My boy & I went to dinner with my brother last night and we landed at Potbelly Sandwich Shop ! It can be described as a more local version of subway. I got a roast beef and provolone that was amazing. I'm super upset at the fact that subway got rid of their roast beef. So, I was thrilled they had a roast beef option. Definitely a good sandwich ! Good flavor. Good service. The restaurant had a very rustic feel. I recommend giving it a try ! read more

Potbelly - Roast Beef - Sandwiches Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

Potbelly is a good and quick spot to grab a bite to eat. I went with the CBR wrap on this visit. It never misses and they have a wide variety of different sandwiches and wraps. The service here is pretty good not anything crazy but hits all the marks. Its location is perfect as it is right on kirkwood right outside of the sample gates. This place also has amazing shakes that never miss. read more

Potbelly - Chicken bacon ranch wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

We ordered online and when we arrived, our leader smelled marijuana in the restaurant as she entered. We ordered 5 sandwiches for our group and 1 was supposed to be Italian and it had barbecue and pickles on it. The other sandwich was left off the order. We only got 2 of 3 bags of chips we paid for. They had no sweet tea. We did not have time to go back because we had an event we had to go to so some of the kids did not get their food nor drink. This was Sat night around 7pm. Very disappointed read more

I go here regularly and they're very consistent. Great staff, good food, good rewards program and discounts (also free food fairly regularly), and the store is also very consistent. It has the traditional antique vibes to a Potbelly's with some random new item you'll notice up above that you've never seen before. All around a solid place to grab a quick, cheap lunch. read more

I have been to this Potbelly over 20 times and received amazing service every time. They are always extremely accurate and as quick as they can be (it gets busy on BOGO days!). Today, when placing a mobile order, I ordered the wrong sandwiches on accident, which was completely my fault. Potbelly still offered to remake the sandwiches for me! Shout out to Logan and Ray for taking the time to help me out even with a long line. I sincerely appreciate it so much and love Potbelly's so so much. These are easily my favorite sandwiches on Kirkwood. read more

This was a delicious late evening meal option which did not disappoint. Tasty soups, delicious sandwich (so many options!) and good value, good service despite dining 30 mins before closing and with cleaning and restocking in process... the place was super organized and the two female "bosses" clearly had things under control! read more

The restaurant was amazing and the decoration and atmosphere of the restaurant was just the type of place I like to go on my lunch break. The staff have always been super nice and friendly when im there, always putting in aome nice conversations. The food itself also always hits the spot for what im feeling whether its just soup for the day or salad or sandwhichs like they are known for. Ive never had an issue with this restaurant or the staff and its always clean. read more

My eye catches Jimmy johns easier because it's on the corner and has a more colorful logo, but if you walk a few steps further you can find a pot bellies that is hiding in plain sight. I've been to both multiple times each, but if you got the time to take the few extra steps it's worth it. You go from a good sandwich to a great one.and the ambiance is a little less hectic. read more

The food is very fresh and delicious. We recommend everyone to participate in the experience

Just like any Potbelly - nice staff, tasty sandwiches, and quick service! I came in on a particularly hot day and still loved a warm sandwich with some chips. read more

Don't order delivery from Potbelly - the driver will leave your order on the sidewalk, treat you like garbage, and hang up on you. They use a third party service (Door Dash) and they do not care if you get your food. This is the first time our office ordered from Potbelly - we were looking for more restaurants that deliver downtown since we are in such a busy office and don't have time to go out for lunch. Very unlikely we will order from Potbelly again. The website doesn't work for online orders, you have to go through the app. The chicken pot pie soup was quite good so I added a star, otherwise this would have been a one star review. I ordered a veggie melt as part of the soup and sandwich combo - it was the most pathetic sandwich I've ever seen. I took a photo to show my husband how ridiculous it was. I'm including it here. Our office continues to search for a quality restaurant that delivers, but Potbelly isn't on the list. read more

Potbelly - Pathetic Veggie Melt - Sandwiches Near Me - Bloomington, Indiana

The chicken salad sandwich was terrible, it was flavorless. The description says it comes with cheese but then when you order they try to charge .65 for cheese. I gave 2 stars because the cookie was delicious. read more

This review is not of the local Bloomington, IN shop--they are great and the food is always good. This is a review of the Potbelly corporate office. I ordered a $50 e gift card on April 20, 2023 that was never delivered to the recipient. I've reached out countless times to Potbelly corporate asking them to fix it, with absolutely no response. I've submitted the contact form on their website 3 times, sent 3 emails to their social media team, sent messages via Facebook, Instagram and Twitter...nothing. They charged me $50, but never delivered the e gift card to the email of the recipient that I requested it be sent to. Terrible customer service, Potbelly corporate. read more

I ordered delivery on the app and it took a little while so I called to ask and the staff handled it so well! They were kind enough to comp my food even though I said it wasn't necessary. Wish I remembered the girls name I spoke to on the phone. Customer service on point read more

I ordered (for carry out) the half and half meal with the pizza sandwich and the chicken pot pie soup. My husband got the "wreck" sandwich meal. My husband liked his food. I will say my soup was good. But my sandwich was pathetic. The bread looked like it had been stepped on and the end of the bun was stale and hard like a crouton. There was barely anything on my sandwich. It was supposed to have meatballs among other things- I opened up the sandwich and there was one flattened meatball. Also they gave me the wrong chips. I personally will not order here again. read more

pretty good, kinda reminds me of quiznos content with the amount of avocado signs around the store, really want to steal that dope usa flag but i will refrain, the ppl here are nice cool chip brand, haven't seen them since i was in new orleans, would not expect this place to give me nostalgia read more

I was always a fan of Potbelly--cheap, quick, and a lot of variety. read more

See all

Tried this place for the first time today. You can download their app which allows you to order and pay ahead of time. You can choose pickup or delivery. I chose delivery. My food came early. The Mac and cheese is delicious and the Mini Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies are to die for. I also got the coleslaw, macaroni salad and potato salad. All yummy. I'll be back! read more

Ok. I loved potbelly when I was in DC. dont think anything changed, but I'm just not as much into it. When I go to this one, it feels more corporate. Food is just as good. I kind of forget its there. I lo e it for catering. Great options, cheap, and something for everyone. It's rare that I find something that pleases everyone in my office. Roughly $8 per person. I get salads for celiacs and it goes over well. Always on time. read more

Being new to Bloomington, I'm trying to find new restaurants to have for lunch. This was not a success. I ordered turkey club. Bacon burnt. Pickle was so old it looked pathetic. The turkey I'm not sure it was turkey. Tasted like canned chicken. Potato soup was potato soup. I won't be trying again. read more

This used to be my favorite go to spot to grab a salad for lunch when I didn't have time to make my own. However, today the person working the counter assisted the person behind me and then the person behind them while I patiently waited in line for my salad order to be taken. I can't say that I will be going back and while losing my business won't ultimately change how well this location does, its extremely disappointing to receive terrible customer service as someone who prides on giving great customer service myself. read more

Dependable and decent. Food: You know exactly what you're getting every time. I like the mini chocolate chip oatmeal cookies and the chocolate brownie cookie - yum! I also like the efficiency of eating here. I always get my food relatively quickly. Service: Everyone that works there is always nice. I only experienced one aberration where one of the employees was having a weird power trip. read more

I didn't expect to write a review of Potbelly's, but the servers were so friendly and above-and-beyond helpful! (Also, I feel terrible for not finding the tip jar for our carry-out order! ) There were hot Clubby samples ready for us, a super sandwich maker who recommended all kinds of delicious combos and add-ons, and a kind cashier. Awesome sandwiches, too: a Clubby, the Dirty Roscoe (this might not be the right name-- buffalo chicken with BBQ sauce, etc.), and a Chicken Salad. The excitement about good sandwiches was contagious, and totally substantiated. Great lunch! read more

THIS REVIEW PERTAINS TO POTBELLY'S DELIVERY SERVICE: The sandwiches at Potbelly are satisfactory. However, I would not recommend delivery from this restaurant. They are not forthright over the phone about their delivery fee ($3.50) which ended up being an additional 75% fee on my $4.70 sandwich. I was only made aware of this exorbitant fee when the delivery person arrived and handed me my bill. As it was clearly not her fault for this failure of communication (or possibly an intentional deception) I reluctantly but politely paid her almost twice the amount of money I expected to have to pay for an average and cold (it was meant to be hot) sandwich for which I had waited around 45 minutes to receive from order to delivery. My advice is to just order Jimmy John's if you're interested in having a sandwich delivered. read more

Absolutely delicious for a decent price. Employees are always nice and great at striking up convos! Always enjoy a nice visit to potbelly

Smiling and welcoming. Easygoing and down-to-earth. Musicians who play as visitors at this location fit these descriptions as well.

The food is great but affordable, which is important for broke college students like me. But even better, the service is amazing! The staff is all smiles and they're so kind to their customers (but genuinely so, they don't try to hard or fake it like some other people do). It makes for a welcoming atmosphere. I absolutely love this shop and would recommend it to anyone looking for a quick bite to eat. read more

I have eaten here and can, in fact, confirm that this is a Pot Belly. Same menu as the others. Also found out that I still enjoy "The Wreck" with everything on it. Also I still tend to titter gleefully at the teensy little cookies they put on the straw of the shakes. read more

5 stars for the food if ordered dine in and 1 star for delivery, so I'll give them the average of 3. Love their food and we used to order delivery at least once a week, but it always ends up being more hassle than it is worth. Half the time the delivery isn't available online because their drivers come and go and they forget to update the website. One time we faxed in the order and after almost two hours with no food we called. Turns out we didn't specify a time on the delivery form so instead of assuming it was for now or calling to clarify they did nothing and the manager was very rude about the whole situation. It's always a ridiculously long wait (1+ hours) for delivery. read more

I have no idea why the rating is so low, and I'm picky about where I eat. Great for what it is. Tops jimmy johns AND which wich, in my opinion. Toasty bread and lots of options. My all time favorite is the meatball sub. SO good. Seriously, try it. read more

Another chain on Kirkwood with nothing special to offer. Meat quality is better than most chains, but the sandwich is ruined by their tasteless bread. Not a fan of walking through skateboarders or panhandlers on that side of the street to get there either. read more