I've never had a dish like this with sooo many capers. The he salt level was way too high. It seems like they played with perfection and went way over top. I am used to lemon, shrimp, garlic with white wine and chicken broth and that's it This had unripe hard tomatoes, about a jar of unrinsed salty capers, a slurry to thicken the sauce which made it like an thick consistency. Wasn't a fan. Kids had a simple chicken parm over penne and penne al la vodka. Server was very attentive and got the extra star. read more

Joey Garlic's - Shrimp Scampi??? - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

I've been here 3 times and its always good! Everything is super flavorful and the portions are ridiculous. Service is always fast and friendly and perfect for families. I've had a taste of most of the menu and I can't find anything bad. read more

The food was great. In had the meat pizza and then another night I had the chicken parm. The service was great Jovanni was an amazing server and the atmosphere was great. read more

Joey Garlic's - Pizza. The double pep and the meat pizza - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

See all

Amazing portions of food. You get what you pay for and it's all delicious. Eggplant fries are awesome. I was pleasantly surprised that they have a room for private events. They handled a fairly large group without an issue. Super friendly service with a large group. I will return with family and friends. read more

See all

Family friendly Italian spot with massive portions of salads, pizza, pastas, grinders, and a bunch of other classic Italian dishes I came for lunch and got one of their pizzas. It was very fresh and delicious. It was unique in that the crust was sort of like a flatbread Apparently the wait can be really long on the weekends, which is surprising given how many seats there are both inside and out, but other reviewers have said you can avoid this through their app/website read more

Joey Garlic's - American Near Me - Newington, Connecticut

Loved their pizza , they are the best . We also ordered sweet potato fries which were delicious . Their service was prompt and servers were very friendly . The ambience was decent . read more

See all