Top tier everything and it is our first time ordering. Everything was delicious and we will definitely be a returning customer!!

Heard a lot of good things about Mario's, so we gave them a try. Unfortunately, they're not my favorite in town. Too greasy, and the flavor was odd - I don't know why it tasted smoky to us, and I think there was too much oregano. I wanted to like them more! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Naugatuck, Connecticut

Excellent Food and service!! Quality and generous quantity. I ordered for my team of employees the chicken parm. They loved it!!

Family owned and operated Connecticut business, Mario's Pizzeria is a must try. Their pizza is delicious along with their garlic knots - you cannot get one without getting the other, trust me. Their prices are affordable and all of their product is made fresh upon order. You really cannot go wrong with anything on their menu. The service is great and you could tell it is a family run business. Everyone there is very kind, greets you with a smile, and holds small talk while handing over your meal. You could also see into the kitchen, watching all of the pies enter the Firestone oven. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - 59. Grilled Chicken Salad Red Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naugatuck, Connecticut

Terrible. The gyro meat was dry as the Sahara desert! They have a $5.99 cheese pizza special during the week, but you can't even up-charge for extra toppings, it's full price plus toppings if you want 1/2 pepperoni. What is up with that? The pizza sauce is sweet and it's the pie was just greasy!!! Instant heartburn. Never again. I paid $60 for a large cheese 1/2 pepperoni, and 3 gyros. Not worth it if it's that nasty. read more

Great pizza awesome service and made the way you ask. CompAible pricing with great selection.

I'm sad to report that this place doesn't taste that good after trying several times. I've given ample chances at going back but none any better than the first time which was also dismal . It's bare bones basic so so pizza. The meatball parm isn't that good either. The service upon picking up is always pleasant and upbeat but it ends there. The food unfortunately doesn't measure up to the nice demeanor that you receive. Smaller right parking lot. Sorry to rain on those who feel this is very good in their standards. It is ok for a last minute filler if that's all that's available to you. Just giving our views on the handful of times we've tried them. You can only give a business so many chances when you finally decide it's not too your liking no matter what they do to try to make it better. read more

See all

Their pizza is delicious! I travel over 25 minutes from another town for their pizza, they have good deals, great service & friendly staff. Definitely recommend it! read more

Well a friend of mine was treating and I told him to go somewhere else because the last time I went there they charged me 4.00 for extra onions in my burger, anyway I said please get me a order of BBQ wings so when he arrives with the wings they didn't smell or taste like BBQ I don't know what the flavor was but it wasn't good and the worst thing was the wings had those thick hairs on them so that means they weren't cleaned before they were cooked just disgusting, this definitely means I will never go to Mario's again and I will spread the word to my friends and family, just nasty Mario's You Need To Do Better!! read more

Mario's pizza is decent when you're hungry. The pie can be a bit greasy at times and the sausage is sliced like lunch meat, which diminishes the flavor quite a bit. Overall, you can't beat the prices when they run specials. If you're looking for affordable takeout, then definitely stop here. read more

Every time we order from here we're blown away by the flavor and quality of the food! We've lived nearby and driven past for decades and never tried it. One Monday night - for a birthday - we needed pizza and of course most Italian restaurants are closed Monday's! I asked on Facebook for recommendations and was told to try Mario's - we did and have ordered multiple times since! Don't let the outside fool you - these people can COOK!!! We order through Grubhub and the food us always perfectly packaged and hot as well as delicious!! I don't have pictures as the food never lasts very long but we've tried their pizza (I LOVE their Sicilian and I don't eat thick crust pizza!), their dinners, wraps, grinders, garlic knots (OMG!!!!) and much more! Tonight we tried their Parmesan garlic wings for the first time and I couldn't stop eating them! Never had a bad meal and always wish we'd discovered them sooner!!! read more

Got a medium half pepperoni half meatballs and they charged me $17.20. Thought it was overpriced since I usually get a large for $16. Went on their website and ordered a medium half and half and the price was $15.57. Be careful read more

Not bad-not the best but not the worst but definitely very affordable and probably one of the best garlic knots I have ever had-so fresh with oil, fresh garlic, oregano, basil and parm, an order of these just once will ward off any vampires coming your way for your lifetime! All kidding aside, we loved these-texture was great and everyone loved these in our home. As for pizza, it was solid and tasty. I would not make the trip out to Naugatuck for it but if I was here, I would definitely stop by. Great open space with very clean kitchen and conscientious workers who are meticulous in their preparations. This pizza was a little reminiscent of New York pizza and the crust had some good crunch to it. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - pizza for only $ 5 99 - Pizza Near Me - Naugatuck, Connecticut

See all

This is real Rick oven pizza. Thin crust, no flop, great variety. Wonderful staff, quick, punctual, warm, nurturing environment, and I have to say it again. It is suggest probably the best affordable for a real top-notch pizza. read more

Best slice in Naugy. True NY style pizza. It's no frills without inside seating but they have a patio for the warm months. Recommended.

Let me start by saying I never write reviews. Stayed right up the street this weekend for an event in town, wanted to grab a quick bite to eat before the show and found a little pizza/deli with a hole in the wall vibe. Convinced I'd probably have some kind of stomach ache due to greasy mediocre sub shop food but whatever I'm used to it. So when we got back to the airbnb and unpacked the bag with these massive sandwiches I wanted to eat fast so I had time to let it settle before the show. No. I had the best chicken parm sub of my life. I usually go for like an Italian or a steak and cheese but I ventured out, regrettably. And I say regrettably because my boyfriend got the Italian sub and I've never been so jealous of someone else's meal in my life. 10/10 recommend. So sad I live 3 hours away and this isn't my neighborhood sub shop. I'd also probably weigh 300 pounds. Also since the sub was so massive I couldn't eat it all. It's currently in my backseat waiting for the fridge. Super friendly too! read more

Food NEVER disappoints! Pizza, pasta... oh and you have to try the garlic knots!!! Simply delish!! Always friendly staff! Only downfall is you cant sit in and eat.. read more

After seeing all the good reviews I said let's try this place. The good new they were very prompt with their service, the staff was very nice, and their prices are very reasonable. The bad news we didn't care for their style pizza at all. Thought the crust tasted like cardboard, didn't like the sauce, and found the pizza lacking flavor. read more

Best Italian style pizza that I've tasted in Naugatuck. Food is very consistent. They also sell a variety of slices. Everyone who works here is super friendly. Conveniently located close to the highway. Easy on and off Route 8 exit 26. Its primarily a takeout place but they do have a few benches in front of the restaurant for those nice summer days :-) Try it! read more

Their pies are great and fresh with good ingredients. Would not recommend to get food by the slice there. They sit out and are not the best heated up. Their tiramisu was frozen over with no flavor as well. The workers there were kind and are hard workers. read more

The food deserves a 3 but because they had excellent customer service, they receive an overall 4. We ordered several items off of the menu including a large pizza, cheese sticks and garlic bread & also a 2 liter of coke. The pizza crust was really great- but the part under the toppings was pretty soggy, which neither of us cared for. The cheesesticks were a bit firm & very basic, especially for the price. We liked the garlic bread and I loved the marinara sauce. We don't particularly feel the need to go back, but we absolutely loved how kind the employees were. They thanked us enthusiastically for our service & offered a free two liter of soda. read more

See all

This place is rediculas. I ordered 2 pizzas and garlic knots. They gave me one price then when I get there they want to charge me a different price and give me less food. I will never ever eat there again. This is the 3rd time this has happened. They are robbing the local people that support them. I will make sure this is all over social media so people can stopped being robbed just to eat. read more

My son's favorite pizza restaurant. We come from out of town specially for it. He loves the friendly staff, cheese, the thicker crust which isn't blackened & the flavorful sauce. Garlic sticks are delicious too, especially after a hike at the nearby state forest. read more

Ordered 30 minutes before they closed through door dash (i know last minute orders before close can be a pain)... everything was perfect! I got a chicken bacon ranch wrap, fries, and a salad. Wrap was loaded and hot, fries weren't soggy, and the salad was fresh. I got all my dipping sauces and salad dressings- and the salad came with a piece of fresh garlic bread too. The price was a steal too- even with the DoorDash fees/tip it came out to around $20 all together. For sure my go to place to order in naugy from now on. read more

Friendly owner. Good guy. BUT... his pizza slices are only $1.00 ....but barely worth a buck. Too thin, too small, no cheese, plain minuscule. read more

Mario's is so yummy! When they have their $5.99 pizza special we get it multiple times a week. Their calzones are great and the pita's are a must try. The salad with grilled chicken is delicious and comes with a roasted pepper medley. The small is so big! It comes in a round tin as opposed to other places that come in that small styrofoam container when you order a small. I'm kind of surprised at some of these lower reviews. The service is also spectacular. Everybody here has been nothing but friendly. read more

I had two slices of pizza with bacon at $2.00 a piece. The owner said that if I didn't like it, he will refund my money "double". I took it home and enjoyed every bit. My dog loved the crust. I like it when an owner stands by his product. Good luck on your business The parking isn't the greatest, but I found a way to get there. read more

Excellent pizza..one thing I will eat when visiting my family (from California)..Can't seem to make pizza in California like they do here..

Clean take-out pizza joint, and quite delicious pizza. The garlic knots were VERY garlicky..... good prices as well. They only do take-out... no tables ! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - My hottie buddy - Pizza Near Me - Naugatuck, Connecticut

See all

Don't spend your money here. Extremely unpleasant experience. The owners threatened to damage and then tow my car , a customer mind you for parking inside the parking lot of the establishment. On top if it the place was less than 30mins from closing and I wasn't in anyone's way because no one else was even there. I have never witnessed anything so petty. Oh and the food is not good. read more

2nd time eating here and the first time was better. Got 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni I only eat the cheese part though and it was a bit doughy ... sauce is great read more

Mario's Pizzeria - First time I had this place , it was phenomenal ... this was my 2nd time and it's a B- at best - Pizza Near Me - Naugatuck, Connecticut

I had a surprise pizza delivery for my birthday a couple of months ago from a friend of mine. It's pretty good but a bit too greasy. It would've been very delicious if they omit grease. read more

They are open on Mondays yay! Most pizarras are not! The have gluten feee pizza but not cauliflower yet.. I didn't like that I had to order online to save 10%. The online ordering was very confusing. The pizza was okay a little tough/chewy.. wish there was a little more cheese. I always like their sauce.. I like that they are prompt with their time of orders. read more

Unusually thick pizza. Nothing special. Clean place. Polite prompt service except for one young blonde girl complaining out loud that an older coworker should be fired for incompetence. read more

Best Chicken Parm! Sauce is amazing, dinners are always good and pizza is fantastic. Owner has a great disposition and is always thoughtful and friendly! Love eating here! read more

We ordered pizza and wings for our business from here and it was the worst, greasiest pizza I have ever had. They must have changed something in their ingredients because other times we have ordered it was decent. This was a thin, very limp crust pie, the toppings were lost in the grease. The "wings" were basically boneless fried pieces of chicken breast, obviously from frozen, sauce was bland. I doubt we will order from them again. read more

You need to use other than Grub Hub for delivery, the delivery person was on the phone for 10 minutes unable to find where we live, could not understand what was being asked of them ... very discouraged with this driver ... total of 15 minutes of wasted time on the phone . read more

For actual flavor it's worth 5 stars, the amount of toppings, cheese and sauce is perfect. The only complain I have is that's quite soggy. This is the perfect pizza for reheating. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Meatball sweet green peppers, hot cherry peppers, meatball, and mushrooms. - Pizza Near Me - Naugatuck, Connecticut

See all

We went for a quick pizza today. I was very surprised at the thin crust that was absolutely delicious. I'm adding this to our list of go to take out for us. read more

We have been going to Mario's Pizza for many years. We absolutely LOVE their pizza, dinners and grinders! Their Naugatuck Special pizza is one of our favorites!!! The service is always friendly and welcoming. Thank you for being the best pizza place in Naugy!!! read more