As I write this, Posto has been open less than one week and already the over-the-top haters are coming out to play.
In the manner of a review vigilante, I will over-the-top rate Posto four stars. In a better world where people actually focused on, say, an entire menu, staff, and experience after the restaurant had a chance to work out the kinks, I'd give the restaurant four stars, which is more appriopriate for a casual restaurant making excellent family-friendly fare in a restaurant with televisions over the bar.
With that out of the way, there's something really, really, really important you need to know about Posto. IT JUST OPENED.
That's right. It opened last Thursday. I ate there on a Monday night. Only its fifth service ever.
You get it? They just opened. Posto isn't a smooth-running machine yet, there's a staff very recently thrown together, some just starting work the night you meet them (as in the case of my super-friendly and personable bartender, Jeremy, who still wasn't familiar with the menu on his first night ever at Posto, but went out of his way to get answers, chat with the diners at the bar, and make everyone feel welcome).
So now that we have that established, let's talk about what Posto is about.
Posto is about great regional food, well-prepared, using fresh, local ingredients in season. They don't scream about it on the menu (there's little-to-no namechecking here), but chef Joe Cassinelli has made local sourcing - and artisanal products - a priority. And he's got the chops.
While pizza is the focus here (a wood-fired oven imported from Italy bakes a pizza in 1.5 minutes), I think the antipasti are the real stars. There's a huge variety of interesting variety meats - crispy pig ears and tripe served in the style of Rome. On my visit on a monday night, we ate flavorful, slightly spicy with a 'Tuscan Vinaigrette", perfectly crispy calamari. For $11 it was a reasonably large portion and we enjoyed every bite. The soft pillow of fresh burrata ($12), topped with pesto, pine nuts, olive oil and Parmigiano-Reggiano was a hit at our table. We had to fight each other for the last bite. We also shared a fava bean, pea and string bean salad ($12), which was near perfect except for slightly-too-many raw onions thrown into the mix. Even my dining companion, a self-proclaimed raw onion fanatic, didn't finish the onions.
Pizzas range in price from $12 for the Margherita DOC (the signature Neopolitan pizza made with Caputo '00' flour, San Marzano tomatoes, and Fior di latte buffalo mozzarella from Italy) to $18 for more fancy pizzas, including White Anchovy and Prosciutto Cotto. They also have several add-ons - for $3 you can have a soft farm egg cooked on your pizza, some roast pork (hello porchetta!), or white anchovy. For $5 they'll add prosciutto. The pizza is very good - though you can tell that the pizzaolos are still getting to know their oven. Our pizza was cooked just a smidge under perfect, with the crust needing just a few more seconds of browning time before coming out to our table. My neighbor's pizza was more perfectly baked, and I was envious (don't get me wrong, it was still great, I just am a stickler for crust perfection).
If you aren't of the mind to order pizza, they also serve three meaty pastas and have daily specials of traditional red sauce Italian restaurant hits (eg lasagne on monday, cacciatore on tuesday, spaghetti and meatballs on Wednesday, eggplant parmigiana on Thursday, etc.). Its cute and sweet homage to 'traditional' Boston Italian restaurants.
Dessert is, I hope, a work in progress. It is a simple menu, priced at $5 per dessert: there's affogato (espresso and ice cream) served with a biscotti; a duo of ricotta cannoli; and zeppole, a simple Italian 'donut' served with honey. We ordered the cannoli, and they were very competent, full of vanilla flavor, but lacked the excitement of the rest of the menu. I hope with time the chef expands the menu and makes it as showstopping as some of the antipasti and Insalate.
I'm planning to go back later this week to try out more of the menu. I'm hoping that I'm able to get a seat - even on a Monday night, a week into opening, the place was a zoo. There was hardly a seat available at 6:30 pm. So plan to wait. Not really a problem though, as there are delicious craft beers on tap and lovely snacks to nibble on while you wait. read more