I've heard great things about prime pizza and finally got around to trying it. I'm ordered for delivery on ubereats and my pizza was still warm. I ordered wings and a whole round pizza and it was good. I ordered my pizza well done and it was cooked perfect, no soggy pizza or toppings sliding off! I see they have square pizza, pastas and salads I'll have to try that next time I order. Will definitely return and recommend to friends. read more

Our go-to spot after a park visit or play date! Their pizzas have the right balance of chewy, crunchy dough, seasoned sauce, generous topping and overall goodness! Very nice patio space perfect for the neighborhood. Our usuals are Sicilian, grandma, pepperoni, spicy pepperoni and sausage and kale! Definitely get their lemon pepper wings and always get extra ranch! They make amazing ranch sauce that we always leave with a bottle! Service is friendly and fast! read more

Prime Pizza - Slices of simple but excellent pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

So so good! Definitely one of the best slices I've ever had in California. I don't normally care for garlic knots either, but I'm a huge fan of them for this location! We ordered for pick up and they had our items fresh, hot, and ready to go fairly quickly! While we didn't get to sit in to eat, the lively outdoor seating looked adorable. read more

See all

What more could you want? Nice beer selection, friendly staff and crunchy delicious pizza. I only tried the pan pizza; I like the by the slice option. Spicy pepperoni has a heat that builds. read more

Prime Pizza - Grandma and spicy pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

One of the best cheese pizzas I've had. I ordered 2 pepperoni slices and 1 cheese slice. Each slice costed $4.75. The pepperoni slices were good but the cheese slice was even better. For cheese pizza, they are able to cook it a bit longer so it's a bit crispier and the cheese is more baked which I love. There was no line but the tables outside were all full on the Saturday afternoon I went. They also have a mini bar for drinks/coffee. There isn't really any indoor seating but the outside seating is plenty and the atmosphere was filled with parents taking their kids out to enjoy their fave food. read more

Had the gluten free pizza. The dough was one of the best I've had. They make it in house. Be patient it may take a little longer, but worth the wait especially since it's fresh and made to order. Definitely not sitting around. I could taste the difference. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

By the slice, my favorite place that never let me down. Whenever you order a whole pizza and ask for extra protein, that's when the disappointment begins. Their idea of extra protein is different than mine. Five pieces of sausage on an entire pizza does not constitute extra protein, nor justify the cost. Nowcthat they can offer alcohol, no one's putting much thought into the wine selection. Back to Tardino Bros we go for a superior pizza rich with ingredients. read more

My boyfriend and I were out for a late night snack and decided on some pizza by the slice at Prime Pizzza. They have a small parking lot and a nice outdoor patio. There is limited seating inside at a ledge, but that didn't look too comfortable. We decided to order and seat ourselves outside. When I looked at their menu earlier in the day, I was drawn to the Meat Lovers, but that wasn't one of the ones they sold by the slice. My boyfriend ordered a classic triangle Pepperoni Slice ($4.75/slice) and I went with a fun rectangular shape Spicy Pepperoni Slice ($5.50/slice). We were given a number for our order to place wherever we decided to sit. They had some water dispensers inside and outside that were self serve. We got some water while we were waiting for our food and sat ourselves by a cozy heat lamp, since it was a cold evening. Considering it didn't look too busy, the order was a bit slow for reheating to slices of pizza. When we received it, I noticed that my boyfriend's pizza was thinner than mines. And the pepperoni distribution was lacking. It didn't go all the way to the crust. My pizza was nice and crispy along the edges but thick and filling. At least it had a good amount of pepperoni. We both felt like the pizza was pretty average but it was a nice adventure. Not sure we would go out of our way to come back here, but it's not bad if we happen to be in the area. read more

See all

We're back at Prime Pizza for some slices. A breezy nice day on the patio. We got cheese & veggie slices. The slices seem to be getting smaller. Hmmm. Still yummy . Limited parking lot and free street parking. read more

See all

Lot of my friends and family and co workers have told me to try this place, and I'm a huge pizza lover so I had high expectations, the spicy pepperoni is holy smokes one of the best slices of pizza I've ever tried, the hype is real !!! I highly recommend the staff is also so nice and welcoming and they have parking and over all great experience I recommend y'all try it!!! Especially the spicy pepperoni ama be a regular cause that pizza is terrific read more

See all

Pizza is great! Love that slices are an option, have gone multiple times! Really benefited joining the points program, I got $5 off after signing up! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

The first two visits to Prime were meh . However after eating the square spicy pepperoni pizza though, I've completely changed my mind . Had this with their cesar salad & both were amazing . The spice was perfect & the pizza was made quickly . Great for take out , one slice got me full so make sure to share this big beautiful pizza. Definitely getting it again. read more

Prime Pizza - Spicy Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Wanted a pizza, but just a couple of slices. Not many places do that, so I decided to check this spot out, which is like a 10 minute walk from Casa De Gilbert. How convenient. This location used to be a bakery for a while, so I was surprised to see a pizza joint in its place. Not much parking and it's in a weird corner spot that's tricky to traverse since it's at an intersection. So proceed with caution. Anyway, this place has a really good vibe. Spacious outdoor, covered seating that's clean and well-maintained. Great spot for family and friends to eat and hang out. No fountain drinks, however, just bottles and cans. Onto the food. These are your thin-crust pizzas, nothing deep dish here and nothing way too fancy. Ordered the following slices: - Pepperoni - 7.3/10: Solid AF. Nice balance of cheese to sauce. Felt a little cheated with the Pepperoni, though, but the flavors are nice. - White - 7/10: Not as good as the Pepperoni, but still a solid slice. Not too oily or salty. Nice blend of cheeses. Crust is nice and crispy, but nothing too special about it to be honest. Lacked a bit of texture. Prices aren't too bad at all. It's not the greatest by far, but the appeal for me is that you can order by the slice and it's a nice environment to bring family and friends. Menu has other non pizza items, so that might be worth checking out. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

Ordered and paid for our pizza online with a pick-up time of 5:10PM. It's 5:40PM and they've given out tons of pizzas to at least 13 other customers who arrived after us. We've been waiting in the rain and still don't have our pie yet... 2 stars because their pizzas are good. It's just a very unfortunate experience with service. We're so frustrated!! read more

It's... fine. Perfectly serviceable pizza. Nothing terrible, but nothing excellent either. We have ordered from here a few times, but more recently, I have been suggesting other places that I like more. Recently, we needed to get food a group that included a gluten free guest who said they liked Prime Pizza's GF pizza, so it's nice to know there are options for those who need it. For me their pizza lacks the texture I want in a good pizza crust. The crust is thin, but lacks chewiness or very much flavor. We also once tried the square pies, which were also decent but lackluster. I do love that they have online orders and each time I arrived on time, the food was ready and waiting for me. The last visit, parking was a little difficult because the spaces were filled. I feel like they need more spaces reserved for just pickup, but I was able to find street parking. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

Such a great pizza spot! The chicken parm sandwich was really good! Both the food and service were amazing. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and delicious. Definitely coming back, highly recommend! read more

What is happening to our favorite pizza spot? This is the second time I've ordered pizza and it's been a soggy soupy mess. I called and let them know about the issue and was met with defensiveness and told to call Uber Eats and file my complaint with them. Super disappointed really just wanted to call and let them know that their quality was slipping. I don't even care about getting my money back. I just want our neighborhood pizza spot to be as awesome as it was when it first started come on guys be the pizza place we know you can be. read more

Came here amd thoroughly enjoyed everything we ordered. Really appreciate the tasty gluten free options that are usually hard to come by at pizza spots. Service was prompt and everything was clean. read more

We loved Prime Pizza!!! We went a little crazy and got 5 flavors -- the Grandma, the Sicilian, the Spicy Pepperoni, the Vodka, and the BBQ Chicken. All of them were AMAZING, the square ones have an addicting crust and the ratios are perfect. My favorites were the sicilian, the vodka, and the spicy pepperoni. The workers were extremely kind and the vibe is very nice too. It's a casual patio-like scene, designed super trendy and cute. I will definitely be coming again (they have rewards!!!) read more

Prime Pizza - Top row: BBQ, spicy pepperoni Middle: vodka Bottom: sicilian, the grandma - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Given the wrong order as per usual, and Cold as can possibly be. I'd like to be able to order from this establishment and not have to triple check that I've recieved what I paid for. It was nowhere near busy. I don't understand. The staff this Tuesday night was horrendous. Will you guys ever get it together? read more

$2 slice opening special! We went to the special! The pizza was delicious, and definitely loved getting it for $2. We sprung for four spicy pepperoni slices. Served fast. And the outdoor patio was great. We will be back! read more

Prime Pizza - New location for lunch! - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

Excellent service, g not great pizza. Veggie pizza has too much spinach and not enough other veggies. I'd make my request differently next time, and it's worth going back. read more

Great pizza- delicious and a nice selection of choices! We really enjoyed this place!

The pizza always has great flavor. Been there 3 times. But this is two times that i get home and open the box to cold pizza. I live 2 minutes away. It sucks to pay this much for pizza and have to reheat it as soon as i get home. Friendly staff but it seems like there are a lot of them! read more

Such an amazing pizza joint. The pies are amazing! Wife and I love the arrabiata and we add mushrooms and jalapeños. We get a pizza from here about once a week. read more

The restaurants in Altadena have been getting a lot of news coverage due to the fire destruction and road closures making them inaccessible. Well on a Sunday night the pizza shop was busy. We picked out three different slices and a coke which cost me 18 bucks. I'm a pizza snob and I can tell you these slices were delicious and the pizza dough is first rate with that perfect crunch. They are also selling special Altadena Fire fundraising t-shirts. read more

Prime Pizza - Vodka slice FEB2025 - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

NY pizza in LA. Or is it LA pizza in LA? Whatever you want to call it - this place is the BEST place for a slice. Service is great - straightforward and efficient. Pizza is always perfect. Best sauce to cheese ratio and that perfectly thin crust. read more

Heard the spicy pepperoni is the perfect amount of spicy, and it is :) Staff was friendly and helpful. Outdoor seating is casual & cozy with wood tables and benches and pergola-style wave shade sails overhead. My first visit, but observed what appeared to be local families enjoying an early dinner at 4:30 pm on a Friday evening. Will visit again for more spicy pepperoni pizza. Approx. 9 parking spots on site and street parking. read more

Prime Pizza - nice outdoor seating, some parking on site and on streets - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

Just Wow!!!! We were traveling through this area on our way back home to Northern California and wanted to get some "great" pizza in the LA area before we started making that boring drive up north I searched and searched until we found this spot, locals raved about it on Reddit, so we decided to give it a chance It was amazing!!! NY style with a thin crispy bottom! No flop! It's the type of pizza I dream about!!! Also the folks there are super friendly!! Can't recommend it enough! It's our new favorite So Cal pizza spot!! read more

We were working in the area and got one to go. Regular cheese pizza. It was very good. Especially the crust. Great taste and good crisp texture! Moderately priced. read more

They survived the Eaton fire and are reopened!!!!id been meaning to try this place out. We came at lunchtime on Super Bowl Sunday. Got a pepperoni pizza for two adults and a child. Sizebis great for the price. Pepperoni was not too spicy and the crust was great. We sat on the beautiful patio and enjoyed the amazing SoCal weather. They have a small parking lot that was a little tricky to navigate but we managed to find a spot. Price was good for the quality. Being Super Bowl Sunday they were doing a robust about of takeout business but our pizza didn't take too long to come out. Everyone was friendly and courteous despite being slammed. Will absolutely come again. read more

Prime Pizza - Round pepperoni pizza on the patio - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Finally came and dined in ,order the spicy pepperoni,a salad and garlic knots.The spicy pepperoni is so good even the next day it tastes the same. lol Knots and salad fresh and delicious as well. Service friendly and welcoming. read more

Came here on a weeknight. Place was packed. Parking was difficult. But it was all so worth it. Their best is their pepperoni square pizza. The dough is like an airy foccacia. The sauce is memorable. Pepperoni's were tasty and abundant. - The only improvement would be to serve it at a warmer temp - Mine was given to me slightly warmer than room temp Had a taste of another type of pizza. It was nice and aggressive with the garlic flavor. Thin crust was meh. I think it was spinach and tomato toppings. - Decent, not the best They also serve brewed iced tea packaged in their own packaging. The cashier suggested I come back for their wings. I would recommend going here in the off hours so you don't have to park far away. read more

See all

The food was delicious but thought it was kind of pricey but expected. It was cold outside and the outdoor heater was not working or the staff forgot to turn it on after being told it was too cold outside. Lacking attention in my opinion (IMO) read more

Prime Pizza is a cute off-the-beaten-path local shop. Lunch service is brisk and busy but they have a sizable staff working to keep the wait to an absolute minimum. They're good for lunch because they sell pizzas by the slice in addition to full pies. The slices are all premade but they warm them in the oven just prior to serving so they are nice, hot and tasty. read more

Prime Pizza - Sicilian Pizza slice to go - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

8.5/10 spicy pep Sicilian !!!!! Definitely add this place to your list as you travel through read more

Prime Pizza is the place that started it all for me. I've been to all the Prime locations, except Fairfax. Unfortunately, I have had really inconsistent experiences with Prime lately, particularly from their Little Tokyo spot. These experiences compounded, and eventually soured my perception of their brand. They recently had a promotion, which enticed me to finally try their new Altadena location. Upon arrival, I could not help but smirk. It instantly reminded me of the Burbank location (can't believe I drove all the way to Burbank for Prime Pizza back in the day lmaooooo). Horny CRE agents can start spamming Prime now 'cause it seems they have a type: medium traffic oddball intersection with an afterthought of a parking lot. I wonder how often the parking layout changed with each City Planner. Lol. The staff were all very courteous and competent. Even so, I was so ready to be disappointed when I got home. But with one bite, the nostalgia instantly took me back to 2017 when I first had Prime Pizza. Damn, Prime Pizza still got it. They really still got it even with all the new competition. Great chew, great sourdough kick. The drive was quite pleasant as well. My road rage did not activate. I might even order regular sauce next time instead of light sauce as regular sauce + road rage = soggy pizza. Squares are still where it's at. Imo, rounds here are a waste of time. read more

See all

Prime Pizza used to be my favorite go to for a nyc style pizza when I first moved to LA. I was really happy they had another location closer to me for delivery in Pasadena, but there has definitely been a quality change in the past couple of months. Before, the pizzas had a crusty, thin bottom. Now, it's a soggy, doughy mess. The crust tastes under-cooked and a chore to gnaw on - I have to pre-heat my own oven now to finish cooking the dough through to be enjoyable. I'm not sure if they have new cooks compared to the higher quality I've expected for the past 2 years, but this is my third order in two months that has disappointed me enough to look into other alternatives. They've usually been great, but again - the past three orders of mine have been a huge departure from the standard they used to have. read more

I have tried this neighborhood location in Altadena. I have a dozen times now and I can tell you, there is consistency in their pies. I prefer the whole round pie with a crispy thin crust.I also really like the sauce, the cheese and the dough. You can taste the ingredients are high-quality. I would highly recommend the pizza at this location. read more

Prime pizza is tasty and their slice prices are great. The people are always friendly and as someone who has started food delivery to help pay bills, they have been a wonderful establishment to work with in such a capacity. It also doesn't hurt that they have a nice front patio to hang out on. read more