Missed the mark... I was starving after a long ski day and since it was the only thing open in the area, I decided to give it a shot. I got the Margherita pizza. It didn't have any sauce... there was a heavy layer of cheese which wasn't great. There were a handful of tomatoes. Margherita I expect a balanced pie with good sauce base. The staff were friendly enough when picking up and the space is small good for pickup or delivery. The pizza is not my favorite giving it two stars because the people were kind and they were the only thing open at night. read more

Pizza One Avon - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

See all

I tried to call and ask a question about how they prepare their gluten free pizza. Despite their message directing you to press 1 to ask a quick question, they did not pick up during any of the 3 calls I made. If you are celiac like me--or have any food allergies--I'd stay away from here, unless they're able to reliably answer questions before arriving read more

Pizza was ok. Salads were small. All was overpriced. They made me purchase parmigiana cheese for $2. It was a tiny cup most pizzerias would just give you. It was visibly moldy. Bummer. read more

Grabbed pizza and wings for the Super Bowl. Showed up on time for pickup and both were only warm. Wings ordered extra crispy with bbq sauce and they were decent. Supreme Pizza was only average. Crust wasn't memorable and little flavor. Could've used more toppings. Service was good. read more

Pizza One Avon - 14" Large Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

See all

Good-not great:) I am an avid pizza maker and orderer.. crust is thin but lacks character-not chewy or pillowy-just there. Sauce is also good- not exceptional. I guess for a small place like Avon - this is great.. but they can up their game and make it memorable. Just my opinion:) read more

Terrible pizza. The service was horrible. We paid $90 for a small pizza and dessert. Dessert showed up frozen. If you are considering this pizza, order Domino's instead. Way better pizza and value for your money. read more

after boycotting the popular pizza place in Avon their absolutely horrible treatment of me and other guests that I've observed. I've been frequenting all of the other pizza establishments in the valley this year. We recently tried pizza one in Avon after great experiences at Gondola Pizza (Avon), Marko's (Edwards) and Il Mago (Edwards). Pizza One has a great online ordering system and understand they have multiple locations, but this is the only one we've tried so far. We ordered online through the site and picked it up at their location near Walmart and Home Depot in East Avon. The pizza was very good. A generous amount of toppings and cheese and a delicious crust. Our order was ready when promised and we didn't receive any nastiness the popular local Avon pizza, places dish out. To the contrary, the server greeted me with a smile, was courteous, and thanked me with a smile. Didn't even mind that my Doodle was tethered to the front door when I ran into to pick up my pie. I'm adding Pizza One to my regular rotation of pizza places!!! read more

This was my first time ordering from pizza one and I now have a new favorite pizza spot. They even attached a hand written note to my receipt. Its the little things that make me happy with a restaurant read more

Awesome options for those gluten free, dairy free, and intone looking for lighter pizza option. They offer vegan sausage, vegan cheese, cauliflower crust ( not dairy free), and GF crust. We got the GF crust and vegan cheese on half the pizza. The crust was perfect! It held up to the toppings and cheese and did not crumble with each bite. The vegan cheese was excellent and the perfect amount was used. We ordered delivery to our hotel room in Beaver Creek and the food was delivered exactly at the time predicted during my online checkout. Couldn't have been any easier! We will absolutely be eating here again in the future. read more

Pizza One Avon - GF crust with vegan cheese - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

Pizza was very good and the wait was minimal. Prices were reasonable too. It was hot by the time we got it home

Had surgery in Vail, delivery is sparse this time of year. This place was available via DoorDash. Fees were a little steep on the app, but I love supporting the locals. Had a gluten free pizza, was pretty tasty. The garlic bread was a little heavy, but had a great garlic taste. The side salad was super fresh. This has always been my go to pizza place when staying in Vail. read more

Pizza One Avon - Cheese sticks. I requested a side of pesto sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

See all

Best gluten free, diary free pizza I have had! It was actually, like, really good! If you've had gluten free, diary free pizza's before, you know that most taste absolutely awful. To be honest, I didn't even want pizza for dinner, and was bracing myself for your typical gluten free, diary free pizza, but I was in for a treat and really glad I tried it! I ordered the gluten free, diary free, egg free crust, with vegan cheese, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, peppers, and olives. I also got a side of sauce. I placed my order online. After I placed my order, the website said my pizza would be ready in 22 minutes. I really don't know if I arrived early, late, or right on time, but my pizza was ready when I got there. The man behind the counter was very nice and upbeat. He helped me right away. After I paid and got the pizza in my car, I had to open it and sneak a peak (it smelled amazing).....it looked fantastic, just full of veggies!! I got home and opened the pizza, it was still hot. I had two slices and it was fantastic. I was disappointed that I couldn't eat a third, but am excited for leftover pizza later. The gluten free crust was thin and crispy. I am glad I had the extra sauce to dip it in. I will return the next time I am in Vail. PS. I have no doubt the regular crust, regular cheese pizza's are great here if the gluten free, diary free one was great! Enjoy! read more

Pizza One Avon - Build Your Own Pizza (gluten free crust, vegan cheese, and lots of veggies)! Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

See all

Are you kidding me?!?! Talk about delivery performance; they must employ an F1 driver to operate the car and a sprinter to run the hallways of Beaver Creek's hotels with your meal. Ordered two pizzas, bread, mozzarella sticks, a salad. This was 6pm the week after Christmas when Beaver Creek is insanely busy with every property running at capacity. We were in the furthest possible room you can have at the Park Hyatt Beaver Creek; top floor, last room on the floor at the edge of the building. It had been snowing for seven days straight and the roads were questionable. The food showed up in 45 minutes to our hotel room door! It was good on top of that! The drive from them to the Hyatt alone is ~14 minutes, and walking the floor from the elevator at normal pace is another three; wow! Want more? We placed the order on their website without even having to bother through the time waste of a phone call. It gave us a time slot for the order. It gave us 5% off for paying cash, which beats my 2% credit card rebate. That is how you do it! read more

I didn't love Pizza One and crossed them off of the list of potential return visits. I ordered a chicken, feta and pesto pizza, salad and garlic wings. It was all very average. Average is the kiss of death when you are surrounded by so many really great restaurants. The pizza and wings were delivered lukewarm. This was more of a problem for the pizza. It zapped all of the flavor out of the finished product and left the crust overly chewy and near tasteless. The wings were wrapped in foil and looked like they were cooked long before I ordered them. The meat fell from the bones and needed the abundance of sauce to add moisture and revive them. read more

See all

Pizza One is a gem hidden in a strip mall by the Wal Mart in Avon. It's not fancy or pretentious, just a great takeout pizza joint. They have online ordering or you can call them. We got the American Pizza (mushrooms, pepperoni, extra cheese and sausage) which was fantastic. We also got several salads which were extremely fresh with high quality lettuce -- more than I was expecting. Highly recommend -- my favorite pizza in Beaver Creek, Avon and Edwards. read more

Pizza One Avon - American Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

Lots of great choices, all of them delicious! Staff is friendly and you get a free pizza after your ninth pizza!

Pizza One is the best pizza in the Vail Valley. They use great ingredients and consistently make the best. The owners are extremely nice as well. read more

This is the place to get pizza! What makes this place different is the sauce they use when making pizza and the dough. The sauce almost has a sweet taste to it. The location it self is pretty small. A large table and a small eating section up against the wall for more people to come in and eat. The staff is extremely friendly they also give you plates to use when eating inside. As for the drivers these guys are funny. I haven't used the delivery service but when we are eating inside they always smile and make jokes with people inside. The only draw back is the bathroom is in another part of the building. Other then that this is where you take your friends to eat pizza. They also have an in house reward program for frequent visitors :) read more

Pizza One Avon - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

One word to describe this meal- dry. We ordered a few pizzas for the family and overall were underwhelmed. We got an XL bbq chicken pizza, an XL supreme pizza, a gluten free veggie pizza, hot chicken wings and bbq chicken wings. Our food was delivered promptly and was still warm when it reached us. The pizza all has thin crust and good quality ingredients but they all felt dry- I think the core problem is with their crust recipe. The supreme pizza especially felt as if it was lacking enough sauce. The bbq pizza had more sauce and was better but couldn't make up for the dryness of the crust. I didn't try the gluten free pizza but I didn't hear any complaints about it. The bbq chicken wings were decent with bbq sauce drizzled over their oven baked wings. And the hot wings were some kind of dry rub, further contributing to the dryness of the meal. Overall I was pretty disappointed with this meal. I'd be willing to eat the wings again but will definitely pass on the pizza unless they revamp their crust recipe. read more

Pizza One Avon - Supreme pizza- looked delish but with very little sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

See all

I should have taken the bus into Vail and gone to Pazzos. Ordered through Uber Eats. Pizza arrived late and barely luke warm. Supermarket frozen pizza quality at best. Buyer beware. read more

Great pizza!! Ordered online and paid in cash for discount. We just got takeout but it ready quickly and in the time promised.

I didn't care for this pizza. Update: after posting a more descriptive review, I received a very nice note from the owner or manager who expressed his concern. He offered to refund the cost of my order (which he did) and highlighted that they are updating their ground beef based upon my feedback. While I was not a fan of the pizza, I give them credit for the follow up. I also recognize that pizza preferences are personal, and obviously given the number of positive Yelp reviews, people like it. To that, I updated my original review and increased the star rating. read more

Pizza One Avon - Pizza with ground beef (or rabbit droppings - you be the judge). - Pizza Near Me - Avon, Colorado

We had a big order, enough to feed 13 people. The pizza was ready right on time and all of the pizzas tasted great! I will definitely be back to Pizza One Avon. read more

Pizza was great. 8 sr. guys on ski trip and we orders 3 large supreme pizzas for delivery. They were as appetizing as it looks in the web site pics. Delivery was estimated 55 min but arrived in 45. Gonna keep this number for next years trip. We were a little hesitant at first because only 39 reviews, but the negative reviews had nothing to do with food quality. I recommend this place for pizza. read more

Favorite pizza spot in Vail Valley. Hands down. We get a large pepperoni bacon and jalapeño pizza and it's excellent each time. Delivery is also very fast and convenient. read more

This was a great grab and go option in our first night in Vail. Only a few miles from our place, 2 pizzas were ready in 35 minutes! I didn't get any pics since the pizzas were gobbled up in minutes! read more

Best delivery pizza in the Eagle Valley. Wish they delivered to Wildridge. Would be willing to pay a premium delivery fee.

Ordered over $50 worth of food and after an hour and a half I called to find out the food hadn't even been picked up by the delivery service yet (would have been nice to receive notice from the business earlier). I offered to pick up the food myself and had a chat with Tony, the owner to try and figure out a solution. After I rejected his insistence I pay extra on top of what I was already charged he rudely added-- "you're not eating here tonight, go to domino's or something" and hung up on me. It seems he aggressively combs over these reviews and refutes any negative feedback with disdain. Others have mentioned there's a potential for fake positive reviews padding the restaurant's rating and it wouldn't surprise me if this were true given my experience. read more

One of the best pizza's I have had. Was passing thru on I 70 heading west and found them on the web. I am from Oklahoma City and would definitely consider driving back for another. Highly recommend you give them a try. Those guys were very friendly and helpful. read more

We got a meat lovers regular crust and a cauliflower crust with white sauce both were super tasty, loved all the topping choices available . It was finished in time they said. read more

Absolutely delicious and easily the best meal we had during our trip which is saying a lot. The next time we return to the area we will be sure to frequent this restaurant multiple times. I wish they had one where I live! The service was great, also. We elected to pick up the pizza ourselves and the gentleman who helped me could not have been nicer. A great experience al around! read more

Good pizza.....extra cheese pizza was quite good. Felt the multi topping pizzas got a bit expensive, but good pizza option if taking pizza to go. read more

I had low expectations when I ordered pizza on a Friday night, during an Av's Stanley Cup playoff game for 35 people. I figured something would probably be wrong with the order or we'd all be starving, but I was pleasantly surprised. Not only did they get everything right, but when I called them to ask about finding plates for the group, my call was dropped as I drove through the mountains and they called ME back to make sure I had everything I needed. Excellent customer service, especially in these times! read more

Wanted a quick pizza and salad - both were great and the salad tasted fresh, not like it came out of a bag! We will return!

Seriously I cannot express how fantastic this place is to not only have gluten free/dairy free crust but to also offer VEGAN CHEESE! No other pizza place in this valley offers this and their pizza is delicious! Thank you Pizza One for being inclusive of people with food intolerances! read more

The pizza was amazingly GOOD! More than I expected! Great flavors and authentic! I am a local and I recommend!

Pepperoni w extra cheese...wow...it was on point. Definitely recommend. Delivery was in 30 minutes too.

The ingredients are fresh. The crust is superb. In a town where everything is expensive, this is a very cheap meal for two.

Great pizza, excellent service (ordered 6 large multi-topping pizzas, all properly prepared). Definitely recommend.

Man, for a great pizza in Beaver Creek, you have to check out Pizza One, after being disappointed with another higher end restaurant in town, some Pizza One pizza was needed to hit the spot late night! We ordered the American Pizza which was phenomenal. Good pizza/sauce/topping ratio with a doughy medium crust. This is how fast pizza is supposed to taste! And they deliver! read more