While visiting family in Windsor we felt the urge for pizza on a Friday night. Never being in this area, I wasn't sure where to go. I ordered for pickup. Large pizza with ham and sausage. When I arrived they got my pizza for me and opened the box. My eyes must have looked like saucers. The size of their "Large" pizza shocked me. You see, I hand tossed pizzas for 4 years in high school, so I know pizza. And, I'm quite particular about my "za." The pizza they served me was a medium sized pie from where I come from all day. Definitely, not a Large. Then, my next issue was the amount of toppings. There was barely any sauce, minimal cheese, about 8-10 small diced pieces of ham. Looking hard for a minute or so I was able to find several small chunks of sausage. Now, the pizza tasted ok. But could have tasted so much better with more of what makes a piece of bread, a "pizza." Staff was nice and friendly. Overall, I was quite disappointed. I most likely would not return and can't recommend this establishment based on my above description. read more

Shopey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

This place is phenomenal - homemade everything. Colorado firecracker is classic arcade games, quality food, classic pizza parlor and sports bar read more

Good pizza, good atmosphere. Just don't have it delivered unless you want to spend a lot.

I was visiting my daughter ordered pizza from here , it was gross, the crust was almost burnt and very little toppings. Their cheese bread was good don't see how they can cook that without burning the crust read more

I ordered two pizzas, one of which was the specialty Supreme pizza. Somehow, they forgot to include four toppings! They gave me a pizza without the proper toppings, and when I asked about it, they offered to fix it--but by then, it was too late for me. That said, the overall quality of the crust was good, the sauce tasted great, and the cheese was flavorful. read more

This little spot is awesome for great pizza, pasta and salads. They have a cute little patio and everything is made fresh! Super relaxed and a nice little local spot! read more

One stop pizza order for sure. $30.00 for a pizza that was flat as a pancake, awash in grease. I went to Maverick after 1st slice and enjoyed a $3.29 slice to ease my pain. read more

ordered two pizzas and one had the wrong toppings. I called to let them know and was told my pizza would be refunded. it has been three weeks and no refund. Pizzas weren't great anyway and the dough was not cooked all the way through. would not recommend. read more

Better than Domino's, but that really isn't saying much. The previous pizza shop had better pizza crust and toppings. The sauce wasn't as good either. Not worth it for me to drive from Greeley. However, the service is a step up from the previous owners. read more

Great food..service was suspect, maybe it was the time of day. I would go back for another visit read more

Great menu of Pizza and pasta. Service was kind and efficient. You can eat in or take out. Plenty of room inside.

We're picky, annoying, self-proclaimed pizza snobs from NY. Before reviewing, we got pizza from Shopey's TWICE - just to be sure of the consistency... they delivered the quality perfectly. Loved the dough, the crisp, the foldability ;), and even the drip of grease indicating a perfect slice. Well done guys! read more

Shopey's Pizza - Pizza with mushroom and ham - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

Finally, a quality pizza place opens in Northern Colorado. Opening in the former Anthony's pizza location, I'm unsure if the owners simply changed their franchise affiliation or if Shopey's is run by an entirely new crew. Either way, it a big step up from the old eatery. Schopey's is actually serving good pizza, in a comfortable dining room, and with a soon to open full bar. The menu offered a variety of pies, pastas, and salads. Their appetizer menu will pair nicely with the bar, when they get their liquor license, and will make for a good happy hour location. The pizzas were sizeable with average pricing. The pizza was made well; with flavorful toppings, a good red sauce, and a perfectly cooked crust. Regarding service, the staff were very friendly and delivered the pie to the table in a timely manner. Shopey's is much better than its predecessor and definitely worth a try. read more

See all

Came in at 8 they close at 9. They were out of almost everything? Just confused as to why that is, and why they couldn't just make it. Not the best customer service. Felt very rushed. Overall I would not come back here read more

The food is above and beyond not something you can find everywhere else we love sitting outside on the patio for a wonderful meal, the service is top notch everytime we go and it's very reasonably priced! And extremely delicious and well presented! We love Shopey's pizza our favorite place in Windsor! read more

Shopey's Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

See all

More than fast food pizza which is very good. Even better they have some pastas that are really good especially the lasagna.

Our experience with the management and staff has been great. We raised a few issues and the team worked with us to rectify to our complete satisfaction. Shop and eat local! And beers and wines are being poured. Always nice having pizza and a beer. read more

As a 20+ year fan of Anthony's Pizza, I was thrilled to find one in Windsor when we moved up here. And then it sold. Enter Shopeys. I can honestly say they are better! By far the best pizza we've tried up here. read more

The staff was nice. They were very cheap with the toppings however. I wish I would have went to King Sooper's and bought a microwave pizza instead. I would have $35 more in my pocket and ate the same type of pizza. The large was like other restaurants medium. They forgot most of the toppings on our farmers salad as well. I gave 2 stars for the friendly girl at the front counter and the cleanliness of the establishment. read more

Shopey's Pizza - 1/2 combo, 1/2 sausage size large - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

Great local place to grab a bite. They have lots of options and great pizza. I cannot wait until they get a liquor license and hopefully some local beer. The atmosphere is laid back but a great spot any night of the week. The employees were all super nice. A+ experience. read more

Shopey's Pizza - White Pizza with Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

Super NY thin-crust pizza. Really good cheese bread with warm marinara. Friendly staff. Clean. Reasonably priced. Nice music selections 60/70s. Highly recommend! read more

Best Pizza in Windsor / Timnath area ... I'm reluctant to post this ... I don't want the place to be too crowded ... but I can't help but say this is our favorite place for thin crust pizza! read more

Their Meat Pizza, Chicken Bacon Mac, and Pepperoni Rolls are simply the best!! After Shopey's got on board with Dash Pass (DoorDash), the total cost of their food+delivery was more reasonable. Blows the well know pizza chains out of the water. read more

I love a good calzone and they delivered! We had the meatballs they were delish and my son had the pepperoni rolls and devoured them! The food came out supper fast and the older gentleman that brought us our food was a gem! We will be back! read more

Outstanding!!!! We ordered two different pizzas, garlic knots and meatballs and it was all delicious. We will definitely order from here again! read more

Went in with low expectations since very few pizza places can make a New York style pizza with a decent crust. Ordered a chicken bacon ranch and a pepperoni. Both pizzas were cooked perfectly with minimal grease and a solid crust. The pizza is 5 star, but there are some issues with the location. The shared bathroom with Jimmy John's was gross, I'm not sure who is responsible for cleaning it but they are not. The other issue is it was freezing cold in there. It will be nice in July and August but my wife had to wear her coat in the restaurant to enjoy dinner. read more

Good pizza! Pickup always ready when I arrive. Greasy, cheesy goodness. Lots of seating for a fairly small suite.

The top of the pizza was one of the best I've seen. I was excited to get home and eat. Unfortunately , the bottom was burned black. I ate the top of one slice and then the whole pizza went in the trash. Disappointing. read more

Excellent NY style pizza!!!! The wings & house ranch are also great. Highly recommend this place as an East Coaster.

Wings are easily best in the area and fast delivery! Have ordered multiple times via DoorDash (with no fees over $12).

Came here for lunch for the first time. Great lunch specials. Staff is friendly, clean restaurant, great choice of toppings and pizzas. Got slices-red sauce was a little bland but loved the crust! May try a different sauce next time. read more

Awesome service! Darian and Jay were terrific and very easy to talk to. The food was outstanding and very very moderately priced, especially the lunch specials. Ambiance was very fun to be in as well, the bar top was quickly our favorite spot in the place! read more

Placed a $200 order and the restaurant only uses door dash as delivery service. When we we received the order, part of the order was incorrect and we called the restaurant to remedy the situation and was told they could not do anything to help and we had to go through DoorDash. DoorDash only gave us credit for 1/3 of the original cost of the item. Be aware if the restaurant messes up your order for delivery you will get nothing from them even though they got their money for the order. Poor customer service in my opinion!!! read more

First time we've ordered from here. Crust is very good, overall the pizza was very good. The toppings were pretty skimpy..... $25 for a pizza you expect more than just cheese and crust.... read more

Ordered pizza for take out and it was fairly burned. I'll likely come back and try again but for now they get 2 stars.