Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rebecca's Cake Pops

    4.4 (15 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Rebecca's Cake Pops Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Rebecca's Cake Pops

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Otter cake pops
    Halle S.

    Cutest cake pops around!!! Every time I see these cake pops I'm so wowed by them. Serious artistry. And to make it even better, they taste super good!! A little on the pricey side, but considering the details and the fact that it's a small business I say it's worth it. The staff is always very nice and happy to help. The cake pops themselves are in a cute little stall. It has other food halls around it so you can get a meal and have a delicious and cute cake pop for dessert!

    cake pops lack flavor, very disappointed. as you can see this even looks very doughy, tastes like straight flour

    a display of different kinds of cake pops
    Howard H.

    I'm not a fan of cake pops but this place is just really fun - it has whimsical designs and is straight up fun. Cake pops designs vary from animals to mermaids to your good old regular boring balls on a stick. The mermaid ones were really well done and little kids absolutely adored them. Flavor was also good - cake wasn't too moist or too hard. Staff here was very nice and prices weren't that bad IMHO. They're definitely a bit of a splurge but a lot of work went into their creations so it's worth it. Thumbs up.

    Rose cake pops
    Stephanie W.

    The prettiest and tastiest cake pops! These cake pops are adorable!! My boyfriend got me the cake pops shaped in a rose for Valentine's Day and they were too pretty to eat. Crunchy, sugary exterior with a chocolate fudge interior. The stem was made with chocolate, how cute! They also have other designs for their cake pops and they're located in the Essex market! Check them out!

    Cake pops
    Carol L.

    Super yummy moist cake pops, but definitely pricey! I can totally understand why since every cake pop is made very carefully. The prices actually range depending on how intricate the design is! I loved the cake pops that were filled with chocolate cake and birthday cake! They're definitely incredibly moist aka the perfect cake pop texture. I wish they'd list the prices next to each cake pop in their display though. A worthwhile splurge if you really like cake pops, but you can also just get a slice of cake somewhere for the price of 3 of these cake pops haha!

    Kenny C.

    I'm not much of a sweets guy, but I appreciate crafstmanship. They were able to do a custom order for my nephew's space-themed birthday party. All the pops were planets, and the attention to detail was amazing! We did a tray of chocolate and one of vanilla, and they were a big hit! Oh, not to mention delicious. The chocolate was my favorite.

    orange teddy bears on a stick
    Paulina K.

    Perfect gifts for kids, adults or yourself! I brought these from NYC to DC and they traveled flawlessly. They're obviously adorable, but what I didn't expect was for them to be so delicious! Every element of the cake pop is so thoughtful and YUMMY. From mini m&ms to what I believe are chocolate covered sunflower seeds, everything about these cake pops are perfection.

    Michelle L.

    Holy deliciousness!!!! These are hands down the BEST cake pops I have ever had and I do consider myself very picky, and a connoisseur. We tried the Thai iced tea cake pop and the rainbow cookie cake pop, both were moist and DELICIOUS! The staff is extremely helpful and friendly as well.

    The prettiest chocolate covered Oreos

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Not only the cake pops look like a masterpiece but it is delicious too. Definitely, will be back when we visit New York again.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 6
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Halle S.
    168
    132
    267

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kenny C.
    1052
    4499
    19744

    5 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Paulina K.
    629
    40
    37

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kal L.
    0
    392
    1819

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Rebecca's Cake Pops

    Review Highlights - Rebecca's Cake Pops

    I just happened to be browsing inside of the Essex market and stumbled upon this cute cake pop shop on the lower level.

    Mentioned in 4 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 12,015 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Evercake - 7" Pink Champagne in vanilla cake with French Cream and raspberry

    The Evercake

    4.5(162 reviews)
    3.9 miUpper East Side, Yorkville
    Locally owned & operated
    Women-owned & operated

    Great cake both taste and look. We were thrilled with how they made it extra tall to accommodate…read morethe additional people guests attending the party.

    I feel bad to write this review because I want to support a woman owned small business but...I wish…read moreI had not ordered my birthday cake from here. I was initially lured in by the good Yelp reviews. I liked that I could do everything online, I had a particular vision for what I wanted my birthday cake to look like and they communicated with me via email that could make my vision come true. I had a birthday celebration at a restaurant, which I asked The Evercake to have delivered directly to the restaurant. The delivery was smooth and the restaurant had the cake before I even got there. The cake was very cute and did look like what I had pictured. But...what I majorly disliked was the actual taste of the cake and being misled about what the contents of the cake would be. I selected the strawberry shortcake option for my cake and what I got was not what I thought it would be. I think it's quite normal for a strawberry shortcake to have like...real strawberries in between the layers. My cake didn't really have that, and if it did it was hidden in all the strawberry jam that there instead. I was not a fan of the cake texture too and the cream outside of the cake. Overall I felt so sad that I was feeding this to my friends and I told them that they didn't have to finish it because I wasn't going to either. So embarrassing :( Would you believe that this flop of a cake was nearly $200? And that's after the 10% coupon. I'm giving 2 stars instead of 1 because it wasn't completely bad, but the cake not tasting good was the biggest thing for me. I would have preferred it the other way around at least, like if the service was so bad but the cake tasted amazing, but unfortunately that was not the case for me. After digging through the reviews some more, I found that this happened to another customer as well. I wish I had seen their review before ordering a "strawberry" shortcake from here lol dang

    Photos
    The Evercake - Chocolate Frida Cake

    Chocolate Frida Cake

    The Evercake - 7" Clouds & Posies cake in strawberry shortcake.

    7" Clouds & Posies cake in strawberry shortcake.

    The Evercake - 7" Geo Prism cake in blue velvet and rock candy gems.

    See all

    7" Geo Prism cake in blue velvet and rock candy gems.

    BakeStreet - The casino cake

    BakeStreet

    4.6(9 reviews)
    2.4 miMidtown West

    My cake was beautiful and delicious I recommend using bake…read morestreet. I picked the cake up in Queens with minimal contact. I paid online.

    WARNING! CAKE was AWFUL! FELL APART!…read more I ordered a cake from a professional baker (Soma cakes) a few years ago that was beautifully made but was a bit bland, so I decided to look for a different baker. I found BakeStreet online, and I chose a baker, only to find out these are not "professional" bakers but HOME BAKERS! I didn't realize they employ home bakers until I asked my baker for the address. The NYC address they use for their business is NOT a real bakery! I thought these were professional bakers working out of a bakery. I found this part to be very misleading and only found out after I selected my baker and paid a deposit. My baker was 30 minutes from the city by car. I had made a deposit, and even though my intuition told me to back out, I decided to take a chance based on her reviews. I'm really curious if the reviews for the bakers are from real customers. Makes you wonder. You have to realize these cakes are being made in their homes! There are no sanitary rules that you know are being observed. My cake was placed in a cardboard box, and although it didn't really look like what I wanted, and the tassel, lettering, and diploma looked amateurish, what can a customer do after they paid for the cake and need it for a special occasion. Seriously, this is a great way to get ripped off! Once we got home and took the cake out of the box, it was falling apart, and the company had the nerve to tell us it was made properly! This cake was worth $100 maybe $150 but NOT almost $400. A cake that is baked properly will not fall apart after a 15 minute car ride! At the time that I picked up the cake, I told her I could hold it in my lap, but she said it wasn't necessary and placed the cake in the car. My Soma Cake that lasted an hour in the car to a different location never fell apart! The company had the nerve to offer me a $50 credit for a future cake that I would NEVER purchase! Why would I purchase another cake from a home baker? Poor customer service! They can enjoy my money! What a RIP-OFF! If a cake cannot make it in 15 minutes from pick-up to your location, there is something wrong with the cake! If you want to have a cake beautifully made, use Soma Cakes but don't get the red velvet. She is very talented. Her cake looked so realistic and we received a lot of compliments, but unfortunately it was bland, but it was a lot cheaper than what this company charged me, or you can just make your own cake. I'm sure it will be better than the disaster I received! Also, PLEASE do your research on this company. They have bad reviews on TrustPilot! If you want an okay cake, order from here. If you want a cake for a really special occasion, please go somewhere else. Find a place with an actual bakery and professional bakers. You will pay the same amount but get better results and not have to deal with their awful customer service!

    Photos
    BakeStreet - 50th Casino cake

    50th Casino cake

    BakeStreet - Custom Cake

    Custom Cake

    BakeStreet - Custom cake

    See all

    Custom cake

    Samantha Bakes Cakes - Rustic adn textured royal icing cake

    Samantha Bakes Cakes

    5.0(14 reviews)
    3.5 miPark Slope
    $$

    I have had the honor of not only tasting Samatha's delicious cakes, cake pops, and cookies at my…read morebaby shower, but also of working with her prior to her starting her own business. Samantha is professional, sweet, charming, and super talented. For my baby shower, Samantha created a beautiful spread of Dulce De leche cake, cake pops and adorably decorated cookies (rattles, onsies, champagne glasses) for my baby shower in late February. All of which fit perfectly in the theme of twinkle twinkle little star mixed with she's about to pop theme. Through out the event guests asked me who made the cookies, cake, and cake pops because they were so good. The decoration was classy, elegant, and festive. In just one bite you can tell her ingredients are top notch. The cake and cake pops were unbelievably moist and had the perfect balance of sweetness. Yes, it's months later and I'm writing this review now. Motherhood has rushed over me like a stormy wave of physical and emotional intensity that has changed my life forever, but those cake pops and cake still float through my mind as a pleasantly sweet memory that I still smile to myself about.

    I am so happy with Samantha's work. I found Samantha on yelp and was obsessed with how beautiful…read moreher work was. I contacted her about 2 weeks before my event and thought I would not be able to book her due to short notice. Samantha is the definition of professionalism. She contacted me via phone after my email and we went over what I wanted. She allowed me to make changes and did not appear money hungry. It was so easy working with her and I will be recommending her to friends and family. When my cake was delivered, it was packaged beautifully. When I unboxed my cake, I was stunned. Her work was amazing. Booking Samantha for my daughter first birthday party was a great idea. Thank you so much! I felt so bad cutting into the cake but it was even more delicious to eat. I will be using you in the future. Your cakepops were also great!

    Photos
    Samantha Bakes Cakes - Fondant, buttercream, and gold sequin cake

    Fondant, buttercream, and gold sequin cake

    Samantha Bakes Cakes - Moody cake

    Moody cake

    Samantha Bakes Cakes - Tailor your dessert to your taste buds.

    See all

    Tailor your dessert to your taste buds.

    Rebecca's Cake Pops - customcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...