Wonderful night in ski town. We ordered the Krewe and the Southern Belle (one with white sauce, one with traditional red). Both were wonderful in their own unique ways. Service was great and efficient. I dropped my wine glass ): and they were so quick to clean up and replace it. I'm a bit of a pizza fanatic but this exceeded my expectations. Great wine, great pizza, great service. read more

Rotolo's Craft & Crust - Pizza Near Me - Keystone, Colorado

See all

The food is average. What you would expect. The reason why I gave them two stars is specifically for their customer service and their lack of quality associated with communicating when someone walks in to ask for a table. On four different occasions, no one asked us if we wanted a table and we felt like we were intruding on their personal conversation to be waited on. During our meal if we stopped our waitress, she would just say what do you want? So the service there is extremely low class. On two occasions, my husband had a guy's party at Keystone and they walked into the restaurant. No one greeted them. They waited for quite some time and gave up and left. So hey Owner, if you're reading this, your staff is not welcoming and also makes you feel like you are inconveniencing them asking for them to wait on you. There are a lot of restaurants in Keystone and my suggestion is to avoid this one. read more

Great food Good service Clean The prices were a bit up there but the ambiance was worth it I would recommend it read more

There is nothing...nothing...that ends a day of shredding better than pizza and beer. On that vibe, Rotolo's is your stop after a day at Keystone. Small, lively, and a decent volume level, it's the perfect place to come down after a hard day on the slops. They have FANTASTIC pizza and other entrée choices to make everyone happy. Their drink choices are superb, and they pour a LOT of margaritas here. For the win: Start with a Mexican Cocoa or margarita for aprés, smash a Big Apple and The OG, and wash it down with a local craft. Good luck making first chair the next morning. read more

See all

Service was quite abysmal. We never got water and it took them about 20 minutes to just greet us. However, the pizza was quite delicious, especially the ricotta one! read more

I was very apprehensive about this place as it was the only post ski dining without an hour wait (In retrospect I think that's because 1- most people ordered out and 2- it's a wee bit farther from all the action) I did a major eye roll at the $5 up charge for cauliflower crust pizza but was starving so rolled with it. I was not disappointed! Like at all. This was one of the best (hopefully) gluten free pizzas I have ever had. Even my daughter gave it two very enthusiastic thumbs up. Given the prices, I was a bit surprised by the portion of the chicken fingers but hey- this was one of the busiest Fridays I have ever seen in my life skiing Keystone so- given that fact- I think I am more surprised that the food came out at all, let alone quickly, and that everyone left full and happy... I have to go ahead and highly recommend this place (4 stars because for the prices... I can't say this was a five out of five place but I will still Come back if every post skiing I am craving pizza) read more

See all

Service is terrible. Bartenders are burnouts with attitudes and not worth spending any money there. Not surprising for a village restaurant but there are still better places to go with better food and better service. read more

Rude waitress. Slow service. We were forced to pay on a kiosk and tip minimum of 22%.

they don't got pineapple. and now i'm sad the service was good tho. characterlimitcharacterlimitcharacterlimig read more

Rotolo's Craft & Crust - The boy - Pizza Near Me - Keystone, Colorado

Great pizza, great service, awesome IPA. Would recommend you make a pitstop here when you're in Keystone and order the Big Apple pizza. read more

Rotolo's Craft & Crust - Big Apple Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keystone, Colorado

The Angry Pig pizza was amazing. Great service at the bar as well. Good beer options.

Good drinks, good vibes, good service. Not overly expensive and I'm sure good pizza. Close to the ski runs.

Friendly, attentive staff. Quick family friendly meal. Truffle fries were delicious. Pretty affordable too for a ski town.

After a couple hours on the slopes with some small children, this spot was amazing. The hot chocolate was probably the richest and most decadent that I've had in a while. It's a little bit closer to the base than the other pizza place. So overall the food, the service and proximity to the base and the standout hot chocolate would definitely bring me back. read more

See all

The pizza was first class. We have been talking about it since we left. We got two pizzas for the three of us boys and there could have been a slice or two left but we prevailed. When it was time to order and when it was time to pay our waiter was hard to find, I think that's just the way it is in Colorado. Thank god they had a self serve water table. I will say that if you like your pizza hot and taking your time, sit inside. The pizza was too hot to eat when we got it and basically refrigerated by the time we were done. It was 45 outside. read more

Amazing quality service they really helped me out with everything I need and everyone was very friendly and knowledgeable. I could not ask for a better bar read more

Delicious Pizza and strong cocktails just a few steps from the slopes at River Run. The Big Apple pizza was my fav, and the whipped ricotta cheese was outstanding. The crust was crispy and all the ingredients seemed fresh. Service was excellent, our waiter was kind and funny too. Service was slow from a New Yorker's point of view, but was probably on par for mountain area restaurants. Our friends enjoyed their Deluxe combination pizza. Ambiance was standard, but we chose this place because of the abundant outdoor seating outside in the bright sunshine. read more

See all

Great drinks and better service! Thank you, Lucas! The restaurant was clean and had a solid music selection

Great pizza and salads, especially for a place at a ski resort. Service was quick and friendly.

Rotolo's is our favorite stop on the mountain. Their Boudin fries and $5 margaritas are incredible! Staff is kind and the service is wonderful. read more

Best happy hour in Keystone. Great food, drinks and atmosphere especially after a long day on the slopes

Good Caesar salad and the pizzas were pretty good but pretty floppy. Still, the options are good and they are generous with toppings. Super nice staff too. read more

Great service and great food. A good place for families. kids ordered a pizza and mac & cheese. Older son and I ordered the Smashburger and my husband ordered the Mac & cheese pie. read more

We got take out from Rotolos, and it was decent. The pizza was definitely not the best we've ever had, and the worst part was that we ordered a large Caesar salad but it was plain. They didn't put any dressing on it or include it at all. So we did have to call them but they were very helpful and met us halfway to give us it. Not exactly the best experience. But normally we dine in and the food is top notch! So maybe it was just unfortunate, but we didn't have the best experience. read more

This spot is unbelievable! Great vibes at Rotolo's. Alysha is the best ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Busy, thriving place! Lots of great food options for respite from the cold day outside, thank you!

We LOVE Rotolo's. We live nearby and often take pizza to go. It is so to have a restaurant in whose pizza is not 50% crust. They have several different unusual offerings, the sauces are flavorful, and the pizza is always fresh and hot! They also have several other entrees that you can take home, and everything we have ordered has been delicious. Another nice thing about Rotolo's is they do not close during shoulder/mud season like so many other restaurants that must think no one lives here! We hope they are around for many years! read more

Great pizza, excellent service. $5 margs are the best. The guy behind the bar in the flannel was great

Great Bacon Mac and Cheese, and the hot chocolate is phenomenal! Can't beat the $5 margaritas, either. Service was impeccable by Robert. Gen X friendly playlist is appreciated :) read more

Excellent sauce, crispy crust, great staff. Would highly recommend visiting here. Jfkdkdndnxicjjfnebdbc

Amazing pizza! We had a big group and got 5 different pizzas, all of which were delicious. I'd recommend the Big Apple or the Italian Club pizzas *chef's kiss* Also, as mentioned, we had a big group but got seated immediately despite it being 6pm on Saturday in a mountain town! Our waiter was so funny and nice, and he was very on top of service. Definitely go here if you're staying in Keystone or looking for some grub before hitting the road. read more

Pizza is good, hits the spot and a short walk from the slopes. Great beer selection at reasonable prices. One pizza serves about 2 comfortably. This I would define as "artisan" pizza, like a thin crust light on cheese but loaded with toppings. Crust cooked to perfection. Good vibes & good service. We went at noon and there was lots of open tables. read more

Rotolo's Craft & Crust - The OG - Pizza Near Me - Keystone, Colorado

See all

Stopped in here for lunch and we loved it. Pizza was insanely good and the server was super nice. We also got a gumbo which was tasty and a salad. Definitely give them a try! read more

Rachel and Jeremiah are the best! They checked in on us often and were super friendly! $5 Margs are also

Stuff is nice enough, but the food isn't that great for what you pay. The chicken strips were good. Pizza sauce is kind of weird.

Great service and good food. We'll definitely be back next time I come to Keystone! The cheese fries were amazing!

Willy was an a true Keystone saint. He helped my friends and I have the best time on our ski trip. The food and drinks were solid. Rotolo's won't disappoint and don't forget to ask for Willy! read more

Wow! We literally only came here for a beer and not only was that a great decision due to their selection but the spinach artichoke dip was actually incredible. Had a nice table outside, the waitress was super attentive, really great place read more

Great food, great service and great environment! Baked Mac was great and the pizza had a great crunch to it! Would make for a perfect spot after a long day of skiing if it were winter! read more

Pizza was alright. I wouldn't go again but it was a nice experience just the pizza didn't really have a flavor that separated it from a concession stand pizza. read more