We had delicious dinner. The hail Caesar was big enough to share. The pancetta is an extra touch. My husband got the Zealot. It was a Large pizza with lots of toppings. I ordered the Capricciosa without ham. I loved it. Both of us liked the crust, too. We will return. read more

Delicious food every time i go! The pizza is unique and delicious, especially the Bee Sting! The shakes are also incredible! I sometimes come just for the shakes . Service is pretty quick, everyone is nice. Definitely worth a visit..... or 10 visits read more

Came in the evening after Christmas and they were doing some good business. We were met immediately upon coming in and asked if we need any help or had questions with the menu. Ended up getting a New York style cheese pizza and two salads, everything was great and I can't remember the last time I had a slice big enough to fold and eat!! And to make it better it wasn't even greasy. Two thumbs up and will definitely come back for more! read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

My absolute favorite food place in Rexburg. The food is amazing and the staff is even more amazing!

I ate at Righteous Slice in Rexburg ID for the first time yesterday and was really pleased! we live in Rexburg but usually go to Idaho Falls for restaurants and Doctors. Our Dr told us that he comes to Rexburg to go to Righteous Slice, so we had to try it! It was very clean, the food was surprisingly delicious and the service was top-notch! We WILL be back. read more

Best pizza and customer service in Idaho! Their pizza is so good and the staff is always helpful and happy!

Food is amazing, there was a hiccup in the order and the staff went above and beyond to fix it. Appreciate their awesome customer service. Definitely recommend!!! read more

Didn't even get a chance to eat there. Tried to call and place an order over the phone, and after the second time trying to call them they picked up the phone and hung up. read more

First time here. The place was packed. We loved it! Delicious crust and flavor. We got a pepperoni and an all meat pizza. Loved both of them. read more

I don't give out 5 stars often but this place deserves it. Went last night for our first time. 20 min before closing and the place was still busy. The staff was very polite and courteous. They even commented and apologized for the recent price increase (inflation). I ordered the Bee Sting and Garlic Cheesy Bread and two shakes. While I waited staff checked in with me and brought the shakes down. I watched as they made the pizza and put it in the oven. I ordered another one on the fly and they quickly made it and got it in with the other. No issues or complaints. Got home and ate. Pizza is fantastic. I'm not supposed to eat wheat or gluten but this was on point. Definitely a place to go back to. read more

Stopped in for the first time today. This place has been on my radar for a while, but I don't come to Rexburg very often. That will officially change after today. My buddy and I split the Bee Sting, a Godfather, and a meatball skillet. The flavors on each pizza just hit all the right notes. The marinara and basil on the meatballs was the star today, though. The staff were super friendly, which these days is hit or miss at most eating establishments. I would recommend this to friends and family, but I will definitely be bringing my family back here soon. read more

Great pizza! So delicious! Would go back again! We drove from IF just to try it....it was worth it :) read more

Righteous Slice - New York Style Pizza....18 inches!! We had lots of leftovers - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Literally the yummiest in the area and you have to get the Hail Caesar salad to go with your pizza

My first time and my pizza was amazing and delicious. Super busy maybe on Friday but it was worth a wait.

So I decided to give this place a second chance after saying "no way!" A year ago. The good: There was more pepperoni and salami this time on my create your own pizza. The dessert pizza was amazing! And the fact that it only had like 3 toppings was so cool. The crust on the pizza was so much better. The wait wasn't that long either. The bad: my only complaint is that I got a sprinkle of Gorgonzola on my pizza... like it had 6 or 7 tiny little blobs on it... so sad because I LOVE Gorgonzola, like I'd have it replace the mozzarella if I could. read more

See all

EXCELLENT PIZZA! Every time we drop kids off at college we hit Righteous Slice at least twice! They use top quality ingredients and cook their pizza to perfection in their wood burning oven. Everything is made in house! The service is prompt and friendly. The atmosphere has an energetic college vibe. Plan ahead for a line of customers! Worth the wait! Highly recommend! read more

The food is great with different kinds of pizza that are unexpected. The Bee Sting is quite flavorful.

Located at the heart of Rexburg, find a modern pizzeria you can not miss. Right across from Porter Park & next to Five Guys. You open the door and the menu is on their wall. Their pizza, in my opinion, is a rival to most "expensive" & luxury pizzas. You can order a preexisting recipe or build your own, Oven baked & deliver to your table, you can eat and overlook the busy street. Their salads are also MASSIVE & just as delicious. You can also order these big & unique milkshakes that they make upstairs. My favorite thing to get is the the Bee Sting Pizza & the Caesar Salad. Mozzarella, honey, pepperoni, etc. I am hungry just thinking about it. Righteous Slice is popular rexburg favorite. My biggest observations are; 1. The food can be expensive- keep that in mind 7/10 2. Due to its popularity, there can be long waits 7/10 3. This Pizzeria is a perfect date place or families 9/10 Overall, I would say it is just short of perfect, but still a favorite, we will be going back soon 9.5/10. read more

We've been coming here for years, like since the menu was 5 options. And it's just as good as day one. Hog heaven and the balsamic with strawberries salad. read more

The pizza crust always comes out burnt. We've tried going a couple of times hoping it will be better than it is. We also had our order taken and they said we could just wait wherever and took our phone number and waited for over half an hour upstairs expecting to get a text only to come down to check and see that they had already made it so they give us this lukewarm pizza like nothing happened. read more

Super great ambiance and friendly staff! Just happened upon this on our trip to Rexburg and it didn't disappoint, reasonable priced for hand made pizza! Totally recommend! read more

Righteous Slice - Focaccia Bread, and The God Father pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Best pizza!! Best service! I am still trying everything they have (so far, everything is great!!) And this is coming from an Italian NYer!

First time to Idaho ever and Righteous Slice did not disappoint. The Spudharvest was my favorite and the ricotta on Popeye was so creamy. The pizza dough itself was the crown jewel of it all! Do yourself a favor and get a milkshake. We got the Reese's PB but must go back before leaving town to try a different flavor. read more

Best Pizza in Rexburg most definitely recommend! Pizzas were phenomenal! Customer service was amazing! Lots of room for seating had an amazing time:) read more

The pizza was good, but the service and ambiance was less than optimal. I get that Saturday night in the summer is busy, but the service could have been better. We asked for water at the cash register. After waiting 15 minutes, we flagged down a worker who gave us some empty water cups that were maybe 6-8 ounces. I finally figured I had to go to the first floor for water. On a hot summer day in a hot restaurant, I wanted more than 6-8 ounces. I probably went up and down the stairs 5-6 times I was there. I had to take my child to the restroom--downstairs. I had to get some more water with my tiny water cup. Again, I went downstairs. I had to get some napkins--downstairs. I might have burned more calories going up and down the stairs than actually consuming the pizza. Memo to owners: Get a water station on the second floor. Consider bigger water cups. Bring napkins with the pizza. Try to bring all the food at once for the table. Get darker winder shades. Long term, consider a new location with one floor. read more

We LOVE each and every bite! Best pizza I've ever had. Better than the ones in New York to be honest! We also love the young man who brought our order...ISAAC! He is so polite, very attentive and hardworking! Please give him a big fat raise!!!! read more

This place is kinda expensive for what it is, but it's straight fire. Can't beat their bee sting pizza. Super delicious!!

Righteous Slice is awesome. It is unique in that if offers two very different styles of pizzas. It does personal Neapolitan pizzas. They are authentic. Real 00 flour. High quality ingredients for EVERYTHING. Real wood burning oven. That means a little char. It is virtually impossible to not have any on a pizza cooked this way (I used to live in Italy) which is authentic. The crust is soft and chewy with just a little crunch on the outside of the pizza. Their flavor options are OUTSTANDING. I recommend you try them AS IS before venturing out on your own. If you can't stand a little char on your pizza then you might want to go with pizza by the slice. They also make large New York Pizzas and sell them by the slice. It's a different crust and baked in a different oven. They don't skimp on the pepperoni- just look at the photo! I have traveled all over this country and these pizzas are top notch. You will be hard pressed to find better pizza of these styles. (Pizza is very subjective in terms of judging it.) Rexburg is fortunate to have such great pizza. I have not had as consistently good Neapolitan pizza anywhere else in the USA. read more

Righteous Slice - New York Style Pizza - Pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Price: a little pricey. But it's fair because it's one of the only somewhat nice places in Rexburg. So they can get away with that one in my opinion. However the portion sizes are small. Expect to pay about $9 plus for a pizza that's about the size of two of your hands Atmosphere: one of the nicer looking places in Rexburg which is sad because it's not amazing. But it's definitely a step forward for the town. Customer service: not to swell. Went to the cashier lady we had to say hello to her and start ordering, she just sort of stared at us, didn't repeat our order back to us to confirm. Was sort of awkward. Maybe she was having a rough night or something Speediness: meh it takes a while to get your food. Expect to wait at least 15-20 minutes. Not terribly long. Ordered our food around 5:56 didn't receive it until 6:14 so not too long at all! Taste: it's nothing to write home about but it's definitely one of the best pizza places in town. Considering the only non commercial well known competition is Pizza Pie Cafe, and we all know that place is a disaster. They had gender neutral bathrooms although it's a whole trip to get over there. The one thing I hated was they use styrofoam for the to go boxes. Sad. It'd be a lot nicer and better for their company had they used cardboard and advertised their name on it. read more

See all

Delicious above and beyond what a pizza should taste like. I love the one with artichoke hearts and Kalamata olives. So very tasty.

WOW! This is the best pizza in Rexburg, in Idaho, and dare I say, probably some of the best pizza in the world. Not only is the pizza amazing, I was SO impressed with the staff. They're friendly, fun, happy people! Overall, very happy. I'll be back soon :) read more

Righteous Slice - I was SO happy with my experience at Righteous Slice. The pizza was beautiful and delicious, and the service and employees were fantastic! - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Best authentic pizza place I've ever tried. Pizzas are in general very refreshing, the Bee Sting is covered in a honey sauce and sweet soft cheese that's amazing. lots of ingredients are imported from Italy, everything is made in house. Food quality is always consistent and the wait times are short (we usually receive food in under 30 minutes). read more

Love this place! A great option for rexburg! I got the Italian job salad and my husband got the spud pizza and we shared. Great crust & good flavors overall. The salad had a lot going on and the dressing was really good I would totally recommend! I also thought the prices were great! The portions are large and a personal pizza is totally shareable! 2 things I think that could be improved on is the way you get your pizza & more topping options. I think getting a number and having an employee bring you your pizza would be a lot more inviting for customers instead of huddling around waiting for a name to be called. Also would love to see some bbq sauce, (bbq chicken anyone?), ranch, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers etc. as options on the menu! read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

One of my favorite places in Rexburg! It's so nice to have a unique eatery that's not just burgers, especially for any fellow vegetarians out there! They have a few super unique vegetarian and vegan options. My husband and I went here for dinner Saturday night. We were very surprise that we got our food so quickly, as it seemed like it would be a busy night! The staff was very friendly and helpful, and was super patient with all of my questions. I got the Che Figata and my husband got the Bee Sting. Mine was amazing and my husband loved his, as well! It was such a unique pizza, but all of the flavors blended together so well. We will definitely be back to try more! read more

Righteous Slice - The Che Figata. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

I'm not a huge fan of the name, but I guess it is located in Rexburg. I really enjoy the location of the restaurant and wish more places would look this nice. Now to talk about the items that really make the experience; service and the food. We were greeted right when we came in and the cashier was polite. It did almost take half an hour to get our food, which was one margarita pizza. Keep in mind we came in during dinner time so that could be a factor. The pizza was surprisingly good and featured a crust that you can finish without feeling like you're eating cardboard. Their tomato sauce was right there next to the crust, yummy. Along with the mozzarella and basil, I would say it made for a good Neapolitan style pizza. A few suggestions on my part: maybe if they had a better way to get people their pizza like a buzzer you take to your table instead of having to wait close by. Also, I believe introducing a handful of specialty drinks to go along with the Italian theme might be a nice touch. read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Best pizza place ever!!! Fun toppings with a chill atmosphere. We come here all the time. The service is excellent, the employees are so nice and the food is really really good! read more

So I have to say 5 stars cause the pizza was pretty dang good. This is Italian style pizza. Means it's not to be compared to Pizza Hut , or dominos or any America style pizzas We ordered our pizza on the way back from yellow stone, did it 40 mins prior online and when we went there, we got there expecting the pizza to be ready and they said we still had 20 more minute to wait. Places was packed of orders. Call ahead and see what the wait is. Pizza, crust and ingredients were excellent! If I am ever back in Rexburg I will come back to eat this pizza. Two floors. Cool place, brick oven awesome pizza! read more

This place is absolutely the best pizza option in all of Southeastern Idaho! Pay a little bit more and get so much more out of it. read more

the price is way higher than the quality. the pizza is mid and theyre very inconsistent with topping portions; sometimes it's barely enough and other times it not enough. also don't order ranch unless you're cool with 2$ for a small cup. starting prices is 15$ for a pizza that feeds maybe one. Costco pizza is the best around at $10 for a 18inch pizza. Don't ask any staff questions just go to one of the store owners, none of these kids knows anything and just repeat questions to the owners/managers. read more

Great slice in Rexburg. Didn't know where to eat, but got this as a recommendation and really enjoyed the pizza. Would recommend.