Cancel

Open app

Search

Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop

4.3 (14 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop Photos

MAMA RUTH'S PIZZA SHOP ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop

Recommended Reviews - Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

the front of the restaurant

I've driven by this place for years, wondering how the pizza was at this small shop in the tiny town of Gilcrest. They managed to stay in business, so I figured their pizza must either be handy for the locals or is really good, so I finally gave them a try. They are a very no-frills type of pizza place. They have seating but you order at a counter though they will bring your pizza out to you when it is ready. Sodas are available from a fountain or in bottles. The pizza arrived in about twelve minutes, and from the first bite, I was thrilled I made the trip. The cheese was tasty, the sauce and sausage wonderful, but what really impressed me was the crust. I like thin, cracker-type crusts and this was one of the thinner crusts I've found in all of Colorado. It was crispy, but still held the cheese, sauce and sausage without collapsing. I inhaled the pizza, it was wonderful. Too often surprises are bad ones; this place was excellent and I will definitely return.

Pepperoni pizza with green chili
Elaine P.

What a find! If you're on Hwy 85 and hungry this is a perfect stop! Pizza with green chili was soo good. Wings were perfectly seasoned.

Dining room

See all

Photo of C S.
1
301
60

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

What I love most about living in a small town is how great our food places are. Love the Pizza rolls !

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Christa N.
55
108
80

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tristan R.
282
11
27

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Joel D.
5
89
13

8 years ago

Just stopped here for a pizza to go due to other positive reviews. Looks and smells delicious. I love traditional pizza places like this.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop

Review Highlights - Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop

“What I love most about living in a small town is how great our food places are.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Chicken Wings 178 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Crosscut Pizzeria and Taphouse - Delish build your own

Crosscut Pizzeria and Taphouse

4.4(397 reviews)
44.8 mi
•$$

Crossroads has won me over! What a great discovery at the quaint town!…read more The pizza we ordered was the TEO with a homemade chili honey, bacon, plenty of cheese and jalapeños- if you want them. I chose not to have jalapenos. The beer and ciders are local and delicious! My two favorite things about this restaurant besides the obvious food would be the river views and a breeze , and service! Casual relaxing atmosphere! Free parking.

Line wrapped around the corner. Everyone waiting said it was the best spot in town. After a little…read morewait, we snagged a table. Luckily, two tops seemed pretty readily available. I want to say it was busy for sure but because it's pizza, there is no actual urgency. The pizzas take as long as they take so give yourself plenty of time. A few things I'd like to take a moment to point out. A.) Pizza needed to be cooked longer. I would have preferred them to cook it so that the cheese all melted. It's not really appetizing when it's not. Maybe another min or two could help but I'm guessing with them being as busy as they were, they may have pulled them early. B.) plates could have been cleaner. Server also asked us more than once if we needed anything else, and I did ask for a glass with ice so I can add it to our warm water that was on the table when we arrived, and I also asked for a straw and never received either. Pretty disappointed in the service. Nice enough young lady but don't ask me if I need anything and then never do it. Twice. It could have been cleaner across the board. Lots of flies and gnats flying around. I waited tables for decades and I always hustled. Clearing, cleaning, greeting a table so you know someone is coming even if you can't take their order yet. I think maybe just the small town and laid back lifestyle could explain it all. On the plus side, I am excited about reheating the pizza for lunch today because it was a little under, it will cook nicely today.

Photos
Crosscut Pizzeria and Taphouse - Entryway

Entryway

Crosscut Pizzeria and Taphouse - Built our own pizza

Built our own pizza

Crosscut Pizzeria and Taphouse - Pliny the Elder IPA and Wild Cider

See all

Pliny the Elder IPA and Wild Cider

Antonio's Real New York Pizza - Antonio with a 26" pie.

Antonio's Real New York Pizza

4.3(1.4k reviews)
38.5 mi
•$$

Antonio's is insanely good! They have some unique, award winning pizza options. I got to try their…read moregarlic knots, spicy pizza (the one with ricotta, sweet peppers, balsamic, tomatoes, etc.), and their homemade NY cheesecake. I've had a lot of pizza over the years and I can honestly say this is the best pizza I have had in a long time. The flavors worked so perfectly together. The spicy, the savory, the cheesy! As someone who had never been to Estes Park before, I'm so sad that I will probably not get to have their pizza again. But, gosh, I'll tell everyone about it! The pizzas are also delivered by robot which is super cool. The cheesecake was top tier too.

We did take out, and I had heard about this place as a must go to at some point. I was honestly…read moresorta disappointed. The process for picking food up was not very good. The actual pizza was fine but nothing special and had gallons of oil and grease on it. The cheeses bread was good! But also soooo greasy. I'm not one to complain about grease but it was a little crazy The Godfather Prosciutto di Parma, spicy Capicola, Genoa Salami, pepperoncinis, provolone, parmigiano reggiano, roasted red peppers and garlic. ---- at first, we were unsure if they gave us the correct pizza because we couldn't see or taste any meat Garlic Bread / Cheesy Garlic Bread Real house-made Garlic Bread, choose between cheesy and regular! You get the whole loaf of bread just like you see in the photo. ---- this was better than the pizza in my opinion

Photos
Antonio's Real New York Pizza - Six 10-inch personal pies.

Six 10-inch personal pies.

Antonio's Real New York Pizza - Sicilian pies are a house specialty.

Sicilian pies are a house specialty.

Antonio's Real New York Pizza - 26" beef, pepperoni and extra cheese

See all

26" beef, pepperoni and extra cheese

Mangia Mangia Pizzeria - Meeker Margherita

Mangia Mangia Pizzeria

4.6(25 reviews)
38.9 mi

We hired them to cater a dinner for 100 people. the pizzas were excellent! However: 1. they could…read morenot keep up with the demand - people were standing in the rain for 15 + minutes waiting as fresh 12" pizzas came out 3 at a time. 2. they ran out of salad (said they had prepared for 125 - but people were eating healthy... bottom line, you be prepared, just don't "run out")... 3. also ran out of plates (they had 150 - but if 100 people each use another plate when they come back for another slice...do the math). 4. there was a mandatory 25% gratuity, and if that was not enough, they charged the gratuity on the sales tax! Bottom line - great pizza, I would pay $20+ for a pizza from them as a food truck, but over $5000 for what we got was excessive.

This is a food truck located at the Lumpy Ridge Brewing Company, at least on Sundays. Google does…read morenot give the correct directions - when we followed them, we ended up in a random parking lot a block over. I recommend setting the GPS to the brewery rather than the truck. When we visited on Sunday after hiking at RMNP for the morning, there wasn't much of a crowd here. We ordered and the the food only took about 8 minutes to arrive. Meeker Margherita ($21) - Perfectly cooked crust in this pizza. The cornicione in particular is expertly risen and cooked, giving plenty of charred bubbles and the perfect chewiness. The undercarriage, while floppy, isn't soggy at all. It hold up very well to the ingredients on top. The crust is first slathered sparingly with tomato sauce. The sauce is reduced quite a bit and tastes almost like a concentrated tomato paste. They don't use a lot so it doesn't soak into the crust at all. On top, there's a couple of pieces of basil giving a very noticeably fresh aroma. There's plenty of melted mozzarella cheese, which seem to be of the pearl variety, mild tasting and stretchy. They apparently also drizzle some EVOO, although there's no particular peppery or fruity notes, or heck any real olive oil flavor at all. With how well all the other ingredients worked together, the olive oil is very disappointing. Still, it's a very well constructed pizza. (5/5) Panorama Peak ($23) - Again, this pizza has the perfect crust. Instead of tomato sauce, it's slathered with ricotta cheese, making the pizza very rich and creamy. More melted mozzarella on top of that for even more fatty richness, then pieces of proscuitto, chewy and salty. The meat isn't sliced that well so it's messy to eat. They then essentially cover the pizza with an arugula, tomato, and shaved parmesan salad. The arugula is super peppery and bitter, the tomatoes are fresh and sweet, and the parmesan adds more saltiness. The main sources of salt are the parmesan and the proscuitto. Neither are added in large enough quantities to make the pie overly salty. Mixed in the with the arugula are a couple of stems of cilantro for some reason. Nothing on the menu actually uses cilantro so I'm a bit confused where it comes from. It's essentially a salad on pizza dough so everything falls off the crust very easily making it messy to eat. (4/5) I'm very impressed with the food served at Mangia Mangia. I didn't expect to find such great pizza in a small touristy mountain town. I'll be back next time I'm in the area! Bathrooms - Two unisex rooms in the brewery

Photos
Mangia Mangia Pizzeria
Mangia Mangia Pizzeria - Panorama Peak

Panorama Peak

Mangia Mangia Pizzeria - Menu (Oct 2025)

See all

Menu (Oct 2025)

Mama Ruth's Pizza Shop - chicken_wings - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...