Disclaimer: I always use stars as a way of rating "how good is this restaurant considering what it is," which means I'm not comparing this to a 5-star Italian restaurant in NYC. It's a small town pizza joint, and I'm rating it as such. My mom is new to the area so we've been exploring restaurants here, and this is one I won't be going to again. The service staff were friendly but extremely slow, as our server spent most of our meal flirting with a few men at the bar. The food was "meh." I ordered the BBQ chicken calzone (it has a name, I can't remember it) and it was average at best. Not a ton of chicken - mostly just sauce and cheese. My mom ordered the lasagna and said it was "TV dinner" quality, and our salads were just big hunks of bagged lettuce with pepperoni and mozzarella cheese. I wasn't expecting knock-your-socks-off good but this was solidly average. They also only play some Sirius XM station in there that is like dance/rave music. Very strange. Not horrible if you're looking for a quick place to eat but nothing to write home about. read more

Their food is delicious, the process for ordering pick-up needs much improvement. We always enjoy the meals we get. It's rare that we dine in, but when we have, we haven't been disappointed with the service. We order for pick up fairly often, probably once every two weeks. My gripe is that more often than not, probably every 3 of 4 times we call, we end up on hold for longer than 7 minutes. I've experienced times where I've hung up, called back, been put on hold again and then wait 10 more minutes. It's evident that calls on hold are continually forgotten about. When they do finally pick up, there's never an apology for the wait, and if we mention it, it's a quick apology and we are moved onto our order. Something needs to change for those who call in their orders. read more

I highly recommend the Carolis at Roma. The "Manuel's Favorite" is my favorite too! It comes with meatballs, mushrooms, cream cheese, and mozzarella -- all stuffed inside a crispy, baked dough! And this all comes with a side of marinara dipping sauce. Yum! read more

Underdone garlic bread. Ranch is from a bottle. Marinara is watery. Worst thing is that crust is flavorless. Toppings were alright though so 2 stars. read more

One of our favorite places! Love the pepperoni cheese bread and Manuel's Favorite Caroli! Great pizza, and homemade pasta. They have weeknight specials and fair prices! Go to Roma! You won't be disappointed! read more

Been going to Roma's in Greeley for a long time. Decided to try Windsor Roma's last week. This was the worse spaghetti I have ever had Sauce was soupy and no taste at all and all cold Top it off the service wasn't any better and supposedly she was the manager. I don't think I've eVer been to a place that acted like they didn't want us there The cheesy garlic bread was delicious We will not be going back. read more

The pizzas and carolis are usually very good and you can get a great deal of you use a coupon. I don't like visiting this Windsor location because they have messed up my order several times, the wait is always long, and the staff is often rude and unprofessional. read more

When expansion occurs with a business, often times the quality of their product is diluted. Fortunately for me, that did not happen with Roma. Still the same good foodI remember, way to go Roma in Windsor. read more

This place is delicious. Every time we have ate here it has been fantastic. The specials are great and it is very affordable with large amounts of food. read more

Roma Windsor - Spaghetti with meatball and lasagna - Italian Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

Pizza is good but the crust is flavorless. The half off pizza on mondays makes it worth it. My dog does enjoy the crust though.

Not impressed with this place at all. It's cheesy inside. The staff are okay, a uniform should be required. They prepare their lasagna early in the day, but takes forever to bring it to you. The food was okay, nothing to write home about. Pretty sure I'll pass on this place in the future. read more

Amazing every time! Would highly recommend!! My favorite is the Hot House Caroli! Kids love the cheesy bread or cheese pizza!

This is my favorite Italian restaurant in all of northern Colorado. Great food, cheap for the quality of food, and hands down the best Caroli/Stromboli this side of the Western Hemisphere. read more

Roma has been around forever- Greeley location at least since the 1980's. Food is always good! Known for their caroli. Ambience is casual, as are the wait staff's attire. But good service and good food. read more

Food is good, i think they need to learn to stretch the dough cause the center is always wet, way to thin, and then the crust is a little to much. But when you go to pick up a carry-out order and then they literally ask you to tip, wow! I tip for service, when you ask for a tip you should have done something NOT just take my money, a clean hair cut isn't doing it for the rude front desk asking for a tip. Food is good not great, drink specials also good borderline great. BS asking for a tip cannot believe a service company asking for a tip verbally you should get one if you deserve it. DON'T ASK FOR A TIP! IT IS RUDE! read more

There food is usually good here. This locations send to be understaffed. They could not handle a mediocre lunch crowd very well today.

We're fans of Roma Windsor. The prices are tough to beat (especially when using the available coupons or dining on the special of the night) and we've always found the staff friendly. The only thing that kept me from giving Roma 5-stars is the fact that cell and internet connectivity inside the restaurant isn't good. (My wife and I like to play on our phones while waiting for the food!!). In today's world, having a decent wifi system seems like something every restaurant should offer. read more

Service was a little slow but my pizza was fantastic. The bazooka beer was ice cold and refreshing

Pick up a couple of corrolis every Thursday when they're half-price. Place gets pretty busy.

The best Carolli's ever!! They have some that come with cream cheese. I highly recommend THE Carolil. It is to die for. Although, everything is amazing. I love the taco pizza. They also have great spaghetti and over all you can eat I believe on Tuesday's. It is also a great price. They also have half of pizza on Monday's. On Thursday's they have 1/2 off Carolli's.plus you can print coupons on line. read more

Yes, Windsor has nine pizza places and with Fireside pizza didn't need another one, BUT I've been eating Roma for over twenty years. I'm happy to say it's in Windsor. The website needs work and the phone number was almost impossible to find, but it's worth the effort! Carolis, pizza and Italian food better than anything we had before. read more

Definitely a big change from the original restaurant (and not for the better). This place used to be a quite, dark atmosphere family style Italian place. It's doubled in size and has more of a cafeteria feel and food quality. Oh well : ( read more

Bad service. Bad food. Everything is frozen. Servers are high or drunk don't know which. A better quality of frozen food.

The food here is fan-fucking-tastic. It's amazing. However the service is not good. The waiter seemed uninterested and seemed annoyed he was at work doing his job. Also, he made the worst marg I have ever had. So, in short go get some food whenever the server with the plaid NY hat isn't working. read more

My experience with the Windsor location was awful. I get we get busy, that's totally fine. What's not not fine is how the staff handles stress. My order was behind so I took a seat next to another person who was patiently waiting. We witnessed one of the cooks throwing things, slamming things, clearly not happy to be at work. His demeanor was very uncomfortable. The kitchen is wide open. Everyone can see, I would never act like this. All the customers were standing around watching him and shaking their heads. Someone send the guy home. He's about to lose his cool. I wanted a refund so I could just leave and forget about it, but they said it wouldn't be much longer. So I sat there and watched him continue to throw things around. When my order was up, he said my name, didn't make eye contact, just went back to being angry throwing pizza trays. I personally love the old romas in Greeley. I will not be back to the Windsor location. read more

The noodles were so thick and mushy, the sauce was bland and acidic, there was just no appeal and not very authentic. I've had the Roma's in Greeley and was equally unimpressed but gave this place a try since it was local. I wanted to love it but I just couldn't. read more

The food use to be AMAZING but it's lost it's touch! However they offer cream cheese in their pizza so one star just for that!! Yum! Take out is the best option. Inside is dirty and service isn't that great! Print the coupon. Can't show it on your phone. Have no idea why-but you can't! read more

Went there with a group of friends. The servers were kind, and the pizzas were good. Great Time!! Thanks to y'all at Roma!

We love Roma Restaurant and are thrilled that one is now in Windsor! My work called and ordered for Carry-Out and they were excited when they answered, and were prompt with our order. We will definitely be ordering with them often! Great Food, Great Service! read more

Update..... We decided to give this location another shot and so far we've noticed a huge change in customer service and the environment feels more welcoming then our first visit. We returned 3 times now and have not been disappointed. Good job to whoever turned this around. Upgraded from 1 to 4 read more

Reasonable, good, fresh food, attentive staff. Have enjoyed dinners numerous times as well as take-out.

We really like Roma's Windsor. We order from them a lot. Food is always good. Cant believe their specials. Not sure how they make money with the coupons they put out. 40%-50% off coupons. Lots of good food for the price. read more

Love the homemade spaghetti noodles! All the ingredients taste fresh and homemade, not canned or frozen. A great addition to Windsor restaurants. read more

We have been there twice since they've opened. The food is really good and they've brightened up the restaurant. We will definitely be making it a place we go to often. read more