I've tried again since this business changed hands. I waited too long. Much tastier than my previous experience. Fast and friendly service. Great toppings average crust and sauce. Fans of Pappa Murphys will really appreciate this place. It's the best take & bake around. read more

This is our first time here we drove from Denver to come have pizza here my wife found this place online I will say that this is super delicious unbelievable. Much better I think than that other place that's in Idaho Springs. I won't say the name of it, but it starts with a B. Lol we will definitely be back here. The workers here are super nice as well. read more

See all

This is a true hidden gem that we heard about from a local resident near the Keystone resort. It was totally worth the short drive into Silverthorne to this little spot in the easy-access shopping area for picking up pizzas to take home and eat at the cabin after a day of skiing. The women at the counter are friendly and went the extra mile to make sure every order they handed out was correct - they really know how to make their customers happy! The pizza tasted fresh, generous toppings spread close to the edge, perfectly cooked with a crust that is that magical combo of crispy and chewy - highly recommend! read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - 3 pizzas for the family, love it when the pepperoni is baked on the top - and the crust was perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

We spent 30$ on a pizza yesterday and it could've been done by digorno for 7.99. They hit us with a 'baked pizza tax' as well as a 'customer service fee' that ended up cost 30% more. One 16' pizza should never cost that much and it didn't even come with tomato sauce on it. I would recommend dominos or eating snow instead. Probably worth your time and money more. read more

I'm really disappointed with my most recent experience with Nick-N-Willy's Pizza. It's unfortunate that what looked like a great deal turned into a letdown. They had an appealing offer on Yelp. The deal was "Pay $8 for a $17 value". Sounds great, right? It prompted us to drive all the way across the town for this deal. When we got there to take advantage of the supposed deal, however, we were told the offer was fake. At first, the staff claimed they had no knowledge of the offer being advertised on Yelp. Then, when challenged, their story suddenly switched to "we've attempted to reach Yelp about this issue with no success." They wanted us to believe that Yelp is somehow trying to sabotage their business by posting fake deals solely because they don't advertise on Yelp's platform. Clearly a lie. Be wary if you're considering accepting any offers from them. You may wind up wasting time and energy like we did. I believe respecting customers' time and offering clear, genuine deals are essential in any business. Sadly, this experience at Nick-N-Willy's Pizza was devoid of these. AVOID for now until they sort out their operations! read more

Thanks for saving us from certain starvation! It was 8pm and hardly anything was open but we stumbled upon Nick N Willy's and we made it another day. You can order online or via phone, making it so convenient. The prices are so reasonable and they offer so many toppings and varieties of pizza (including gluten free) so if you can't find something you like here, you got bigger fish to fry. Can't wait to go back again and again. read more

Way overpriced for the quality. The chicken wings were burned and extremely spicy, despite not being asked for that level of heat. When I politely asked to have them taken back or exchanged, the manager flat-out refused. Very poor customer service and disappointing experience overall. Definitely not worth the money. read more

I used to go to Nick n Willy's all the time when I was kid and honestly pizza has not been the same since they all started closing (only remaining locations being this one and in Boulder). So stopping at this location was super nostalgic and hit the spot just like it did years ago. I got a personal (which is a great size for one person) pizza with pineapple and a Caesar salad. My boyfriend got the Nick n Willy's classic and he also enjoyed this place especially on his first time ever trying it. My parents used to love the wild Willy combo so considering I do not live close to this location, you can bet that I got one to go hehe. I think besides the high quality of food, the staff was really the cherry on top. They are so nice and make sure you don't need anything so really top tier service. As a kid, my Nick n Willy's used to have honey bottles because their crust with honey was great. I asked for honey and the employee went to the back and found an almost empty bottle but offered to warm it for me which is very kind of them since they were technically going out of their way to make sure I had everything I wanted. Also I must point out, they have GREAT music taste, felt like they were playing my playlist lol. It is a small location with limited seating but it is such a clean and cozy environment and it felt very family owned which is always a plus. I super recommend this place/location as their food will fulfill your hunger (especially after skiing) as well as the service will leave you feeling cared for. 10/10 recommend read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Pineapple pizza with red onions and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

See all

Me and my boyfriend's favorite pizza spot in Silverthorne. Their pizza is always amazing and staff is very polite and sweet to us. They have a great taste of music in the restaurant as well. Looking forward to going back!!!! read more

Quick and easy! Delicious, classic pizza and friendly staff. We ordered cheese with black olives and oregano..yummy!

This place is your standard small town pizza shop. The staff were friendly and the pizza was pretty good.

Perfect little spot to grab a bite! We were on our way to the mountains and stopped here for some pizza and it was good! Nothing bad about it, just wasn't the best pizza ever. They also have a patio, so we were able to sit outside with our dogs which is always a plus. read more

Ok so -- new owners are amazing. An entirely new vibe. Take and bake options are plentiful. They customize if you don't like what you see. Personal size pizza is killer for one. Salads to add. Recommend. read more

Awesome variety on the menu! Very quick and yummy. They cooked and we took it out. Fun variety of hot sauces and there are some inside bar seats if you're looking to stay in one place. Friendly staff! Thanks! read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Garden veggie - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

My partner and I were on our way back from rafting in kremmling and were starving. Stopped by and grabbed a quick bite to eat. Super fast and was very sweet. Great vibes. Fun and funky music. OUT OF THIS WORLD PIZZA. wow I did not expect it to taste this good but damn! read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Garlic Cheese Bread - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

See all

Service was friendly and great. We got take out but there is a small area to eat inside. Our pizzas were amazing. Highly recommend this place. read more

Drove in by accident, my dog was nervous in the car ride, we came to this plaza. It's next to TJ Max. This pizza place is run by two beautiful ladies, they are so professional and sweet. These ladies have HAPPY faces, it makes our eating there, so enjoyable. We ordered the Hawaiian Kahuna, it had bacon and pineapple and a little surprise to me orange slices in the pizza. It was thin crest, that's how we like it. It was just right and very delicious, it filled our hunger. And this place provided with a special spice sauce that you can use on their pizza. I wish you sell whatever that secret sauce was. It was yummy. Thank you for providing a beautiful experience! Muah read more

The pizza was amazing! It only took about 7 minutes to cook, and we played complimentary chess while we waited. The two owners were working on a Sunday night! They are committed to their business. It was a small restaurant, but the delicious food was what we remembered! read more

Pizza was AMAZING and the employees and the owners, Lily and Patty where so kind and sweet. You do not want to miss out on this outstanding pizza. read more

Ordered LG pepperoni and got a $20 cheese pizza. Wasn't super stoked on that. Should have open the box before I left I guess. Tip: check your pizza before you walk out. read more

Good food. New management. My favorite take home and bake pizza. Across from Lolita's. Good corner for hanging out on weekends. read more

Post-ski pizza and Nick n Willy's does it right! We found this location thanks to Yelp. Located in a shopping center just off I-70, it's a convenient, delicious, and fast way to get a meal in the mountains. We got the lunch special- $12 for a 12" medium pizza, two toppings, and two drinks. You can also get an individual 8" pizza with two toppings and one drink for $6. Pizzas are all made fresh and bake quickly. If it's available, be sure to check for the Yelp deals- we bought the $17 for $8 deal, but also saw a 15% off. Only small note- the restroom is in the back of the restaurant and you have to walk through the kitchen. Not a biggie, and the staff is welcome to you using it- but just a heads up. Staff was incredibly friendly! We'll be back! read more

See all

Pizza and garlic bread were good but by no means spectacular. It's convenient. Tried to call in an order for pick up a few days later because I was on a job site with no oven while working in the area and they ran out of boxes. That is not a mistake. "They ran out of boxes"and only offered taken bake option to go. This town needs a good artisan pizza and it doesn't have one now. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Family size good pizza and garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Pizza is average. They offer two different coupons on this app, however, the ladies working there claim they know nothing about said coupons and WILL NOT honor them. I don't know why they don't just take them down, I chose that place specifically because of their deals and it turns out it's just false advertisement. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - The coupons they DON'T HONOR - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Wait: I ordered ahead of time and there was no wait to get my pizza! 5 large pizzas took about 30 minutes to make which is amazing Service: the kids working the counter looked happy to be there and were helpful in getting all my extra toppings, plates, and napkins Good: this pizza was soooooo good. They added lots of toppings and had such interesting flavors. My favorite was the garlic chicken bacon pizza. There Hawaiian has pinapple AND mandarin oranges which I thought was super unique and tasty. Other: this was a great post snowboarding meal and I'd come back again. There's plenty of parking and they accept credit card read more

The food here is absolutely delicious no complaints at all. The place is kinda small, but the place is clean, nicely decorated, and has a few board games to play while you wait for your food. The wait time is not a lot, and the staff is very friendly, and are willing to help when clients need something else. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - The Earthborn Pizza with bacon and pepperoni added - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Very good I got breadsticks with Nicks meat lovers pizza for $35. Feels a little expensive but I'm not from around here so I'm not sure of the going rates. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Great pizza. Never would have expected that in Colorado, Aldo try the empanadas next door. Both places are delicious

Awesome pizza, nice staff and it smells incredible inside the business. Yelp menu prices are outdated but I've uploaded the current menu with current prices. Also you can visit their website directly for more info/current specials and prices. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Updated menu 2/12/23 - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

See all

We were unaware that this was a "take and bake" type pizzeria. When we picked up our pizza and brought it back to the hotel and was NOT informed we were supposed to bake it. Staying at a hotel we had no way to make our $60 pizzas. Very upset. read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - We asked for a peperoni pizza and got a cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Kind of a hole in the wall type of place. Was great pizza, prices were reasonable. We will definitely stop by here again. Easy to get off I70 and get back on. Staff was friendly. read more

Good pizza to go!! They have good vegetarian options and are willing to do 1/2 and 1/2 pizzas to satisfy families with different food requirements. read more

Fantastic pizza! We found this after skiing Keystone. Super fast, super delicious, super friendly. We'll definitely be here again.

Such great staff and the pizzas are so very worth it! Yummm yumm yummy Don't forget your wings while ordering! read more

After working in the pizza industry for over 5 years I have been disappointed more often than not from pizzas I get, Not only did I get my food very fast it was delicious and perfectly cooked, i could taste how fresh the dough and ingredients were. Highly recommend the BBQ chicken read more

Personal pizzas were a little smaller than I thought they were going to be but they were loaded with toppings! Despite the size they were filling and really fresh! The wait was about 10-20 minutes but what do you expect for a fresh pizza? Also $4 for the garlic bread and it's way larger in size! I'd def come back. Staff is also super friendly! read more

Good pizza choices in Summit are limited but this is probably the best you can get. It's nothing spec but always hits thr spot when crazing pizza. read more

We dropped by Nick-N-Willy's Pizza to pick up pizza since it was right by our hotel. I really enjoyed the pizza we ordered. We ordered a garden veggie pizza and a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. They were really generous with the toppings and it seemed fresh. It wasn't overly greasy either. It's not the best pizza, but satisfying. I also enjoyed the wings. read more

See all

The pizza was good! I wish they had a few more amenities like kids cups or straws though. The extras are nice for travelers.

Was okay, pretty expensive for what it was, but that's true for most of the area. Prices on yelp are not at all accurate.