I just can't get enough.
The minute Posto opened, it became my favorite restaurant in Davis Square. This is one of those places that adds up to more than the sum of its parts. I could describe menu items in detail (and actually, I will), but this is one of those restaurants that has a certain something that pulls it all together and makes eating there fun for the stomach AND the soul.
So, when you go to Posto you basically have two choices: pasta or pizza. They do actually have some full plated entrees (salmon, steak, etc.) that I have heard are good. I haven't tried them myself, because I never get past the pasta and the pizza.
Pizza is Posto's trademark, and the pizza here is the best you'll find (as long as you like thin crust). The crust is flavorful, and the perfect combo of crispy and chewy. Posto makes its own mozzarella in house and features imaginative ingredient combos. For example, honeycrisp apple, gorgonzola, bacon, caramelized onions and arugula. Or egg, caramelized onion, scallion, fontina, and parmesan.
Pro tip: eat the part of the pizza with toppings on it, and then eat the edge/crust as breadsticks, dipped in the chili-infused olive oil you'll find in a bottle on your table!
But what I'm really in love with is the pasta. First of all, everything comes in either a full or a half order--helpful when you're not in the mood to spend $20 on an entree you won't be able to finish anyway. Not sure if the pasta is made in house, but it is definitely fresh, not dried. Always super fresh and al dente. Pasta that has a flavor of its own and stands up to the sauce.
Looking through the less positive reviews, one theme seems to be that things are salty here. I agree they can be a bit on the salty side but it doesn't seem like anything over the top to me. I do notice that some dishes are on the fatty side. For instance, the short rib gnocchi they had last winter... Eating it, I felt like I was storing calories for hibernation. It seems like sometimes, the folks at Posto are going for rich and sumptuous but instead you just end up with your pasta swimming in oil. The first bite was heavenly, but if they want people to enjoy even their full half portion, they need to lighten it up.
Speaking of the half portions: they actually vary in size. Last time I went, I ordered the agnolotti with spicy goat ragout. I only managed to finish half of my half portion and was concerned that maybe I received a full portion because the server didn't hear me when I ordered (Posto and the Painted Burro have the same ownership, and Posto is almost as loud). But when the check came, I had indeed been billed for only the half portion.
The previous week, I had the seafood tortellini (stuffed with a mixture of crab, lobster, and scallops). When I asked for the half order, the server actually strongly suggested that I get a full order. He said he always recommends this and not a single person has ever not finished the full order. When it came, I'd say there were a total of 8 to 10 tortellini. The sauce is also pretty light for this one--a pea broth with parmesan foam/cream. He was absolutely right--I finished it all, no problem. I'd say the half portion of goat agnolotti was larger than the full portion of seafood tortellini. Whatever, it's fine, just be warned.
After you make the pasta vs. pizza selection and the half vs. full order selection, one more important decision looms: wine or beer? (I hear they also have cocktails, but I'm not the one to ask about this.) They have a smallish but well curated list of draught and bottled beers (maybe 8 of each), a mix of New England and Belgium (and of course, Peroni always on tap).
But the wine...oh, the wine. They have about a dozen each red and white on the regular list, and they offer everything by the glass. There is also the "Enzo" list: rare bottles that they offer by the glass with a special imported Italian wine preservation system. However, lately some of the prices on the Enzo list are actually lower than some of the prices on the regular list. Another little oddity that I'm willing to overlook.
The list is heavy on little-known Italian grapes. If I can give you one piece of advice, it is to try the Terre Primitivo, an Italian red with low acidity--it is like drinking velvet.
One small decor note: the restaurant's windows face southwest and there isn't a tall building across the street, so if you are there when the sun is setting you will be subjected to a blinding glare. Posto, if you are reading this, could you invest in some shades?
If it seems like this review is dragging on, it's because I don't want to go. I don't want to end my love letter to Posto, and I don't want to face the fact that once I live in Wisconsin, my visits to Posto will probably become less frequent. I'm hanging on the phone... No, Posto, I don't want to say goodbye. YOU say goodbye. (No, YOU say goodbye.) No, YOU say goodbye! read more