(review from summer 2013) First visit, will return. Went for our first visit tonight, liked almost everything about the place.
We were seated promptly and service throughout the whole night was excellent, food came out quickly too, considering they had a full house that was impressive. I was surprised at both the quality of service and the speed of the food.
The food itself was delicious. The fried squash blossoms were amazing. I took one bite and said wow. Recently returning from a trip to Chicago where we had some $200+ dinners and that squash blossom was the best bite of food I've had in awhile. You couldn't really taste the squash, but I didn't care, the filling was ambrosia. It came on a little cucumber salad which was also very good, the whole plate was executed to perfection.
I also had the GRIND which was a scotch egg, very good, a little tarragon in the sausage which was nice. My wife also had a mixed green salad with berries which was very nice.
Then we split the ROAST which was beet falafel, and the GRILL which was trout with a white chocolate parsnip sauce.
The falafel plate was the one bad note. They were good, but a little mushy on the inside, not quite like actual falafel. What I really disliked was that curry sauce and the plate was littered with cilantro. I understand some people like that spice, I'm not one of them, in fact I've heard a portion of the population genetically tastes cilantro like soap, I think I'm in this group. There was no mention of cilantro on the menu, I think if a dish has a strong spice like that (or perhaps sage) it should be listed. Not all curry has cilantro as a rule. (I also thought it was a overpriced, almost as much as the very large very expensive looking burger, the other prices I thought were reasonable)
The trout however was excellent. Who knew that white chocolate with parsnip went with trout?
For dessert we had the "birthday cake" which was a cherry and chocolate cake and very very good, and again better than anything I had in Chicago (nice portion too).
It was noisy in there, but what can you expect with a room full of people having a good time? We'll definitely be back.
-------
Update: We went back many times, one of our favorite places in East Lansing before we moved. Their theme dinners are especially fun. For instance they had a 5 course pork theme dinner with wine pairings for $70 a person. I always tell people, eating at Red Haven is the closest you'll get to being a judge on Iron Chef, at least anywhere near East Lansing. It may not always make sense on the menu, but it is usually delicious in a unique and amazing way. read more