The cheesy bread and pizza is wonderful. The servers are friendly and polite. The atmosphere is clean and fun. We go here often.

I'm not a big pizza fan. But I love this place! My brother-in-law was the owner's mission compassion back in the day and he told us about this place and how the owner always wanted to open a pizza joint. Well, he opened a really good one! We ordered the Bee Sting/Godfather pizza. The Bee Sting has Crushed red pepper, oregano, assorted spicy Italian cured meats, ricotta, & Howells Honey, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, olive oil. I never thought of putting honey on my pizza. Honestly, you can barely taste it. The Godfather has Italian sausage, cup-and-char pepperoni, sliced meatballs, provolone, mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, pecorino Romano, crushed San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano. We ordered the New York crust. It was crispy and it held its shape. The sauce was not overpowering and blended well with all the spices The Dessert Katie Kay pizza was amazing. It had strawberries, blue berries, strawberry gel, fresh whipped cream and powdered sugar. What a great way to satisfy your sweet tooth. read more

See all

Righteous Slice makes a wicked good pizza. This place is definitely worth checking out. I got the hog heaven. Unfortunately I thought their house made sausage was really gross. Everything else was top-notch. The Popeye pizza was spectacular. We ordered our pizzas ahead of time and showed up to get them when they're ready and took them to go. read more

See all

This place is a bit pricey, but worth it. We wanted hearty pizza and a good salad. This place had both! The salad had mixed greens, arugula, candied pecans, strawberries, fresh shredded Parmesan cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette dressing. Yum! We ordered a NY style pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and cherry tomatoes. They had a soda machine and lemonades. Plenty of parking nearby. read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Tried the gluten friendly pizza! The absolute best pan style pizza. Thank you for making the best pizza ever!!!! read more

Righteous Slice - Gluten friendly pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

The New York style pizza here is 10/10. Employees are kind, and the environment is pretty fun. Highly recommend.

let's just say I won't be missing New York City anymore delicious pizza I love the staff, too. The name Righteous pizza speaks for itself can't wait for the next pizza night. thx read more

Righteous Slice - My son and I after Righteous - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

We stopped here on our way up to Yellowstone and are so glad we did! they weren't sure at first what to get but the lady at the counter was so nice and helpful. The pizza was absolutely delicious! The crust had such a great texture and I loved that it was crunchy too. Great flavor! My kids loved it as well, which is always a good thing. It was easy to find and there was plenty of parking. there is lots of places to sit in a nice and open upstairs area. We'll come back when we're in the area! read more

See all

Came here for the first time while visiting my brother in law who's attending BYU-I cause he said it was the best pizza near campus and boy was he right! We had the bee sting pizza and the cheese pizza and the bee sting pizza probably had one of the best flavors I've had on a pizza before! I'm not entirely sure the what the white dollops onto of the pizza were but they had a slight sweet flavor to them which was delicious plus it being topped with honey *chefs kiss* the pizza does have a slight kick to it but nothing you can't handle. The people were very nice and friendly as well. I would 100% recommend if visiting Rexburg! read more

Amazing pizza and staff. The manager came to our table and visited with us. It was our first time eating there as we were just passing through on a trip. He was very personable and even comped a dessert for us. We will definitely go there again if we get the opportunity! read more

$35 for a pizza that is thin crust, hardly has toppings on it, and is just ok. Meat lover, or veggie lover, it doesn't matter - you won't get much of anything put on top even when you're paying a good deal on it. Pizzas has been really oily the last 2 times we've aten there too. read more

I have been here countless times over the several years it's been open. It's delicious. My favorites are the spud harvest and the Che figata. The place is nice and has a fun rustic modern vibe. Service changes a ton because it's a college town but they usually have awesome workers and if there's a problem they are quick to make it right. Definitely my favorite place to eat while in Rexburg. read more

Righteous Slice - Spud harvest - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

This is the best pizza I have had in YEARS!! Excellent customer service Easy location and parking read more

Excellent customer service. Their pizza never disappoints! Thank you to the employee who took our order and made sure not to add provolone cheese to our New York Pepperoni pizza! read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Great people work hard there and answered my questions with pride and gratitude will be back soon and the New Yorker was a great pizza. Thanks :) read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Perfect place to enjoy pizza by yourself or in a group. My favorites are Che Figata and Bee Sting. I've tried them all. Most are great. One or two are meh. read more

I can't say enough good things about Righteous Slice! Their pizzas are incredible, interesting ingredients and great dough. In addition to that, their team and owners are amazing. I left something very important to me at their restaurant on accident, and they found it, and shipped it back to me the next day. Great pizza, great people! read more

Maybe the best pizza we've had since Italy. Love the bee sting pizza (won't see this in Italy but it's delicious !) Also loved the salad we shared and the meatballs. Service was fast considering they make everything to order. Atmosphere was fun. We liked eating upstairs. read more

Righteous Slice - Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

When you think of Idaho pizza likely doesn't come to mind, but Righteous Slice offers up noteworthy pizza that would do well in any major city. The staff is really friendly and they crank out the pizzas fast. Very reasonable pricing, too. I've tried the Neopolitan Margherita and Neopolitan Che Figata. Both are great options. You can't go wrong with either one. Matter of fact, I doubt you can go wrong with anything on the menu here. read more

There was 12 of us! Our son took us all there to celebrate our granddaughters BYUi graduation. The pizza was AMAZING! The quick SERVICE, exemplary! Even though it seemed everyone in Rexburg was there, we had no problems at ALL. Amazing. Even the atmosphere was great, everyone there was happy. We'll make sure to come every time we are in Rexburg. We have great memories. read more

Great place with lots of seating, great menu, fabulous service, and delicious pizza. The raspberry lemonade was spot on and the service so great. They answered our questions, checked on us enough to help but not be annoying. The pizza crust was thin and perfect and the flavors married well. Definitely a place to stop in and enjoy a meal if you ever find yourself in Rexburg. read more

Righteous Slice - New York size half Bee Sting and half Sweet Italian - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Best pizza ever. Absolutely incredible. Such an awesome place. I wish I lived closer. Can't wait to come back!!

Some of the best pizza pie I've ever had since I was in Europe. The service was excellent and made sure we had plenty of napkins. Everything was so clean and organized even the tiled walls didn't have any specs of anything on them or on the grout between tiles. I really enjoyed this dining experience only thing that I would complain about is the sodas were flat but they fixed that right away. And that's just normal pops business in the restaurant industry. No complaints about the at all. It's a bit spendy, but I'm sure the rent on that space is a huge expense. That's not the business owner's fault, that's the building owner's fault. You and your crew make a very good pizza. read more

Wow. This pizza is amazing. I've always been a big fan of Neapolitan pizza, and this didn't disappoint. Very on par with other Neapolitan pizza places like Punch Pizza in Minnesota. We ordered a verity of pizza, but the bee sting was probably everyone's favorite, with the forbidden fruit pizza right up there with it. Service was excellent. They delivered all our pizza to our table, even though we sat on the second level. The ambiance was nothing special, but nothing bad about it. Overall amazing pizza! 5/5 stars read more

See all

Pizza made the REAL way...Reminds me of pizza in Italy! Except the staff have fantastic customer service skills unlike Italians. lol

I make sure to visit this amazing pizza shop each time I'm visiting my kids at BYUI because it is the best food I have had in the area. It gets insanely busy for good reason, but it's completely worth the wait. The shop is light and bright with ample seating and excellent service. We have tried a variety of the pizzas but my favorite is the bee sting. The sweet, hot honey on the creamy burrata cheese with the spicy, crispy pepperoni on the perfection that is their pizza crust is top tier! Thank you Righteous Slice for this offering in a cute little college town. read more

See all

Super impressed by the high quality ingredients ...even the parm on the table was great! Nice fermented thin crust and tasty pepp. Friendly staff and quick service was great too to get us back on the road. Yay! read more

Righteous Slice - Half of the Roni - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Fantastic pizza, exceptional salad, and wonderful service. This is an all around great pizza place and well with the effort to eat there. Parking is available both in front and behind but it's a popular place in a college town. read more

We went here as a group of about 12 to experience, righteous slice for the first time. Since we were headed to the temple afterwards, we thought there would be no better way to feel more righteous before the temple than by eating at righteous slice. We were absolutely right. It didn't disappoint. I would say it took a good 10 minutes or so for our time to get to us. Definitely a fast casual where it does take a little bit of time to get your food but it's worth the wait. I will say that the pizzas were good and most the adults split a salad and a Neapolitan pizza which was a perfect amount of food. Great comfort food and if you like, you can just get one slice of pizza (only available for pepperoni and cheese). read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Fantastic and delicious. The best pizza anywhere I've ever had. service is great and the atmosphere is nice, frequently busy though.

Awesome pizza. We are visiting and ate here our first night. The pizza was so good we came back for dinner again the next night! Literally the world's best cheese pizza (won the world contest in Italy in 2025). But the other pizzas are awesome as well. Definitely try it!! read more

Started with the Hail Caesar salad, perfect to split. Tried a build your own Neapolitan pizza. Excellent flavor with lots of meats to choose from. We definitely want to come back. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Idaho! They've won a bunch of awards including international pizza competition. I've only had their New York style pizza but it's excellent! If you love little Caesars pizza or Domino's then you probably won't appreciate this because you like crappy pizza. read more

Everything they say about this place is true. The pizza is excellent and the price really isn't bad for how much you get. The service was great and they brought us a free milkshake at the end that they had made by accident. Since that first visit we've gone back anytime we're in the mood for real pizza. Rexburg has no business having a pizza place this good. read more

Second time here and first review. I love the pizza here. Service was great. Everybody we interacted with was friendly and helpful. Nice open space with plenty of seating. Parking was easy as well. Had pizza and one member of the party has salad and that looked delicious and pretty large. read more

Righteous Slice - Italian Salad - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

THE BEST oven-fired pizza! My post here will save you a lot of time at the register asking questions. There are a few good things to know before you dine at Righteous Slice. You have to know the difference between the 2 types of pizza they make: SMALL (12") NEAPOLITAN PIZZA: The small / personal pizza size is called "Neapolitan", and has a thicker, soft, chewy crust with a slight char around the edge. If you want to Build Your Own pizza (choose your own toppings), choose this small pizza. (Also, you cannot make the small / Neapolitan 1/2 and 1/2 with different toppings.) XL NEW YORK PIZZA: The XL pizza is like 18-20" (huge!) and is called the "New York". It has a thin, crisp crust with large slices that can be folded in half. You can do each 1/2 of a different kind, but you must choose from the specialty / featured combos they offer on the menu. No changes or substitutions may be made. Their featured pizza combos are tried and true -- so just try them! Our family faves are the Forbidden Fruit and the Bee Sting. Also great to know is that they use only high quality, FRESH ingredients. (I watched them picking nice, fresh basil leaves, tearing the leaves off the stems.) So that should help you get past any initial sticker shock. This is a family-owned restaurant run by pizza aficionados who are always seeking to improve their skills and product. It is not your cheap chain kind o' pizza - at all. It's fantastic! Give t a try! read more

So delicious! We had dinner, came back for dessert, and then lunch the next day! We'll be back the next time we're in town!

Amazing pizza spot. We dropped off our kid to college and found this place! Food was great, but honestly the staff made the difference! Each one of them were awesome and made casual conversation with us. read more

Really good college town pizza. Our order was out quickly and it was soooo good!!! I would go there again today! I wanna try all their pizzas. read more

Been wanting to try this place on the recommendation of a family member. Drove right by - hard to see if you aren't familiar with the area. Although the service was a bit choppy, the pizza was Extremely flavorful!!!! Ya gotta go try it. The restaurant was clean, music volume was just right read more

Righteous Slice - Zealot pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho