Very attentive staff. We started with the Cesar salad (delicious) and clams oregano (a little dry). I had lobster ravioli, which was perfectly cooked, with a yummy cream sauce. Absolutely delicious. The tiramisu dessert was fluffy sweet perfection. I would definitely eat here again. Thank you for a great meal! read more

This is one delightful restaurant in the sea of thousands of restaurants. I met my wife, her boss and some friends here for dinner on the 'almost eve' of her retirement. Since it is close to their business, they are fairly regular customers. Both the ambiance and service here are perfect. It is a comfortable place to sit back, relax and have their wonderful team take care of you. All in all... great Venue. My wife and I tend to share most of the time so we perused the menu and came up with what turned out to be a truly wonderful dinner. For our appitizers: Fried Calamari - Extremely tasty - Crispy on the outside and fresh- tender on the inside Mozzarella Pomodoro Basilico -Fresh mozzarella with tomato, basil and olive oil | With Prosciutto di Parma - All the components were perfect fresh-tasty. Very generous portion. Main Course: A very large piece of Chicken Parmigiana that my wife and I comfortably shared. Thin chicken, tasty cheese and sause. Perfect. Great meal and time with friends here. KUDOs to the team at Pomodoro Rosso. read more

See all

I came here with a few friends for dinner on a Monday night. I had the gnocchi with pesto and chicken. It tasted fine, but for $33, I was underwhelmed. Nearly all the entrees were $30 or more (as of Oct '25). All of the waiters were friendly and our food was good, but I likely wouldn't return. read more

Pomodoro Rosso - Gnocchi al Pollo e Pesto - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We stopped in last night for a quick bite,one of my son in-law favorite ,he brings everyone there,It did not disappoint.The ambiance was excellent,very cute place ,my son in-law had the stuff soft shell crab ,my wife had the chicken special,I had the pasta with baby lobster tails and shrimp ,my daughter had good old chicken parmigiana,needless to say there were doggies bags ,everyone plate was clean,the staff was amazing,friendly,professional,on top of everything.it just goes to show you you can have a excellent meal with great service at a reasonable price,They have a very good wine list.We all had a different glass of wine from italy .sorry no pictures this time read more

Wonderful!! Great food prepared beautifully. Service was on the mark perfect, Place is so pretty and even though was very busy, was quiet enough to hear eachother. Was a pleasure to just dine in the environment. read more

If I could leave no stars I would. The food was disgusting, highly recommend you stay away. 238$ for 4 people with only one starter 2 mains and 2 pizza and 3 drinks Is outrages Food was disgusting read more

Came here on a Sunday for lunch with a big group. Our group ordered a variety of items like the burger, omelet, chicken parm, calamari, and the lunch special. My husband and I specifically ordered their lunch special which is $26 for an appetizer, entree, and dessert. This deal is only from 12-3. There are only 4 pastas you can choose from if you order this deal, a choice of Caesar or house salad, and tiramisu or a cannoli. I got the angel hair pesto which was pretty good but definitely oily. My husband got the fettuccine which he said was fine. The only caveat for this "lunch special" is just be aware the portion size for the entree is significantly smaller than if you were to order a normal entree. We also got the tiramisu which was super whatever and the salad which was fine. Overall, the deal is not worth it and I would recommend getting a real entree if you came here. The food overall also was pretty average and nothing stood out so I also wouldn't recommend coming here for the food either. The service was also pretty slow even tho the restaurant was not filled either. Overall, the food and service wasn't great and you can easily find better Italian restaurants in the city for the same price range too. read more

See all

Food: We were a group of 10 and dined here on a Sunday afternoon. The restaurant wasn't full but there were some customers. The food here was good but not one of the best Italian restaurants. Some of us ordered the lunch special for $26 which includes a choice of Caesar or house salad, entree (choices were rigatoni vodka, shrimp parmesan, angel hair pesto, and primavera fettuccine), and choice of a dessert (cannoli or tiramisu). The salad was tasty. Entrees were also very good, but portions are small. I would recommend the angel hair pesto! The tiramisu also was nothing special. The chicken parmesan comes with a piece of chicken and spaghetti. The portion of spaghetti was not big and also had too much sauce. Overall, the food wasn't bad but again, not the best. Service: Service was average. Ambiance: The place was able to accommodate our large party of ten but space was tight, and they put a bunch of small tables together. I would say it's a place for smaller groups. Overall, I wouldn't particularly recommend this restaurant. There are better Italian places around. read more

See all

This place has amazing service and great food. I came here for a good steak and a glass of red wine after work. The steak was delicious with the fries. I enjoyed a glass of Merlot as I spoke with the staff and the owner of about my experience. Of course, this place has good foot traffic on a Saturday early evening for the dinner hour. read more

Pomodoro Rosso - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Came here for a dinner date with a friend of mine. We were seated outside by the sidewalk which is either lovely if you love people watching or distracting if you like a little more reserved space. The food was pretty good, the eggplant special was probably my favorite. Service was solid and the owner was very kind. Overall a good option for an average Italian dinner restaurant. read more

See all

Had high expectation for this place but was disappointed. Despite restaurant half full, service was not attentive with server forgetting request or walking away as soon as they ask what we wanted to order. Food was just ok and not justify especially when you look at the price. Ambiance was ok and the restaurant is a mix of locals and tourists. Would not come back again - lots of better other option nearby. read more

See all

Tried it again and was much better. Frutti De Mare is excellent. Restaurant was super busy. Service was good.

Things got off on to a great start at Pomodoro Rosso, as I was greeted by one of the nicest New Yorkers I had ever encountered. The wait staff was also excellent, which leads me to believe that the restaurant has a good heart and culture. A lovely ambiance with both indoor and outdoor seating added to the enjoyment. Where things go is with the food. Good, not great. I can't judge based on my appetizer, as it was the first time I had ever had that particular type of artichoke. However, the homemade pasta with meat sauce was very bland and overcooked. The ciabatta, however: excellent. read more

See all

Eating outside as if I were in Italy, I had a wonderful pasta dish tonight served by an attentive staff. When I inadvertently spilled my red wine, the kind manager and staff tried to put me at ease, almost making it seem as they were thankful for the red blotch on their white tablecloth. The whole experience: delicious food in a warm setting. Barbara G. read more

Came here a few times prior over the past few years., My brother was visiting with his wife who now live in Arizona and we wanted to get together at a convenient spot. I gave them 4 stars for food and service. The restaurant has been here a long time and I would give them 2 stars for decor and ambience. The best word to describe the decor is "tired". There are a lot of new food and retail locations popping up and it's important to make investments back into the business for sustainability. With that being said the entire staff worked well as a team, were very friendly, did not rush us, no time limits and the food was good. They have an extensive menu, full bar, indoor and outdoor seating which the outdoor seating is pet friendly. We started with some Chianti wine and a few appetizers which were the Melanzane which was eggplant with tomato sauce and Fontana cheese. We also shared the Gamberone which is grilled shrimp sautéed in olive oil and garlic. For entrees we shared the spaghetti squash with grilled chicken and shrimp, the salmon and the Pappardelle with 6 oz. lobster tail, shrimp, spinach and shitake mushrooms in a garlic light tomato sauce. Everything was tasty and a good size portion. For desert we shared the profiteroles which are Chocolate covered cream puffs with chantilly cream. I would recommend them as long as you can look past the slightly tired look. Service and food was good. read more

See all

Walked by here on a beautiful Sunday afternoon, they have nice outdoor seating, so we decided to stop. On Columbus between 70 & 71st, perfect location to stop by after a nice walk in the park. Staff is very friendly and the food is good. Weekends have brunch, but traditional Italian is excellent. BTW... if the inside looks familiar, it was featured on Seinfeld It was the popular breakup spot, but this neighborhood trattoria serves good home cooked classic food and drinks. Vongole Oreganata are 8 nice sized whole clams baked with garlic, oregano and not too bready. Chicken Parm was a big portion with crisp chicken, a very good sauce and topped with the perfect amount of mozzerella. It was a nice lunch, in a nice setting. read more

See all

Food is consistently excellent, freshly prepared and delicious. Love their Shrimp Parm. Lots of tasty specials every night as well. The place could use a renovation though as its looking tired. Also the last time we went service was abysmal. No one came to our table for 15 to 20 min. Had to keep flagging a waiter down. No one checked on us the entire meal either. It looked like there was no manager there and it was a weekend night. Usually the manager or owner I think his name is Peter is there and things are better run. The food though is usually excellent so we keep coming back. read more

Nice Neighborhood spot, it is ok to go for a quick bite or nice dinner... except it will not be a quick dinner it will be long, long, only because service is...let's say "very relaxed" slow is an understatement. I had the chicken parmigiana and it was a lot of food but it all tasted very much like Olive Garden, cheesy and stale. I thought it was just fine, but not special. That's it read more

Had dinner last night and it was not as good as we have had in the past. Food was lacking flavor. Service was slow and unattentive. Had a reservation yet we had to sit outside in the shed....humid and a lot of bugs. The only good thing was the bread and Pomodoro Bellini. read more

See all

Friendly and courtesy staff met us at the door. We went around 4:30 on Sunday. By 5PM it was getting busier and busier. They take reservations. We had entrees and tea. Food was hot and very tasty. A good place to go if you're in the neighborhood. We spontaneously came across this spot and recommended it. read more

Pomodoro Rosso - Eggplant Parmesan - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Came here last Sunday with the family , decided to sit outside since my mom still doesn't dine indoors . Nice enclosed outdoor seating and although it was pretty cold outside it was very warm in this enclosure , they have plenty of heat lamps . We ordered a pizza , tortellini and chicken parm , the food was good although the service was terrible We got pasta sauce on the table cloth from the Chicken parm and although they came 3 different times nobody cleaned it until I had to say something and ask for more napkins to clean it myself . They served us dessert with a dirty tablecloth instead of just wiping it down for us or at least giving us a few napkins to do ourself . I would give it a second chance since my mom lives in the neighborhood and the food was decent , perhaps service is better indoors read more

See all

Pomodoro Rosso's food and service were fabulous! We were a large group of 17 celebrating two retirements late afternoon on a Friday. Our dinner reservation was at 5:30pm. We began to gather at the bar at 4:30pm. We sat at two tables in their semi-private room which was just perfect for us. We could make toasts, give speeches, tell stories and clap and be a bit loud without bothering other diners. The food was delicious and well-presented. We ordered a la carte. We had a vegan and a gluten-free person who were both accommodated. Our party met at the bar before our dinner reservation while we waited for our entire party to arrive. I would recommend doing that to anyone dining with a large group. It was a nice touch. The service was attentive. Peter, the owner knows hospitality and made sure we were happy and we were. Waiter Omar who I (I was the organizer) dealt with beforehand and that day was both pleasant and knowledgeable. I had made the reservation online and then I went in person to confirm the details (I needed to do this for my own piece of mind!). Omar answered all my questions. Omar even gave me advice for me to pass on to our party about local parking. I was impressed when of my colleagues had a particular question about a particular wine and another server who wasn't Omar (I can't remember his name) said he didn't know the answer, but he would go find out and he did. The timing of everything was perfect and we were not rushed. We ordered dessert from the a la carte menu. I have gotten feedback from the group and everyone liked Pomodoro Rosso. It was a memorable evening. I have also eaten at Pomodoro Rosso for years, mostly for dinner, but an occasional lunch, and have always enjoyed the food and the service which is why I chose to have the retirement party there. Pomodoro Rosso is a solid place (and you know in NYC one has many options!) to meet friends or family for dinner and I can now also say that it is good for groups. They have outdoor dining at this time of year too. You'll feel like you are in Italy! read more

This is a very pretty restaurant with a large mural on the interior wall. The food is nothing special, particularly given the price. read more

Was looking for a good place to eat lunch outside and came across this place. When we were seated, we were sort of rushed to order our food since their computers were supposedly shutting down in 5 minutes. I assume it's because they were probably closing before reopening later for dinner. The waiter was nice and gave us a couple extra minutes to decide on what we wanted. The bread that was served at the beginning was served warm and very fresh. I really liked the bread! The dish I got was very tasty and fresh. The tomatoes and Basil gave a lot of flavor to the dish. Pasta was Al dente, which I actually liked. The waiter grated some cheese on top, so that was a plus. My dad got the chicken Parmesan sandwich and enjoyed it. Overall, my experience here was pleasant! I wouldn't say that I'd rush back here as I would rather try a new place next time I'm in New York, but I would recommend this place to others. read more

See all

Real deal Italian food. Had two of the specials and the linguine del Mare. Everything was authentic and the oil with rosemary and garlic for the bread was amazing. Would be there all the time if we lived here. Best meal on this trip. read more

Pomodoro Rosso - Tiramisu and cappuccino - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food was good but nothing special...whole wheat linguini with shrimp and vegetables with a garlic truffle oil was tasty. The chicken breast topped with goat cheese, sautéed with sundried tomatoes, Portobello mushrooms, was really good! Could have used a little more of their bread to soak up that sauce!! Solid menu, OK wine list, descent service which at times seemed a little rushed. read more

Great little Italian restaurant.. no frills but very friendly wait staff and excellent food. Pretty good wine selection, too.

I have never had a dish that disappointed here. Everything is outstanding, from the bread (fresh, served with olives and garlic-infused olive oil) to the entrees (the chicken parm and veal chop are just two faves of mine) to dessert (a truly perfect tiramisu, or the chocolate lava cake, are must-tries). The service is above and beyond--everyone in the place is friendly and happy to offer recs. For a solid solo dining experience at the bar, date night, or a an intimate small group dinner, you can't do much better in this part of the UWS. read more

See all

Wonderful family style dinner for the 7 of us. My 8 year old nephew loved his mussels and I had the red snapper which was superb. Terrific service! read more

First time in the upper west side and stumbled upon this place! The service was super quick and the outside setting on the st had a great ambiance. We came 10 minutes before they closed for lunch and they still seated us. I ordered wine and got a very generous amount in the glass, which made me very excited! The food was served all together and had great seasoning. Unfortunately, my pasta was cooked way too al dente due to the rush of them closing I assume but it made my meal less enjoyable. I ordered the pasta con salciccia and there was more meat than mushrooms and pasta combined, which was a tad overwhelming. Overall very happy I found this spot and enjoyed the time here! read more

See all

When we walked in on a Friday night and saw the place half empty, I got suspicious. Every other restaurant we had just walked in, in the area, had a wait. My attitude was , "you can't mess pasta, pasta is pasta" Was I wrong! Pasta was tasteless and very heavy/oily - no way I'll go there again. Nobody in our group of 4 finished their pasta dish - and we had all ordered different pastas from the menu. read more

Great Italian restaurant in the city. Food is amazing and so is the atmosphere. The service is excellent. We were a party of three. We had the Pollo Rugantino. It was chicken breast in a mushroom sauce with a hint of sherry wine. It was topped with goat cheese. So delicious! Probably one of the best Italian dishes I have ever had. We will definitely be returning. read more

Been eating here for many years - one of our go-to places for decent UWS Italian food. Had dinner here last nite with another couple as our guests. Horribly disappointing & embarrassing with no acknowledgement from owner(s). 2 of our 4 entrees were completely wrong with 1 pretty much inedible for me. Server & other staff ignored us/disappeared. When bill arrived, I asked staff to let owner/manager know we had a big problem - was told he was very busy and would tell him later. 15 mins. later we left with no word from anyone. We'll find another UWS Italian restaurant as plenty of good choices. read more

medicore food, but nice service & ambience. That being said, I wouldn't eat here again. I feel like I wasted my money.

A wonderful Eggplant Parm with two glasses of wine and a tip - $100. A little pricey for just a quick dinner ... I just need to quit wanting wine with my dinner! read more

Stopped in for a quick snack. We were really happy with our order and drinks. The fresh mozzarella hit the spot. Calamari needed more salt and could've been a bit crispier but overall we liked the spot. read more

See all

After a lovely afternoon with family visiting from out of town, we were looking forward to dinner at Pomodoro Rosso, where we had a reservation outside. Well, unfortunately, the experience was a disaster due to the unacceptable and extremely rude behavior of Peter the manager. After my 82-year-old mother spoke with him, he said he'd find a table in 5 minutes. Over 30 minutes later and my husband going into the restaurant as well, my mother was still standing with her walker. That was the last straw. To be so oblivious and disrespectful especially to an elderly person, and to not even offer a glass of water and chair while waiting is inhumane. We are all human beings and should be treated as we would want to be treated. Just as the "golden rule" has been taught to generations. Guess Peter missed that lesson!!! read more

My food wasn't amazing and I came face to face with a rat yet I'd still return -- am I crazy? The meal started wonderfully -- a fennel and arugula salad with avocado, asparagus, almonds, and love. It was delicious. I could've eaten another and called it a night. Next up were the swordfish and scallops. Neither was that great -- not horrible, just not that great. However, the glazed carrots and broccoli served along with them were quite tasty. I also tasted the osso bucco which was super tender and superordinary. Again, it wasn't horrible but it wasn't great either. It was served with mashed potatoes that may have been slightly over salted but that's how I love them so I had no complaints. While seated in the outside dining shed/shack, I saw a rat scurry out of the planter and make its way precariously toward me. I don't blame the establishment for this. it's New York City. The streets don't belong to us, they belong to the rats. If I dare eat outside I have to contend with the rats and pigeons. Such is life. With that said, this place has potential. There are several dishes on the menu I'd like to try. The table next to me got the tiramisu and it looked like heaven. That alone is enough for me to fend off the rats one more time. A great tiramisu is worth fighting for. read more

The decor is still in the 90's & it desperately needs a renovation. When all the restaurants around it have light & bright interiors, this place looks dumpy. We had their lunch prefix salad, pasta & dessert for $26. Clearly Caesar salad had been sitting out, didn't taste fresh, store bought croutons & barely any dressing. Their pasta/vodka was over cooked and just looked unappetizing. Tiramisu - not fresh. Total disappointment. read more

Really good penne a la vodka, great wine and atmosphere, lovely service. I love the outdoor seating. read more

Pomodoro Rosso - Penne with vodka sauce and prosciutto - Italian Near Me - New York, New York