Ordered out 7 pizzas (all traditional crust) on 7/26/26 for a large group. We have a family member with anaphylactic allergies to peanut and soy protein and the staff that amswered the phone were VERY helpful. We ordered the following pizzas and would definitely recommend all of them:pepperoni, sausage, margherita, veg out, and Peak 6 Traverse (my personal favorite). Delivery was fast, efficient and delivery person was very nice. Highly recommend you order from this pizzeria. I know we will. read more

EXCELLENT. Just had a slice of pepperoni, extra crispy with extra sauce. They cooked it to perfection and their sauce is good. Priced fairly as well. Very satisfied !! read more

The restaurant has really tiny area for bar/indoor seating. Patio is more open. The pizza slice is huge and customizable with a variety of toppings. Old fashioned cocktail was delicious and very well concocted! Didn't expect such a great drink at a pizza joint :) read more

See all

We grabbed a pie for takeout here. Service was quick and friendly but the pizza sauce weirdly tasted of taco seasoning. We didn't order a special pizza just with cheese, peppers and mushrooms. It was okay but I think we'll be looking to try another spot going forward. Convenient location with parking and outdoor seating though. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in Colorado! Their specialty pizzas were really unique with different toppings and the pizza came out piping hot. Service was friendly and it is clear there were a number of locals that stop by this place. We weren't there for happy hour but they had good deals read more

See all

They serve several styles of pizza here as well as some entrees. We ended up going for the deep dish because the place is called Windy City, so we figured hey, we should probably go for the Chicago style pizza. Glad we made this choice because it was actually an exemplary version of the style. The cheese and ingredients were top-notch and the crust was done to absolute perfection. It's a cute little place to sit down and eat, and the staff were super warm and very real. Bravo! read more

Great pizza! Fast service! Just passing through town and it was a great stop for us. I would come back. Delicious!

Small little mountain restaurant with pretty good pizza. Small dining area and a friendly staff. Pizza was pretty good. Kind of bland though. Had to salt, and red pepper the slices to bring out some flavor. The crust is GREAT though!! We got the thin crust and I was extremely happy with it!! Salad was good. Price was good read more

See all

Carrie out pizza 1/2 ham,onion,pepper1/2 pepperon, mushrooms regular crust not thin. 3/4 ham, onion,pepper. Crust paper thin basically fell apart. Worst pizza ever threw 3/4 out read more

Potentially the worst pizza I think I have ever had. Absolutely terrible. Barely cooked pizza. Super soggy. Barely cooked crust. Shame on your for suggesting this is anything close to ny pizza. Come on now. Don't bother with this place and definitely don't order the bruschetta that comes in a blob in tin foil. Wish I could rate you zero stars. Should've just got the frozen pizza at target. read more

Windy City Pizza Silverthorne - Mystery. Bruschetta in a blob In foil. - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

The stuffed pizza was awesome, well portioned and delicious! Service was also excellent very quick and friendly!

The pizza was out of this world and the service was amazing. Everyone was kind and the food didn't take long at all. My 2 year old was very thankful! read more

Don't do it!!!!! Honestly, I love this place. Only because it hires locals. But the food is terrible!!! Clearly there is No over site or accountability with the ownership in YEARS!! (As a 20 year veteran, who simply just wants to give them a chance ) It's a mountain pizza that taste like pabs blue ribbon mixed with a soft stale sock... but with cheese and dirty mop water smell... ordered it from a delivery service and it'll taste like everything I just said but cold and soggy.... Go to City market and get a frozen pizza! Seriously! Do better summit county zaa read more

Servers were great up until the end. When I order the last beer, they forgot to bring it. I requested to bring my last beer with an tip of 10 usd because of the great service. I waited for 10 min and the beer didn't come. I went inside to ask for my beer and the server was really terrible. Asking me if I wanted another beer, I told him I already paid for it, he raised his voice and then he started talking to me in Spanish as if I didn't understand what he was saying in English. The racist shit i have ever experienced since I been here in Colorado, 6 years already. Do not go to this place if you are Latin and you are visiting Silverthorne. read more

Great pizza and happy hour. Met some friendly locals each time I went and the staff is great!

A regular stop for us every year traveling from Denver to our vacation spot in Parshall. When you can get reheated pizza slices to go, and it's great.... You know you have a winner read more

Windy City Pizza Silverthorne - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Love Windy City for a good earthy pizza. We typically take out ... so won't comment on anything other than the pie. Expensive but what is these days? read more

We ordered a pizza and caprese salad delivered to our hotel room. It arrived early and everything was fresh and fantastic!

We got pizza to pick up and enjoyed it in our Airbnb near by. We got wings, pizzas, and the mozzarella rolls. First, the mozzarella rolls were delicious. The roll was soft but filled with a ton of cheese and I like how the cheese on the outside did get a bit crispy. The wings were also good. Lots of sauce. The pizza was pretty basic pizza but good! read more

Definitely make this part of your stop! We were starving on the way to steamboat and stopped in with a fairly large group. They were able to seat us right away. We ordered at the counter and it wasn't long before we were enjoying the delicious food. We started with a salad then had a slice of cheese pizza as well as garlic knots. Everything was delicious. The sweet sauce on the pizza was an unexpected surprise. I enjoyed every bite! read more

Windy City Pizza Silverthorne - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

See all

Pizza good. Chicken parm sucks. Crappy sauce and just one cutlet with mostly soggy pasta. read more

Windy City Pizza Silverthorne - Lame chicken parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Our new favorite stop when we are travel across Colorado! The mozzarella rollups add bacon are the best for road food. read more

See all

Need a warm hug!? This place gives off all those feels. The food & staff are amazing. They seem like more of a family then a place of work. You will feel the love in the food. So fresh! So delicious! I highly recommend the meatballs, wings & deep dish. Much love at Windy City Pizza! read more

They don't cook the pizza long enough. We get the thin crust and even it is very "doughy". We had pizza delivered tonight and the box was smashed into the pizza. We had to pick the paper from the box out of the cheese. They just don't seem to care about quality all the way around read more

See all

Just stopped In while our car was charging and it was phenomenal. One of the best pizzas I've had in a while. Staff was kind and the chill, laid back ambiance was great. read more

We didnt get the pizza. This review is for the salads and the pastas. Really pricey for really terrible pasta and salads. Maybe their pizzas are good but we were disappointed with their non-pizza items. Pastas were bland, overcooked and the kids plain pasta was overcooked, dry and burnt. No seasoning, no oil or butter. For almost $10. Perhaps you'll have better luck with the pizzas but avoid other parts of the menu. read more

This is really good pizza. Got the Send the meat and the Peak 6 Traverse. One poor patron was stuck eating a glutton free pizza. She said the pizza was good and crust was good but a little underdone. Service was unique. Got the feeling they couldn't care less if we ate there or not. Send the Meat won the day read more

Windy City Pizza Silverthorne - Who wouldn't admire the cheese work? - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Great pizza, but i've never waited longer for a pizza delivery especially for being only a mile and a half away.

I just moved to Silverthorne from the DC area. I have been fortunate to try great pizza across the country. So wow, what a surprise Windy City Pizza was. You would not know it from the outside of the establishment, but it hides what is probably the best Chicago style pizza I have ever had. A perfect blend of sweet and tangy sauce, abundant cheese and an outstanding crust. It will be my new go to! read more

This pizza is very good. Bummed I'm only just finding it after coming up to the area so often. The wings are done well too- very crispy.

Excellent food! Everything looked so good that we wait to go back and try something else.

Great thin crust slices! Awesome lunch stop in Silverthorne. Good wings also! Great value , on the cheaper side for lunch.

The pizza we had was nicely cooked, the crust was crispy, and it had good flavor. We took it to go, which make it better because their space is pretty small, but the staff was nice and they took care of us. read more

Best pizza in Summit County. Service was excellent. I had a beer on tap from the bar and chatted with the crew there who were really friendly. I will definitely go back. No much ambiance, but the pizza's so delicious you won't even notice. read more

Uhm not the greatest. I ordered wings and a large pizza. Half pepperoni half sausage with mushrooms. The flavor on the pizza was not very flavorful. The wings were spicy but needed to be more crispy. Not my favorite place. read more

Decent thin crust pizza. Great salads. Picked up food and it was quick! Fresh and flavorful too!

Disappointed. Paid $40 for pizza & it doesn't have sauce. Go somewhere else, I'm local & this was sad. read more

Windy City Pizza Silverthorne - Pizza that they forgot the sauce on...What's the point? Don't waste your time - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

Pizza was great- much better than expected. We opted for a thin "Peak 6 Traverse" pizza. Great crust, great sauce, great ingredients, good waitstaff. We also had some mozzarella rolls with marinara sauce as a backup plan - but they were great too!There are a few outside tables, and a few inside tables. Like most pizza places, they obviously rely on pickup and delivery. Ambiance is minimal, and on this 85 degree summer day, it was very warm inside. We opted to eat inside because of Canadian smoke in the air. Far better pizza than I expected in a touristy ski town. I'd probably give it 4 stars in Denver, but it was very good and an unexpected treat. read more

We did takeout here last night. Friendly service and order ready in 30 minutes. We got the white room pizza on thin crust. It didn't seem like thin, more like regular crust. Still, pizza was good. Pepperoni rolls were just amazing!! Must order these when you stop in. Also got some garlic Parmesan wings that were very overdone. The meat was completely dried out. The seasoning was good, I think we just got a bad batch. read more

This little pizza joint surprised me! We got the garlic knots and the cold smoke pizza - and wow! Delicious! All of the other dishes that came out also looked amazing! I'm so glad we stoped here before we head back to Denver! The staff were also very nice read more