Order Classic Slice Takeout or Delivery
Classic Slice Photos
Classic Slice Popular Dishes
CLASSIC SLICE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Classic Slice
Recommended Reviews - Classic Slice
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Large portion of calzone. Freshly made and extremely hot. The staff us very helpful and friendly. The space is pretty quiet for early lunch on a weekend!
I was in the mood for pizza and I have been here before, but eons ago, so I pulled up. Ordered the lunch special with sausage and pepperoni. That is my barometer for pizza reviews. Cheese only is for toddlers. It came out piping hot, fresh and smelled delicious. I was eating in the truck, and the box was durable and kept me almost perfectly clean, but was cumbersome around the steering wheel. The crust is crispy with a nice char. The sausage is flavorful, spiced up well and a nice texture. Pepperoni had a good zip and was spicier. The sauce had a fresher tomato taste, and not simmered down to a pulp. the price was around $10ish and all the workers were friendly and welcoming. I didn't eat inside, but it is casual and cafeteria like seating. A slam dunk winner for a good lunch spot pick up, but I do recommend eating it at a table. Not all of you are expert car eaters as myself, and I still managed a speck of sauce on my shirt. What I do for you people, let me tell ya!! :)
Call in a to-go order and order was ready perfectly at the time I asked. That was convenient as I was somewhat in a time crunch - so I was super happy. The food was overall decent. The pizza itself had good flavor - we had the Skippey Ahoy. I added carmalized onions and it made it super tasty. We also ordered a Caesar salad - which was really good, but the dressing seemed off. It was very citrusy. The breadsticks were pretty ehhh I don't think I'd order them again. They were basically pizza dough with a garlic butter, but they were pretty dry and boring - we honestly didn't eat them - which was a bummer. I like Classic Slice, but I think they could improve the breadsticks because who doesn't love a good breadstick!!
Classic Slice Pizza - Bayview is truly a classic. You will love their pizza, they have a perfect size slice, and a pretty trendy and cool vibe.
My fiancée and I were hungry and decided to try a new spot. Living in Berkeley and the Bay Area for a long time, this place felt like home. It was retro--the menu, the font on the menu, the cashier even looked like he was the Silent Bob from Clerks. Such a cool place! Now we can get into the pizza. I had a slice of the pepperoni cut into a triangle and the crust was crunchy, thin--but NOT soggy and it was pipping hot! The fiancée had their slice of the week, the Sicilian slice and she ate every last bite. Her crust was a little crunchier--too hard to cut with a knife but she said this is her new fave pizza spot. They also have Dang soda here and give a student discount on slices if you want to come and try it. I'll be back--my taste buds will thank me...my waist size, not so much! Hahaha!
The pizza is fine? But this whole place is wildly overpriced. Two slices of pizza and a side order of three meatballs is $35 and takes 40 minutes... to just heat up. (I ordered at 4:0 PM, for context, would hate to think how long it would have been if it was busy.) Would not recommend this place unless you're desperate or rich.
Fave spot to get a slice of pizza, not only is the Giorgio Moroder pizza my current favorite but I love the seating area that's on the side of the building its always nice during the summer!
Great pizza for vegans and vegetarians! This local Milwaukee neighborhood spot is a great place to grab a slice or a whole pizza. We stopped in and I was thrilled to see the vegan toppings offered which included soy cheese, vegan Italian sausage crumble and a huge vegetable selection! The restaurant is casual, offers wooden long tables, 4 top tables and window bar stool seating. The prices were reasonable and the pizza was thin and crispy and served hot. I would recommend Classic pizza for a quick lunch, dinner or to take a pie home for friends and family. They also serve salads which looked tasty. Street parking is available just outside of the restaurant.
Tried classic slice for the first time and it was pretty good! It was a great thin crust slice and they had plenty of options to choose from. I got my slice to go however they did have seating inside for dining in. While the pizza was good, it didn't have as much flavor as I would hope for. Additionally, it was a little expensive as this slice came in $9 for one slice. The slice was pretty big though. Not a top pizza place for me in Milwaukee but would recommend trying this place out!
Hands down, best pizza in Milwaukee! Made fresh to order, with obvious love, don't skip this spot! Their garlic knots are so good it's almost sinful. From the hot handmade slices with all the toppings you could imagine, to the freshest burrata salad, nothing on this menu should be off limits. Great stop after any night out in Bay View. And the servers are always happy to see you. We'll be regulars for life at this one.
Such a fun little spot in Bayview area! Lots of options on the menu so even my kiddos were happy! Slices as big as their heads! Food was made fresh so there was a bit of a wait which was perfect because we had time to play some of their old school games they have. For being busier place they still answered all my questions and were friendly. The outside area is cute and inviting as well!
8 days ago
First time here and I want to kick myself for not going sooner. The crust on the pizza is perfection. Thin, crispy and with the right amount of chew. The pizza was the star, but the salad and knots were extra too. Counter service with a clean dining area. Highly recommend!!!! read more
3 months ago
Their pizza is really tasty! And I liked that they have varieties that are not basic and boring, that can be found at any place. This is not the typical pizza place and that's a great thing! If their slices don't sound good you can always build you own too. The sides are good and the pizza slices are enormous! read more
When looking for a good pizza in the bay view neighborhood.... Look no further!! Classic slice has delicious pizza by the slice. They have a rotating slice of the week that is always a great combination of flavor. Service is quick and friendly. And the vibe inside is super cool. Arcade games, and good music fill the space and make for a top tier pizza experience! read more
6 months ago
I was in the mood for pizza and I have been here before, but eons ago, so I pulled up. Ordered the lunch special with sausage and pepperoni. That is my barometer for pizza reviews. Cheese only is for toddlers. It came out piping hot, fresh and smelled delicious. I was eating in the truck, and the box was durable and kept me almost perfectly clean, but was cumbersome around the steering wheel. The crust is crispy with a nice char. The sausage is flavorful, spiced up well and a nice texture. Pepperoni had a good zip and was spicier. The sauce had a fresher tomato taste, and not simmered down to a pulp. the price was around $10ish and all the workers were friendly and welcoming. I didn't eat inside, but it is casual and cafeteria like seating. A slam dunk winner for a good lunch spot pick up, but I do recommend eating it at a table. Not all of you are expert car eaters as myself, and I still managed a speck of sauce on my shirt. What I do for you people, let me tell ya!! :) read more
11 months ago
Call in a to-go order and order was ready perfectly at the time I asked. That was convenient as I was somewhat in a time crunch - so I was super happy. The food was overall decent. The pizza itself had good flavor - we had the Skippey Ahoy. I added carmalized onions and it made it super tasty. We also ordered a Caesar salad - which was really good, but the dressing seemed off. It was very citrusy. The breadsticks were pretty ehhh I don't think I'd order them again. They were basically pizza dough with a garlic butter, but they were pretty dry and boring - we honestly didn't eat them - which was a bummer. I like Classic Slice, but I think they could improve the breadsticks because who doesn't love a good breadstick!! read more
2 years ago
My fiancée and I were hungry and decided to try a new spot. Living in Berkeley and the Bay Area for a long time, this place felt like home. It was retro--the menu, the font on the menu, the cashier even looked like he was the Silent Bob from Clerks. Such a cool place! Now we can get into the pizza. I had a slice of the pepperoni cut into a triangle and the crust was crunchy, thin--but NOT soggy and it was pipping hot! The fiancée had their slice of the week, the Sicilian slice and she ate every last bite. Her crust was a little crunchier--too hard to cut with a knife but she said this is her new fave pizza spot. They also have Dang soda here and give a student discount on slices if you want to come and try it. I'll be back--my taste buds will thank me...my waist size, not so much! Hahaha! read more
3 months ago
3 months ago
The pizza is fine? But this whole place is wildly overpriced. Two slices of pizza and a side order of three meatballs is $35 and takes 40 minutes... to just heat up. (I ordered at 4:0 PM, for context, would hate to think how long it would have been if it was busy.) Would not recommend this place unless you're desperate or rich. read more
8 months ago
Fave spot to get a slice of pizza, not only is the Giorgio Moroder pizza my current favorite but I love the seating area that's on the side of the building its always nice during the summer! read more
2 months ago
Great pizza for vegans and vegetarians! This local Milwaukee neighborhood spot is a great place to grab a slice or a whole pizza. We stopped in and I was thrilled to see the vegan toppings offered which included soy cheese, vegan Italian sausage crumble and a huge vegetable selection! The restaurant is casual, offers wooden long tables, 4 top tables and window bar stool seating. The prices were reasonable and the pizza was thin and crispy and served hot. I would recommend Classic pizza for a quick lunch, dinner or to take a pie home for friends and family. They also serve salads which looked tasty. Street parking is available just outside of the restaurant. read more
3 years ago
Tried classic slice for the first time and it was pretty good! It was a great thin crust slice and they had plenty of options to choose from. I got my slice to go however they did have seating inside for dining in. While the pizza was good, it didn't have as much flavor as I would hope for. Additionally, it was a little expensive as this slice came in $9 for one slice. The slice was pretty big though. Not a top pizza place for me in Milwaukee but would recommend trying this place out! read more
1 year ago
Hands down, best pizza in Milwaukee! Made fresh to order, with obvious love, don't skip this spot! Their garlic knots are so good it's almost sinful. From the hot handmade slices with all the toppings you could imagine, to the freshest burrata salad, nothing on this menu should be off limits. Great stop after any night out in Bay View. And the servers are always happy to see you. We'll be regulars for life at this one. read more
Such a fun little spot in Bayview area! Lots of options on the menu so even my kiddos were happy! Slices as big as their heads! Food was made fresh so there was a bit of a wait which was perfect because we had time to play some of their old school games they have. For being busier place they still answered all my questions and were friendly. The outside area is cute and inviting as well! read more
1 year ago
The pizza was phenomenal, some of the best in Milwaukee. Incredible hand pinched sausage, to die for pesto topping, and a great crust that while thin, holds form to eat. read more
10 months ago
10 months ago
2 years ago
Amazing food. Amazing customer service. Late night hours. Delicious homemade ranch. Quick local delivery. I've never, ever had even a slightly bad experience here. Goooooo! read more
1 year ago
3 years ago
Let me start by saying this: I've never been to NY but if I ever do I want my pizza to look and taste like classic slice. One slice is enough to fill you up for 2 days. It's oh so cheesy heaven. They have the regular toppings along with some nice concoctions. The vibe is pretty chill and they have great customer service. It's a small cute retro place and they have arcades ! And a nice little patio. I don't ever wanna have pizza from any other place ever, kudos Home Slice read more
4 years ago
Always great! You get what you expect Shippee ahoy slice is my go to Artichoke dip is a pleasant surprise as well read more
3 years ago
Talk about a good pizza! I was honestly impressed how good the pizza was from here. On top of that Classic Slice is not only a great Pizza spot for meat eaters but also a great Pizza joint for vegetarians and Vegans. Now Classic slice does NY pizza really well, but the vibes in here are also done very well! I ordered pizza to go and got to Classic Slice a little early so the pizza wasn't quite ready. Luckily I had nothing to fear because they had some old school arcade games for 25￠! So my date and I decided to play some Donkey Kong, ( which I did win at I might add), and our pizza was ready before we knew it. Overall spent about 10 minutes in here, but could honestly spend a couple hours here playing these old school arcade games. Now let's talk about the za! So we decided to go the vegetarian route and order LA Dolce. I'm going to be totally honest and say vegetarian pizza is usually not the move for me, so when I say I was impressed I mean I was REALLY IMPRESSED. The slices are huge and really encompass the NY style pizza. The flavors were so well blended I felt like I was eating pure art! Honestly classic slice has given me appreciation for vegetarian pizzas that dozens of other veggie pizzas have never been able to do. So is this the best pizza location in Milwaukee!? It's tough to say, but I will say it is definitely in the top 3 for me. So go ahead and take a cheat day and grab a classic NY slice from Classic Slice! read more
Where do I even begin? I rave about Classic Slice to any friend that hasn't been here before. The vibes are super chill and very welcoming. This is my usually go to spot to share with friends who aren't from Milwaukee or familiar with Bayview. It's a great place to come when you have friends that all have certain pizza topping preferences and here you can get a massive slice with all the toppings. I'd recommend getting the garlic knots to share with your friends or just yourself. When it comes to classic slice bring some playing cards, bring your friends, and get ready to leave with a happy heart and even happier stomach. The slices remind me of a classic New York style pizza but with an added selection of flavors and topping. read more
3 years ago
Classic Slice: Let me be upfront that my preferred style of pizza is pan because I love a thick, soft, chewy crust. Classic Slice serves hand tossed pies and individual slices. I was invited to dinner here by a family member that was visiting because a large number of vegan options are offered and my family member is vegan. Without going on too much of a tangent don't ask for my opinion on veganism or vegan pizza (honestly, pizza is not pizza without cheese!) because I'll probably offend you. The restaurant is also known for its ridiculously enormous individual slices. I got a slice of cheese pizza because I use it as my standard for judging a pizza parlor and lets face it, I love cheese pizza. I won't deny that my slice was not gigantic, but when I first started eating it I was a little disappointed because it was smaller than I expected. Good news is that my eyes are bigger than my stomach. While I managed to finish the entire slice, I was indeed stuffed. The cheese pizza was good, but other than its size it was nothing to write home about. Customer service is not great though (I emailed them a question over a week go and never got a response). Recommended if you like thin crust pizza, are vegan, or enjoy oversized food. My top MKE pizza parlors: 1. Pizza Shuttle 2. Pizzeria Scotty 3. Marco's (on Howell) *Review from 2019 read more
Classic Slice is one of my favorite pizza spots. The slices are pretty big you could order one of their specialties slices or you can build your own, vegans and vegetarians are also welcomed. They also have board/card games so you can just play some games with your friends while eating pizza with. I definitely recommend it. read more
WOW I'm a Chicago guy and I have a favorite pizza place but I have to say that this place has some good pizza. The place itself is very cool and has some great bones from the past with exposed brick walls, high ceiling with the the old school metal truss work held together with rivets. The space is wide open with stools along the wall of windows, bench seating on the opposite wall with a long community table in the middle. A couple old school video game machines are at the front entrance which was cool. I really like the concep here which is order a whole pizza with many options from the menu or a slice of one of them or the build your own pizza and even build your own slice. You could come in with a group of 10 people and everyone could have a different giant slice of pizza and be happy. While looking the menu over I saw the fresh dough getting tossed and not to be difficult but I didn't care for any of the menu pizzas so the 4 topping build your own slice was what I did. I'm going to get a little nuts with my slice and get sausage, spinach, mozzarella, goat cheese with red sauce. WOW when I opened up the box it looked fuc#ing amazing and everything looked very fresh on that huge well topped slice. I have never had this combination before and OMG that's fuc#ing delicious. The spinach taste got lost in translation with the tasty fennel sausage and rich goat cheese being the dominant flavors. The crust was really good also because it was thin with a nice balance of crisp vs chewy with that dusty golden toasted bottom. All the fresh ingredients really makes the difference here and it shows in the quality of the food. Wow if you want some great fresh pizza or want just a slice and have it your way than this is the place to go to because they do a great job. read more
2 years ago
2 years ago
Page 1 of 12
More info about Classic Slice
Ask the Community - Classic Slice
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
33 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
8 years ago
8 years ago
16 years ago
15 years ago
12 years ago
14 years ago
2 years ago
8 years ago
10 years ago
5 years ago
8 years ago
12 years ago
4 years ago
11 years ago
12 years ago
4 years ago
18 years ago
13 years ago
12 years ago
18 years ago
