this whole location for Steven and I is so wonderful for people with disability and they just re-warmed the wonderful pizzas because they knew that we really wanted to put honey on read more

Slyce Pizza - fun - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Revived a burnt pizza that should have never had it to me. Should have been remade the sec it was pulled from the pizza oven. Waste of $50, was a doordash order, but that should NOT matter. Went right into the trash. Order was on 4-29-2026 A Wednesday night. read more

Slyce Pizza - pepperoni and sausage Burnt 12in pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I picked up five slices today. The pizzas in in the display case looked awesome, but the attendant grabbed slices from already cooked pies underneath the counter and heated those up. Three of them did not have toppings going anywhere near the outer edge of the pizza which means most of the slices were not covered with the ingredients shown on the display pies. Pretty disappointing. read more

Slyce Pizza - Dry slice no toppings - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

As a person who needs to avoid nightshades, I am pleased to say Slyce regularly has three to four "white" pizza options at all times for folks like me who need to side-step the red sauces. It's nice to have to pick. Also they do some intriguing flavors of the month. read more

Slyce Pizza - A Slyce pizza box with logo - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

We got a pepperoni and a cheese slice. The slices were pretty good though pricy for the size. The cheese did not have a ton of flavor but thought the crust was pretty solid. Quick service! read more

Slyce Pizza - Pepperoni slice and cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I really enjoyed Slyce the first few times we got it. The past few times (over the course of multiple months) it just tastes... burnt. It has an odd taste and an odd smell. I want to support them and like them, but the smell, taste, and rising pricing is really pushing me away. Unfortunately, I think this was my last time ordering their pizza. read more

Pretty fine. Came here cause they had gluten free crust, and I needed some for a gig. I've never been a huge fan of NY adjacent thin pizza: it can be pretty good fresh and hot by the slice, but once it cools down it feels like you're eating a soggy saltine. Not great if you're trying to feed a group. Again, this is more about my weariness of thin pizza, but there are definitely cheaper places that do what they do that are very similar. read more

Sure, come if you like burnt pizza slices. The place is convenient and the ambience is like any other place that sells by the slice. read more

Slyce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Pizza was really good and the service is quick. Slices are around $5 but they are good! read more

Slyce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This is both the worst AND the most expensive pizza I've ever had. Why people pay so much for such mediocre pizza is incredible. The tomato sauce tasted like cheap canned sauce and there was barely any cheese on the pizza. It gave my son diarrhea and I had a stomach ache immediately after eating. read more

The prices are on the higher side, but the slices are generous and absolutely delicious! We had our dogs with us so we ate out on the patio. No one else was dining outside, but it was pretty late. Overall, we'd definitely order from here again! read more

Slyce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Slyce Pizza is a dangerous place, and let me tell you why. The pizza here is that good. With the combination of delicious, fresh pies, incredibly reasonable prices, and fast, friendly service, it's far too easy to eat way more pizza than I should--and I'll be the first to admit, I've done it more than once. Whenever I'm in Old Town running errands or just out shopping, Slyce is my go-to spot for a quick and satisfying bite. The ambience is perfect, with bar seating that lines the large windows, giving you a great view of Old Town as you enjoy your meal. It's just the right mix of casual and cozy. What I love most about Slyce is the variety. There's always a huge selection of pizzas, but if you don't see something you like, just ask what else they have because they've got even more delicious options tucked away under the counter. So, if you find yourself in town and in need of a fast, flavorful meal, make sure to stop by Slyce. It's the kind of place where you'll leave with a full stomach, a smile on your face, and the promise to come back for more. You won't be disappointed. read more

Slyce Pizza - Can't go wrong with a slyce of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Overpriced and stale. Appearance could be better, they pizzas look like they've been sitting out all day

Staff is super friendly! The pizza is great! It's counter service. They have a variety of slices ready but I definitely recommend calling ahead for whole pies. Menu online shows some more options read more

Would give Slyce a 4.5/5 stars. The staff was friendly and the restaurant was clean. The pizza was pretty good-unfortunately neither slice was heated up enough so they were just luke warm. The pulled pork slice with red onion and sweet corn was by far the star of the two slices we got. If they had been heated a bit more, would have been a 5 star experience- we had already taken some bites of the pizza slices or would've had them put back in the oven. Slices are kind of steep ($6). read more

Slyce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Service was friendly and atmosphere was nice and clean. The Mac and cheese pizza wasn't warmed up enough for me at least. The cheese was barely melted and it didn't have flavor, just salty and mild cheese flavor. The other flavor I ordered was a jalepeno chicken cream cheese one with a tomato base. That one had a little more flavor yet it also wasn't warmed up enough. I don't know, I want to like this place more but I left feeling unsatisfied and disappointed. read more

I had heard about this place years ago but finally tried it out recently. Wish I tried it out a long time ago. Its got excellent pizza, great atmosphere, excellent service and convenient. Highly recommend. read more

Fresh, delicious, Pizza from traditional to classic and exotic for some. Fired in the oven, it's tasty! You'll enjoy the HUGE slices and save some dough! read more

Just moved to Foco recently and I have to say- Slyce might be some of the best pizza i've ever had!!! They warm up the slice for you, and I'm not sure what kind of oven they have but it gives the BEST crispy texture! The staff is super friendly, the Mac and Cheese pizza is AMAZING, and the vibes are super low-key but comfortable at the same time! Love the neon pizza sign. I'm definitely going to be a regularly returning customer!!!! read more

Slyce Pizza - Mac -N- Cheese Slice (the best slice) - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The only good thing about CSU is this pizza. Amazing people, good music, good prices for how huge this thing is. And it tastes amazing.

I just finished moving back to Fort Collins after a year of living about 30 minutes away. And I just tried Slyce for the first time a few weeks back. I was originally thrilled to walk the couple blocks over from my new place tonight, but now I won't ever be back. I placed an order for a 20" BYO, marinara base, and explicitly asked for the regular mozzarella. Then I started listing toppings, and asked for the vegan pepperoni and sausage, and a few others things. The person behind the service counter seemed to be struggling with the computer for a few moments, but then closed me out and said it would be about fifteen minutes. Once I got it home, I immediately noticed the texture and appearance of the cheese was off, and confirmed my suspicion that the pizza had been made with vegan cheese with a bite. I called into the restaurant, and the folks working admitted the mistake but excused themselves by saying they were "just confused" because I asked for vegan toppings. Except at no point did they ask for clarification. They pretended to register my order and then assumed I would accept whatever I was given. If they couldn't ring in or otherwise accommodate my request, they could have and should have explained it, and had every opportunity before taking my money. I was told I could walk the pizza back over and they would remake it. I was already going on hour 12 of loading and unloading boxes; ravenously hungry and well beyond my physical limits. I should have been offered a refund, but it became really clear that whoever I was speaking to on the phone wasn't going to do the right thing. I have higher expectations from a place slinging $50 pies. I sincerely hope that the folks at Slyce receive more accountability in service than they display. And, turns out, the pizza was mediocre. read more

One afternoon I was walking in old town and was looking for a quick bite. I saw Slyce and stopped by hoping for a ham + pineapple slice and a cream soda. The option they had that day (every day?) was a ham, pineapple, cheddar, and ranch pizza. Price for a slice felt steep, but I'm aware that businesses need to stay afloat... and I was hungry. It was a nice combo of flavors and the crust had a nice texture. They don't have a soda fountain, however, have a variety of bottled drinks. Yay for the cream soda! Friendly staff. Plenty of places to sit, however, the interior color scheme felt dark so I chose the front patio to enjoy the sunny day. No shaded seating upfront, however, on the west side of the building there is a bar stool sitting area shaded by trees- which is where I'll choose next time. 3 star as I didn't feel wow'ed by the experience. The pizza was delicious, so I'll try again. read more

Amazing food and amazing service. Shout out to the young man behind the counter. This place has passion. 10/10

Some cool NY style pizza by the slice right here in Fort Collins. Located in a 100+ year old building (yes, it shows). Has the friendliest staff and a wide variety of rotating options of slice. Reasonably priced for the size of the slice. Parking can be a nightmare, but if you're walking or biking, perfectly fine. The slices are hot and nice, and are sufficiently crispy with enough heat to burn the top of your mouth just like a NY slice. We got the spicy chicken and blue cheese (4.5/5), red pepper and mushroom (5/5), ravioli (4/5) and the artichoke one (4.5/5). We'll be back to try more. read more

Slyce Pizza - Ravioli and the Artichoke Spinach - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Prices are right, pizzas are one of a kind. The dough recipe seemed to have possibly changed? But it was still good per usual

Yes the pizza is AMAZING, however, their salads are not be overlooked. All of them are well thought out, dressings are house made and the best Ranch ever. Close second to Parmesan peppercorn. Even their kale salad is great, get it with parm/peppercorn. There's a new salad for every season and I'm craving the summer salad. read more

*Terrible Experience - False Advertising and Poor Communication** I had an incredibly frustrating experience with this pizza place. After placing an order over the phone and providing all necessary information, I was assured that my delivery would arrive within 40 minutes. However, when that time frame passed and I called back to inquire about my order, I was shocked to be told that they don't even offer delivery service. This level of false advertising and poor communication is completely unacceptable. It's clear that this establishment lacks basic organization and honesty in their operations. I will not be ordering from them again, and I strongly advise others to steer clear as well. **** Jeremy.... I called your store directly. I truly don't understand your response in the way you describe what happened. I never used a third party and therefore I was never "reimbursed" for the pizza. I was never rude or unreasonable. I feel like you may be referring to someone else in your response to me. read more

We were looking for good pizza for lunch... now we are from Chicago and I'll be straight up with you. We are pizza snobs aka picky with this category. After searching around my fellow Yelp peer reviews we stubbles on Slyce. To get right to it ... Slyce has a solid lineup of pizza. We went with the 4 cheese 20" pizza which was very good. The various cheese (Asiago, Mozzarella, Parmesan, Gruyere) and rosemary was a pleasant surprise which made for a nice tasting pizza. The garlic was an excellent taste to top it off. The only thing with this is we would have liked some red sauce. Don't get me wrong... it tasted very good and would go for this pizza again. The second pizza was the Italy- feta, spinach and tomato. wow! This was fantastic. We all seemed to really like the balance of the flavors in these ingredients. The staff was friendly, food was easy quickly and pizzas were excellent! I would recommend Slyce to you. read more

See all

Wow! So disappointed. Came in late to Fort Collins and needed dinner. Decided to order delivery since we were exhausted. Very Expensive stone cold pizza and very little lettuce in a large caesar salad. No plates, no forks, not even a napkin included. You know it's going to a hotel maybe you could include some essential items? Guess not. Well it was food, but just barely. I would never recommend this restaurant. And I'm sure they will blame it on Grubhub so they don't have to accept any responsibility whatsoever. Ok rant over. Just don't send anyone you care about to this place. read more

Grub hub order arrived cold to the touch. Over 100.00 on food here and it's cold. Will NEVER order here again. read more

Delicious NY style pizza! The dough is soooo fresh the crust has such a nice crunch. You know a pizza is good when you'd easily eat the dough/crust alone. I had a slice of the chicken parm and a slice of the the pepperoni and hamburger - both were incredibly delicious. Definitely need to come back for a slice of the bbq pineapple! read more

Slyce Pizza - two slices of pizza on paper plates - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This place. This pizza. Amazing!! Cool ass location, great friendly employees, and a very cool oven in the back you can watch! Buy some SOCKS!! read more

Great pizza options in a cool, old vibe setting. They will reheat your slice to take it to go or eat there. Reasonable price for the size of the slice. read more

Slyce Pizza - BBQ Pineapple Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Loved the slice pizza options. Staff were super nice. I sat on their patio and it was a perfect place to enjoy some pizza in nice weather.

Slyce has been my favorite pizza in Fort Collins since forever, and when it came time to select a caterer for our wedding we had the absolute delight of going through Slyce!! If you need an event/party/wedding/whatever catered I can't recommend them highly enough. Their catering options are awesome, we got to completely customize the pizzas and salads we served, and they brought these sick little mini pizza ovens to our venue so our guests had the same experience as people do in Slyces shop, it was so cool. Everyone we worked with was so kind and genuine, but I have to give an especially huge shoutout to Emily, thanks for everything you did for us. Also, Slyce was super accommodating to the varying dietary restrictions our guests had. I was told by multiple people that they served the best gluten free and vegan pizza they'd ever had. Our wedding food was delicious and memorable, thanks so much Slyce. Can't recommend their catering enough! read more

SLYCE. Y'all charged me for my pizza. But never gave me my veggie feta tonight. It was super busy so I'm going to let it slide. But y'all charged me and I tipped. Got home and realized it wasn't there in the mix of other slices. Y'all are usually on point. Outside of this situation. I've been to SLYCE so many times since I moved here last month. It's amazing great and they are usually on point. It was super busy tonight so I'm still giving five stars. But mark my words. Y'all short me and charge me again lol 1 star lol read more

Slyce is an Old Town pizza favorite, voted year after year as a top tier pizza restaurant in Fort Collins. They offer a unique take on NY style pizza - twisting traditional NY style with creative concoctions of pizza flavors including chicken cordon bleu, macaroni and cheese, pinapple barbeque, and Nashville hot chicken among others. It's location is easy to access, albeit parking can be difficult, and it boasts a casual ambiance perfect for a small pizza parlor. Their unique pizza creations mean there is generally something new to try anytime you visit. However, the traditionalists need not fret as they still offer traditional pepperoni and cheese pies. The major downside of Slyce is their pizza prep and ordering setup. They bake a lot of pies in advance for those who want individual slices. Then, when you order, they reheat the slices you want. This results in an overcooked crust which is borderline burnt and a cornicione that is so hard it's inedible. Instead of buying by the slice, I will need to try buying an entire, freshly baked pie to see if the crust sucks as much that way. If they would bake individual slices to order as other establishments do, they would drastically increase quality. Overall, it's a good pizza restaurant. It stands out for the variety of topping combinations and would make a great place for college kids to eat after a night out. However, there are better options in Northern Colorado. read more

As a New Yorker, I LOVE pizza and I am super picky. We've lived here now for almost 5 years and I must admit it's been hard to find a great pizza spot... But my son came in to town from Denver and I asked around a few of my friends to find out what their pizza recommendation would be. Based on their feedback I chose to get a large pepperoni and sausage pizza from Slyce! Since I am eating Paleo... All I could do was drool all over it!! And I relied on my son to tell me that this was great pizza! That's all I needed to hear... Because he's as picky as I am when it comes to pizza! So if you're looking for a New York style pizza with tons of toppings and cheese, this is the place! read more

Tried the pepperoni slice and the "famous" pesto artichoke slice. It was mids...nothing special in my opinion. For $6/slice it should be much better and bigger. Good service though. 6.9/10 read more

I didn't think pizza could get any better but Slyce made it happen. Mac and cheese pizza?! Incredible. We were looking for something quick and it was perfect, I would go out of my way to come here again. $5 per slice is a bit much, but it was a specialty slice and it was delicious Also nice there was plenty of seating Everyone was so friendly too! Great spot read more

Slyce Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado