This is a fabulous gem of a neighborhood restaurant. They just finished a nice renovation and the pizza and pasta are as incredible as they've always been. I hope everyone will give this restaurant a try and support a small local business. I went again this week. All of the pizzas are great, the sausage is my personal favorite. We also had pasta, salad and fried calamari. All delicious. GO!! read more

A hidden gem or a pizza secret? It's definitely PIZZA SECRET I MUST SAY I REALLY ENJOYED THIS RESTAURANT A RELAX ATMOSPHERE WITH A GREAT STAFF!! LETS TALK FOOD! Had the 12 inch margarita Pizza so fresh top of the line ingredients it just melted in my mouth!! Had the Polpette Della Nonna it was an appetizer of 3 meatballs parmigiana it was 5 wow so delicious I also finished it with a dessert called "Dolce Segreto with Nutella like 30 little zepplos I can wait to come back and more delicious food from their menu read more

Pizza Secret - Tiny zepplos - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We were lucky to get here in time to be seated quite quickly for a Saturday evening. The place was buzzing and quite packed with customers. Nice little spot on the corner with a very high energy and involved owner. He's super nice and definitely a lot of fun. Stopping by each table and joining in conversation if the group is open to it. But he's also assisting with seating and helping folks get settled or bringing things out to the tables. Because it was so busy, our pizzas took a bit of time but the calamari came out on time. The calamari wasn't bad but definitely wasn't the best I've had. The pies however were quite nice. Definitely prefer the margherita and it's great cuz you can add things to it as well. They also offer wine and drinks and a selection of dessert. I'd love to come back to try other pies and update my review. There's only one bathroom fyi so they could be a wait if not timed right read more

See all

Loved this pizza spot. A nice air of elegance with a modern Italian menu. The service was lovely, very nice and accommodating staff. The pizza was so good and the drinks were amazing. A small outdoor seating option but from the inside the windows are wide open so it was nice! Great restaurant for dining and after works drinks. Definitely recommend read more

Pizza Secret - Personal pizza (the standard size) and drinks. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We had a pretty racist experience. The staff moved a table and my umbrella dropped to the floor. The staff tried to give my umbrella to the people at the table next to us and acted like I was trying to steal my own umbrella. The staff basically ignored us for most of our dinner. They gave us our bill with an attitude then acted like they weren't expecting a tip from us. They didn't deserve us, they didn't deserve our courtesy, they didn't deserve the tip we left, and we didn't deserve the service we got. Would not recommend. read more

Not your regular pizza shop in and out in a strip mall. This place is refined dining with inside and outdoor seating. Staff was attentive and prices reasonable, including a happy hour cocktail. The bathroom was available to use and CLEAN. Chefs kiss! We thoroughly enjoyed the Margherita pizza, mozzarella appetizer, and focaccia bread with rosemary seasoning. 5 we split it all between 3 people and had left overs. Star all of it. We came early for a Liberty game and this place was less than a five minute walk to Barclays, couldn't ask for a better first time experience. Sold on Happy Hour we enjoyed a Spicy Margs that were perfection. read more

See all

Nice ,cosy , friendly space. Pizza dough is excellent but they have to figure out the sluggish core (a' cupola) to make it perfect . Focaccia to start was excellent. They got good selection all around. Friendly, professional service . read more

Food and drinks were great! Good outdoor seating as well! 10/10 service. Great for dinner and a show you might see a tweaker come in and try to fight the employees read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place was truly a gem! Everything we ordered was delicious. Secret salad - fresh, perfectly dressed, really yummy Stracciatella dip - indulgent but light & delicious. The bread that came with it was very crispy, dip was better with the table bread. We got a pizza on special with pumpkin & sausage. It was SO GOOD. Sweet and savory and incredible. For dessert the cannolis hit the spot, 10/10 Loved the ambiance too, cute little place. I would return read more

The sun was out. It was an extremely busy day in Park Slope. Fifth Avenue on a Saturday is extremely busy, Pizza Secret was a welcoming surprise. We were seated quickly in their sidewalk seating. The waitress was fast and gave suggestions. The home made Sangria was fruity. The wine punch served over ice did not disappoint. Americana San Marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, honey spice olive oil, basil, with sausage and pepperoni had all of six slices. The oven crispy fire roasted crust was good, but it was definitely smaller than I expected. The staff was attentive, friendly, and the atmosphere was nice. Televisions and surround sound was everywhere throughout the restaurant, to be at the bar during the NBA finals would definitely make for a great evening. I wish I would've been more selective with my dinner choices. The pizza pie was garnished and seasoned well, but it was small. read more

See all

They provided the authentic Neapolitan flavors paired with warm hospitality service make Pizza Secret a MUST-VISIT! Definitely highly recommend, excellent vibes for a unforgettable dinner experience read more

See all

We came here with a group of 12 with a toddler for a birthday and overall had a nice time! The place definitely gets crowded and a bit loud, but the staff is nice and the food is good. Had some critics in the group, but everyone enjoyed their food. We got pizzas including the truffle pizza, calamari , mussels, meatballs, olives, bruschetta, prosciutto, truffle cacio e pepe, truffle fries, ragu pasta, Caesar salad, tiramisu, panna cotta and the pillowy desserts with dip. The pizzas were tasty, the sauce had a yummy sweetness and I really enjoyed my pasta Genovese which had like stewed meat and potatoes with homemade pasta. The dessert was really good even without the dip, tiramisu was yummy and the wine was good as well. The Moscato was a bit flat, but good enough. The prices were a little high with portions on the smaller side, but overall it was a nice meal for my husband's 40th. The service was nice, but missed a few marks (i.e. asked if my husband's tiramisu dessert could have the candle or be specialized and they brought out the panna cotta with the sparkly candle which was cool, but in the wron6f dessert and it went out before they got to the table lol...) I did come back the next day for take out to get the pasta Genovese again because it was so good, but at 23+tax, a 30+ min drive and not a full stomach, it will probably not be a regular place for us. Good for groups and child friendly though! read more

See all

ABSOLUTELY AWFUL. First time and LAST TIME ordering. Marguerita was undercooked and did not travel well during delivery. All of the cheese slid off to one side. And / the worst part ..... There was only one - YES ONE - small little basil leaf. Very disappointed! I should have read the other reviews. HOW IS THIS PLACE STILL IN BUSINESS ?!??? read more

We had a reservation but they had trouble seating us when we got there then they rushed us our whole meal. Trying to take dishes before we were done and bringing the check before we said we were ready. Apparently they had to seat the next party 20mins after they sat us. The pizza was not that special. Would never go back. read more

Normally I enjoy a Neapolitan pizza. A fast cook, chewy crust, and fresher ingredients than what goes into a normal pie. Unfortunately this pizza was expensive and you only get four slices instead of six. The pie I got was also really sweet, sickly so. Maybe other pies work better, but this nearly ruined my palate. The honey was too much. I also felt the crust was way too chewy. The side Arancini is really delicious even though you only get two of them. That was nice. I am mixed because the food has potential but this was just slightly off the mark. read more

Pizza Secret - Arancini - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

3% Credit Card Fee! I don't believe this was on the menu. I decided to drop by Pizza Secret around 4:45 on a Monday. I was the only person there, but two other parties came by the time I finished eating. They have a decently spaced interior, though the tables near the window are a tighter squeeze. The interior has modern decor around the pizza oven. I ordered a Margherita pizza ($19). I think it is on the pricier side but not outrageous. I enjoyed the pizza; the dough was soft and chewy, the tomato sauce has a nice acidity, and there was no burning or char on the pizza. I wish there was a bit more basil, but the pizza still tasted good. As soon as I sat down, the waitress told me about the most popular pizza, which is the Americana ($22), which I just didn't go for because I'm not the biggest spice fan. Everything else was self-serve; I served myself from the bottle of water, so I cannot speak that much to service. Overall, I enjoyed the pizza and would come back if I needed a fancier bite in the future! read more

Pizza Secret - $19: Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We had the caprese pizza was ok. The calamari had absolutely no flavor. They didn't even put black pepper on it. The service was good and the food came out quickly. I guess that's because they didn't season the food. read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Stopped in real quick to grab a bite to eat after the game. Was greeted by a friendly face and promptly seated. Service was quick and friendly and the pizza was good. Will be back next time I'm in the area. read more

Came here for New Year's Eve dinner tonight and Pizza Secret did not disappoint. Firstly, the name of this restaurant is fantastic, kudos to whoever came up with the name. Making a reservation was very easy, and they had no problem accommodating my party of five, and I only called this afternoon. We ordered plenty of appetizers, the Tiella Mista, a sampler which came with a variety of fried items, as well as the Polipo Grigliato, and the Parmigina al Forno. As a table our favorite was the Tris de Montanare. I was not a fan of the Parmigina al Forno, the eggplant, the cheese was super over cooked and hard and not nearly enough eggplant. I had ordered a cosmopolitan with my meal, but sadly the drink wasn't a true cosmo and was far too watery. I wouldn't recommend getting a cocktail here. For the pizza, we had the Pummarola & Prosciutto and the Bufala D.O.P. Both were fantastic and full of flavor. I really enjoyed the Pummarola & Prosciutto because of all the arugula and cheese combinations. Our waitress was lovely and working so hard to accommodate all patrons. Considering how busy it was tonight, she still was nothing but sweet. Definitely a stand out tonight was the service. read more

Pizza Secret - Tiella Mista - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here for lunch randomly and it was actually really good. When you get inside the restaurant looks nice and spacious and you're greeted when you enter. The waitress was extremely nice and made sure we were good the entire time we were there. The food itself tasted really good. I'm not a big fan of salads not made by myself but this one had me clean the plate lol. The squid wasn't too chewy at all and you can't say that about a lot of places. My girlfriend had this pasta in tomato sauces with tomatos and it tasted sooooooo good as well. The wait time was not bad at all also. Will def recommend trying it out and will be back myself. read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The food was amazing. I just came back from Italy but the experience here makes me feel like I never left. The service was top notch. The ambiance is romantic and cozy. I can't recommend it enough. read more

We were looking for 'that' Brooklyn pizza before catching a game at the Barclay's Center. Check out Pizza Secret which is just a couple blocks away. Great pizza, atmosphere, and attentive staff. We had the truffle fries and the Americana pizza - pepperoni with honey drizzle. The coal fired taste and the crust are outstanding! read more

See all

This place was very good circa 2022 but it went way downhill. I picked up a large pizza yesterday and it was a soggy mess. It seemed like it was barely cooked. I don't know if they were busy and trying rush it, but I had to finish cooking it at home. Brooklyn has so many great pizza places. This is not one of them. read more

Food and service was very delicious .We enjoyed the service and Thomas was amazing with us :)

My girlfriend and I prefer Napoli style pizza. We have a go to restaurant in NJ but this is excellent too. Bufala Pizza is excellent and overall good vibe. read more

Food - provola and pepe pizza goes down as one of the best I've eaten. Could even be the best! Drink - Bee's Knees, first prep was too sour, second perfectly balanced. I was expecting a pretty little glass, this was served in tall highball one. Dessert - the chocolate lava cake, didn't impress. It was frozen to thawed and not flowing properly. On bringing that up - it almost seemed like they took that plate, microwaved and brought it back - even the cream was flowing this time :p Service - top notch and extremely friendly. Simple, rustic, clean decor. read more

Had an early dinner here for the first time before the Liberty game last night. The pizza is definitely good, but way overpriced for what it is. They do not offer the larger pizzas for dine-in. They also have pretty meager pasta portions. The service is ok, but don't check on you enough. I won't go back. There are many other options nearby. I really wanted to like the place, but nothing particularly bad, and nothing particularly good that would make me return. Good luck. read more

Food was good. A quick place to stop at before a game at the Barclays center. Definitely better pizza around in NYC. The salad was good. read more

See all

If you are in Brooklyn. It's a must stop in for delicious pizza, pasta, ricotta dip, salad really we tried everything oh and the cocktails. Juan was awesome! Even though it was really busy the food and service was fantastic! read more

We came from Connecticut to try their pizza. 100% worth the trip! fantastic service and delicious food!

Recently came here before heading to a basketball game. Great location and fast service! My party ordered 2 pizza, 2 salads, and an appetizer and it was just the right amount of food for 4 people. I'd recommend the mushroom truffle pizza. The burrata pizza was good as well but it came with meat on it so as a vegetarian, I would not order it again. The salads were fresh and the tiramisu dessert was super cute and tasty. This is a great fun and casual dinner spot for a nice meet up. read more

Pizza Secret - Tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I came here for lunch, it was my pick. I never ate here before, but I saw Teyonah Parris (black Ms Marvel) eat here, so I wanted to check it out. This place is usually very packed, so I was excited to see it empty and have it all to myself. I went when they had just opened. We were served by MISAEL. He was very friendly in taking out orders and explaining menu items. Here's the cool thing, the menu was on an iPad. This was my first time ever seeing anything like that at a restaurant, very cool. I didn't have to squint to read small print, I ZOOMED in. We ordered an Americana Pizza, and a Salsiccia/Friarielli Pizza (hard to type and pronounce). The Americana had pepperoni on it, and the SF pizza came with broccoli Rabe puree and sausage. It was a good size pizza for one person. It was definitely fresco tasting, and I liked that. I like natural ingredients in my pizza. We had a Limoncello Drop, and a Whiskey Fix...yeah I know...but it was 5pm somewhere so, drink up. Drinks were good. Everything came quickly, and hot. I'm very greedy and I like to eat fast so I burned my mouth trying to eat the pizza. There were minimal decorations, it felt like I was eating in someone's dining room. It was an open concept. We could see them making our pizza. Got a free dessert for checking in on the Yelp app. We got the tiramisu. I didn't like it but my wife did. She said it was creamy and delicious. I've never liked tiramisu. I only have two negatives about this place. The tables were too low for me to fit my legs under. I had to swing my legs to the side in order to eat at the table. I'm 6'4, so I know it's not fair to say cuz most people aren't that tall, but I wasn't comfortable. The cost of eating here was high. I know we were in Park Slope, but our bill was $89 before tip. Sheesh, I can only eat here every once in awhile. I suspect it's that high because the ingredients are fresh, and possibly imported from overseas. But the way my budget is set up..... read more

See all

Their secret? Unprofessionalism and total lack of regard for customers health. I hate writing bad reviews but this was by far the worst restaurant I have EVER been to. Politely tried to send rotten entree back, were told it wasn't rotten and we both woke up food poisoning, Thank You, Pizza Secret!! Long story short: We ordered a pizza, took one and two bites, realized it was rotten and politely asked for something else, were told by the owner and chef (through our waitress) that they "disagreed" and refused to "waste $23", but we both still woke up the next morning with food poisoning! Me and a friend went for dinner last week (party of two), and were looking forward to trying the pizza's, as a local I had never been and Pizza Secret's atmosphere always looked so welcoming and fun. However, our experience could not be any further from that. We ordered the Fritto Di Marse (average), 4 Formaggi, and pesto pasta (unable to find it on the menu, but attached a photo below). While the fritto di marse was good (7/10), the pasta took over 45 minutes (3.5/10) and was too hard, the sauce was okay. However, the 4 Formaggi (-10/10) made both of us sick. Initially, after trying it, my friend asked me if it tasted fresh and was okay to eat- from one bite, it tasted absolutely spoiled, we both regularly eat blue cheese (and the other ingredients...) and it was clear to us (and our waitress) it was no longer good. We politely asked our waitress for something else and she was instructed by the owner and chef that there "was nothing that could be done", when we clarified that it was not a taste issue but a health concern, our waitress understood and tried to clarify things with her boss and the chef but again was told, "nothing could be done" and they "were not okay with wasting $23". We of course were not going to continue eating something that we felt was rotten (And thankfully we didn't because from 1 bite and 2 bites we both had food poisoning) and were charged the full price. Neither the chef or owner ever approached us or had any comment, explanation or apology. We both were throwing up and sick the following morning/day:( I am local and dine often/frequently in Prospect Heights, Park Slope, and Fort Greene, I am mainly bummed because of the service, I understand things happen, and wouldn't have thought twice and perhaps would have been a regular if the situation was handled a bit more tastefully (seriously no pun intended) and professionally. Regardless, I do want to recognize and acknowledge our waitress, as she was the only person who showed any hospitality or really common decency. Our entire interaction with her was polite on both ends, she repeatedly apologized, and condemned how the Chef and Owner handled it. She additionally gave us two limoncello's as an apology, as she was "humiliated" it was being treated this way and understood and agreed with us. We really appreciated her:)) read more

See all

The food was ok. The genovese pasta was the best thing ordered. Personal sized pizza for $22+. Decor is nice. The service could've been better. Seated quickly but a long wait got service. Staff is nice when you do interact but it takes a while to get serviced. I could go without a return in store but would order pasta to go read more

See all

I really enjoyed the taste of their bufala pizza but I won't be using Uber Eats again LOL Probably best oven to table! read more

Pizza Secret - Bufala D.O.P Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great food and service. Updated interior looks great. We had the pizza and the gnocchi, and a few beers from Naples. read more

Pizza Secret - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Poor excuse for a pizza just look at the pictures - enough said. Flipped over to show how unappetizing that dough looks at the bottom. Looks appalling. $40 for this. I can't speak to takeout or dine-in which HAS to be better but I ordered delivery so maybe that screwed them over but even a delivered pizza should never look like that. I'm not trying to hurt a hardworking business's reputation, just giving my honest review and saving people's wallets ahead of time!! PS: I didn't even order a plain Neapolitan, I ordered a Montanara which is supposed to be a fried, crispy version of the Neapolitan - the exact opposite of the soggy mess I received read more

See all

The pizza was amazing. The crust was light and airy and the sauce was great. Service was top notch. I would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Pizza Secret - Margherita pizza and Calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

6/8/24 was the first time I came here. I came here with my GF. We sat outside since it was nice and warm. The pizza was good. I thought it would be bigger with more slices but it's ok. The red sangria was not bad. The employees there were nice. read more

I had a great dinner at Pizza Secret tonight! The polpettina & ricotta pizza was so delicious and fulfilling, I finished it all in one sitting. And I received excellent service as always from Coleen! It was the perfect setting to get some peace after a long day. Thank you! read more