Upon some research of places to eat in Rexburg, I decided I had to try this place out. I absolutely love the pizza in Italy! I was pleasantly satisfied with Righteous Slice since it comes fairly close to the pizza I had in Europe. I'll start off with the customer service: the cashier was extremely sweet and helpful. Those preparing the pizzas were also very friendly. I think it's awesome that you are able to visualize the preparation process of the pizza. The menu had a lot of great options and it was hard to settle on one pizza combination. The restaurant itself has a really cool vibe but I took off one star for the cleanliness. I can imagine it would be hard to keep up with all the families in there but still no fun to sit with crumbs everywhere. The pizza itself was so so yum! The crust was perfectly crispy/fluffy, the sauce had that authentic zing, the ricotta was creamy and the toppings were just so flavorful. Overall, I would totally go back again and again. read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Good but honestly a little overrated. Such a long wait to just see your pizza be taken out of the oven and sit on a counter for fifteen minutes while they wait for your other one to be done in the oven. Then bother get to sit on the counter for another ten minutes and by the time you get your pizza it's cold. So if you like cold pizza this is the place to go. The atmosphere was nice just really packed in the store. Expect a long wait in line and an even longer wait for your food. read more

Loved it. Fun atmosphere, awesome pizza. Bigger pizzas than I was expecting and we took a lot of leftovers home.

Absolutely incredible pizza! Took the kids and grandsons out for pizza and wow! I got the Bee Sting, while the grandsons got the Roni and Cheese. I'd eat the Bee Sting everyday and twice on Sunday - perfect blend of heat and sweet! Great decor, very prompt service, and super customer friendly staff! Oh we also got the garlic cheese bread and this was just a delight - wonderfully soft and succulent crust with the perfect blend of garlic and cheese. Can't wait till I'm back in town for another visit. read more

Righteous Slice - Waiting for the goodness... - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Pizza is probably 3 stars, but you're in Rexburg so 3 star pizza is really good. It's like being the best hockey player in Ecuador....how good does that really make you??? Toppings were good and the oven put a nice char on the crust edges, which I like. Sharis had the margarita and I had The Godfather. The sausage was good by any standard....or by the standard of a Utah guy eating Rexburg pizza. Was great after a day hitting the salmon fly hatch and being hungry. Staff was nice and accommodating. Would go back. read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Visiting Rexburg and tried this place out.... We ordered cheese bread and the Bee sting pizza. They were delish however I didn't taste any honey on the bee sting like it described. I would recommend it. I gave 4 stars because they were a bit cheap with the sauce for the cheese bread. I wish Yelp would actually let you do 4.5 stars! read more

Righteous Slice - Bee sting pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Super fast, friendly, and delicious!! Had the margarita pizza and a raspberry shake would recommend both! read more

Righteous Slice - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

The fact that they call their shakes "The Burg" shakes is a disgrace. They are average soft serve in a cup at best. Lacking in toppings and flavor. Not worth the $5. read more

Righteous Slice - The Nutella brownie shake... obviously forgot the Nutella and the brownie and anything except vanilla soft serve - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Love everyone wearing masks when they make the food. Star Witness and Bee Sting are my favs read more

Righteous Slice - Star witness - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Best pizza I've ever had. Super nice staff. They do need to change their gloves after touching their nose or the handrail to the upstairs, before touching the counter where they make the pizza or the food. read more

Best pizza place in Rexburg! The Praise the Lard pizza is my favorite! The staff is super friendly and usually pretty quick to get your food to you. read more

Longtime fan coming back after a few years. Awesome to see how the business has been and will be growing soon. New additions to the menu are way cool. Its a shame they don't have the paninis anymore, but everything else more than makes up for it. read more

Absolutely wonderful NY style pizza!!!!!! Perfect crust, superb cheese, excellent toppings (e.g., sausage)... and good price-quality balance. We also love the dessert (Star Witness). read more

The people are really nice. Food takes a pretty long time to come out even when there's not that many people. The pizza is overpriced and not that good. I got the bee sting and it was so soggy :( I wanted to love this place but I just don't. read more

Honestly, it's very modern pizza which is good, but you can't pick it up with all the toppings falling off and it just flopping over...love the burger shakes though! read more

I love the pizza! I love the environment. Me, my girlfriend and her roommate usually go every Monday! The desert pizza pies are fantastic! they are quick and make sure to give something back if the wait was longer then expected read more

Great pizza spot if you are in Rexburg. We were visiting for the week and this place did not disappoint. We got the true believer pizza and the Fresca salad. The pizza dough tasted so fresh and the pasta with the strawberries was a big hit with my kids. The pizza was big for a family of 4. Would definitely be back if we are back in Rexburg. read more

If your looking for the best quality of pizza in rexburg, this is the place to come for. I tried every different types of pizzas in town and none of them come close the high quality this place serves. If you haven't came here you need to come here and try it for yourself. The owners and the workers are amazing and have a great environment to be at. I would encourage everyone to come and try the food. Much love read more

Amazing! Great service and even greater food!!! Quite impressed over all! Parking was a tad hard to find, but I'm willing to walk for this amazing food read more

We stopped in here for my sons birthday dinner. It was fabulous. We have been back weekly since! We had family in town and went here for dinner before they left. We tried everything! Our favorites are the Praise the Lard, The Bee-Sting, the Katy-Kay. The salads are pretty good too, I just wish the bacon was crisper. read more

Hands down, this is the best Pizza in Rexburg EVER!!!!!!! I would love to come back again anytime I want Pizza, I love how baked in the fire oven. Some of the best Pizzas in the world are made in ovens like the ones they have. So please go Righteous slice, and again BEST PIZZA in (not just Rexburg) but ALL of Idaho. read more

See all

Their bread is amazing but their pizza crust is so thin that everything falls off instantly. The flavor is really good but the crust really holds it back. read more

I always love it here. The margarita pizza and the Katy kate is the best! I can't say enough good things about this place the brick oven the atmosphere the feeling of the building is amazing. read more

Righteous Slice - a plate of fruit pizza and a plate of fruit pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

The New York style pizza is as good as it gets! I thought the Neopolitan style was good, but the New York style is terrific!!

This place is not great they throw the toppings on the pizza they are not spread on the pizza it was that way on all the pizza's that were ordered We had 6 there was one shining star of the party which is all I would consider ordering again it was the pepperoni pizza with extra cheese that was tasty They need to clean there pizza oven the crust on all pizza was speckled with black pieces of ash or soot which was nasty and yes I have eaten pizza that type of oven before I would not recommend except for the pepperoni pizza read more

Delicious pizza, very happy. Kind of pricey...but for an occasional splurge it fits the bill. I ordered the sweet Italian

This place is awesome! The pizza is so fresh and yummy. Cool ambiance! Definitely would recommend the pizza and shakes!!

Such good and unique pizza. They also just started the paninis and dang they are good.

I'm super upset with the serice from this restaurant. They took our order asked for my name, which I gave. I expected to have my name called once my order was done(just two pizzas). BUT, I had go ask if my order was done!! None of the five-plus workers called my name when my order was ready. BECAUSE they were standing around talking to each other, seeing who was going to be working the next day. Get this! I was the only one in the restaurant!!! Totally felt ignored as a customer, absolutely horrible service. Plus it was the first time I went there. Terrible first inpression!! P.s. Just had the pizza. I'm sorry this is Rexburg's "best" type of pizza place... So sad. read more

I wish I could give it 3.5 stars, but I guess the averages will take care of that. Good pizza, but overpriced for what it is (decent pizza (7.5-8/10), but slow. If you want to sell pricy pizza, I don't think it should be 1/2 hour of wait time after you get through the 15 minute line when this isn't a restaurant, and - at least when we went in - there was essentially standing room only (we ended up finding 1 chair to share between the 5 of us while we waited. By the end I was wishing I had gone with Pizza-Pizza or delivery, but we'd already paid, so we were just stuck there. I've waited less time to be seated and served at a sit down restaurant, and at least they let me know the wait time when I walked in. If they are expecting people to spend an hour there like they would at Olive Garden, then I really think they should have a little sign with an estimated wait time or let you know that they're behind or moving slow if it was more of a one time occurrence. Overall it just wasn't a positive experience, so even through their product (the pizza once we got it) was just fine - good even, the service seemed sub-par enough that that's what I remember and I wouldn't choose to go back over Pizza Hut unless I was trying to make it a social meetup or business meeting spot where I wouldn't mind sitting and talking for an hour. read more

This place is really good, the bee sting is amazing! It's a little expensive but it is high quality food. It can be hard to afford on a college budget but somehow I always find a way ‍ read more

first and last time going here. we got the bee sting pizza and I don't remember asking for water as a topping but the pizza was so soaking wet the box was dripping. i am not exaggerating when i say this is the single worst pizza i have ever had in my entire life. read more

Righteous Slice - bee sting - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Loved the choices and food was great. Fast service and neat, clean location in college town. read more

Righteous Slice - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

Pretty good. Fast. Good service. In my 3 times eating here the crust has always been charred black in places, my only complaint. The bee sting has been my favorite pizza so far. If I could do 3 1/2 I would add a half star. read more

The service is excellent. The food is great. I've been there over 10 times and I still enjoy it. It's a solid, affordable choice for a night out. read more

I LOVE righteous slice. As someone who grew up eating Italian-style pizza in the Northeast, I can say this place reminds me of real pizza. No offense to Dominos or Little Caesars... The brick oven pizzas here are all amazing flavor combinations. I just think this place is a hidden gem in Eastern Idaho. read more

There quality has gone down so much within the past few months. My friends and I have decided to not come here again. Used to be really good, I believe they changed some things to be more profitable. read more

Best pizza I've ever had! It's so good and so tasty! The owner is a gem and they now offer milkshakes upstairs!

The food tastes soo good!! Definitely a good place to visit and the second floor has some cool views of the street! Definitely recommend!

I loved the pizza we got. It was the bee sting. Spicy and sweet. Super tasty. Just A little too soggy on the bottom for some reason..... We went to the top to eat and watched below to see the pizzas being made and had a few concerns. One was they had one rag and they would all share it between 3 employees for different uses and then handle the food with the same hand that they used for wiping down the counter... Wasn't impressed with that. It's overpriced but it's yummy. You can expect to pay $10 or more for a decent one. (Can split a pizza but it's more personal sized) And the girl that made ours dropped a few pieces of pineapple on our pizza. Just a minor annoyance. I just felt that the way they make the pizza was careless. Overall very tasty food. read more