Food at Brooklyn Square is great. We come here every week for a reason. The relaxing atmosphere and great service from Maggie keeps us coming back! The pizza is the best in Pasadena. Way better than Prince Street around the corner. Only novice pizza eaters would go there. Sandwiches are delicious too, I like the Cajun Turkey. read more

Brooklyn Square - Pepperoni and Jalapeno pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

See all

I always come around here when I want a nice simple lunch. Maggie is always great and the service is friendly. My favorite spot in old town

great service and food! the sandwiches are the best. magdalena is always very welcoming and so is the rest of the staff!

I guess I haven't been to old Pas in a while so when I was in the area to do some shopping, I stopped in here to grab a bite. I saw that they have a bunch of pizzas and sandwiches on the menu and while I love pizza, I just had pizza the day before so I decided to try their sandwiches. The person who helped me was pretty no nonsense and efficient, I guess this is what it feels like if you are actually in Brooklyn? lol There are a variety of lunch specials daily from 11 am - 4 pm, and happy hour with $3 draft beers from 3 pm - 7 pm. PIzza options look really good, whole round pies are 18", 8 slices, and are all about $30. Square pizzas are also about $30 for 8 slices. I ordered the Cajun Bridge sandwich (cold) because I like all things spicy, and I love squaw bread, so this one was calling my name. So glad I did because it was so good and hit the spot! There are two entrances into the restaurant. The counter to order, as well as restrooms, requires you to go down a level, but the left entrance has a lift if you need in order to go down. read more

See all

We tried Brooklyn Square Pizza and overall we had a really good experience. The pepperoni pizza came out hot and fresh with plenty of pepperoni and cheese. I definitely liked that they weren't stingy with the toppings. The crust was good and had a nice crisp to it. We also ordered the fried ravioli with marinara sauce, and those were really good. They were crispy on the outside and cheesy on the inside, and the marinara had a lot of flavor. The service was good. Everyone was friendly and we didn't have to wait too long for our food. The atmosphere was pretty laid-back and casual, which made it a nice place to sit down and eat with the family. I gave them 4 stars because the food and service were both really good, but there's still a little room for improvement. I would definitely come back and try some of the other pizzas on the menu. read more

Brooklyn Square - Fried ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

See all

Fuggedaboutit if you are coming here for a healthy salad. Twice I have tried to get a basic crisp salad, and twice I am wondering why. The tuna salad I got had no romaine as advertised, and no garbanzo beans. It all felt thrown together. Maybe the sandwiches a pizza are better? I'll never know. read more

Brooklyn Square - They claim this is arugula. It's not. There's no garbanzo beans, and it all around is kinda meh. The ranch does not taste fresh. - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Came here for a late lunch and got a slice of New York cheese pizza and a sandwich. The pizza is okay, tastes like how it looks. The sandwich on the other hand was very tasty, with good / fresh ingredients and decent portion. It did get a bit messy to eat. Will return again to try out other sandwiches but will probably skip the pizza. read more

See all

If you're going to come here for slices, I definitely recommend coming here earlier than 9PM. Luckily, I've had the good fortune of trying their pizza before, so I've already tried some of the better options. The service was fast and the ambiance is decent too, I wasn't here long this time, but I'm glad I finally for to see the Pasadena location. Still a fan of getting the whole pie, it's so much fresher! read more

See all

I'm always down to try some new pizza spots and Brooklyn Square satisfied my pizza craving! Huge plus for selling ready made slices. It's always great to see pizza spots offering slices to go or slices to enjoy inside. The location on Fair Oaks in the busy streets of Old Town Pasadena. Parking garages are all nearby or street parking around the building. The location has a number of tables and TVs to enjoy the games. The staff here were super friendly and made us feel very welcome. There were an abundance of ready made slices to select. Per the staff, they have vegan cheese options for whole pizzas, but none for ready made slices. Just as an FYI. They also offer a number of sandwiches as well. The number of items is vast and of great variety. Now for the pizza. The selection was a mix NY slices and square slices. I was looking for some to go. So I decided on the squares cause I love those slices! I went with Pepperoni Grandma and a Pepperoni Honey DeNiro. The staff will heat it up for you on the oven and even cut slices in half to enjoy them. I loved the flavors and the crisp edges. It had a great crunch in each bite and taste was solid. My favorite of the too was the Pepperoni Honey DeNiro. The hot honey on this slice made this option stand out to me. The mix of sweet and savory paired with heat is my kind of combo of flavor. :) I would come back again if I'm craving pizza and would think of the trying a sandwich too in the future because their menu looked good. Thanks, Brooklyn Square! ( ^_^)b read more

See all

Just going over receipts and found one for this subpar pizza. Wanted to let folks know they charge you a 3% fee if you sue a card. That's the merchant's cost and they are passing it on to the customer. The pizza is subpar and in no way representative of a New York slice. The sauce has absolutely no flavor either. Dough Drop for what's hot in town right now. Not cheap but it's quality read more

Brooklyn Square - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Last time I came the AC was broken and so was the soda machine 3 months later the soda machine is still broken but they got a deli. This place is joke. Especially for customers who love eating inside and enjoyed refills with my pizza. Last time I come. Almost an entire year without fixing it They just don't care read more

Was in the area and needed some lunch. Walked down the street to see the options we had and I loved how the pizza looked from here! I haven't had pizza in a while and love the idea of pizza by the slice. We got a pizza and salad to share! Greek salad 10/10 and pizza was delicious too 10/10! I would love to comeback when in the area! Most of the parking here is paid street parking or lots. They have a tablet to order your food from. Pretty busy but service is still very quick! read more

See all

The pizza did not have enough cheese. I had a slice of pepperoni and a grandmas pizza. Too much sauce and not enough cheese. The pepperoni did not have enough flavor. I've had a lot of Brooklyn pizza and this is not authentic Brooklyn style pizza. read more

I ordered the Meat Lovers grandma for pickup. There's not a good place to park just for pickup, you'd have to find adjacent street parking or park in the structure. I was with my bf so he got out while I waited on the street with emergency lights on. It took awhile and when he came out he said there was nobody around working so it took awhile to get service so that wasn't ideal. As for the pizza itself, thankfully it was still pretty hot by the time we got home. The toppings tasted fresh and they didn't skimp on them. I like a thick Detroit style crust or pan so for me it was delicious. Even my bf who prefers a thinner crust still really liked it. It's a little pricey but in line with these more specialty type of pizza spots. Overall I enjoyed it and could see myself ordering from them again. read more

Brooklyn Square - Meat Lovers - Grandma Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Came by the other day craving pizza and wanted to try something new. They have a good selection of slices and square pies, plus some sandwiches. I got a square Honey Dinero and a slice of margherita. The square was decent, cheesy with crispy edges, but I couldn't really taste much of the honey and it felt a little dry, could've used more sauce. The margherita slice was the winner for me. Crispy edges, gooey cheese, and a good balance of sauce. Next time I'd probably stick with the slices over the squares. I'm also curious to try their sandwiches since they use Boar's Head meats which is usually good quality. Overall a good spot if you're looking to switch it up. read more

Brooklyn Square - The Honey Deniro Pie , tomato garlic pie - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

4.5 stars Came last night around 8pm so there wasn't many single slice options available which was unfortunate. Single slice range from $5-6 & were huge! I love the ambiance, they have great music & they play sports on their large tv so it's a good vibe. Our favorite pizzas were the plain cheese pizza & the honey deniro pizza! Also tried the pepperoni & chicken bbq. The black & white cookie wasn't great but I've always wanted to try one. Total $30 with tip The round pizza slices have a crunchy bottom & thin crust. The square pizza slices have a crunchy bottom & fluffy center. Parking in Pasadena just isn't as convenient, have to park down the street at the meter but not too bad since it wasn't busy read more

See all

We always have to get pizza somewhere when we travel and when we walked by this place we had to check it out. They make pies (both NY & grandma) and sandwiches. They sell by the slice as well and there's always a dozen different options ready to go in the display case. The kid working the counter was great very polite, helpful and personable (great customer service!). We liked it so much we visited two days in a row! We tried a variety of grandma style slices and they all were fantastic! The dough was great it had a good chew and crispy sides and bottom. Good quality cup & char pepperoni and ricotta cheese! read more

Brooklyn Square - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

See all

We enjoyed the pizza so much we went back twice !! The slices were huge and flavorful !!! $5.50 a slice !!! The guy at the counter (didn't get his name) was super friendly and a hard worker . read more

See all

The place looked cute with its black and white themed design. They have a wide array of options from pizzas and sandwiches. Was craving pizza and tried their Honey De Niro pie. They warmed it up before serving and added drizzle of honey. It was kind of the server to bring me some to-go boxes after I got up to change tables. A slice of one pie was bigger than expected, but well worth the price. Although the flavor was lacking for me not sure what it is with the tomato sauce but it was pretty bland. The dollops of cheese on top though saved the pizza, not sure if it's ricotta or something else. Overall taste of this pizza didn't meet my expectations but do appreciate the size to price ratio. Would like to return and try the sandwiches though! read more

See all

Great value for the price, perfect size, and tastes great! I definitely recommend it!! read more

Brooklyn Square - Spicy Pepperoni Square Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Always looking for a true NY Deli experience and O found it in Brooklyn Square. I got a hot Rueben with added corned beef on rye bread. I met a lady who frequents the deli saying it reminds her of true NYC pizza and sandwiches. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. Don't forget to ask for pickles! Enjoy read more

Soooo good, cant go wrong with any of the pies! I like that they have a good mix of square and round pizzas. I haven't had their sandwiches, but I'd love to come back to try. They're quick with toasting your slices and bringing food right to your table. FYI - they're on InKind app! read more

Brooklyn Square - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Sandwiches are huge and tasty - top ingredients and always split one as it's just too big for the average person - Please make sure to include extra pickles as they are so delicious read more

Brooklyn Square - 1/2 of the BQE - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Amazing service!great staff! Maggie definitely goes above and beyond to help with customer service and make sure im catered to. Definitely coming back again. read more

Pizza isn't bad, nor is it great. We tried the NY cheese, grandma pizza and the spinach ricotta slices because, in addition to pepperoni, that was all they had available for pizza by the slice. For a place that offers pizza by the slice, that's really not a lot of options, considering their menu for full pizzas is very extensive. Overall the pizza was really lacking. Limited fresh ingredients and almost no flavor. Not a lot of grease, though. For it being called NY pizza, it didn't have that satisfying chewy texture that I remember. Got the 8 piece chicken wings as well, and the chicken meat was really dry. Service was slow. This place gets a lot of food delivery orders so it can be a bit of a wait if there's a lot of orders that came before yours. The only great thing was that a small Mango Cart on tap was $3, which is really unheard of for beer. read more

Ordered a large sausage pizza for $26.50. The crust was a little thick for New York pizza, but the house made pizza sauce was very good. Street metered parking only. read more

Brooklyn Square - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Got their vodka round pie and it was huge and so tasty!! They had accidentally gotten our order wrong so we ended up with half of an eggplant parm pizza as well which i surprisingly liked even though i don't care for eggplant. Would def check out if you're in Pasadena! read more

Brooklyn Square -- A Deep Disappointment Masquerading as New York Pizza Rating: (1/5) Brooklyn Square markets itself with the confidence of a New York-style pizza institution, but my visit revealed a product and experience that fell dramatically short of that promise. Between the lackluster execution and a serious food safety issue, this was one of the most disappointing pizza outings I've had in recent memory. Ambiance - 2/5 The atmosphere was busy and energetic, which initially suggested popularity and strong demand. However, beyond the crowd, there was little about the space that evoked the charm or authenticity of a true New York pizzeria. It felt more commercial than crafted. Authenticity - 1/5 Let's address the core claim: this is not New York-style pizza. The crust lacked the structural integrity and chew you'd expect from a proper slice. It didn't fold correctly, didn't carry that thin-yet-resilient texture, and lacked the subtle char and balance that define authentic NY pizza. It was just simply a very thin pizza. I've had more convincing renditions from major chains. The name sets expectations the kitchen simply does not meet. Flavor - 1/5 Even setting authenticity aside, the pizza itself was unremarkable. The sauce and cheese failed to create any memorable depth of flavor. But what truly ended the experience was biting into a large piece of plastic embedded in the pizza. I physically had to spit it out mid-chew. This is not just a minor flaw -- it's a serious quality control failure. Food safety is non-negotiable. Service - 2/5 The restaurant was busy, which may explain some operational strain, but that cannot excuse foreign objects in food. Regardless of rush volume, quality control should never slip to this degree. Cost - 2/5 Given the quality and the safety lapse, the price point feels unjustified. A high rating and branding can only carry a restaurant so far -- execution must follow. Final Thoughts Brooklyn Square may have built a strong reputation, but based on this visit, it feels overrated and poorly managed. Authenticity was absent, quality was inconsistent, and food safety was compromised. I sincerely hope management takes this seriously -- because no diner should have to worry about biting into plastic while eating a slice of pizza. read more

See all

I was looking for a good Italian sub and came across this place on IG. I ordered the Italian Bada Bing, some fried Ravioli, and a slice of spicy pepperoni pizza. The stand out here was the pizza. It was well balanced, had a crisp crust, and pepperoni were bomb. The ravioli were ok. And that sandwich wasn't great. I think the main issue with the sandwich was the cheese. I love cheese, but in this case it overpowered the sandwich. Every bite all you can taste is the cheese, and it made the sandwich not that enjoyable. I'll definitely come back and try some more pizza, and possibly a different sandwich. This place is in Old Town Pasadena, so you know parking is going to be a headache. read more

See all

I was in the mood for some pizza but didn't need a whole pizza because I was by myself. Luckily they sell by the slice and I picked out the square cut Spicy Sausage and it cost around 6 bucks. The dough is perfectly crispy crunchy and that Spicy was hot and it burned my mouth. It was delicious and I was able to watch the Rams vs Falcons football game on the big television. read more

Brooklyn Square - Spicy sausage DEC2025 - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

I don't know what they do differently from their pies, but their slices are excellent here. Sometimes the pies come out a little extra doughy, but these slices are the essence of what an east coast slice is. Crispy and thinner undercarriage, no flop, entire slice holds its integrity--all 3 for a little under $16. Honestly, for prices these days, that ain't too bad in my opinion. Service was impeccably fast, per usual, and the options are always great to choose from. Highly recommend if you're in the area and are looking for a quality NY style pizza. read more

Brooklyn Square - The Italian Bada Bing Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

See all

Brooklyn Square is extremely close to the Schoolhouse Parking Garage which has a very low parking fee ($1-3). The sandwiches were enormous! I was very hungry after walking around the Pasadena Chalk Festival and half a sandwich and a bag of chips was more than enough. I took the rest to go! This is a counter service restaurant. Staff are a little blunt, but were helpful, which was all I needed. The restroom is on the left side of the registers, it's a little hard to see. read more

Brooklyn Square - The Reuben Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

See all

This is more of a 3.5 and I may upgrade it after visiting in person, as I've only gotten delivery. I'm from the northeast and have tasted a lot of NYC pizza, and theirs is pretty good! I like their unique combinations like the honey deniro. However, I would actually recommend their sandwiches over the pizza. They have some really tasty combinations and you can also make your own. They are PACKED with fillings so they're a good value for the money, which is rare nowadays! I especially like their honey mustard on anything. Usually they last for two meals for me, especially with some chips. read more

Brooklyn Square is a downtown Pasadena gem- it's a reliable go-to for oversized New York-style slices and hefty square pizzas. While it might not reinvent the wheel, it executes the classics with impressive consistency. And a cheaper alternative to Prince St. Pizza! The value-to-quality ratio is the real winner if you want high-quality. They have regular slices of pizza as well if you don't want anything hefty, and best of all nothing tasted greasy. I do wish they gave a bit more pepperoni toppings, but otherwise solid spot! read more

This is a regular place we get takeout from. I've tried their regular cheese pizza, but the one we always go back to is The Honey Deniro. The slices are huge, as you can see from my photo which is half a slice. The pizza is a little thicker, but the flavors are something special. I always get extra honey, it just pairs so well with the sauce and cheese. The people who work here are fantastic too. They know our order and how we like it (extra honey) without us having to ask. We have only gotten takeout, but they do have some tables if you want to dine in. We probably order this pizza more than any other because it's always perfect and there are always leftovers. read more

See all

Saw that there was a new pizza spot open, so I popped in for a try! It did not disappoint; the service was friendly, the pizzas tasty, and the food was reheated fast. read more

Brooklyn Square - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

Brooklyn Square has fulfilled all my wildest pizza and sandwich dreams. We ordered a slice of the Honey Deniro and the Mr. Chipotle Chicken sandwich. I'm a huge advocate for ricotta on pizza, and Brooklyn Square delivered. The true star was our sandwich though. Lemme tell ya... the combination of chipotle chicken with honey mustard, crunchy vegetables, pickles and avocado on squaw bread no less?!? Absolute heaven. One of the best sandwiches I've ever had in my life. Service was friendly and quick. They brought our order out to our table. There are big TVs that were showing different football games on each of them. So yes, a well-known competing square pizza place is just a few blocks away, but please do yourself a favor and try Brooklyn Square! read more

Brooklyn Square - Mr. Chipotle Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

See all

Hello I ordered delivery DoorDash for Brooklyn square ordered the honey dinero with chicken. I have mixed emotions about my pizza because it was soggy. Not good at all. I've had them before so i know they typically have a good crust but this experience was not so great. I tried to fix it by putting in the oven but it wasn't the same. I'm not sure what went wrong if it was delivery or if it was the pizza from the start. My advice to you is go pick up to ensure you receive the freshest experience possible. read more

Brooklyn Square - The Honey Deniro Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pasadena, California

4 states for the food, 5 for the service, and maybe 2 for the limited seating inside. Brooklyn Square offers solid Detroit deep dish with generally interesting flavor combinations. The price per slice is about $6, seems high though slices are big. My favorite was the BBQ Chicken Pizza, robust flavor from both the bbq and ranch sauces, and I personally wanted more chicken and onions. Second favorite was the Pepperoni Honey DeNiro, a nice balance of sweet from honey, salty from pepperoni, creaminess from clumps of ricotta, a nice balance but one that does get slightly messy and sticky. The regular Pepperoni and Spicy Pepperoni are very similar, barely a hint of spice, and they offer jalapeños that can turn the heat up read more

See all

This place is super cute. The buffalo pizza was soooo good the cheese bread was also yummy. Wings needed a little more lemon pepper. The ricotta pepperoni slice was also delicious! Service was helpful and patient. Definitely will be back. read more

See all