4 stars for Colorado, but if I were back East, this would probably be a 3-star pizza spot. Pizza Casbah is solid and definitely scratches the itch, especially compared to a lot of the pizza around here. The slices are big, the crust has a decent chew, and overall it's satisfying--but coming from the East Coast, my pizza standards are unfortunately obnoxiously high. The sauce/crust/cheese ratio just doesn't quite hit that classic NY/NJ pizza level for me, and I wouldn't call it amazing pizza if I were rating it back home. But for Fort Collins? It's one of the better options I've found. So: Colorado rating. East Coast rating. read more

Came here for the first time in 10 years...So good. Always so accommodating. Just ordered two slices right before closing and they were fantastic. Perfect. Classic "dive" college pizza/beer place. Menu is confusing, but it always has been. If you're around and not eating this pizza, you're messing up. read more

Pizza Casbah - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Was expecting a decent wing and pizza date. But the wings are horrendous. And my girlfriend got the pizza...it was burnt

Pizza Casbah is a place you have to try! The pizza is the best I've ever had, the service and ambience are top notch, and Pete is an amazing person! Go support this local business!!! read more

Simply the best slice in FOCO and pretty cheap. Just walk in and try it out, you will not be disappointed.

Everything is always burnt and they sell pizzas that are short 16 in are sold as 18 in

Bbq sauce on bottom of box now all over my leather seats, I didn't get bbq pizza. Also was burnt to a crisp. Overall do not recommend. read more

Pizza Casbah - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

I have been here multiple times since my freshman year of college. The prices are always friendly, and they even do deals some days, which I really appreciate. I love the artwork on the walls and how they have made the space feel really cool and fun. The pizza is always so good and my roommates and I love the sauce that they make. Overall, a great spot to grab something to eat! read more

For starters a lot of these reviews are very skewed and definitely not accurate. The pizza here is some of the best you will find until you hit Connecticut. All of the food is fresh, homemade dough, hand grated cheese, sauce on the stove for 8 hours. You can taste the difference, and the service is great. It is a lot of students which might explain some of the reviews. The ambiance is as old school pizza joint as you can get!! go and get you some!! read more

The owner Pete swears and cusses customers out when his shitty "restaurant" screws up your order. I haven't eaten here in months because last trip they again gave me the WRONG order. Not even close!! Pete will hopefully be OUT OF BUSINESS very soon. His lack of appreciation for paying customers is pathetic and inexcusable. I won't ever be back after he told me to "F off" This was after they burned the pita bread and made me wait while they made another one...with lamb meat BURNED AND BLACK. I took one bite and threw it away. Waste of 8 dollars and no lunch thanks to them. He doesn't deserve to work at McDonalds. This place has gone far downhill and his terrible attitude is probably to blame. Avoid this place at all costs I will also be contacting the BBB in Fort Collins to alert them of this asshole and his read more

this place is so good and so affordable, i eat here what feels like every other day. love having pizza slices the side of my head and the gyros are also pretty good read more

Best pizza place in Fort Collins. Regular cheese pizza and mozzarella sticks are typically our go to, but their specialty pizzas are the ! Highly recommended!! read more

See all

Here's the rub. I like their pizza but hate their customer service. I stayed away for years because of a lunch time fiasco (I had ordered lunch, gave them my card. Waited. Waited more. Called. They "lost" my order. No delivery. No lunch. No apology.). That was enough for me. I should've stayed there. Seriously, folx. But the years passed, and I decided to give them another try. A few deliveries to the office every now and then, followed by a few in restaurant pick-ups. Staff is always curt, like they have better things to do than take my order. Not my favorite feeling, but I've tried to extend grace. Ordered a pizza this evening. Specifically asked delivery driver to NOT leave pizza on the floor outside my door. Indicated I would mask up and answer door to accept pizza. Not what happened. Driver left pizza on the floor outside my door. And, my Caesar salad had disgusting brown iceberg lettuce in it! Who makes a Caesar with iceberg? Not to mention the bonus of receiving Kraft dressing. No thanks on so many levels! Consistently poor service. Kraft salad dressing. I've learned my lesson. I chose to pass on the Casbah experience. read more

Pizza Casbah - Brown iceberg lettuce in my Caesar salad. No thanks! - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

The first time I heard about Pizza Casbah was in a class at CSU when Pete came to speak to a class. I figured I might as well check it out, and brought a friend with me. . . and I wished I had heard about this place sooner! The pizza is by far the best in Fort Collins. I'm a sucker for good pizza dough, and man is Casbah's is AMAZING! The pizza is a little on the greasy side, but that makes it taste even better! Pete does a great job! I wasn't a huge fan of the seating/area inside, but they have an amazing patio to eat outside! This is defiantly a pizza place you NEED to check out! Best in Fort Collins! read more

This place is just a classic college pizza joint. You get the feel walking in with the couple of arcade games, sign for $1 PBRs, and just this vibe like many college students have definitely vomited here on late nights. But that certainly doesn't take away from the pizza they produced. A friend suggested Pizza Casbah so craving pizzas to-go while in town during the lunch hour I figured I'd check them out. I really appreciated that their menu had a wide array of vegetarian options. The prices weren't too crazy either even for these specialty pizzas and I enjoyed the ones we tried. Even if you want to stick to cheese, I got a 18" and it just hit the spot and was a lot of pizza. Employees were respecting COVID-19 precautions while I was there and told me when I ordered on the phone that masks were required to enter so much appreciated on that front. Ultimately, I'd return again if in the mood for a pizza and in reliving college days for some reason. As I don't drink anymore, I'll pass on the $1 PBRs and the possible insane drunkenness when we get out of COVID times. In conclusion, Sharif does like it! Pizza Casbah! read more

I have eaten at Pizza Casbah several times, and if I am being completely honest, the first time I went, I just wanted one of those pizzas you can't fit through the door. After trying it, I can honestly say it is my favorite pizza in northern colorado. The crust is always cooked perfectly with the perfect amount of sauce and toppings. The restaurant is annoying to get to and I wish there was one closer to windsor, but excellent food every time! read more

Realized it had been too long since my last visit. So I jumped in the car and I was very happy I did. Just as I remembered, simply excellent NY style pizza. And just seeing the 24" pizza laid out in all its glory, always makes me grin from ear to ear. read more

Sept 2018- updated review Just placed my semi-annual party order this past weekend and was once again super happy with the crew at Pizza Casbah and the quality of our food! I almost ordered from another joint closer to home, but just couldn't bring myself to do it. Thank Goodness! Pizza casbah is the best! Shout out to the three that helped me on this order: Harley, Asia and Owen. All three were awesome and friendly. Previous review: If I'm gonna eat pizza, I want it to be great... calorie-worthy pizza. Pizza Casbah is, every time. It's a small joint near CSU. Not a ton of indoor seating, but normally we don't have a problem grabbing a table. It's New York style pizza.... thin crust deliciousness. The menu offers tons of specialty pizza options for both carnivores & vegetarians. I typically order one of the veggie pizzas but the cBBQ pizza is also amazing. Only hungry for a slice or two and don't want the same thing as your dining partner? No problem! They'll sell any type of pizza by the slice! I also order form pizza casbah twice per year for special event. They've never messed up the order and have been polite, accommodating and on-time. This place is seriously my favorite go-to pizza joint in FoCo. Come and you'll be glad u did! read more

See all

Casbah is my favorite pizza place in the world (no joke). I used to go here all the time for dollar slices as a broke college student. Never disappointed! Now that I'm older, it hasn't changed a bit! It's the same great slice time and time again. Quality chewy crust (ask for extra crispy). Quality cheeses and toppings! Absolutely love this pizza place. It's the best in Fort Collins if you like NY style pizza. Check them out! read more

In town for a night and this place was recommended by a friend. Good pies, easy ordering experience through the yelp app and the delivery was on time delivered by a nice, friendly delivery driver from Casbah. Look, I am not gonna tell ya it was the best pizza I've ever had BUT....it was a really good pizza, it's quite filling for a thin crust style Za and it was very convenient! I'd definitely do it again next time I'm in town! read more

Pizza Casbah - "Build your own" veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Great little hole in the wall serving good pizza for a great price. The HUGE slices run $3-6 (3 for a cheese and then more for the specialty types). I got the gyro sandwich instead of pizza, which I throughly regretted. The lamb on the sandwich was over cooked and it could have used way more tzaiki sauce. Stick with the pizza for sure. Service on a Monday night was quick, and I love the location in downtown Ft. Collins, where I could walk around while I wait. The systems that they put in place due to COVID appeared to be effective and they weren't super inconvenient. read more

See all

Great food and great people. I haven't had anything on the menu that isn't great. It's just a fun place to visit. read more

They're pizza fugs great crispy crust, good sauce, and plenty of cheese. Price is right too and service is good.

I'm just a slut for greasy pizza. Has some of the best prices in town for the wettest, greasiest pizza in all of northern colorado. Gotta hand it to the boys in the back for makin it sloppy. read more

We have been ordering pizza from this place for the past 3 years and is always great! Last order, pizza on a snowy day for pickup. They were jammed, phone blowing up with orders but the guy at the register was super nice and kept his cool. I definitely recommend this place Ps: PARKING for pick up can be a little difficult as there are little spots available so if possible, two people in the car are suggested. One to get off and get the pizza and another one to go around the block if you don't want to pay for parking in that really tiny alley around the corner. read more

It's extremely disappointing when you have an amazing pizza, but only half your order was for failed. Caution. read more

Pizza Casbah - It's extremely disappointing when you come to this cross. Missing items in your order. - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Marinara and ricotta base. Sausage and fresh basil. Well done. This is one of the greatest pizzas I've ever had. Thank you to whoever made it. read more

Pizza Casbah - a slice taken out of a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

You should go to cosmos or slice for better pizza. They do have a mural on the wall with Frank but this place is not good. This town is dry when it comes to good pizza. read more

What a treat!!! We got there and it was packed with college kids, middle agers, a dad in town visiting his student son, and a young family. So obvi a very eclectic clientele. We could see why right away. There was something for everyone!! Including a 24" pizza!! That thing was soooo huge! Wings. A million kinds of pizza. Sandwiches. Mellow Yellow on tap. We got a giant slice of The Queens and it was delicious! Exact same size you get in NYC! We also got an All American pizza. Tator Tots on a pizza? Yes please!!! It's a tiny hole in the wall. Narrow and deep just like the pizza places in NYC. So even the actual restaurant was authentic. Loved it. Go!!!! read more

Pizza Casbah - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Pizza Casbah is exceptional NY style pizza right here in Fort Collins. The pizza is a great value, and always tasty. The Brooklyn Deluxe is my personal favorite. And, getting extra cheese on any of their pizzas is always a really nice bonus (some places it's too heavy or makes the slice fall apart). Also, they have a nice little dessert option in zeppoles (I like the cinnamon sugar + icing). I've actually never eaten in, so I can't comment on that part of the experience but their delivery is always earlier/faster than expected. read more

Heard good things about this place and decided to check it out. Waited over 35 minutes for our pizzas. It this is "New York's Finest Pizza in Ft. Collins" the bar could not be set much lower. Totally overcooked and not even close to expectations. Could have done better at Papa Murphy's read more

Pizza Casbah - The Soho Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Great pizza and great atmosphere. Definitely will be back when in the Fort Collins area.

Absolutely delicious! Legit New York slices! Friendly! Fun hole-in-the-wall! Harley was an awesome employee and very helpful! Highly recommend! We tried four different kinds of pizza and two types of wings with a happy-hour beer :-) read more

See all

First time ordering and the pie was excellent! The delivery man was polite and on time. Casbah is my go to place for pizza! Ordered delivery for a meatball sub with spicy marinara and a Greek salad. OMG the spicy marinara was excellent and the sandwich had a great deal of meatballs. It was delivered hot and on time. My favorite place for Italian food! read more

This has been my go-to pizza place for years because when they get it right it is delicious pizza. In the last several months, though, the pizza hasn't been consistent- it's either raw and floppy or overcooked and burnt. I'll start the search for a new go-to. read more

Pizza Casbah - Burnt crust - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Best pizza in Fort Collins for the price. Good atmosphere and ambiance in the restaurant as well.

85% Chance they'll get your order right. But even if you get the wrong stuff the pizza is solid. Good crust.

There is no better pizza place in town in comparison to Casbah. Any occasion, in-laws in town, celebrations, you name it, I go here. Amazing and authentic NY style pies. I can't get enough so I stock up on the frozen personal pies to go and fill the freezer. Still amazing!! read more

Pizza casbah was one of my favorite places to go when attending CSU. Decided to stop by for a bite to eat the other day and the experience was less than pleasant. The restaurant roof was under construction and there was debris all over, they definitely should not have been open while the work was being done. Secondly, our food was cold and seemed like it had been sitting out for some time. We were told we could sit on the patio since we couldn't sit inside but the tables and chairs were chained up so we ended up having to leave. Also disappointing that they got rid of their specials during the week. Can't say we'll be returning after this. read more

I asked a co-worker where the best pizza in Fort Collins was and she immediately answered Pizza Casbah! We were not disappointed. We got an 18" pie for 4. We really enjoyed the thin crust pizza with its rich sauce to the basic toppings-- pepperoni, mushrooms and extra cheese all the way to the end of the crust--foldable at the beginning to the slightly chewy toward the end. The counter staff was great. Polite, friendly, accurate. What more could you want? If you like New York Style pizza, check this place out! read more