Growing up in Boston, I've had my share of excellent pizza over the years. So when my band was recently in Dillon, Colorado and I saw that they had East Coast style pizza... Of course I was skeptical. Boy, did they change my mind! The pizza was fantastic. The Philly cheese steaks were great. And the Buffalo wings were straight out of Buffalo. They wanted me to post a picture of my food, but I was too hungry and this is all I could muster up. Ha ha! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Pretty solid pizza spot with some good options. I liked the all meat and the pepperoni the most. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

We had a 14 inch Works pizza. It was delicious!!! It's a fun local atmosphere & everything is made from scratch. They also have a nice selection of local beers. Highly recommend! read more

Hands down best pizza joint in the Rockies! First off, the wings are incredible. Perfectly cooked with just the right amount of crisp on the outside and juicy on the inside. Not to mention the quality and size of the wings are next to none. All the flavors are DELICIOUS, but the Honey Old Bay ones are the absolute BEST! I literally have dreams about these wings. The pizza is just as awesome. The crust has that ideal texture--crispy yet chewy--and the toppings are fresh and generous without overwhelming the pie. You can tell there's real care put into every pizza that comes out of the kitchen. Scrappy's has a laid-back vibe that makes you want to hang out, whether you're there with friends, family, or just grabbing a quick bite. Last but not least, I have to mention Nick, the owner. He clearly takes pride in what he does and goes out of his way to make sure customers feel welcome and taken care of. That personal touch really elevates the whole experience. Between the wings, the pizza, the atmosphere, and the hospitality, Scrappy's absolutely delivers. I can't wait to go back again and again! PS: They have great Scrappy happy hour deals and DELICIOUS ranch read more

Scrappy's is a must-visit! The pizza was outstanding, the Philly Cheesesteak was incredible, and the Old Bay Wings were absolutely phenomenal. Nick and his team went above and beyond to make our experience amazing. "We'll definitely be back and can't wait to explore more of the menu!" Kim C. read more

We did a take out pizza and LOVED it! Great service and price is what you would expect in a tourist area! We will definitely order again- the next time we stay in Dillon! read more

Best food / pizza I have had in Colorado. Super affordable and the sweet Thai chili wings were the best wings I have had in my life. We also ate the fried ravioli, pizza by the slice and the margarita pizza and everything was phenomenal! You better come here ! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - So good I ate it before the picture - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Wow! We were so pleasantly surprised by the wonderful pizza, service, and views from the patio!!!! We will definitely be back. We hear their cheesesteak sandwiches are awesome!!!! read more

Amazing food and even better atmosphere! Great place to get dinner after skiing. Cheesesteak was great!

Scrappy's was yummy pizza with superior service! The staff went above and beyond to take care of us! They have games in the dinning area for kids if they still have energy after skiing all day! The Margaritaville pizza was the family favorite! read more

See all

Excellent food. Great vibe. Definitely worth a stop if you are in the area. Amazing selection of local Colorado beers on tap. Owner and employees care and I feel like that is rare but definitely nice to see. I highly recommend. read more

Pizza was excellent. Nick and his team make for a great experience. I came back for a second night on a row.

Scrappy wasn't here today but I did get to meet Helen. I would of loved to have given this place a five but it barely gets three. Really sad because I did love Helen and the place is cute. Pizza wasn't cooked very well, toppings were poor, hardly any sauce and it wasn't cut, argh! YOU ALL NEED TO KICK IT UP A NOTCH! read more

See all

Great service! Friendly staff, and checked in on us several times. The small Italian chop salad was yummy, and big enough to share. We also really enjoyed the BBQ chicken pizza. 14" can feed 3-4 depending on hunger level. Crust was just right thickness and plenty of toppings. Great meal before our concert at the amphitheater! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - BBQ chicken 14" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

See all

Ordered the gluten free cauliflower pizza with pepperoni. I thought there could have been more topping on it. Crust was good but the rest was kinda limp. Also ordered the house salad which comes already made up with tomatoes, iceberg lettuce, and croutons. There are fountain sodas and bottles to choose from. Inside and outside dining is available. Staff is friendly and helpful. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

See all

Everything about Scrappys is great! Loved the vegan pizza! And my kids loved playing the ring game. A great place to go for a relaxed dinner with family. read more

Came here for pizza on a Monday night around 6 pm. Lots of room in the parking lot and many open tables. The lady behind the counter was friendly and welcoming. We ordered a small bbq cheese pizza for ~$27. The pizza was pretty big and average. Not the worst pizza but not my favorite. I thought it was a little expensive and wish the pizzas came in different sizes. I probably should've just ordered slices individually. The pizza was very filling. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Enjoyed the Gnarnivore pizza and a salad. Friendly staff - close to our hotel. Outside seating was great.

Great Pizza Again.. BBQ Chicken is Awesome - Hand Tossed. Service is Great & Order on Line - Pulled out of Oven as I walked In. Thanks Again. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - BBQ Chicken!!! - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Pizza was delicious and the staff is very kind. The New York style pizza was very authentic, and the crust was cooked perfectly. The ambiance is truly unique. We enjoyed playing foosball and Pac-Man while our pizza was cooking, which brought back good memories. We will definitely come back again soon! read more

New Owners I am told pizza is really really good unexpected. Hope they keep up the good work.

I really wanted to love this place. The prices are ridiculous... $20 for what they say is 14" but it sure seems smaller. $24 or $28 (?) for the larger one. The thing I find insulting is when you order on the website, you HAVE to leave a tip for takeout. WHY!? I'm driving there in a snowstorm to pick it up to save the delivery charge, yet, I have to pay it anyway? And, the options are 25%, 20%, and 15%... for TAKE OUT. There's no "no tip" option... that's on top of already overpaying for pizza. Then, the pizza was so sloppy, looked like ovals. And, it was under-cooked, chewy like dough. Plus, they are super skimpy on toppings. I always want to support local spots instead of chains but I wish I went to a chain place instead... at least you know what you're getting. read more

We had a spontaneous family gathering at the park that needed a lot of food and Jay and the team at Scrappy's made some great pizzas! Highly recommend. read more

I've been coming here since this place was called Jersey Boys pizza, under a previous owner. The new owner renamed it Scrappy's and changed the rock, Led Zeppelin, album-covers-as-decor into a place with a Scooby Doo groove vibe. While the new owner changes the vibe, she inherited the pizza recipe. The previous owner grew up in the Jersey town next to the one where I was raised. And his pizza was a slice of East Coast heaven. Under new ownership, the pizza had largely tasted the same. Thin, foldable crust; a bite if oregano in that sweet sauce or "gravy," for you Eas Coasters. Last night, however, while the pizza was still good, it wasn't quite as good. I think the crust was a little too thin, and it definitely didn't have enough pizza sauce. The dining room corners were pretty dirty, and the bathroom looked like people were living in it. That being said, the staff is attentive and nice. And it's easy enough to toss a little more red gold on the pizza and run a mop through the dining room, so it won't deter me. I'll be back. read more

See all

Pretty disappointing, skip it if you're on the fence. Really wanted a local joint to be good but idk what they are doing in there. It's super overpriced for what you get both in product and service. The employees were sitting around playing switch and didn't give us marinara for the breadsticks. Got our first pizza without sauce, it was bbq chicken so we figured they would just give us a swirl on top after we let them know. They insisted on making a brand new pie which was nice but after a 15 min wait then they barely put any bbq sauce on it anyways... so that's confusing? The pie tastes fine, but 30+ dollars for a large pizza with barely any toppings and a couple squirts of BBQ sauce is pretty wild. Save your money, go down the street for the other options. The branding and the colorful inside is cute tho, just wish the pizza and attention to detail matched the premium price. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - BBQ chicken pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

I haven't had much pizza in Summit County because honestly the ones I have had were not very good. Thankfully Scrappy's recently opened to fix that problem!! The pizza here is great!! We did a build you own 18" pie...it was HUGE and tasty!! I really want to try the Philly pizza next time we are in. The staff was super friendly when we picked up our pizza. I liked the fun wall art inside as well. Looking forward to dining in once we can!! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - BIG Pies! - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

WOOOOO MAN what can I say, We got done working a 3 hour appetite from the lily pad trail and we saw this place, Looks pretty nice! LOVED the lobby, The moment I entered I was greeted with a huge whiff of nostalgia. Man don't even let me tell you about the owner, He was super nice, Actually I don't know if he's the owner but he's super cool. The pizza was INSANE. It was so good, There's multiple other pizza stores in the area, But NOTHING you hear me NOTHING compares to this. unbelievably crispy, This lowkey sounds like I got paid, But im just happy this place brought me back to my childhood. Yall gotta check it out. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - BUILD your own WITH FRESH INGREDIENTS - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

See all

Some amazing meaty chicken wings with a honey and Old Bay dry rub. Showed up during dinner rush after a day of skiing and sat at the bar. Looks like it is a popular place hidden in a little nook where you have to know it's there. read more

This place is da bomb! 4 of us from out of town decided to try it since it had great reviews and beers on tap. Service was excellent, vibe was chill and the food was amazing. We had 3 different pizzas and all were fantastic. The vegan cheese margherita pizza was probably the best pizza I've ever had. Can't wait to go back next time we are in town. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Large pie? Nahhhh. They said this would feed 6. Don't think so. Pizza was mediocre, kind of chewy. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Bruh. This is a large pie? - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Traveling from out of town, found Scappys on a whim. Kiddo who loves Scooby Doo loved the decor and games. Pizza was amazing; sad we don't live here to be regulars. Service was excellent, the vibes for dine in fantastic. Full bar and local brews on tap. 10/10. read more

See all

Scrappys is Crappy! The woman tried to charge me $160 for 3 large pizzas. When I tried to explain she must not have heard me correctly, she hung up. read more

Great pizza. Great staff 2 slice lunch special is a great deal. Good place to hangouts read more

Don't bother. Paid almost $70 for two fettuccine alfredos - one with chicken and broccoli added - and a garlic cheese bread. There was no sauce on either dish, and the garlic bread was an undercooked half of a cheese pizza with a cup of cold marinara. The Uber Eats driver got the food to us in about 6 minutes, so the quality was not their fault. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Fettuccine Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

See all

First trip to Colorado! Just finished snowboarding and skiing at keystone resort and our group is super hungry! We found Scrappy's pizza, less than 10min away! We were immediately greeted and attended to! Currently drinking a nice cold mountain time beer and about to indulge on this margaritaville pizza!! Yummm! Stop by if you're in the area for some fresh delish pizza and good customer service! read more

See all

We stopped in before heading to Sapphire Point at Dillon Lake. They did not disappoint! Instead off marinara, we went with the garlic and olive oil on our meatball and onion pizza. Every part of the pizza was perfect. We had garlic cheese bread as well and saved some of that for later. The delivery van is in the style of Scooby Mystery Machine read more

Amazing food all around! Highly recommend! Pizza, cheese sticks and wings were great. read more

Second crap pizza from them now! However, I had a philly from their vender stand at a shoe and it was awesome. No more pizza from them though. read more

We really like the pizza here. I've also had their cheese steaks which are very good. So nice to have Scrappys near us in Dillon.

This one hurts, I was torn so I rounded up to 4 stars. The restaurant is awesome. The records and record player available for anyone pick a song (If you are old enough to operate a record player) is awesome. Mystery Machine delivery vehicle, also awesome. The pizza, was super mediocre. Making a pizza at altitude has to be difficult. The family at the table next to us sent a pizza back because it was scorched. We took our pizza to go, drove about one mile to the hotel, and opened our soggy crusted pizza. In all fairness the cooks were trying to figure out the oven temperature, I just wish they had it dialed in before they made our pizza. The sauce was ok, the toppings were pretty good. They are a pretty new business. Maybe they just need a little more time. read more