Okay, it's safe to say that I am a fan of Polly's Diner and will continue to visit. Last weekend, when I woke up, I was not in the mood to make breakfast. Instead, I wanted someone else to cook for me and I knew just the place! I suggest to my hubby that we visit Polly's Diner and he was all for it! When we arrived, we had to park out in the back (I really hope the parking lot can be updated or repaired in the future becuase right now, it's so bad), but that's not going to stop me! When we walked inside, we were greeted right away and they had a table available, so we were seated quickly! Our server was already offering coffee and water to us which was perfect. She gave us time to check the menu and since I already knew what I wanted, I helped my hubby make a decision since so many items were on his list. He eventually ordered the western skillet and I ordered the strawberry pancakes which I could not wait to eat! While we waited for our food, the server(s) on the floor were checking in with us and chatting with us ehile they refilled our coffee. Once the food arrived, I was so ready to dig in! My pancakes were topped with strawbery glaze and so many strawberries, I knew I would not be able to finish, but that didn't stop me from trying. I did eventually need to ask for a box and broght them home for later. My hubby said that the skillet was really good and had all his favorite food items included. It was such a good breakfast and honestly, for the price, we know we were fed well. Once we were done, we went to the counter to pay and were on our way. Polly's Diner is just a cute little Fenton restaurant and I am so glad that we have it so close to the house. I already plan to go again later this week! read more

Excellent service! Great home cooked food. Great prices! I had Chicken Fried Steak and Eggs and it really hit the spot. The pancakes were good too. read more

Great new retirees retreat, home style meals perfect for when you don't want to cook at home. LOL!

Breakfast! Polly's Diner is kind of a hole in the wall, and I can't speak for any other food except for the breakfast. The place is always busy when we are there, the waitstaff are hustling and friendly. Quick and efficient and getting the food out quickly. Eggs and hashbrowns are great, taste like eggs and hashbrowns. No strange oil used to cook them that overpowers the taste. Biscuits and gravy are peppered gravy and not sausage, they are great. Busy place, efficient and friendly, quick service, decent pricing and great breakfast! read more

Polly's Diner - Breakfast special sub ham - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fenton, Missouri

We came for a late breakfast and appreciated they serve breakfast all day until they close at 3. I ordered the Daily Special with scrambled eggs, sausage patties, and hash browns. Scrambled eggs were served hot and steaming. The gravy was just ok; it needed more sausage in the gravy.Biscuits were so so. A cutely decorated diner with only mediocre food today. read more

See all

Very fast service...order taken and food came out within 5 minutes. I had the western inlet with has brown sand a small stack of 2 pancakes. She had the one egg breakfast with bacon and French toast. Very reasonably priced. read more

We parked right next to the main door, but family had to park two lots away. Yes, it was crowded, but service was FAST & food hot. So many specials & large menu makes me want to come again as well as the workers. Everyone was nice & some were related. So many pie/cake choices I was literally distracted to a halt on arrival, Then when leaving I was enthralled by a gigantic bowl of candy...also generous variety. Sadly, I did not have room for pie/candy. Served the most fries of any restaurant I have eaten at in 2025, & the thickest roast beef sandwich I have ever eaten. Hubster got a basic burger & polished his off as well. Family got a sandwich my mom would have wanted, but I'll be bringing her back for pie! I look forwarded to looking at the decor more on my next visit...pirate-vibes made me smile. We were engrossed in conversation & were one of last to leave before the closed. They did not rush us. We were there over an hour and half. Only restroom at a restaurant I have ever been in with a bidet! read more

See all

Went to Polly's Diner in Fenton on a weekday morning and I had a wonderful breakfast with a corned beef skillet that came loaded with delicious hash browns, 2 eggs on top and a side of 2 pancakes that was a meal and a half that filled me up for the whole day and costed a little under $20 including a coke with free refills and the tip. It was much better than chain places like Denny's and similar chain places I've ate at for breakfast around St. Louis, I'd give it a 4.5 stars if they allowed half stars. Although I don't think Polly's is quite good my favorite breakfast restaurants in South St. Louis, this place is closer to me. I enjoyed their Polly's signature hot sauce on my eggs that added a little heat but not too hot for me. I loved that they offer a dish called the horseshoe for breakfast as well as lunch that's originally a Springfield, Illinois' typical signature dish overloaded with hash browns, bacon or sausage and sausage gravy for breakfast and for lunch is usually overloaded with fries and whatever variation of toppings that comes with it so I'll order a horseshoe the next time I'm there , maybe for lunch. Service was quick and friendly with a smile and the restaurant has a nice diner ambiance. read more

Polly's Diner - My corned beef skillet with eggs & hash browns along with the side of pancakes. Was starving & could barely finish it. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fenton, Missouri

I have been wanting to try Polly's Diner for months now and finally had the chance to do so! They have an extensive menu. Their daily specials are posted just inside the entrance. For my first visit, I chose the mostaccioli and garlic bread. To drink, I ordered coffee and water. The coffee was strong and freshly made. The mostaccioli was cooked to perfection, and the garlic bread was quite tasty. Portions were generous and the prices were reasonable. I received excellent service and was acknowledged almost immediately after being seated. The diner's decor is a mix of oddities including parrots almost everywhere you look. Be aware this place is really busy. If the upper parking lot is full, they also have a lower lot for overflow. I'm looking forward to visiting Polly's Diner again for breakfast. read more

See all

Polly's has not been open very long but on our day they were hitting on all cylinders Snappy environment, welcoming servers, great food, and a menu that hits all the right spots. Beware, portions are huge. Good luck Polly! read more

Polly's Diner - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fenton, Missouri

Service has been fast and friendly. Portions large! Might just be the best breakfast spot in Fenton. read more

Polly's Diner - Horseshoe - better like tasty Gravy! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fenton, Missouri

Cute little American proud diner. Wonderful breakfast spot! Steak and eggs were solid and the vibes are wonderful.

Met friends at Polly's for lunch, it was super busy, so we had to park in the overflow lot. We were seated right away though and were waited on immediately. Super friendly and fast service, the food came out pretty quickly, I ordered their Reuben w/fries....yummmm! So good! Everyone ordered a different dish and were equally pleased with their choice for lunch. Unfortunately, it was so good, I forgot to take a pic before I devoured it...so I will have to go back! Super cute little diner in old town Fenton, check it out! read more

See all

First time to eat here on a Sunday at 8 AM. Parking lot was full but there were spaces in the overflow lot and there were still empty tables. I was seated promptly, my order was taken and delivered quickly. Kitschy decor, but I wasn't there for the ambiance. I had the meat lovers skillet which was ok, if a little bland. Until I noticed Polly's hot sauce on the table and I added that and it was VERY good! Server didn't check back with me, but I didn't need anything so no complaints! read more

Great Old Fashioned diner with awesome prices. Service with a smile and lumberjack size portions. Set done with a friend or bring the family you won't be disappointed. read more

Brand new diner in Fenton! Everyone was friendly and considering the crowd and the newness of the place, service was reasonably fast on a busy Sunday morning. My taco salad was delicious. Would like to know whether they make the taco in house. My companion and I couldn't get enough of it. That alone is worth a return trip. The decor is eclectic. I like the parrot look; lean into that. I like Polly's and will return! read more

See all

Hole in the wall absolutely amazing. Fast food and it's all fresh for a good price. Can't complain about this place what so ever

Good food, fast service and friendly staff. Close to my place of work but this was my first time visiting. Will go back again.

The food was tasty, served hot and quickly after ordering. There were no pies/cakes today but that's okay. Be aware that all of the folks in your party must be there prior to being seated. This place used to be a BBQ place and probably a BurgerChef in another lifetime, but it was comfortable and homey. Enjoy! read more

We love a good diner and I had been wanting to try Polly's for a while now. The waitstaff were very friendly and kept a good eye on our coffee and water. I had the 1/2 order biscuits and gravy with two eggs and a side of sausage and hash browns . The sausage patties were weird. Good flavor , odd texture. The biscuit was mealy like they forgot to add a rising agent. The hash browns were great. My husband had an omelette and hash browns which he devoured and loved. read more

Very excited to try this place as I'd heard great things. Place is cute and kitschy but food was underwhelming. I really wanted to like it but it was just average and I don't see myself going back. Our food took a while to arrive, I got one cup of coffee and no matter how hard I tried to flag someone down, I couldn't get someone to come over for a refill. I did see my waitress stand next to the coffee machine but never looked over at our table. So so service and average food. read more

Everything was ok- nothing outstanding. Can gravy and store bought biscuits. Coffee is barely drinkable. read more

Polly's Diner - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fenton, Missouri

See all

The ambiance is good, the service is great! The people are friendly and personable. Sorry but the food is mediocre. Frozen meat patties, not fresh. The best dish is breakfast. read more

Tried the newly establishment in Fenton not bad nothing Special average Breakfast place.Food was good and service was good price is right if in the area go ahead and stop by !! read more

See all

Been there twice and had a great experience! First time was with my two kiddos. The second time was with just my husband. The portions are large and the food is very reasonably priced. Not sure why people are calling it bland. Perhaps they need to use more of the Polly's specialty house-made hot sauce? This place is exactly what downtown Fenton needed. read more

See all

The quality of the food was excellent. The quantity of the food was YUGE and the service was terrific. We put our order in and about seven minutes later we had our breakfast. Recommended! 5 star. read more

They're always busy, which tells me they're no longer a secret to the community. This cozy diner is run by an amazing staff. Everyone is super friendly and they don't seem to have much turn over so I'm guessing ownership/management is doing a good job by their employees, which is refreshing these days. Personally, I'm a big fan of diners. Love them. This one in particular is fantastic. The prices are fair and the portion sizes are huge. You can easily get your fill for $10 or less, and you'll likely have to take some of it in a to-go box. It's a great value in my opinion. read more

I went to this restaurant with a friend for lunch this past weekend. It was crowded as usual. The staff is friendly but busy. The crowd is of many age groups. My friend has breakfast , that she can get this at noon is a plus. She reports that her food was good. I had a cheeseburger with fries. It was a very generous portion. I didn't finish it all. My friend got carry out for her son. She reported that he liked the food. I have been here a few times and all visits were 4 star. read more

Restaurant was warm but it was one of those 100 degree days we have had recently. I would suggest they have the air conditioning looked at. Breakfast all day. Good portions and well priced. Had a fried chicken salad. Was full of chicken and the serving was huge. Looking forward to going back to try more items. read more

Everything I've had here has been excellent. Great service too. Would highly recommend.

This location has been several failed restaurants. So, I hope Polly's Diner makes it at this Old Towne Fenton location. They only serve breakfast and lunch. My husband and I went on a Saturday morning around 8:30 am and were seated when we walked in. However, on our way out there was a line of people waiting for a table. Still looks like the BBQ restaurant in the inside with same setup, booths and decor. Maybe a few added parrot themed decor. We had Kelsey as our waitress and she was excellent. She greeted us with a smile and answered all our questions we had about the menu. Food came out fast and hot. All the waitresses help each other at keeping the coffee and drinks filled. I ordered the Veggie Skillet with my eggs on the side (menu states they come on top). My husband ordered Polly's favorite with bacon and eggs. Food was good, but, not exceptional. My husband's pancakes came with drizzled Carmel sauce. He was hoping to get some flavored (like blueberry or blackberry) syrup. But, they only have maple syrup. We plan on coming back to try the lunch menu. read more

Polly's Diner - Polly's Favorite with Eggs and Bacon - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fenton, Missouri

See all

Service was very good. Coffee tasted like hot dark colored water. Second fresh mug tasted the same. Very little taste to 4 ingredient omelet. Their hot sauce gave it flavor, I recommend it. Very good. Very noisy, difficult to have a conversation with the person next to me. read more

Food is excellent, you get hashbrowns not hash whites, toast is toasted ! The service is excellent fast friendly and food is hot! Clean and homey feeling! Prices are very fair! Dont fix a thing! Nothing is broken! read more

Stopped in on a Thursday morning during an exceptionally rare opportunity to hit up a diner for breakfast during the work week. Ended up waiting a bit to be seated, but to that point they were pretty busy, and it appeared that there was only one person up front and one waitress working the floor. Looking over the menu, I was pleasantly surprised to not only see some breakfast favorites but some very enticing "lunch / dinner" items like burgers, sandwiches, chicken, steaks, and pasta dishes. We will definitely have to come back one day for lunch as well... Anyway, the food came out fast, incredibly fast, like 4-5 minutes from ordering and it was in front of us. Of course I know that breakfast diners usually have a pile of hashbrowns going all morning as well as sausage / bacon ready to come off at any time but this didn't taste like is was on the flat top for an hour staying warm, everything was as fresh as it was fast! Speaking of which the food was Excellent! I ordered a combo which came with sausage, French toast and 2 eggs plus I added on a side of hash browns. I'm pretty picky with sausage but im happy to say that these patties were fantastic. The eggs were cooked perfect over medium, and the hashbrowns were truly tremendous. Only disappointment was the French toast, but not because of the preparation, but rather the lack of good quality syrup. I know the real stuff is expensive, but it makes such a big difference that I can hardly stand the imitation stuff anymore. Bottom line... For a quick in and out dining experience with friendly staff and good portion size to price ratio, Polly's Diner in Old Towne Fenton certainly hits the mark! read more

Stopped in Fenton on way home from St. Louis to Dixon to go to a chain restaurant but it was closed so saw this little cafe. A hidden gem. Checked yelp first. Best chicken strips ever. Hand breaded and huge. Tender. 4 big pieces. I could only eat 1 piece with mashed potatoes and a salad. Nice waitress. It was very busy on a Sunday but fast service! Great home town cafe. Will be back next trip to St. Louis for sure! read more

Service was good. I went with my cousin and I think her food was better than mine. She had a patty melt with a side salad. I had breakfast with hash browns, biscuit, and scrambled eggs. The biscuit was either frozen or canned and undercooked. No jelly or anything other than butter was offered. I ate less than half of it. Hash browns had an off taste from some funky oil taste. My eggs were good.My cousin really liked her food. read more

Great diner in Fenton. Breakfast was very good and reasonably priced. Outstanding service was a bonus.

Been there for breakfast numerous times and it's good every time. The waitresses are friendly and very good

Always a great meal, great staff. Portions are always generous. They are quick and efficient. Not a fancy place, its some place everyone should try. Thanks Pollys! read more

I loved this place. There aren't many diners left where you can always get a waffle. I had a Greek omelet and it was made just right. There's a lot of variety here, and I'm looking forward to coming back. They really need to open a South City St. Louis location. Hint hint! read more