Rosati's New Berlin is a good choice for a breezy fall Friday evening. It's a relatively small store so I web ordered and it was done at the time I asked for when ordering. The restaurant was clean and the staff were friendly and polite. I order fries, a pizza that was a special this week and two cans of soda. The fries were crisp, had the right amount of salt and were priced right for the amount you received in an order. The canned soda was approximately cold and the had a good variety of Pepsi products in both single cans as well as 2 liters. The pizza was cooked through without being burned. It was not overly greasy or oily and the vegetables were fresh. It was busy for a Friday but the staff were polite, the restaurant was clean, the food was done on time, and it tasted great. Thanks Rosati's for a great experience. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED read more

Workers were friendly. Got a take out - double dough pizza with extra sauce, half pepp / half sausage and mushrooms and onions on whole pizza. In spite of the extra sauce, the pizza was way too dry. In hindsight I wish we got the thin crust. read more

Food was great and hot when i got to the hotel. The mozzarella sticks are perfect. I always get food here when im in town and they never disappoint. read more

I stop here when I can for lunch , the pizza is outstanding...but the crew that works at this location are THE BEST! always friendly and always outstanding service. The prices are awesome too! read more

Gregg and his team delivered a birthday meal for a friend. Once again, everything was perfect! Please go ahead and order from This awesome team! 100000 star service & quality! Thank you so very much! read more

Takeout Order was accurate and ready on time. Food was hot and fresh. We ordered two 18 inch pizzas, cheese sticks and Caesar salad. We fed 8 adults and had left overs. Everyone was complimenting how good the food was. Great pizza sauce, crust is thin but not too thin, sausage and pepperoni also very tasty. Lots of toppings. Would definitely recommend them! read more

We ordered the Chicago deep dish pizza along with some boneless chicken wings with mild sauce and everything was delicious!! It was the first time we had anything from the restaurant and we were so surprised! The food was all piping hot fresh. The delivery was fairly quick despite it being dinner on a Saturday and the man who delivered to us was very nice and friendly! We enjoyed the food so much! The prices are a bit high but we wanted to indulge ourselves this time so it was worth it! Most likely will be getting food from here again in the future! read more

They are not answering the phone for a hour. Been calling since 4 pm. Hales corners answers and Brookfield does first try. Disappointing

Butter Crust I've driven past tons of times but figured that they wouldn't compare to pizza places in the Windy City. Thank you, Groupon. I was wrong, Rosati's will work when I'm not in the mood for a roadtrip to Gurnee to pickup deep dish. Both times I've been in I called ahead with a specific time for pickup and my order was hot and ready to go. Overall, the pizza is really good. The crust is buttery and has a great taste. Toppings were plentiful. Staff is friendly on the phone and at pickup. It's not Giordano's but definitely satisfies. read more

Last night we had Rosati's Pizza for our year end with our family. For the first time we got the "take and bake" pizza. We got two 14" and one gluten free. Bake all three and they came out perfect. We got all the pizza's with sausage and cheese and everyone said they were the best. The "Take and bake" worked perfectly, we were able to enjoy the family and bake the pizza and had a hot high quality pizza hot and fresh. Thanks for making our New Years just a little more special. read more

Great service for catering! Was very informative, punctual and the lasagna & pizza were tasty and had enough sauce& meat. Would definitely order again! read more

Order the large Chicago--style three or four times during football season for pick--up. The Rosati's crew will be wrapping my pizza as I arrive. Expertly made. read more

It didn't taste as fresh as I thought it would. It tasted like it was sitting out for 10 minutes because it was also cold. I personally was not as happy as my past experiences read more

This place is AMAZING! This is the best pizza a ever had, the service is EXCELLENT. Thank you Greg & Staff Carol read more

I'm very disappointed. First the pizza came UNCUT. A large 18 incher...UNCUT??? Bull. Then we tried calling at 8:35pm TO ASK WHY OUR PIZZA WAS UNCUT and NO ONE ANSWERED THE PHONE. YOU DON'T CLOSE UNTIL 9:00pm. Not to mention we kept calling back to lodge a complaint and SOMEONE KEPT HANGING UP THE PHONE. Again. BULL. To add insult to injury, the crust was so overdone it was black and curling up at the edges. You don't want bad reviews. You threaten to sue when people say truths that are obvious. This is a BAD REVIEW. SUE ME!! Rosati's SUCKS. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Brown hard crusr - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

There are two things you get here: quality and price. You get quality pizza at a great price. We ordered the Thursday special which was a 10" Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, garlic bread, and a medium 1 topping thin crust pizza. Everything was amazing and we couldn't be happier. Awesome pizza joint! read more

Rosati's Pizza - I only have one question. Where's the pizza?! - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

Called to order delivery after a very long day and was told there would be a two hour wait for delivery - I assumed it was because of the Packer game so I said I would pick up. My order then would be ready in 45 min, which I thought was interesting, but still decided to pick it up given my complete exhaustion. My 15 year old son, ran into to grab the order, and came back to say, there is no way there is a two hour wait!!! There are no other orders in there, there are three guys working, I think they just don't want to work. . . coming from a 15 year old. Nice! After reading the reviews, I'm thinking this is probably accurate. Whatever the case, if you are going to offer delivery - don't scare people away with fake delivery times! Regarding the food, the pizza was well prepared, and as ordered. Garlic bread and Zappole were very good. How doesn't love fried dough with Nutella! So delish! read more

I've had the 10" Chicago Deep Dish pizza and a slice of cheese from here. The slice of cheese was just ok, nothing special, but not so bad that it wasn't edible. The Deep Dish was pretty good, not as good as actual Chicago pizza like Giordano's or Gino's East, but probably among the best of that deep dish we can get here in Milwaukee. read more

Rosati's Pizza - 10" Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

I don't understand the criticism this place. It's good pizza at a reasonable price. Friendly staff. We carryout or have delivery often. Never a bad experience. read more

We were so excited to see a Rosati's. Moved to WI from chicago and i so miss really GREAT pizza. First time we ordered from this Rosati's it was lovely. Perfect everything. Pizza heaven. Today - blew another $50 - and it felt like just that - a blown $50. Soggy crust, lukewarm, a bad blend of ingredients. So first try - a 5, second try - a 0...average score is a 3. Maybe a gamble on who is cooking? Maybe a new person? Just dont know if i want to take a 3rd try at that price if i get a 0 pizza again. read more

I'm surprised by other people's experience with this location because I have never had anything but excellent service from them. I order delivery (online) once per week and the food is always good and comes within an hour. My daughter loves their Italian Sausage sandwich, and my husband loves their pastas (Italian Beef and the Deep Dish as well he's a greedy one) and I love their thin crust pizza. I've ordered 4 times this month already. I wouldn't continue to spend money with them if they didn't provide quality service and food. Don't let the comments run you off. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

This all started with a Groupon. The pizza was delicious, so I went back. The sauce is nice and fresh, and the cheese is plentiful. They have great daily specials that are a bargain. Depending on the day of the week, there is something for everyone. I messed up and called on the wrong day for the special I like (one topping, large thin crust for $10.99) and due to my loyalty, I received the special Wednesday price on a Tuesday. I appreciate the gesture, and will keep returning for that tasty pizza. read more

I tried this place for the first time today. I got it carryout, so I can't comment on the delivery experience. I Ordered a large 2 topping thin crust, breadsticks, and a 2L soda. Overall I thought the pizza was good, and had a good amount of cheese on it (sometimes places skimp on cheese). Was it the greatest pizza I've had? No. But it was tasty, with a crispy crust. The ordering was fine, and the employees were nice. No issues whatsoever. Used a Groupon, which I thought was a good deal. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

My review should be lower but let me explain. I ordered a Chicago deep dish pizza. Had it delivered and was handed a thin crust. This should be a 1 star review but the pizza did taste good and it was buy one get one Tuesday. Still, $35 for what I received leaves a bad taste in my mouth. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

I love the mozzarella sticks! & deep dish pizza. Great service- my dad is disabled & they make sure he gets his delivery fast & friendly...they go above & beyond! read more

Had a delivery order, a large pizza with 5 toppings and a large order of wings for the 4th weekend. The pizza was a huge disappointment. My guests thought I ordered a vegan pizza. $54 (not including tip). I was embarrassed, everyone thought I ordered a cheese pizza. There was barely any sausage, pepperoni, etc. Frozen pizzas had more toppings. Myself and my guests won't be back. read more

Food came very quickly- vodka penne pasta is good.. ordered a side of boneless wings and umm... the chicken is RAW. Really bizarre and the lady on the phone told me that they are precooked and that it isn't possible.. RAW. How do you screw that up? Pink.. blobby weird mushy texture..AKA they are raw! Yikes. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Undercooked boneless chicken wings... raw? NO refund, barely an apology. - Pizza Near Me - New Berlin, Wisconsin

The food is always amazing from Rosati's and the costumer service is amazing. Rebecca made my ordering experience so pleasant!

My husband and I received a gift card for EatStreet last year when our son was born. Basically we order from a select number of restaurants online and either done-in or pick-up. Due to the close proximity of our home (even though they won't deliver to our home), we always order online and pick-up from the New Berlin Rosati's. Rosati's is a chain, and I've eaten at a few of them before. For example, the one in Oconomowoc is a full-fledged restaurant, whereas this is pretty much a "take-and-go" kind of place. The main thing that varies from each restaurant is the service. The service I've had here varies each time. Some days I have to wait, other days our pizza is ready as promised. I've never had anything other than the pizza from here, so I cannot comment as to how the other food is. Last night we ordered our pizza, and when I picked it up, it was already kind of cold. Not a big deal , but it's always nice to have a hot pizza when you open the box. All in all this place works for us. When we're super busy with our kid and it looks like dinner isn't gonna happen, we'll order a pizza. It works in a pinch. read more

I've ordered from them multiple times. I probably wouldn't have if they weren't on grubhub which is ever so convenient. It's hit or miss. Timeliness: usually they're close to on time, which is an hour by grubhub. Last night they were late...no apology. I haven't had their pizza but their Italian beef sandwiches on garlic bread are decent (I like the spicy giardiniera they have). The boy likes the wings (I didn't try them but they looked tasty and fresh) and their chicken strips are oddly exceptionally tasty, as is the honey mustard (it tastes homemade). The antipasta type salad is decent (not the best I've had but edible if you're craving a salad) and the garlic dressing is good with it. The cheesecake also surprisingly tasty. Avoid: the fish (my bad. I was just craving fish I should have known better) Overall they aren't bad...they do forget sauces and stuff like that. I won't stop ordering from them but I also won't be surprised if one day they just forget an entree and then I will stop ordering from them. It just kind of feels half-assed if you know what I mean. They need a small crackdown on the part of management to bump it up a notch because it seems like they have potential. Or it could be that the pizza is absolutely fantastic and they should just focus on that, and good customer service, and forget the rest. Or maybe I've been watching too much Kitchen Nightmares. read more

We have catered from Roasti's for the third time and we will go back! They delivered and put everything out, they are reasonably priced, and the food was delicious. We love the Italian beef and cheese ravioli. read more

I was craving a beef sandwich so I went here. First off its hard to see from the street because it's in a strip mall with dark windows and not lit up. I had the beef on garlic bread with hot peppers and cheese. This is a tasty combo and how can you go wrong. It's big and tasty and how can anyone screw this up. This filled my craving and I would have this again when the crave hits. read more

Tried this rosatis location tonight. I got one of the calzones. The food itself was pretty good and definitely large enough that it will fill you up. The food and the crew working in the restaurant get 4 stars. The rest of my review involves the "online ordering" I came on yelp to see what looked good for dinner and ended up linking to rosatis website via the link on yelp to look at the menu. I noticed the online ordering and placed my order assuming it went direct to the restaurant. It turns out their online ordering is thru a third party service called menufy.com. It was pretty straightforward but didn't explain things very well. It allows you to put a tip in for the driver in advance if you so choose. But nowhere did it say this would be your ONLY opportunity to give a tip unless of course you had some cash on you. Since i do not believe in tipping a delivery driver until the meal arrives in case he/she gets lost for an hour or any other reason that the service could end up being bad, i chose not to do that expecting that id need to sign the credit card slip and have a chance to add a tip at that time. The driver arrived earlier than the quoted time, and everything went perfect. Handed me my order, turned around and started walking away. No receipt of any kind besides the email sent by menufy.com , no ability to add a tip and i did not have cash on me. I immediately called the restaurant directly and explained the situation and was told i had to call up menufy.com and they could edit my order and add a tip that way. I did that and it was fairly easy i am just really hoping that the driver actually gets that tip from menufy.com ***Protip*** the employee working at the restuarant told me to Skip the online ordering and call the restaurant direct. I was told that the delivery time averages roughly 10-15 mins faster. I can only assume that the reason for that is a 10-15 minute delay in menufy.com sending the order to the restaurant. This would also fix the issue with not being able to tip the driver unless you do so in advance. read more

This location was only closed for the holiday. We just ordered from them last night? read more

Excellent pizza, very good prices. Pizzas are always hot and tasty. Love the Rosatis monster pizza. Everyone comments how good the zah is when we order. read more

They have very good Italian beef sandwiches and pizza we used to get their bruschetta as an appetizer it was great but then stopped getting the cheese says on menu comes with. Sometimes takes longer and have had multiple screw upped orders in past which they did nothing about. So stick with their pizza and Italian beef sandwiches.. read more

In the time it takes these clowns to get the pizza to your door... you could make the dough from scratch grow the fresh herbs kill the meat source cure the meat grind it prepare it cure your own cheese curds ... their restaurant closes in ten minutes and I'm still waiting for my pizza. Never again will we be ordering from there. My 9 year old daughter is quite upset over not having cheese pizza for dinner like mommy promised. read more

I love rosati's pizza , but $44 for 1 Chicago style pizza with garlic bread is insane. I'm glad I called to double check the order and canceled it. I could drive down to Chicago and get a pizza for that price. read more

Called and phone rang until the call was automatically disconnected, say after 5 or so minutes. Waited 5 more minutes (never know, maybe someone is in the bathroom) then tried again--same thing no answer. This is at 5pm on a Monday, by the way. Tried one last time, someone picked up after a dozen or so rings, then promptly and abruptly put me on hold. About 10 seconds later I was disconnected. Was anxious to try their Chicago style, but with so many other good pizza options out there, I don't think I'll be trying them again. read more

Husband picks up food. Ordered beef sandwich, fett Alfredo, and bruschetta. Took 55 minutes and they only had one other order. Employee wearing his pot leaf shirt didn't know what bruschetta was. Refunded our money because he didn't know what it was or if they had it. Husband had metal shavings in his alfredo. Won't be back. read more