Pros: 1. My new favorite is their sandwich. I love the chicken parm and the meatball sandwich. The bread is so amazing and toasty and not hard, not stale, not dense, and not dry. Amazingly it also holds for a day or two (because I always order too much) and it's still good later. Either the other locations don't have it or I never noticed, but I'll go all the way here just for this one item. 2. I love their pizza (esp. the thicker squares) because it is light and toasty and doesn't feel heavy or greasy. But, it is still satisfying. 3. So far all the people seem nice. Cons: 1. Not enough parking, especially for such a popular place at night, but even in the middle of the day when it doesn't feel crowded, there aren't enough places to park. 2. While the pizza is fantastic fresh out of the oven, I find that the pizza is not as good once it cools. 3. Though the original is good, the toppings/flavors on the square slices are too limited - would love a non-spicy pepperoni or some other combinations so that I can order more and have every square be a different flavor. read more

See all

5 families got their pizzas before us. We got pizza by the slice and so did these families. When we asked about it 3 times given that these families payed after us came after us and also got pizza by the slice. When the pizza came they apologized and said "we burned the first slices" but we were clearly annoyed and hangry. Also hard to believe they burned them and 5 parties got theirs first. All parties had come in gradually, and they had clearly forgotten our order. They offered to comp our full meal and they did. The pizza was great the spicy pepperoni was by far our fave. Had they not offered to comp our meal we would have definitely left with sour taste. read more

Prime Pizza has arrived in Altadena and we couldn't be more excited. We usually order from here at least once a week. The cheese and pepperoni pizzas are my personal favorite! And if you happen to go on the weekends, you'll catch Bevel Coffee outside as well! The pizzas are made fresh and are pipping hot. Lots of outdoor seating and minimal indoor seating. Parking is limited but there's lots of street parking as well. Overall, location is very helpful for folks that live near the area. This location does surprisingly well considering it is situated further up north from the freeway. I would definitely recommend stopping by when you're in the area! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza and coffee on the weekends! - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Pretty decent pizza place in Altadena. Service was quick, and the ambiance simple. Outside dining is a plus. It's more popular with my family than with myself, but I'm not complaining. read more

Don't order the gluten free pizza. A standard 18' regular pizza is $30. A got a whole gluten free pizza for $25, thinking it was comparable. No one said anything about the size. It's legitimately a 9 inch square. Total rip off if you're someone looking for alternative crust. I let them know and they do not care. read more

Pass by this place every day and finally gave it a try. Delicious thin pizza and great front staff! Will definitely be back to try other toppings. Ambiance was cozy! read more

Prime Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

I love New York style pizza. I've been wanting to try Prime Pizza since they opened in Altadena. So when I saw that they had a $36 family meal and I had to go check it out right away. The family meal included an 18 inch cheese pizza, caesar salad and garlic knots. This was a really good deal in my opinion. It fed our family of four and we were all pretty satisfied. I thought the pizza was really good. It totally satisfied my craving for a NY style pizza. The caesar salad was really good as well. It felt like it was put together when we ordered it, instead of being pre-packed hours ago sitting in the fridge. The lettuce was really fresh and crisp. The dressing had a nice kick to it as well. I ordered online and it took only about 18 minutes for it to be ready for pickup. I'm a fan and will definitely be back. read more

My friends and I (4 people in total) ordered meat lovers square pizza, supreme, garlic knots. and chicken wings for delivery. The food was solid. I'm usually not super huge into lots of meat, but my favorite pizza was meat lovers. I loved the fluffy crust! It is a thicker pizza, so if you prefer New York style, you may enjoy the supreme more. I do wish there were more veggies on the supreme. The garlic knots were also delicious, and the wings were tasty too. I would definitely order from here again. read more

See all

Nice crispy crust with nearly no flop and good flavor. Good NY style pie. They offer wings and square pizzas as well so there's plenty of options to choose from. read more

See all

The prices are a bit high for what you get. I ordered the grandma square for $30. I thought my kids would like a plain cheese pizza. The tomato sauce was very sour. It doesnt taste cooked at all. I think it gets dolloped on just before coming out. The sour tomato sauce was disliked by my kids. The acidity does cut through the grease and makes it not feel as heavy though. Just not so kid friendly. Maybe the round slices would be a better choice. Overall a pricey pizza that was just ok. I have another Pasadena pizza place i got to for Detroit pizza. Since I'm used to that place and hold it as the standard, this place is just ok. I would pass read more

Superb food all around and a perfect neighborhood-locus vibe. Friendly staff and very community-oriented business. I lean towards the Sicilian-style thick-crust rectangular pizza, but it's all great. The round pizzas are MUCH better fresh out of the oven than they are after traveling home in a box, so I highly recommend eating there. The Sicilians travel better. read more

Rejoice! Prime has arrived in Altadena. Thank goodness because I was tired of going to little Tokyo. From what I understand, opening weekend was lit. Very,very busy! Popped by today for lunch and it was busy but not insane (no line). Parking here is going to be a problem if they keep up the crowds. There are not tons of spots, maybe 10 or so. Pizza was great as always & the staff was really nice. Everyone seemed to be working really hard. I got the spicy pepperoni & grandma slices. I didn't realize they had pasta but they have a vodka pasta and a Bolognese that I will definitely be trying. I am thrilled this is now closer to my stomping grounds and I will definitely be stopping by often! read more

*Update:Their food made us sick! We both woke up vomiting and have diarrhea a few hours after eating it! Avoid this place! Now I know why my dog wouldn't eat it!* For a place to have taken up our beloved Patticakes location spot, I am REALLY disappointed at the prices and quality of food here. I was charged $10 for a Cesar salad that was soo small and had NO FLAVOR. Ugh. You'd get a tastier and bigger cesar salad for 1/4 the price at Trader Joe's! I really regret giving them my money. Esp now after reading reviews on how rude they are to customers, and the owners rude response back to them on Yelp, luckily I didn't engage with them since my bf picked up our phone order. I should've read reviews before ordering. We really regret giving them money. The meatball sub meat tastes like cafeteria meat! DISGUSTING I couldn't eat i really wish I could get my money back. $15 for three gross meatballs on bread ONLY THREE MEATBALLS...I really regret giving them my money I bought two of these ugh. I only liked the sesame sub bread. I got one Cesar salad and two meatball subs. We are truly disappointed. Also they could have fit at least one more meatball in the sandwich. THIS PLACE IS A RIP OFF!! They need to lower their prices significantly to reflect their low quality food but I still wouldn't come back because it taste soo bad. I gave part of the meatball to my cat and my dog and they both refused to eat it so yeah thats how you know this meat is bad! My dog and cat are foodies and would eat In N Out, but not this! They wouldn't even taste this nasty beef! Just wow. We all hated it. We were curious to try it because they call themselves NY Style but it is far from it. If you want actual delicious NY Style save your money and order from Brooklyn Square. I will never come back to Prime Pizza and I hope they close down soon. R.I.P Patticakes Btw: Prime Pizza painted over the Patticakes mural that Patticakes fought years to protect. Now it just a white wall with their dumb logo on it. read more

Prime Pizza - Mediocre meatball sub and an overpriced bland mayo tasting Cesar salad. RIPPED OFF Bring back Patticakes - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Love this place. Great pizza by the slice options for lunch. Crust is perfect the Sicilian is awesome.

Sad to see this location fall off the way it has over the last 6 months. I think the owner may have taken his eye off of it or something. Stale pizza and often sloppily prepared. Truly unfortunate as it was AMAZING for the first few months after opening. Owner please spend more time on the Altadena location. read more

Just grabbed a few slices,;cheese, white and the kids got pepperoni. Nice chewy crust and the sauce leans more to tangy than sweet. The dough is what really stands out for me. The staff was very friendly, I can't wait to go back and try the square slices. A very welcome addition to the neighborhood. read more

See all

Came here and ordered two pizzas, costing $80. Was told that I could not modify my pizza. I've been modifying my pizza at this location for a few years now and all of a sudden they've become a pizza joint where you can't make any modifications. This is ridiculous. What kind of a pizza place doesn't allow you to add toppings make light toppings or add more toppings. It's the most absurd explanation for any pizza joint. Wouldn't recommend coming here. tried to explain my concerns to the manager, and he was rude and disrespectful. read more

First time trying this local place, recently, and it did not disappoint! Loved both the pan pizza and the vodka sauce one. Looking forwarding to trying it again soon! read more

Love that a well-known pizza joint opened up in Altadena. Altadena is becoming a new hot spot for restaurant openings and Prime Pizza is one of them. I'm a fan of thin crust pizzas and had to give their pepp pizza a try. The dough had the perfect crisp to chew ratio and I loved the cups of pepperoni on top. I do wish their sauce had more flavor and the cheese was more melty, because the cheese firmed up quickly. I'd rate the pizza an 8.2. The popular vodka slice was cold by the time I ate it, because the whole pie took about 30 minutes to prepare. I thought this slice was alright, but I'd come back for a simple pepp or cheese slice. The staff here is fantastic and friendly. I'd come back to get in my pizza fix. read more

Prime Pizza - pepp pie - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

Delicious. The place has a cool, hip atmosphere with outside bench tables. The pizza is great. Very crispy , the sauce is tasty and the ingredients fresh and delicious. You also can get full pizza or by the slice. Best pizza I've had in forever. Period. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Great pizza and outstanding customer service. My favorite pizza at Prime is the spicy pepperoni. Thank you Robin for your kindness.

After my first experience, I was contacted by the manager and offered a chance for them to make up for the situation. I was offered a gift card for the amount of my first purchase. I thanked them and approved of the gesture. Then I was asked over the course of a few emails to get them my order (which was in the review) and receipts to prove the order. To witch they gave me a $30 (slightly less than the purchase) digital gift card. I went back and used that to grab a pizza for the family. I got the half/half square pizza. Half Grandma and Half Meat Lovers. Asked for extra sauce. This time around, I ordered online. I arrived about 5 min before they said and shortly after I received a text that my order was ready. Lucky for me it wasn't that busy. I picked up my pizza and decided that I wanted to try it fresh out of the oven. So I sat at a table and had a corner cut. Good god in heaven it was tasty, crunchy and so flavorful. I rushed home and the family enjoyed the rest. So... I am thankful that Prime Pizza went to the effort to redeem themselves and have done so in strong fashion. My Pro Tip for everyone out there would be this: Order Online for pick up. Then: sit at the tables and enjoy your slices piping hot and melting... the way the good lord intended us to. But also be ready to take it home because the parking lot and tables can be a madhouse. Thank you for the effort. You've made a fan out of me! read more

We tried Prime Pizza for the first time last night. We wanted to support this local business, affected by the Eaton Canyon Fire. It was delicious!! We ordered two half and half pizzas: white pizza and kale/sausage, and Sicilian and pepperoni. Loved them all! We have tons of leftovers to enjoy too. I really loved the half and half options. I think the white pizza with chicken was my favorite! Highly recommend! read more

Phenomenal pizza would definitely come back! Service and everything was outstanding! And atmosphere was great for middle of the week

Been coming here since you opened. Very disappointing lately. Horrible attitude from the staff. Maybe they are feeling overworked. There needs to be a better system for orders to be picked up in orders to be placed. Also, there is literally no space to stand. We used to love to sit outside but lately it's just been overrun with dirty tables. Food is always good, but there's flies so that doesn't make it a pleasant place to sit. read more

I ordered the BBQ chicken pizza slice. The pizza was okay, nothing special about. What I like is the patio on the outside. The parking is limited. read more

Prime Pizza - BBQ chicken slice. - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

I'm reluctant to say this is my favorite pizza in Pasadena. I wish it was available by the slice, because it's just so expensive to buy the whole pizza. read more

I can't believe this is a 3.9 on Yelp.. It deserves so much more. It's really good. It tastes great and perfect amount if crisp. And I'm honestly very picky about pizza. Looks good and friendly people too. read more

Their spicy pepperoni square pizza has ruined me. It's like a focaccia pizza... and I don't want any other kind anymore. It's pricy... but so damn good I'll pay it. read more

How is it possible, on a Sunday at 2:45 in the afternoon, to walk into Prime -- half packed with c-h-i-l-d-r-e-n in baseball and soccer uniforms, with DMX blaring through your speakers singing Ruff Ryder's Anthem? The N-Word - 15 times. The F-Word - 7 times. The S-Word - 4 times The B-Word - 2 times. Not the radio edit. Not the clean version. The explicit album version. This is your business model? Really? On a Sunday? read more

Let me begin my saying I am NOT a big pizza fan, however this pizza is unlike any other. I think I could demolish this whole thing it's that good. You HAVE to get their Spicy pepperoni pizza and I also really enjoy their bbq chicken pizza but the true kicker is the RANCH! You just buy a bottle of their ranch because it is that good. Highly highly recommend read more

Prime Pizza - Spicy pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

I tried the ready slices and ended up trying the grandmas squares all were excellent not as good a fresh whole pie but overall it was an excellent experience loved the food and service was great too read more

I'll start by saying I did not like the tomato sauce. It has an acidic taste to it, I just couldn't get past it. The dough itself is really good, the Sicilian is so soft and spongy it almost felt like a puff pastry it's oil stayed on the sauce never dripped off. I had the spicy pepperoni and a regular slice of BBQ Chicken that comes with jalapeños. The bbq didn't taste like bbq at all tho. I enjoyed the toppings as well on both. You can tell everything is fresh and good quality. Like I said I couldn't get past the sauce. read more

The Caesar salad was a joke/rip off! We ordered the veggie pizza, and the crust was soggy and doughy.

Ordered this on Sunday at the pizza came burnt and the wings were dry. Unfortunately will not be ordering from there again. read more

Love the pizza quality at Prime. Staff service at this location is on point as well. Today I was eating a slice and as I was eating they noticed it was slightly burnt on the bottom and brought me a completely new slice, without me even asking for one. Much appreciated! Favorites: White, Vodka, Spicy Pepperoni, Sicilian read more

Excellent pizza with a number of great choices. Terrific crusts in both the regular thin crust and more of a Detroit style. Quality toppings. The chocolate chip cookies are worth saving some room for. Nice, fast service. Nice sitting area outside, too. read more

Omg I got frustrated today. First time there and last time. Waited 45 minutes for a pizza and wings. They even forgot my ranch dressing. My kid was hungry and tired. I should have made her eat while I waited. Got home around 8 and just didn't care anymore. Sloppy honestly. Go to Barones! read more

Oh my gosh! We happened upon Prime Pizza and decided to go this afternoon when we saw that they had gluten free pizza (and not that cardboard, premade crust, but homemade crust.) We hoped for the best but expected the usual mediocrity. When we opened the box, we almost cried from pure joy and we knew it was going to be good. It was absolutely amazing. The BEST gf pizza hands down that we had ever eaten. The slices were square, and thick, with a delicious crispy crust around the outside. It was perfection and we left talking about our next trip back. Also, the staff was all smiles, and amazing. Can't wait to return! Bring all of your gluten free friends. They'll be so happy! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

The food was absolutely incredible and the pizza was insanely big The service was incredible too Overall i would recommend great pizza great service read more