I am glad that my spouse and I decide to share a slice of pizza from this Classic New Haven Style pizza establishment. We ordered by the slice, it was the main street pizza which I was surprised how crisp it was on the bottom and yummy on top. Service was fast and friendly Atmosphere was small and tiny which made it would be perfect for grab and go. It's perfect if you need a fast bite and on the go. read more

See all

I've been a customer of Pietro's Pizza for quite some time and have dined in as well as ordered through DoorDash many times. The pizza is consistently excellent and, in my opinion, some of the best in town. The quality of the ingredients, flavor, and consistency keep me coming back. The salads are also fresh and well-prepared, and the portion sizes are generous, making it a great value overall. Whether ordering delivery or picking up, the food has been reliable and satisfying. The only downside is that prices have increased significantly over time, which is noticeable for regular customers. Parking can also be challenging due to the location, especially during busy hours. That said, the quality of the food continues to make it worth the visit. Overall, Pietro's Pizza remains one of my favorite local spots and an easy recommendation for anyone looking for great pizza and generous portions. read more

Had to make a lunch stop at Pietro's Pizza We ended up with the chicken bacon ranch, a pepperoni and a meat lovers, a mamas garden and a regular cheese to all share. We ate some at home and some at the store. The pizza is thin and crispy, flavorful with many options. We also got garlic knots, which I personally think could use a bit more garlic. The sauce for them (chefs kiss), was the star of the show. It was so good!! They also have deserts, pies and cheesecakes. We didn't get one cause we were so full! read more

See all

Excellent grinders, salads and pizza! Service is always great. Red velvet cake *chef's * read more

Came here to pick up some pizza with my family. We all ordered slices. Can I tell you they are huge! We also got garlic knots and they were huge too. Pizza here tasted good! I got 3 different slices. The veggie special , regular cheese and chicken bacon ranch. None of them disappointed me. I would get pizza here again. They have a Thinner New Haven style pizza and I am a huge fan of that. The Service here was fast , easy and friendly. They even have a Small dine in area too! read more

See all

Pietro's pizza is a busy place located on Main Street in downtown Hartford. I've only tried their pizza and garlic knots (both quite good) but their menu is HUGE. They have calzones, pasta dinners, sandwiches, omelets, 11 appetizers, salads, done-up fries, stuffed breads, burgers and grinders. There is a steady stream of people heading in there to order lunch (mostly take out, there's maybe 8 tables) as well as a big catering operation rolling out of the kitchen door. The staff is friendly and the only issue I've had was I recently got some slices (ordered in person) and they forgot about me. When I piped up, I got my slices in short order and was back to my office. Give 'em a shot, I guarantee they have something on that huge menu that you'll dig. read more

Wow, walking in , tables full of customers eating. A menu beyond cold grinders. A place full of tradition. I had a ham and provolone grinder, soft bread full overflowing of lettuce tomato oil . .old school so so good. A place to come back to against read more

Pietro's Pizza - My ham and provolone. - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

See all

Honestly, I'm not mad about it. I wanted a late night snack and there wasn't much else open in this part of downtown Hartford. Pietro's Pizza came in clutch! Not sure why everyone is hating but the NY style pizza slices were pretty large and you can even see how I split my pizza into two so I even got my monies worth. A bit greasy but that comes with the territory and nothing that some napkins won't fix to dap the extra oil. It was yummy and I finished it in my hotel room afterward. It's pizza. Come on peeps. Yes, more pizza please! read more

See all

Great pizza and the lasagna is great too quick delivery. The Garlic knots are the best

Stopped by Pietro's for a quick to-go order while walking through downtown Hartford. I grabbed a medium pepperoni pizza, a slice of red velvet cake, and a tiramisu--and overall, I was pleasantly surprised! The pizza was really solid--crispy crust, generous pepperoni, and melty cheese that held up well even after the walk home. The sauce was on the milder side, but it balanced nicely with the salty pepperoni and bubbly cheese. The red velvet cake was soft with a good amount of frosting, and the tiramisu had that classic creamy texture, though I would've liked a little more espresso flavor. Still, both desserts were satisfying. Friendly and efficient. I placed my order at the counter and it was ready in about 15 minutes. Staff was helpful and kept things moving even with a few people ahead of me. No issues at all--just easy and smooth service. Classic no-frills pizza joint--clean, casual, and comfortable. There were a few tables filled when I stopped by, and the vibe felt relaxed. It's not trying to be upscale or trendy, just a solid spot to grab a slice or take something home. Would definitely come back to try one of their specialty pies or maybe even dine in next time. A good spot for dependable pizza and sweet treats in the heart of downtown! read more

See all

Food and service were stellar after a long day traveling. Garlic knots were HUGE!! Still drooling

One of my favorite pizza places in hartford. The pizza always feels like it has a little extra spice and love. And I love their penne alla vodka -- the garlic knots are amazing. Thank god it only comes with two! My only issues ever have been when I place a delivery order for a certain time, they always ignore the time and just start making it/deliver it. I've not been home yet before when they call me to say they're there more than an hour before I ordered it for. Would be nice if they paid closer attention, but I get its busy! read more

Pietro's Pizza - A Local Favorite That Feels Like Family I've been getting pizza from Pietro's since 2010, and it's been a go-to spot ever since. Their buffalo and downtown slices are personal favorites--perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and always satisfying. One thing that never changes? The mountain of garlic knots by the register that tempts you every time you walk in. They're just as good as they look! The staff is always nice and welcoming, making every visit feel like catching up with family. That feeling was especially clear when they made a giant, delicious lasagna for my great-grandma's 95th birthday--it was a hit with the whole party and showed the care they put into everything they make. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or catering a special occasion check them out! read more

Pietro's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

Very good pizza by the slice place. The downtown slice is delicious at a great price.!

Super nice people they treat you with kidness the moment you enter the door there pizza is one of the best i have ever eaten i wish them the best and looking forward to always grabbing a slice there read more

I ordered a large VEGGIE MAMA pizza. All that was MISSING was the VEGGIES! I don't understand how its called veggie mama, and the veggies are MIA, MISSING IN ACTION. Once upon a time the entire pizza was covered in veggies, broccoli(BIG PIECES), mushrooms olive, spinach, onions and peppers. NOW, your lucky if you get broccoli on it, AND NOT VEGGIE PIZZA w/just ONIONS AND PEPPERS. I should've posted a pic, but I forgot. Anyhoo, i will order again and hopefully it will be better! IF, it were just a cheese pizza then it would've tasted GREAT, but it was supposed to be a veggie mama, because that's what I paid for! read more

Got some pretty decent pizza from here last night. My husband had the pepperoni pie and I had the chicken Alfredo. I liked the Alfredo pizza, but it could have used a bit more cheese. The garlic knots sadly were not good. A bit over cooked and lacking flavor, they definitely needed less time in the oven and garlic. read more

See all

Pizza was fresh and awesome. Mixed salad also super fresh. Cucumbers peeled, greens super clean.

I was staying in the Residence Inn next door and they recommended the pizza place next door. I figured it would probably be average, an assumption accentuated by the counter service aspect, but I was surprised. Rather simple, but a variety of slices and pies, including styles not normally as popular in a small pizzeria near NYC. The place is really small. I would guess the majority of their patrons don't eat in house. There are only a handful of tables. Not an issue, as there was room. The counter person brought the food out when it was ready and I started chowing down. The food? I tried the Chicago Style. A bit different than I remember Chicago style, but very tasty. Maybe not 100% authentic, but it was a very good slice. For a drink I got a local brew from the cooler and sat and ate pizza.TTT read more

Pietro's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

See all

Super friendly staff... Great pizza with plenty of variety, portions are huge. Hole in the wall place that deserves to be shared. read more

I got a couple of slices of garlic roll because they look amazing and a cannoli made fresh.WHY they rated just 3.5? the food is great. The service is great. Don't believe the nay-sayers and get over here for some great food read more

Pietro's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

See all

Amazing food and Amazing service ! Our go to restaurant for lunch or to bring home for dinner !

Pizza salad wings garlic bread 2L ginger ale freaking amazing best I've tasted in Hartford. buttt I ordered this thru delivery on they website they just made a mistake making my pizza half jala nd cheese instead of what I wanted pepperoni nd cheese called back and they thought it said jalapeño lmao it's fine cuz we got fresh box husband grabbed it it's good asff. I didn't go in but it seemed nice as my husband went in respectful patience people. read more

Pizza is good customer service is not. I ordered 2 pizzas and garlic bread online, they show up with one pizza and the garlic bread with a receipt for $33 when I paid $68. The lady on the phone when we first called was hostile and instisted that they don't do online orders through yelp...yet yall are on here. She kept saying that we were in the wrong when I have my bank statement and my order details in front of me. She puts us on hold to find our order finds it then says she'll deliver the pizza. The pizza took 1 hour to get here. We called after 45 mins she said the pizza was on the way. Mind you this place is like 5 mins from me. read more

Like the friendly service and it was an impulse walk in while visiting Hartford for work. I enjoyed the pizza and the side salad was large. It even came with a side of garlic bread. Yum! read more

Just dropped in for a quick slice and a salad. Excellent and inexpensive. I had the chicken and broccoli pizza and a Caesar salad.

Ordered 3 Chicken Alfredos today and wow were they delicious. Staff was very friendly and helpful when I called back just to order another one! Can't complain. Very wonderful and the ambiance was great, the perfect kind of busy. read more

This is such an amazing place. Had great pizzas, especially for a vegetarian person. Courteous staff, takes about 25 minutes for your pizza to be made. You can also them to customize this pizza, like I asked for their ala vodka pizza without meat /fish and they created an awesome pizza just for me. Must visit if you are a veg in Hartford read more

Pietro's Pizza - Ala Vodka Red Pizza - veg pizza - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

Giant slice alert! Pietro's has a vast selection of very large NY style slices. One slice is never enough and two slices is almost too much but that all depends on how you want to live your life. The service is fast and they always heat up your slices with the options of dine in or take out (which they put in a small box for you). The inside is small but there is always a place to sit. read more

There should be an option for a 0/0. Ive been coming here since I moved to the city, the man that works in the front is extremely rude. When I go I ask for my pizza to be cooked longer.. I'm willing to wait. I went in there and ordered and was waiting for 20 minutes... when I walked up to the counter to see about my food they handed me a box when I checked my pizza it was soggy. I walked to the counter and told him what I ordered.. said my food was fine. i had to lift it up and show him it was soggy. i was gonna wait for the food to fixed but this isn't the first time this happened with these guys. I asked him for my refund and he made a big deal about it and then said he didn't wanna see me back there. what is wrong with getting the food made how I requested it? read more

This pizza is so good. You can buy a whole pizza or just by the slice in store. I ordered a pizza for pick-up and it was ready within the window I was quoted. The staff was kind and gave me an accurate wait time for my pizza to finish cooking. I had to hold back from devouring more than I should. Highly recommend! read more

Best NY style pizza! Just plain cheese was amazing by itself. Actually took the box home with us because the whole family loved it!

Pre cooked pizza slices are thin crispy, very authentic tasting. Very pleased with the food and service.

We are here while waiting for a show at the xl center. It's only a 5 minute walk and the food and service are absolutely amazing!! Would definitely eat here again. read more

Fantastic place, great Italian menu to grab and go. A huge selection of salads, breakfast, entrees, and always fresh pizza. I eat here probably 4 times a week and always great service, fresh, and fast. read more

I was eating at Pietros Pizzeria, they are very attentive when taking orders as I could not eat what I wanted at first. I want to talk about the hygiene they have with the products, I touched a bottle of Coca-Cola but I changed my mind and took another one because I thought the first one was not very cold. When I put the bottle back an employee of the pizzeria came out to clean the bottle I had touched earlier. Kudos for being so careful and so discreet, I didn't see when he wiped the bottle with a brown napkin and I didn't see when that same employee was talking about what happened with another employee. I thought it was a radioactive contamination event. I hope they raise the pay for the employees of that business. I hope they never forget the password to enter the restroom because the customers of that business do not have the right to use it. I liked the pizza but there's always a last time for everything, right? He who understood, understood read more

The pizza was delicious!!! Various options to go. The service was great, inside and outside dinning. Definitely going to order pizza for home read more

Pietro's Pizza - Pizzzzaaaaa - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

I got their white sauce pizza slice. I think it was pretty good and the base was perfectly cooked read more

Pietro's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Hartford, Connecticut

Visited the area and had lunch two days in a row. Great slice of pepperoni and easily the best meatball parmigiana grinder ever!!!

Honestly, I wish that I could give this place a 2.5 rating. Pietro's is good because it's open late and the guys behind the counter were kind of entertaining. However, the food was quite a struggle. My chicken bacon pizza was not delicious at all. I cannot put my finger on it, but it did not taste like pizza. I see that the place has decent ratings in the Yelpiverse, so I probably went on an off night read more