Tried em out for lunch today and have to say I was pleasantly surprised after seeing some negative reviews. The thin crust was good the sauce was abundant and did have a little kick, but great flavor. The sausage was fresh and flavorful as were the other toppings. The employee was great and even asked if the pizza was cooked to my desired level of "done-ness". I even got to play a free game of Pac-Man while I waited in their shop. It could have benefited from some jam band, dead esque ambiance but overall a great first time experience! I'll be back! read more

This was a basic thin crust pizza. Had pepperoni and nothing to extend a recommendation to go try. It's a inexpensive basic slice of pizza. Nice for neighborhood. The server was friendly. Lower star rating because I am in love with NY style pizza and my significant others homemade pizza crust and sauce. read more

Pizza Pete’s - Slice of cheese and slice of pepperoni $4 each. - Pizza Near Me - Cudahy, Wisconsin

For a small place in cudahy... You can really tell the pizza is made with fresh ingredients and lots of love! Staff is super friendly too! I definitely recommend it! read more

Pizza Pete’s - Pizza Near Me - Cudahy, Wisconsin

Today I had the worst pizza I have had from a restaurant in years... and that pizza came from Pizza Pete's. I ordered a thin crust sausage pizza with extra sausage and I received a hand tossed pizza without the extra sausage. I ordered plain (non-breaded) boneless wings and they made breaded. The pizza was so greasy on top that it pooled and we had to take paper towels to soak up the grease. We also ordered a Caesar salad that came with soft/soggy broken up pieces of rye bread as the croutons. They recently changed out their management for whatever reason which I think was a big mistake because there was quality control and commitment to quality food. They have been fantastic for years and now the quality has completely crashed. My recommendation is to stay away. Don't let this place ruin your love for pizza. Check out the photos attached. p.s. to top off the terrible experience, their order form allowed you to order a 2-L of Diet Coke... they delivered Diet Pepsi. lol read more

See all

I've read mixed reviews about consistency, but thought we would give it a try. We definitely loved the pizza. It was tasty, well topped and the crust and sauce and combination of toppings- just YUMMY!! Called and placed the order over the phone, they were pleasant and fun and pizza was ready when we got there. If this is how everyone would receive their pizza- there would be all smiles--- just like ours. Thanks Pizza Petes!! read more

Pizza Pete’s - Opening this box because it smells delish - Pizza Near Me - Cudahy, Wisconsin

See all

Sorry PP I did want to like it. I ordered the "hand tossed" crust rather than the thin crust. When I opened the box the crust appeared to be the thin crust. I called the store (extremely nice employees) and was advised the pizza was indeed the hand tossed version. Could have fooled me, but oh well. Crispy edges with doughy innards, not great. Sauce was on the sweeter side with an overabundance of Italian seasoning (IMO). Scant amount of cheese and I think I saw sausage. Like I said I wanted to like it. In the end the garbage disposal liked it a lot more than I. Though the restro was adorned with Grateful Dead signage, not a Sugar Magnolia could be heard. I had U.S.Blues and in the end I was The Ship of Fools. read more

Mom got huge foot long sub, and she could only eat about a quarter of it. It was delicious. I got a thin crust pizza with bacon, onions, and extra garlic. It was phenomenal Thanks Terrance for such great service read more

Awful pizza , dry fried chicken. They basically try to give it away with the cheap prices. Not worth it. I gave them 3 chances and everything it was the same bad food read more

I Can't Believe how HOT (SPICY) their Pizza Sauce is!!! I ate 2 pieces, not slices. My mouth started burning halfway through the 1st piece! But I thought that maybe someone had accidentally spilled some pepper flakes or some other Spicy Hot item to the Marinara Sauce. I Couldn't eat any more of it. It was too Spicy HOT!!! We had ordered 2 pizzas, mozzarella sticks, and cheesy garlic bread. 1 pizza was just cheese. 1 pizza was Cheese,Sausage,Mushroom and Light Onion. Both were light on the sauce. I only tried the Cheese, Sausage, Mushroom and light Onion, not the just Cheese one. It Wasn't spicy onions, but seemed like Hot Peppers or something similar. My mouth burned for 20 minutes, even though I kept flushing it out with soda. I've NEVER had such Spicy Hot pizza! Then I tried the Mozzarella stick, WOW! They took a pizza crust and wrapped it around a stick of Mozzarella. It's SO Tough to Bite and Chew through! I Can't Believe they couldn't bread the Mozzarella Sticks like all the other Restaurants do! I won't be going there again! I think that Papa Luigi's Pizza is So Much Better! It's just too bad that Cudahy is just outside of the delivery zone for Ned's, bcuz That's GOOD Pizza! read more

Terrible. Ordered delivery, took longer than was told. Food arrived cold. One pizza missing a requested topping and looked like it had been dropped, see picture. read more

Pizza Pete’s - Pizza that may have been dropped was also missing one of the toppings we ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Cudahy, Wisconsin

Ordered a pie for delivery. It arrived 25 minutes after the delivery window time had expired. I had to walk out to the sidewalk because the driver was just sitting in his car scrolling through his phone while being double parked! He handed me a box straight from his car seat that was not kept warm at all with a thermal bag and yes the pizza was luke warm. when I got it inside and opened the cover I discovered the all the sauce and toppings were sloshed to the side and on the inside lid of the box. When you are paying 36.00 for a pizza you would hopefully expect it to be warm and arrive within a reasonable time. read more

The delivery was 40 min late , the marinara sauces which I paid extra for was missing , and the worst part the pizza had NO sauce on it! Let me repeat No sauce on the pizza , it was crust , cheese and very little toppings! And the breaded mushrooms were barely breaded. read more

Pizza Pete’s - Very little breading - Pizza Near Me - Cudahy, Wisconsin

See all

Pizza was scrimpy on the toppings. Too salty. The cheese was rubbery not gooey like it should be. Almost wonder if they use fake cheese? We did carry out, so no opinion on service or atomosphere. Sorry to say, probably won't order again. read more

2 hours to get an order delivered 2 miles away? ZERO communication! If you can't manage the orders, don't accept them. Can't give a review on the pizza because it hasn't arrived yet. Poor performance all the way around. read more

First off, if the Dingbat behind the register would answer the phone rather than leave it off the hook you may get more business. I could here it when I went to pick up my pie. Some of us don't want to deal with an App. I want to call and put my order in. She will always be nothing more than a cashier, very low low energy. I had to repeat my order 5 times; thin crust, olives, onions, pepperoni...5 times. Now the pizza; thin crust it is not. When I think of thin crust I think of Neds Pizza. Ned's pizza will always be the very best in town. While the sausage and other toppings were plentiful it needed more sauce. But if it had more sauce the thick "thin" crust would be even more soggy. Not sure if I did get the thin crust. I see that there is a "hand tossed" crust too, however that differs from the thin not real sure. The Dingbat Low Energy cashier probly got the order wrong. The crust sucks. read more

Food arrived completely wrong and the driver was a complete ass and still demanded a tip not only that but when I called the restaurant to explain the issue I got transferred to the owner who was of no help abd refused to do anything regarding it. read more

Amazing pizza! Love the stuffed crust! Mozzarella sticks are also a must have! Can't wait for them to return soon

My wife and I have been waiting for them to open back up after the fire. Well, it was definitely worth the wait! We got a hand tossed pepperoni and cheesy garlic bread. It smelled, looked, and tasted so good. This was our first time having them and we will definitely be back. read more

Pizza was supposed to be here 2 hours ago. Trying to track pizza. Called and they told me the pizza was sent out for delivery "a long time ago". I ordered at 5:10 pm The pizza arrived at 7:45 pm - a full 2 hours after the time I was supposed to get it. Pizza was cold, cheese congealed. I threw it out and had a peanut butter sandwich. I want my money back. read more

They have a great pie. When they make you a good one. Very inconsistent. Not sure if I will get the good one or the no topping, raw or burnt one. Pizza Pete's is good pizza but they need to work on consistency. read more

The 1st couple times I was there the pizza was very good couple times after that I don't know what was different different crust or something but the pizza was terrible they change something read more

We ordered delivery and really enjoyed everything we ordered: the stuffed crust pizza was delicious, and my husband and daughter raved about the Chicago style pizza. They thought it was as good as Giordano's, just without the drive down south to go get it. This is a great new restaurant in Cudahy, and will for sure become our go-to pizza spot. read more

I'll say first off, the food here is actually very good. The problem is delivery. I've only ordered twice. The first time, they didn't show up at all. The second time they were out of one thing we ordered. They didn't call, they just refunded it, so one person had to find something else to eat. I honestly just think it's a communication disconnect between some shops and the Grubhub service. I can't say why some stores have figured it out and others haven't, but I'll probably just get carry out from now on read more

Had stuffed crust pizza for lunch. It was AMAZING! Then for dinner we thought maybe we try the chicken. Wasn't sure what to expect. Chicken was the best I've had in years. I will be back. Thank s is my new favorite spot! Thanks Kim and crew!!! read more

We ordered delivery and it came quick. We got the cheese stuffed crust and it was delicious! For two people a small size pizza was more than enough, we had left overs for both of us. Definitely worth the price. We also ordered mozzarella sticks and they were ginormous! Really really good food and we were very pleased. We will order here again. read more

Ordered delivery, was charged and no pizza delivered, no one answered the phone. Cannot say whether it is good or not and will never know, too many other places to order from that do actually deliver what you order. read more

Excellent delicious authentic pizza soooo good they made a minor mistake on the pizza topping but made it right irregardless!, My 15 year old GROWING BOY loved yet couldn't even finish his chicken strip dinner great portions, fish fry good, pieces were a bit small but excellent!!!!! GREAT PLACE read more

We live very close to Pizza Pete's and have ordered their pizza's twice now and I LOVE the taste. We will for sure order from there again and again. read more