This one hurts, I was torn so I rounded up to 4 stars. The restaurant is awesome. The records and record player available for anyone pick a song (If you are old enough to operate a record player) is awesome. Mystery Machine delivery vehicle, also awesome. The pizza, was super mediocre. Making a pizza at altitude has to be difficult. The family at the table next to us sent a pizza back because it was scorched. We took our pizza to go, drove about one mile to the hotel, and opened our soggy crusted pizza. In all fairness the cooks were trying to figure out the oven temperature, I just wish they had it dialed in before they made our pizza. The sauce was ok, the toppings were pretty good. They are a pretty new business. Maybe they just need a little more time. read more

Great pizza place in Dillon! Laid back vibes, great pizza, good beers on tap, all at a great price - 5 stars!

Love this place. Great environment and great food. We'll stop in every time we're in the mountains.

Three stars is being generous. Like others I wanted this place to be good. I waited about 6 weeks for them to get there business in order before ordering and judging there pie. Also the prices are so high that I was hesitant to even try it. I WILL pay a premium for a pie that is worth it but I had a feeling that this wouldn't be and unfortunately I was right. I ordered a large with Pep, Sausage, Onion and Olive. I should have taken a photo but I was so sad I didn't even think to do it. The topping amount was ridiculously weak, maybe one to two peps per slice and that goes par for the course with the entire topping amounts. Hardly any toppings at all. For 30 plus dollars I want that shit piled on. The cheese was also terrible, not enough and no flavor and the sauce also was nothing to talk about. No FLAVOR. Flavor is everything and this pizza had none. Also.. I like a little burn on my crust but the bottom was straight burnt, my lady disliked it much more that me. She wouldn't even eat it due to the flavor of excessive carbon. So sad to see. I love and want to support a local business but with these prices and this quality I'd rather pay a fraction of the price and get a Brooklyn style pie from Dominos only because them and Pizza Hut are the only other pizza places that will deliver to Dillon. I know people will read this and judge. Just know I have worked in 12 different pizza places in my life and have worked in fine dining as well as casual and gastropub restaurants for many years. I know pizza and food and was a head chef at my last 3 restaurants. Thanks for reading. I hope they do some more testing and get this right. I will try again in 6 months. read more

We stopped by because we visited it several years ago. Great thin crust pizza. Good service. Good selection of beer on tap.

Not good, took forever and not worth it. Wish there was other options for pizza in Dillon

I don't write a lot of yelp reviews, but this was so bad I felt like I needed to. If I could give it zero stars I would. Now, we all know that summit county isn't exactly famous for its pizza shops, but this just might be the worst pizza I've ever eaten in my entire life. Literally. I was actually amazed and surprised at how bad it actually was. I just felt like I had to try it because I have lived here for years and want to try all the new restaurants. Do not waste your money at this place. I absolutely can not believe that someone who runs this place took a bite out of that pizza and was like ya let's sell this to people! Every part of it was horrible. The crust, there was barely any sauce on it, the cheese was greasy and not good at all. I ate three slices and threw the rest in the trash. I will never go back. Horrible place. Don't ever go! read more

Dang it. Really wanted to like this place by alas..... We ordered simple just to check it out --hubs had Philly.cheese steak which was pretty good, flavor-wise but insanely small for a $15 sandwich I got chicken tendies --I asked for extra wing sauce but for some reason you can't get extra (weird). The chicken was nice and moist but under-sauced, and the thing called blue cheese sauce that came with it was just weird, kinda like Mayo with some blue cheese chunks. Also way over priced at $13 I get it on the prices--chickens. Way up, all good costs are way up, hard to get people to work in summit, but these prices not justified by the food Bummer. read more

Honestly some of the best Hawaiian pizza I've ever had so yummy. The manager was also really nice and was on top of updating us on how many more minutes our pizza needed to be cooked read more

Amazing pizza and amazing staff. I love this place. It's my go-to pizza place when I leave Leadville. Rae saved my life.

Unfortunately our order was inedible and I have been waiting over a month for a promised refund. We asked for no chicken on the pizza and it came with chicken. The person who ordered the food is a vegetarian and could not eat the pizza. We ordered a Caesar salad for another vegetarian person but the Caesar salad never came. The mozzarella sticks were empty with no cheese. The order took almost 2 hours to get delivered. I called the restaurant to let them know of the mistakes and no apology was given or yet to be given despite multiple communications. They blamed Uber eats. Their inability to hold themselves accountable is disrespectful and shameful. Do not recommend. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Empty mozz sticks - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Great pizza and super friendly owner. Prices are a little on the high side for pizza but it's a ski town so the prices are high everywhere unless you want chain pizza that isn't as good. read more

Pizza was delicious, crispy and fresh. Great service and pleasant bartender! Would come back for sure read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

They waited until 10 minutes after we arrived to pick up our 4 pizzas to even START them. Others walking in after us are encountering the same issue. It is now 40 minutes after our set pick up time and only 2 of our pizzas are cooked. read more

We are in Keystone and it's impossible to get food in Keystone. Scrappy's is 10 mins away and worth the drive. It was fast. Great food. Great service. The staff was very helpful. 5 stars!! read more

This place will be everyone's favorite pizza place someday! They not only have amazing delicious pizza, but they also include the best gluten free crust and vegan cheese option pizzas! As someone with lots of dietary restrictions, my server, Jay, did a fantastic job helping me navigate a perfect order. But the real best part of my friends and I's experience was the free foosball table open to everyone! Additionally, there was a Pac-Man game and a huge chalk board for anyone to draw on! read more

First night in town and struggled to find a pizza spot that wasn't packed. Scrappys was our last option but ended up being the best option for our night. The service was phenomenal. MUST ORDER THE OLD BAY HONEY WINGS. These wings were hands down the tastiest blend of sweet, heat, and overall flavor. The group I went with can be a little critical and we loved these wings. The pizza was delicious too but if it's not personally your thing get these wings!!!! read more

We can not recommend this place. The guys were not very friendly until we were about to leave. My husband and I ordered sandwiches. The bread was so tough we could barely bite into it. Possibly microwaved? Even though we were eating in, they were served wrapped in foil and were very messy to eat. The beers were served in dirty glasses. Not worth the $50 we just spent! I don't usually leave reviews but I felt this deserved it. read more

Overall an amazing experienc, and a very clean and friendly environmen. the guy behind the guy was super nice too.

Decided to try this new place out for staff and was very happy. Great NY style pizza. Flavorful and super large pizzas. Will order from again. read more

See all

We are from Alabama where grease, butter, and spices rule the kitchen! The pizza is average. the crust is average. the wings are excellent (Cajun dry rub). The meatball sub is average, and the meatballs are under seasoned. The toasted ravioli was cheese filled( surprised us). For $11, there should be more than 6 raviolis! The ranch reminds us of store bought ranch and is nothing special. When we ordered they told us the total was $101 and when they delivered it was $122. For 12 raviolis, two lg pizzas, 10 wings and 1 meatball sub is ridiculous! That would be under $60 at Domino's. The red sauce is nothing special! The white sauce was not flavorful. The delivery man was very nice and deserved the tip. We would order again just to try other foods! Good Luck! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Hamburger and Canadian bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

Omg, perfect find for getting our bellies happy after a day of skiing! Super nice staff! Amazing crust! Great pizza! And Stevie Ray Vaughan on the stereo! What could be better? We will be back!! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Crust perfection!!! - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

When classic mountain bar with delicious pizza and amazing staff comes to mind, this place has all of this and more. They have live music and an outdoor patio as well. What really gives this place 5 stars is the staff. They're so friendly and accommodating, they truly made me and my group feel welcome. It's the perfect place to grab a beer or a slice, especially before or after catching a show at the gorgeous Dillon Ampitheater. read more

Never got to taste the food. Ordered for delivery. The girl on the phone asked my address but no name and no phone number. Waited an hour and half to call back and they had it sitting there for pick up. No call no nothing. My dinner is ruined. I tried to support a new business during COVID and learned my lesson. read more

I have respect for a new business that started during COVID.. however my experiences have been subpar. The first time we ordered the tree hugger pizza and all the toppings made it heavy and wet. The second time we ordered a cheese pizza and the Scalia sandwich. Pizza was a little burnt on the bottom, didn't mind that so much but the sandwich was TINY for $14. Both times employees we went for pick up, employees had masks around their chins or not on. Additionally the staff member had bare hand contact with ready to eat food while making our sandwich in between using his cell phone which is just not cool. read more

See all

We Really, Really want scrappys to be successful!!! Great concept, and we can tell that they have the potential to be great (hoping they read and consider feedback). We really want a great replacement for Jersey boys! We called at 5:45 hoping for 1.5 hour delivery... delivery was at 2.5 hours so opted for pickup. Food was ready- everyone inside was super nice but seemed overwhelmed with the large amount of orders. Picked up 6:40. Wings were ok. Juicy but a bit slimy (we prefer juicy And crispy). They totally forgot the ranch that came with it (despite confirming at time of order that 2 cups per order would be plenty). Fries were undercooked ( al dente) but has potential if cooked well. Meatball app was ok but 2/3 were burned. Apps approx 2+ stars). Chicken Philly Cheesestake was amazing. Great flavor, a little light on cheese but overall 4 stars. Buffalo Chicken pizza very good flavor (ranch drizzle had great dill notes), had potential to be 5 stars but pieces were overcooked and burned. Scalia pizza had such great potential and flavor!!! Ours was a little underdone (gummy crust), but such great flavors so 4 stars! We are so hoping that quality and consistency gets better as they get their legs under them- we will Try again! read more

In town for a show and stopped by Scrappys afterwards and super happy I did. Incredibly nice staff, awesome food and drink and of course, Scrappy, cool ass dog. read more

Should highly consider renaming this to Crappy's pizza. Sat for 45 minutes beyond the time order was supposed to be done. 3 pizzas sat ready while one was forgotten. So 3 sat getting old why one cooked. Horrible. No recognition on how bad this is. Plus ordered 2 gluten free for bad celiac, no way it is safe. Owner told me "you don't order from a pizza place ever if you have celiac." Also said "you don't order gluten free over the internet" Clearly ownership will be short lived. Refunded my money and took pizza away. Opps.... Bring back the old place, they were great owners. Real shame. Live read more

Really great pies and staff! Will definitely be coming back every time I'm in the area. Mushroom pepperoni was fantastic :)

Disgusting, got an inedible pizza delivered via uber eats and it was so not worth the wait read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Why would you even be comfortable sending this out the door? - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

See all

Like other reviews the pizza was burnt and about half was not edible... hopefully this is just growing pains and not a regular occurrence.

Incredibly great pizza! Go for it! Lindsay will take great care of you even with the COVID staff shortages.

I was heading back to Denver and wanted to stop and hit the Silverthorne outlets and was craving some wings after--I had the wings, Philly cheesesteak, and a beer and it totally hit the spot. I will definitely stop by again on my next trip through! read more

We stopped here only to use the restroom but as soon as we walked in we could smell the pizza and knew we had to get a slice or 2. The pizza was amazing!!! So was the staff the helped us find a perfect place for pictures and were very friendly! I really enjoyed this pizza place! read more

best pizza in summit!! we got the supreme and the buff chick and both were amazing!! cheese and veggies both tasted fresh. New spot for the family for sure!! read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Supreme and buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado

So glad that there is still great pizza in Dillon. Have to get my New York pizza fix somehow. What's really cool is that this authentic recipe is preserved in Colorado, while New York forgets how to make real pizza. Thanks guys... read more

OMG!!! The Philly Cheese Steak was one to be reckoned with. Very impressive. The green peppers and onion, and baguette where so fresh and so clean! I will be back. The staff was super friendly and sweet. Thanks ya'll! read more

The food here is the bomb! They have awesome apres ski food that soothes the soul! They have a good beer selection too. If you don't like the booze selection there is a good liquor store next store. read more

This place is great! The owner and staff are super friendly, and the pizza is fantastic! My buddies and I were blown away. It's a cozy little place, has good beer, and cool vinyls that you can play, We're going back again this week. read more

Best new pizza place in Summit County, bar none. Great food, great people, great atmosphere: all the ingredients for a killer new restaurant. Highly recommend their New Haven style pizza and sweet cocktails. read more

Scrappy's Pizza - Bubbles and I love the new best pizza place in Summit County, @scrappyspizza. - Pizza Near Me - Dillon, Colorado