We went to Windsor Mill Tavern Saturday Evening, 6th of December and we absolutely LOVE it! The staff seems to love their jobs, the service is amazing and the food is delicious and comforting. I had the delicious crab cake appetizer and Salmon in Beurre Blanc Sauce and my husband had the Fried Cheese Curds and Stuffed Pork chop. Both absolutely delicious. Best Mashed potatoes I have ever had. This was our second time at Windsor Mill Tavern and we love the warm Irish Pub Style atmosphere. Only thing missing is a fireplace! This is our new favorite hangout after having moved here to Severance, Co this past March. We love it. Oh! And the seats are comfortable as well. We will be back. Love having a place that is only a couple miles away from where we reside! Well done staff and management! This place is a gem!!!! And the prices? Quite reasonable! read more

See all

Great spot in Windsor. It was packed on a Friday night, definitely suggest a reservation. We waited about 40 min for two of us without reservations. We started with the Cheese Curds - these were great, the breading on the curds had really good flavor. Would order again. For entrees we ordered; bacon avocado burger - their burgers are huge, and a lot of great flavor. Would definitely order again Cup of bison chili - chunks of bison meat in the chili and was a nice portion. The flavor is good, I'm glad I tried it and would order again. Moody blue salad - this salad was big and packed full of goodies, it was the best salad I've had in a long time. The balsamic dressing was so good, mixed with the candied pecans and blue cheese, so good! I'd come back simply for this salad. Our server was a little spread thin and had tables on opposite sides of the restaurant, so we felt a little neglected, but when he was around, service was great. Just had to wait for long periods of time for water/drink refills. Overall, glad we stumbled upon this place and will definitely come back again. read more

See all

I love the tavern! This is our got to place for weekday dinner with neighbors or when we don't feel like eating at home. This time we tried the brunch menu and my husband loved the bison scramble bowl. I did my moody blue salad which I'm obsessed with and is my constant go to. The service is always super attentive and the location is perfect. read more

Wow! Loved the vibe here. The prices are great. The full bar is filled with anything anyone could ever want. The staff were nice and attentive. Our food was delicious! The burger and meatloaf were delicious. The crab cake was SO good!! read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

Slow service, mediocre food. Loud atmosphere.. could be an okay place but must improve all.

We've been to Windsor Mill Tavern a handful of times now and it's quickly become one of our go-to spots. I love the weekday deals, it gives us an excuse to pop in without feeling like we're splurging. The menu is huge (in a good way) and honestly has something for whatever you're in the mood for. We've tried a few different things and have never been disappointed. They also have a solid tap list, including our favorite: 805. The ambiance is perfect for a casual date night with a good vibe all around. read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Menu - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

See all

When in the Greeley area, I was hungry for lunch and found Windsor Mill Tavern via Yelp. Fun little place! It's in the basement of a building -- so it took me a few minutes to fugue out how to enter the place. I sat at the bar, and my bartender was great. I started with a cream of chicken soup -- it was excellent, and I wish I had ordered a bowl instead of a cup. : ) For my main course, I ordered the steak bites with mashed potatoes. The steak was ok -- some pieces were pretty chewy -- but I ate most of it and enjoyed the mashed potatoes a lot. Total bill -- with tip -- was $40. Not bad considering how high inflation is! read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Cream of chicken soup -- excellent!!! - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

See all

Had a val pack coupon (buy 1 burger get 1 free). I could not use because of happy hour? It's a special can't do use with other special. This bartender has been rude to me in the past. The only reason I go to Windsor Mill is because of coupon Apparently do not want new customers. Cost me. 45.00 for burger and my drinks. ( Cause buy one burger get one free does not apply during happy hour). Use coupons before happy hour. Was not a happy hour for me. read more

Having been here many times in the past this visit was a bit of a disappointment. The good news is they still have Juicy Bits (NEHIPA) on tap. Curious news is they only have 1 white wine, in this case Pinot Grigio, on happy hour. . The bad news concerned dinner. I've always ordered the curried mussels appetizer with the soup of the day. Before it was prepped with yellow Urey and was delicious. This time it was either red curry but more likely sriracha and it was hot ... TOO DAMN HOT in my opinion. Wasn't an enjoyable meal at all yet it was still described on the menu as yellow curry. It even looked different than times past. Perhaps a one off as we'll try it again. Oh, I also had a cup of the soup of the day which was a steak and potato chowder. It was excellent!!! read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Chicken Cordon Blue w/Asparagus - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

This is our second time coming to Windsor Mill Tavern. We were hoping for the prime rib but they stopped making it. We still had a great experience. The margarita I had was perfection, I got the chicken fried waygu and my husband got the chicken risotto. We also enjoyed the cheese curds and Brussels for a starter. We ended with the espresso torte and bread pudding. Everything was wonderful! read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Chicken friend wagyu - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

See all

What a great place! Tucked into the property with several other restaurants in downtown Windsor. Built in the style of an Irish pub the ambiance is so cool. Plenty of space for guests and diners. I had the Bangers and Mash, a perfect Irish fare. My wife had the Cowboy burger and had to bring half home. Our friend had the Bison Philly and it filled the plate. Try the bourbon bread pudding too. Our server, Sophia was awesome and was very responsive, friendly, and timely. The entire staff was busy and the bar was packed as well. read more

See all

Amazing drinks, food and service. The fish and chips (walleye) was delicious. I'm sorry I didn't take any photos read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Street view - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

All of the staff from initial greeting to servers to food runners were all very nice. Food was good, fresh, not greasy and served hot which is nice. Nice variety in food and drink options. Wish more restaurants would have runners for just bringing out food while it's hot. Prices were very reasonable, brunch was pleasant, decor was cool with the large wooden beams and old building. Cocktails were fun and good bourbon selection. Will be going back for sure and thanks for a good time! Enjoy local non chains, support local restaurants and businesses! read more

Absolutely love this place. We go back almost once a month. The curds are to die for. read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Pineapple teriyaki burger with bison patty and side of soup, chef's special was a steak chowder. - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

See all

Had the chicken risotto and it was absolutely fabulous! One of the best dishes I've ever had at a restaurant

Love their Happy Hour....while my favorite item is the chicken pot pie is awesome! Great atmosphere.... i've even booked their special room for my birthday. read more

We've been pretty disappointed in the food in CO until we got here. Great service (super nice), great drinks and the food was really good.

First time at Windsor Mill Tavern - it was recommended by a friend and we took them at their word. There were a few positives: The hot buttered rum was amazing and a great way to open the meal. The deviled eggs were a delicious appetizer. Finally, the creme brûlée was perfect. Unfortunately, the rest of our experience was generally pretty awful: The restaurant is filled with bar stool height chairs. Not really comfortable for short folks or people with any lower limb issues. There was a single table with normal seating - thank heavens that table happened to be available. The sirloin was the texture of shoe leather. It was ordered medium rare - emphasis on rare - so it was not an issue of overcooking. Very disappointing since we live in beef country. The mashed potatoes arrived at room temperature. The replacement was also at room temperature. I figured that "third time's a charm", so I tried again. The next replacement was just a bit warmer than room temp - certainly NOT hot. Tepid potatoes are pretty unappetizing. The broccoli arrived equally cold - might as well have been on a veggie & cheese plate. The replacement was at least warm enough to eat, but also not hot. Finally, there was no offering of a water refill, despite the obviously empty glass on the table. All of this for $90. Perhaps folks looking for "bar food" will find what they are looking for - we did not partake of that part of the menu. Needless to say, we shan't return. read more

First of all, 2 stars is the average. Service is 5 stars. Food- not good. Hopefully we were just unlucky: Grilled chicken sandwich... driest chicken possible, way too much fig jam and goat cheese, prochutto just burned taste Tritip sandwich: beyond dry meat, bread was stale and sucked up all the just first dip.. cheese sauce tried to moisten the crazy dry beef but just makes a gross gloopy mess. If you come don't order these items maybe the worst food I've had it others liked different items at other tables... read more

Food was excellent, had the lamb chops and couldn't be happier. Hadn't tried a southern gentleman cocktail before, will definitely get again. And our server was attentive, funny, helpful with recommendations. Very nice place to take a spell, partner or friend you want to impress. read more

The service was excellent. The food was delicous and served at a great pace. Portions are huge. Could easily split the sandwiches. Had french dip, wedge salad. Cool interior in an old mill. read more

Delicious food and great service. Muscles were delicious, with a mustard enhanced sauce.

Cool environment, friendly service, good food. We went for some late night food, the place was hopping even at 9.

Had great Service, place was packed and we only waited 10 min. Food had awesome flavor! read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Brussels, Side Asparagus, Steak - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

Not a family friendly establishment. If you want to take your kids with you find somewhere else. Plus they don't have high chairs at all. Their representative said they don't want babies in their restaurant. read more

A very cool place. It's a little loud and not really for kids (we brought ours, assuming there were kids options, oops), but it's a cool tavern with very good food. My husband got the tri tip sandwich and fries, I got the chicken and Parmesan risotto, and both of us loved our dishes so much. My chicken breast was perfectly cooked, moist and juicy. The risotto was cooked well with no crunchy or chewy bits. The goat cheese and sundried tomatoes worked really well, and I don't even like goat cheese. My daughter got a half order of chicken fingers and garlicky green beans, which she ate most of. Drinks were good, prices were good. We'll be back. read more

Always a hit. Every menu choice is a good one. Daily specials are fun. Staff friendly but let you enjoy time with table mates. Family friendly too! Pretzel and Wedge salad get my top billing. read more

The staff at the tavern are amazing,hard working,just the best in town! The food is also very good! The atmosphere is always a good vibe!

The food is awesome but man the service is slow! Expect to be there a minimum of 2 hours. This was our second time here and both instances we were there for three hours, woof! Maybe if you show up before 6:30 it goes faster but I am not sure... read more

While in Fort Collins/Loveland area , we decided to check out downtown Windsor for a late night dinner. We arrived about 8:30 and they were pretty busy and became much more busy as the night went on. Bethany was our server and she was super sweet, fun and accommodating. We started with some cocktails & beers, as well as ordered some appetizers for the table (cheese curds & boneless Buffalo wings)-- everything was very good. For dinner, we ordered the crispy chicken sandwich (table favorite), the Meatloaf (came out on the colder side) and the Cottage Pie (cold & not much flavor). Our server accommodated the mishaps, which was very kind & appreciated. Great atmosphere, fun menu. read more

See all

Excellent service for our group of 10!! I shared the Brussel sprouts (not cooked soft enough), deviled eggs (good), and a Blue moon or moody salad, added chicken and it was decent, but not amazing. Chicken could have been more tender. My son had the chicken fried steak and it was huge! My husband's hamburger and French fries were delicious. read more

My boyfriend and I went here a couple times for date night from appetizers to entrées to drinks. All was amazing. I haven't had a bad thing yet. The weight stuff is amazing and very attentive and the ambience is nice and relaxing. read more

This is one of our favorite places to go out for dinner both with family or for a date night. HOWEVER, getting rid of the brussel spouts is a crucial mistake... and for that you lose a star. read more

HOLY GUACAMOLE!!! THIS PLACE IS HEAVEN!!!! WOOOO. Since moving down from Alaska we've been trying to find a restaurant with actual good food here in Colorado! Everywhere has disappointed - from the Thai food to the Indian food, even the Mexican food here is so bland! Yes you read that right, Mexican food is better in Alaska?? YOU BET IT IS!!! But Windsor Tavern Mill, y'all hit it out of the park with this one!!! Who needs to go to church when you've got exquisite food, music and design!!! I thought I was going in a dungeon when I first arrived - good bye world I'll never see daylight again! AND I wished I didn't!! My tastebuds went off the chart!! Ain't no Piñata in my mouth but it sure felt like it, along with the Casa Bonita theme music. YEEHAW!! If you haven't been here yet - it's a MUST. So get yer behind down into the Tavern mill NOW! read more

We had a great time great menu, the service was ok but a little slow. Our food came out and it was amazing! My husband's potatoes came out a little dry but the rest of our food came out great! The atmosphere around us was amazing, not to loud not to quiet. We will be looking forward to heading back there again!! read more

Have been twice and both times food was great all around. It's a classy pub is how I would describe it . I just moved to the area a few months ago so this is definitely on my list of regulars . Service was okay not the best but I've had worst . Over all good experience and will be back read more

Good and different. Nice atmosphere too. Had lunch and salads and calamari are good. Just different read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - The main dining area. - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

My husband and I came here one night, got a burger, Brussels sprouts and a beer. It was absolutely amazing! The food was so delicious, or service was great and just an overall great experience! We complimented our server on the Brussels sprouts and asked how they made them and then the cook sat down and wrote out the recipe for us. Such a nice thing to do and so unusual and unexpected! We were so impressed! We will forsure go back another time and try other things on the menu. The food we saw go by our table all looked so good. It's also hot a great atmosphere. read more

We asked our server, Ali, for her red wine recommendation - the Hess Maverick Cabernet Sauvignon Paso Robles CA was delicious. For an appetizer we had the scrumptious Tavern Board and followed up with a Bison Burger and a Summer Salad with Shrimp. The food, service, and atmosphere is family-friendly, professional, knowledgeable, and impeccable. We couldn't ask for better and will return! Drop everything and go to Windsor Mill Tavern for a delightful experience! read more

Windsor Mill Tavern - Bison burger - yum - Bars Near Me - Windsor, Colorado

See all

So this place needs to actually be called out. Yes - it's in the coolest building in Windsor. Yes - everything about the vibe inside and bar is great. Yes - the brewery above and location are great. But if we are for realz talking the food, then go down the street to Hearth. This place has bar food and that's it's. It's overpriced. Is it good ? Sure. It's bar Food though. Just normal, burgers and sandwiches and some entrees that aren't that good. I will say the cocktail list is good and would be worth your while to get a drink there, however the food is a hard pass if you are looking for a good food experience. It gets lumped in with everything else good happening in the same building and the good experience here is below average for a "good dinner". Lots of times they are out of entrees also. Plus over priced - go to Hearth instead for a better meal. read more