Upon our arrival, the host asked if we had a reservation. When we said no, she walked away. It seemed to be an issue that we didn't have a reservation even though we were able to be accommodated right away. The quietness of the patio on a Friday evening was striking . No ambiance, no background music even though it was the perfect evening to be outside. It was so quiet that it was a bit awkward being the tables so close. It felt like we were all whispering. Our server handed us the menus and told us what the specials of the day were. The 1 star is for the great service given by her. It's a bit excessive when patrons are warned beforehand of NO changes to the menu. The creativity of the chef seemed more important than the desire of the customer. My husband ordered the hamburger and it had no flavor and the fries no seasoning. It looked like something they didn't put effort in making either. He also said that the iced tea that was cloudy. I ordered from the specials of the day: the duck ramen and, even though it looked great and smelled great, it didn't have a lot of flavor. We were shocked to find the price by the time the check came. Beware of the prices of the daily specials. They are not in the printed menu and prices and not indicated on the Facebook page either. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - No prices listed for special on the menu or online - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

Unique place. Farm to table. The pear salad was delicious. My husbands fried chicken sandwich was great. The server was not the best. He seemed like he would have rather been anywhere else. Didn't check in with us once. At the end asked if we wanted dessert. Ambience was good. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Went for my brothers 40th birthday party. Nice size table near the back. Smaller restaurant farm to table women owned. Can sit by kitchen to watch them work if that's your thing. We had several shared apps notable the watermelon pickle bacon , the onion tarte the best. Pizza - lost boys everyone wanted to try, oh and squash blossoms, a fun one . Delightful, snappy , colorful, tasty. No substitutions on food would be challenging if you have strict dietary restrictions. Service was excellent. I will go back and get pictures next time read more

Incredible food and wonderful staff!! We enjoyed the Spanish garlic butter shrimp, Cinnamon poached pear salad, pork belly entree special and the strawberry Neapolitan for dessert - everything was excellent. We will definitely be back! read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Cinnamon poached pear salad and pork belly special - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

I came here for my 90th birthday and here I am back for my 91st. The food is terrific, I love that everything comes from WI. The staff is first rate. They are so friendly. Thank you for making my birthday dinners memorable. I hope to be back for 92! read more

This farm to table restaurant surprised us in a good way. We tried a sampling of their apps and loved them all. The kitchen is open so you can see them making the food. This is a must try, we will be back! read more

See all

Don't be misled by the name of this place (it's not a cop bar) or the location nestled between factory/ industrial buildings in Germantown. It's worth the trip to try the terrifically prepared farm to table food. Food is fresh, well prepared and all around yummy. Service is attentive. Completely worth the trip to check this gem out. read more

Great food. It would be better if they had a simple beer like a PBR to wash down the delicious food. Their current beers are too fancy and compete with the food. read more

This restaurant has the BEST food in the Milwaukee and surrounding area!!! You can taste the difference in every dish. Fresh wholesome and worth every penny. You will be definitely be surprised at the flavors.. Make your reservations TODAY!!!! read more

We are BLOWN AWAY by the amazing farm-to-table dining experience we just enjoyed at Precinct! We sat in a cozy booth overlooking the kitchen and shared the rib eye and the beer-battered whitefish -- both were sheer perfection. Amanda "Phoebe" and Talia (first day on the job -- she killed it!) took exceptional care of us and Chef Jodi, Angie, Lucas and Chris all came to our table to say hello. So on top of the mouthwatering dishes we felt like royalty. Well done, Precinct. You are a stand-out restaurant for both your amazing food and top-class service. We will be back and next time we're bringing our friends! read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Mouthwatering ribeye steak - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

Pros: ~ Unique & flavorful menu. ~ Great conscientiousness regarding GF & Celiacs! ~ Woman owned business ... who also chefs!! ~ very nice ambiance. I truly will be back to try bacon wrapped watermelon rinds! I tried the Short Rib Fundido and it was superb. Cons: it is too far from my house to visit frequently. I was in Germantown for an hour and searched the nearby fare for lunch. Precinct won. read more

See all

Soooo good! The creativity in presentation We went there as a family of 5 , the first time may 10 All the entrees were amazing and beautifully presented The appetizers were fantastic, I shared (reluctantly) my crab cakes They were tender and not full of "filler" like many One of the I've had besides in New Orleans The creme brûlée was THE best I've ever had The depth of flavor after a spoonful remained No complaints here...impressed with everything And I'm picky picky Our server, Amanda, was friendly and attentive and answered our questions, and made suggestions We definitely will be back read more

See all

This is one of our favorite places to go when we visit Milwaukee. Their bacon wrapped watermelon rinds are out of this world. Yep, you read that right! We haven't had anything on the menu that we didn't thoroughly enjoy. The space is laid back, eclectic and comfortable. But don't let that fool you - the food is elevated and fantastic. read more

We went for lunch, but the menu was actually their all day menu. They are farm to table and the menu changes often depending upon availability anyway. I had crabcakes. This was probably a mistake because I don't know if there are any winter crab farms in Wisconsin... I cannot diss the flavor. However, I couldn't really eat them with a fork. There was nothing cakey about them. It was more like a crab puddle. OK. The staff was wonderful and so was the dessert. So... They are pricey, but close to my house. Maybe I'll take a trip back in the summer. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Crab Cakes - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

I loved this spot in the middle of Germantown! We had a group of 6 and we had no issues finding a table on a Saturday night which was great. Every person at our table loved the food and our waitress was so nice. Our favorite items were the feta and potstickers appetizers and the fish special. read more

My husband is skeptical of farm to table restaurants but after he took one bite of his steak he said 'this should be on Beat Bobby Flay'. Our food was beautifully plated, tender and delicious. Our server was very knowledgeable of the nightly feature and menu. The best part was the reaction to us showing our thanks for an amazing meal with a 'kitchen round'. Check out their website for details on the kitchen round! read more

See all

Wow! Absolutely unbelievably great taste and display of food dishes! It's a Friday during lent, but don't worry this joint comes in top of the line with their fish fry! Not your normal fish fry because you ain't getting chips or French fries, but you're getting this incredible slaw with fried carrots on top of a beer battered white fish. I cannot express how delicious and yummy this dish is. Just look at the picture!!! Oh yeah btw we got the best fried green tomatoes I've ever had, hands down and some killa desserts! The desserts were a vanilla bean cheese cake and fruity pebble cheesecake. Hot damn! This place was sooo good we can't wait to go back and bring our friends and family each time. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Beer Battered White Fish - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

First time here tonight but it definitely will not be my last. Service was amazing first and foremost. Two old fashions were spot on. Bring on the food! Started out with homemade lemon mascarpone gnocchi with prosciutto. OMG! This alone would have been good enough as the entree. But then we split their farmhouse bread loaf special. I think this should just be a staple that comes when you sit down. I got one of the specials. Blackened mahi mahi with toasted coconut rice. It was ridiculous. My wife got Thai basil garlic shrimp with black rice. She didn't like it but I did. Overall, the entire menu sounded amazing and I can't wait to go back. read more

See all

We stopped at Precinct after seeing the great ratings. Our bartender/server greeted us when we walked in and took care of us the whole time. The food and atmosphere are top notch. Stop in and say 'hi' to Courtney. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Yummy food! I had two appetizers and I dream of all the others that are on the menu. I tried the onion tart which is basically a tortilla layered with flavor and cooked until crispy. I also had the lemon gnocchi and was pleasantly surprised on how much I liked it and kept oohing and aahing with each bite. I cannot wait to try their other options and go down the list of offerings. read more

I'm definitely not one for casting stones but a BIG FAIL for one of the very few establishments left in town. We like trying new things we have not had before and my wife and I decided to try the daily specials, Halibut and Ramen with Duck. I had questions about the Ramen Special. I asked specifics to which the server answered, so I thought I'd give it a try based on her recommendation. One bite and I knew, holy cow, super spicy. My wife who likes spicy food had a bite and said oh yeah, this is way spicy. When the server approached us, she said," nobody ever told me that it was spicy and nobody's ever mentioned that", she also stated she never had the dish, )but had no hesitation recommending it). So now my said she would eat it and I ate my wife's meal which frankly I had no interest in but did it anyways as there was NO offer from the server. The server made absolutely no attempt to ask whether or not I was satisfied. Rather, she looked at my wife and said if you need a glass of milk I'd be happy to get a glass of milk if it's too spicy. Needless to say we both went to this restaurant and ordered food and neither of us ate what we originally ordered. Almost $80 later, nothing but here's the check. I wanted nothing more than to praise the restaurant but how can I when this happened? I'm bummed to have written this.... Very disappointed read more

I swear I reviewed this place after we ate there last month but I guess not; so I'm going off memory...came here for lunch. we had some kind of fried elote balls or something as appetizer which were amazing, I remember those! I had the chicken and waffle sandwich as well which was also an experience I won't forget; I think my wife had a sandwich of some kind (sorry don't remember) and it was just ok. Tried the carrot cake which I heard was fantastic, but wasn't the style we typically like; was good but carrot cakes can be made so many ways, we like others better...service was great but music was annoyingly loud for for a lunchtime meal. I definitely want to come back for the burger...by far the best restaurant in Germantown however and it's not even close! read more

The food was OK, I would call this place alternative dining. The staff were very nice and respectful. The food was just unlike anything we've ever eaten. I also think the food portions are a little slim for the price. Overall, it was a nice establishment, but we just weren't prepared for what it served. Another positive thing is the kitchen is wide open so you get to watch the food being made. read more

This is really a 4.5 for me - I'd never heard of Precinct until it was suggested by some friends for dinner. The restaurant is a little tucked away but worth seeking out, even if you have to drive from the city. The space is interesting - there's a cool graffiti mural, a huge open kitchen (with a counter so you can watch the action) and a nice patio for warmer times. It's a big open space so it will be loud during busy times and I'd love to see them take the lighting in the dining area down a notch or two. It's really bright in there and that can feel a little sterile/cold which this place definitely isn't! Anyway - the food!! We started with bacon wrapped pickled watermelon rind which I had never heard of - wow!! Get these! They're sweet and savory - kind of like a bacon wrapped apple pie. So good! The menu is really creative in terms of offerings and preparations and the prices are very reasonable. I had a cumin pork loin with black beans and sweet potatoes - well cooked, well spiced and very delicious. If you go on Thursday they have a TV dinner special which was pork ramen, chili spiced broccoli, miso deviled eggs, pineapple cake AND a shortie of beer (Rhinelander of course) for $12! That's a great deal and it's very popular and can sell out. Service was fun and friendly and the kitchen is doing a great job cranking out interesting, high quality food. I definitely would come back! read more

First time visiting the Precinct, it was fabulous. Courtney was a great host, Michael the bartender kept the cocktails fresh, we got to sit on the patio on the first night of summer. The chef and owner is an artist, highly recommend this as a Best Of Germantown contender! read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Best steak I had in a long time, will definitely be going back! - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Food was fantastic! Tonight's special steak dinner was incredible. Garlic shrimp was perfectly balanced. Feta app is our favorite. Sit at the kitchen bar, you'll have a great experience. We will be back again and again read more

First time here. Had lunch. The Cheddar Apple salad and the soup of the day, Seafood Chowder. Both were excellent. I can wait to try their dinner entrees. read more

We arrived 10 minutes ahead of our reservation to find a grumpy bartender who seemed irritated by our existence. Once seated, our waiter, Sarah, was courteous and cheerful. Our food was not good. Steak was drenched in SALTY sauce. It was difficult to eat. The Thai curry garlic shrimp lacked flavor-no hint of curry. It was nothing exciting or creative, basically an oily buttery sauce, and I left half of it on my plate. My daughter ordered a salad (fresh veggies and great dressing) with added chicken. The chicken had grizzle and after an unappealing bite she left most of it on her plate. The manager addressed our concerns (claimed there was no way we could have bitten into grizzle?!) with a smile and friendly disposition, but $300 later, we left uninspired and hungry. We'll not be going back. read more

I was back in Wisconsin, and a family gathering was on the itinerary. I suggested the Precinct, rather than going to the chain pizza joints we usually have these reunions. The Precinct no longer served my favorite burger, The Bully, maybe to be politically correct. But what I ate was good. They do burgers well, and the Precinct is a good place to hit up if you're in the Germantown area. read more

I dined here in summer of 2024 and had a great meal; I've also purchased gift cards so friends could come and try the food. I was excited to bring our guests from AZ to this restaurant for a memorable meal. Sadly, what makes it memorable for 3 out of the 4 of us was the awful ribeyes on 8/6. When we ordered the steaks we questioned our waitress as to why she wasn't asking how we wanted them prepared; she responded that they all come medium rare-fine, with us, that's what we would have ordered. They came almost well done. They were tough and hard to chew. When she came to check on us I told her that I was not looking to be comped not did I want them to make another one but I told her to take a look at these steaks (with no red in sight) and to please let the chef know that there was no way these were even close to being medium rare. She returned with the craziest explanation I have ever heard. She said that the cook said "all steaks come to the table medium rare-BUT that because we had been eating ours (more like, trying to eat them) for over 15 minutes that now they were overdone!!! Are you kidding me? She was young and I am sure just parroting whatever the kitchen told her to say. No manager ever approached the table; no cook cared enough to come and look at their so called medium rare steaks. It was embarrassing and kind of infuriating considering the prices they charge and the ambiance they claim to have. We will never go back. Two other quick mentions: we ordered the excellent feta/hot honey appetizer-delicious-BUT we still had over half left and all our bread was gone. We asked for a 2nd loaf and were told that they "don't do that". What?! I looked at her incredulously and asked "should we just eat the rest with a spoon?" She went back and checked and then relented that "ok, we will do it, but just this time". She never mentioned that we would be charged for it. Yet $8 for a loaf of bread showed up on the bill. Lastly, as much as I wanted to come home that night and blast this place for lack of customer service and terrible steaks; I instead emailed the restaurant on their website.. Explained our experience-shared that their customer service is subpar suggested maybe they had a bad batch of ribeyes and pretty much gave the exact review as above. Then I waited and waited and waited...still NO RESPONSE from owner or anyone. That should be enough to warn you away from spending good money at this establishment. They do not value their customers and they obviously think they were not wrong. read more

Precinct - Tap & Table is definitely our new favorite! We enjoyed the old Café Soeurette in West Bend and were excited to give this a go. So glad we did! Perfect curbside pickup. The crab cakes were truly more crab than cake. The pork sliders and slaw were the perfect size with great flavor and texture. I wondered if Pizza-the-Hutt's smoked Gouda stuffed crust would be the focus of the pie, but it really served as a delicious treat- with that perfect bit of toasted Asiago on top- to finish the flavor-packed slice (before you started another!) The kids loved the sausage pizza. We also had to try the tots- still crunchy after a ride home and balanced well with a little seasonsed salt and the sweet tomato jam. We appreciate being able to truly taste the quality and sense the pride they have in their work, even from a take-out box! Can't wait to try the rest of the menu. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Crab cakes, tots and jam, pork sliders and slaw, Pizza-the-Hutt, and sausage pizza were all excellent! I'd get them all again. - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Date night dinner there last night (Saturday) ... Food was good, signature cocktails were much too sweet, service was terrible. Veggie pudgie pie, pear salad, and whipped feta were great. Bison carpaccio was totally overwhelmed by sundried tomatoes. Other items were good. When we arrived for our reservation, the hostess erased our name from a large, comfortable booth and seated us at a tiny circular 2-top on the side instead. No explanation, but we could clearly see her doing it. Felt very unwelcoming, and after we ordered a selection of small plates the table was very cluttered. After we received our food, the waitress interrupted us three times while I was very visibly eating dinner to ask if we wanted any boxes. Then a fourth time to list the dessert options. Over half the food still on the plates, very visibly still eating, near full cocktail glass. Why are you interrupting us to hustle us out the door? We had a reservation, and there were plenty of (nicer) empty tables around us the whole 90 minutes we were there. The ambiance is hard to figure out - like they were going for eclectic but it ended up disjointed. Urban exposed pipes, graffiti style art, bistro tables with mismatched silver cutlery. Maybe it was an off night, but I'm upset we paid over $100 to be treated as if we weren't welcome. read more

This is currently my favorite restaurant - menu is so unique and everything is delicious. We order the app short rib queso fundito and grilled Cesar salad every visit - really hope they never go off the menu. Tonight we also tried bacon wrapped watermelon rinds - amazing!! So was the balsamic mushroom Swiss burger. We always order way too much food just we can try a little (or lot) of everything. Come here for dinner!! It's so good. Good service and nice bar, too. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Bacon wrapped watermelon rinds - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

UPDATE: WOW! Finally got back here and the food (that BURGER OMG), lobster deviled eggs, BEER (thank you for finally providing great beers in Germantown, Wis.!) , service, music was all TOP NOTCH. Can't wait to point everyone in the Precinct direction when they come to town. It is THAT GOOD. Enjoyed a delicious lunch on Saturday, hats off to the chef and the wonderful service. What a breath of fresh air to have a farm to table restaurant in Germantown - the land of farms! I had the crab cake starter and carrot risotto for lunch paired with an awesome craft beer - it was divine. I wish I would have taken pics of the other food at the table - the puffier pies looked awesome!Treat yourself and get there ASAP - awesome new spot! read more

See all

Always amazing farm to table. Great drinks, friendly service and tasty food. My favorite drink is the Poison Apple. read more

Precinct Tap & Table - Prime Rib Special - American Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Elevated food that includes some great specials. Seating available that face an open kitchen.

It has been a while since I had visited but I can say that the food here is great, local and tasty! In addition, the drinks are great. Most of the menu changes as it is a farm to table style restaurant. What is pretty cool it is locally owned and it is in the old Germantown police station, or the name, Precinct. It is usually fairly busy so I'd suggest reservations during busier times like weekends. Overall, the food is great and so is the service. Take some time from going to the chains and learn to enjoy your food! You will not be disappointed! read more

My second visit here was shortly before Covid hit. First was ok, this was really great. Skipped the pudgie pies this time and instead went for a signature burger and pizza. Both on recommendations from the server, both were excellent. Beer list is big, but a little heavy on sours and fruit leaning flavors... nice choices, but could benefit from some classic porters, stouts, saisons, ales and such. Craft cocktails are interesting and not overly sweet. Wine list is respectable too. Server was really on point too. While allergies keep her from sampling and commenting on every dish on the menu, she was still able to intelligently describe and suggest. One more visit since Covid has calmed a bit was equally great. read more

The food is fine...good. the atmosphere is good. I even appreciate the girl power chef situation. My major gripe is that there are absolutely no substitutions allowed. Like they don't even give you salt and pepper. The chefs feel they made the dish perfect and the customer has no right for any adds or changes to the dish. That seems a bit self absorbed to me... read more

Had a great meal tonight. It was our first visit and they were preparing for a busy night. Service was excellent. Casual, fun atmosphere with upscale menu. Salmon was delicious and my husband was very happy with the fish and chips. Daughter's pudgy pie was something new and different! Stuck around for dessert and I'm glad we did. Can't wait to go back as there is so much more we want to try! It's nice to have a new option with a fresh and unique menu. read more