Ive been going here for a few years now. Everything I've had is delicious. The pizza is top notch. The tomato sauce is superb. However, all of these item are just bit players, supporting actors, understudies, to the true star of the show... the garlic knots. Pillows of fluffy dough bathed in oil and garlic. These things are ethereal. If god made garlic knots, these would be them. Take a bite, and tell me they aren't made with love, I dare you read more

I've had pizza here a few times, always so good! I tried the chicken parm tonight with angel hair pasta, and wow, was it delicious! Love this place! read more

Pizzaro's Pizzeria - Large half cheese half mushroom and onion - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Connecticut

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza for pick up, i drove down there and the older women was in the middle of making the pizza as i walked in. I paid for the pizza with younger lady there and i had a comfortable seat as the pizza cooked, i like to get the pizza fresh and hot as soon as it comes out of the oven to bring it home still hot for the family. The inside of restaurant looked clean and cozy for dine in, tv's playing and holiday lights on. The pie with one topping and tax came to $21.47 which is alittle more than i would like to pay for a one topping large pizza but all in all it was cooked well and tasty still when i got home. Something to note is that if you want to do a half one topping pizza, it still cost the same amount for the one topping cost which i don't particularly like when restaurants do that. read more

Pizzaro's Pizzeria - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Connecticut

They are amazing! The pizza is always so good and service is great. They are so friendly and efficient. My favorite pizza place in the valley! read more

My family and I went to Pizzaro's on a Saturday night at 6:00. Before heading there, I thought it might be crowded but that didn't stop us from going and when we arrived, there was only one other family there. I was pleasantly surprised! We were greeted by the waitress who was very friendly and she told us to sit wherever we'd like. For appetizers, we ordered Greek salad, cheesy garlic bread and bruschetta, all of which were phenomenal. The bruschetta were especially fresh and delicious. For entrees, my mom and I ordered the california dreamin pizza, absolutely amazing. The crust was crisp without being burnt and the toppings were plentiful. We loved it. We also ordered chicken parmigiana, which was also delicious and flavorful. Overall, we loved Pizzaro's and will absolutely be back!! read more

See all

Good pizza , fast service all and all a good restaurant The restaurant was clean and organized The waitress was pleasant

I love this local joint. It's great to just pop in and get a bite when we're craving pizza. Service is always friendly and fast. read more

Pizzaro's Pizzeria - Small Semplice - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Connecticut

See all

One of my favorite pizza places. Love the pizza they make and prices. Really think it's great that they have an online ordering option that's quick and convenient. read more

I love this place! Great pizza and the sauce is very good which is very important for a lot of the dinner meals. It's definitely the top choice when we want to have pizza in this area. Usually we will get the sides of meatballs and sausage which are also very good. Again not many places eating out have good meat like that. Everyone is very nice there too! Very friendly, great spot! I only wish we could get it delivered sometimes! Lol! Great spot, I highly recommend trying if your in the area. read more

Little pizza place in seymore ct. service was a little slow but the pizza was about a 8 out of 10. Really good by CT standards. Small dining area, definitely worth checking out if your in the area. read more

Good food with good service. I have only gotten takeout but the food is always fresh at a good value

Been here many times and had all kinds of food here. Their pizzas are very good. Not as good as New Haven pizza, but for the Valley area it's very good. Their large calzones are massive. The meatball and chicken parmesan subs are good. Their dinners are good, and very reasonable. Was disappointed in there stuffed breads and service sometimes can be slow. read more

The pizza is very good. Quick service and good value for takeout. I would definitely recommend.

Very good food and service I will return . Excellent brick oven pizza been going for years . read more

Plain tomato sauce, no zip, but was good. Also ordered chicken nuggets for adult, too small, and ketchup was in container but only had 1/4 inch in it. Should get smaller containers. I would go again, friendly people and service, true Italian!! read more

Our go-to pizza spot on Friday nights. Their plain cheese is hard to beat, but the BBQ chicken is right up there. Most places use only BBQ sauce on their versions, but Pizzaro's uses BBQ sauce as well as tomato sauce, which makes for an unbelievable blend! read more

I grew up with Larry when he used to be a co-owner of Roma pizzeria in Ansonia. Larry is a very talented mason and he built the brick oven. Now that he's on his own Pizarro's is just as good as the pizza I remember down at Roma. In fact, it's fabulous!! It's as good as any pizza you will find this side of Wooster Street in New Haven. Larry and his family run a nice little restaurant with a dining area that is cozy and charming. I love this place. read more

My family really enjoys this pizza but I'm vegan and *gasp* I don't eat cheese. Long story short: I appreciate the inclusion on the menu of "with or without mozzarella" because it is a lot less alienating than usual for someone who doesn't eat cheese. And, for a pizza without cheese, it was damn good too. read more

Nice family ran brick oven pizza in Seymour. During typical busy pizza times be sure to place your order early! The pizza is pretty decent and the calzones are huge and delish! read more

I've never been to Seymour before, but my family was driving from NY to MA and we decided to look for the best pizza place along the route. We were sold after reading other YELP reviews. My rating is actually 4.5 stars. Was it my favorite pizza? No. But it was very tasty. Without YELP, we would have driven by. From the outside it's just a pizza place in a small strip mall. Immediately after entering we were impressed. The restaurant is very nice inside. Clean. Well decorated. Was impressed to see how nice the bathrooms were too. Larry took care of us. We ordered 2 types of wings + some garlic knots. We all devoured them. Then, we had 3 types of pizza. My personal favorite was the Sicilian. The boys loved the Chicken Barbecue. I saved the name and address in my phone. We will definitely stop there again when we are driving through. read more

Our families go to place for a pizza and side of fries. Best fries in the area by far. I know it sounds strange saying that but just give them a try! read more

If you love clams, shrimp, and garlic then you will love the Seafood Pizza at Pizzaro's Pizzeria. I can't keep thinking about how good this brick oven pizza is... Keep in mind long wait times Friday's and Saturday's but worth it! Very family orientated environment staff is great. We tried their other pizza and they are good but if you want a really good tasting, brick oven, reasonable priced seafood pie this is the place. read more

Very solid pizza joint in the valley. The bacon pizza in particular is very generous-so much bacon you can barely see the pizza! Excellent service is a big bonus too. They accept credit cards and while parking can be tough, you can almost make your own parking space if you are just picking up. I love their cherry pepper pizza too. One opportunity for improvement-the artichoke pizza. It's strange because the bacon is so right on, but the artichoke is beyond sparse. I've never seen one artichoke heart pulled apart and spread across an entire pizza. Ordering extra artichoke doesn't help, it's still almost the same sparse sprinkling of a few artichoke leaves. I've stopped trying to order artichoke pizza, but it's a minor complaint in the grand scheme of things because this is still hands down one of the better pizza places in the valley (second to roseland of course). read more

I've lived in this town for seven years, and longed for a supremely delicious pizza close to home. Having previously lived close to New Haven, that had been my usual jaunt for good pizza (Pepe's, of course). When this new place opened I of course was skeptical, after all, this is Seymour. The odds of a fantastical pizza to be found here are almost nil. Thought I'd give this place a chance. I entered around noon on a weekday, the place was nearly vacant except for two people sitting waiting for a take-out order. There was a young woman behind the counter, and a man shuffling pizzas inside the large brick oven (brick oven? In Seymour?! I'm already impressed!). The staff were friendly and efficient, quickly took my order, and literally seven minutes later, my pizza came out of that oven and was in a box ready to go. My family is Italian. We don't play around. Pizza is our jam. This was the test. My mom and I sat at her table with two dishes and each took a slice. As we began consuming our slices, I looked up at mom's eyes, we were both smiling. My "I'm on a diet I'll just have one slice" turned into four. There was no holding back, the gates of joy were opened. When we finally finished our lunch, a five minute conversation ensued between us about how glorious this pizza had been, how this is our New Favorite Local Pizza Place. A few nights later, I took my daughter and mom back and we dined-in. My daughter ordered a "small" plain calzone, and mom and I opted to share yet another pizza. A friendly handsome man apologized for the lack of a waitress (really? We didn't notice) and had taken our orders. The food came out quickly. The "small" calzone was rather large and my daughter enjoyed it (brought more than half home) Again, our pizza was heavenly. If you have actual working taste buds on your tongue, and you value a glorious delicious pizza, trust this Italian gal: this is where you will find Your Happy Place. read more

Best wood fired pizza in the area! If only they had a hot oil pizza to offer their customers:)

Most delicious! This place is the best Pizza in Seymour / Oxford area by far. We have lived here 7 years now and are thrilled with the food. We have ordered pizza to bring home (they do not deliver) and now gone in for a sit down lunch. The Italian Combo grinder was fantastic and the pizza was, if course, delicious. Highly recommended read more

Awesome wood fired flavor, most definitely the best tasting pizza for the price in the area. The only sad part is they aren't open Monday or Tuesday's. read more

Pizzaro's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Connecticut

Best pizza and Italian you can get in Seymour! Highly recommend it! Family run and a very nice family at that!

Our favorite pizza place in CT. Never had a bad experience, everything is delicious and fresh. The staff there are always extra nice. Highly recommended. read more

Best pizza around!! We order at least once a week, sometimes twice. Done a couple pizza parties and ordered with them. I have yet had a awful meal or bad experience with them. Fantastic food with wonderful and friendly staff. There have been times I'd have to wait a little bit longer once I get there for pickup because they get slammed, especially if it's a weekend night; I don't even mind waiting. I am in not hurry. Food is definitely worth the wait. One time my husband and I were on our way home from a party with crappy food and we were starving. It was about 15 minutes to closing and I wanted pizza so bad. Called them up and asked if they had any leftover pizza, to just throw it in the box and I'll eat it cold or warm it up at home. They said as long as I was there by 10pm before they close they'll have pizza for me. Luckily we live 1 minute up the street from them. Not only did I make it and they had a box of pizza for me ready, but it was also fresh and piping hot; absolutely made my night. My go to is their chef salad with creamy Italian dressing. The garlic knots, meatball grinders are also runner ups to my salad. There are too many good pizzas to pick my favorite. Seriously can't get enough of this place!! If they were to ever close down - I'd probably boycott pizza and be absolutely livid and annoyed with life. read more

Pizzaro's Pizzeria - Mapamando with grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Connecticut

Best plain pizza in the area an didn't cost a fortune nice thin crust have been comparing all local pizza places, if you can't make a good plain how can you make one with toppings read more

Finally a pizza place in Seymour that does a good thin crust. We ordered 5 pies for a family event and normally have a pie left over, but this time not a slice was in sight! We had cheese, veggie, olive, pepperoni, and meatball. The meatball was slices of meat ball and not the crumbles (something I was told by meatball pizza lovers is a thing). Really happy we finally tried this hidden gem. read more

This place makes the best cheese pizza. Everything about it is perfect. I'm sure their specialty pizzas are excellent as well but i've never had the inclination to roam. The staff are always helpful and welcoming. Definitely worth checking out. read more

So disappointed in this place...had high hopes since I read they are connected to Roma's . Can't speak for the pizza but the dinners were terrible. The sauce on the pasta tasted like someone had opened up a can of tomatoe paste and just smeared it on the pasta...so thick and bitter. The meatballs tasted like they were from a bag...will never return. read more

Great pizza and garlic knots. The toppings were very tasty as well. Staff was super friendly + helpful and the food was awesome. Parking was easy and the place was also very clean. Will defiantly go there again! read more

Very Good Pie. prices are ok. People working there very friendly. Will go here again.

It's about time a decent pizza place opened in the valley. Place doesn't deliver but well worth the effort picking up. Nestled next to a bar, pick up order on Friday night was tricky due to parking however as much patrons dining in, making orders from next door, and pick up--the food only took 12-15 minutes. Ordered the buffalo pizza, plain cheese, fried calamari and grilled chicken Caesar salad. All small orders but portions was abundant, the small salad easily could have been split between two adults. The pizza is excellent here, can't wait to go back and try different pizza specialties. read more

See all

The wings are tasty but so small. They are like mini wings. Antipasto was good, comes with salami, ham and cheese rolls with side of vinaigrette. Quick service read more

Very good, not skimpy with the meat. Good crust and that's saying something for pizza in the Valley. Close to New Haven style but living next to New Haven, I can say it's not quite there. The calzone could have used a little more ricotta but it was very good. All in all, definitely a place to stop and enjoy. read more

I am always looking for a good meatball grinder. You would think they are easy to find. But I am Italian and picky. My friend took me to Pizzaros near CVS. I ordered a meatball grinder with moz. Jackpot. The best meatball w moz grinder in greater new haven. 1. Grinder bread crunchy. Toasted in oven to perfection. 2. Tons of mozzarella. 3. Meatballs cut in half. 4. And a delicious sauce. Fantastico! read more