New owner pledged to keep the pizzas the same. Sadly that didn't happen. It was hit or miss with…read morethe new owner. Not really bad but not as good as we were used to. We had to move on.

Pretty sure this place closed... been trying to call for a couple weeks. My daughter used to love…read morethis place. She ordered a pizza a while back and she got someone else's pizza with sausage and veggies froze it to return it but at this point it's a waste of space. Been calling to replace and never got an answer from the number again.. Does anyone know if they closed down?

Ordered $50 worth of food which included French Fries and we called to have add some ketchup…read morepackets (they don't have condiments), the delivery driver comes and doesn't have a pen to sign off and tip him. Oh oh.... the order also included a $15 salad and no forks Come on...

Everytime I've been to John's has been amazing for pizza ! Thank you!…read more Chunk sausage and pepperonis !

The last time I was here there was flies everywhere. It was so nasty. I understand sometimes these…read morethings happen, but just the way it felt... I'm going to be honest this restaurant is dirty. There may not be a sink in there possibly. No one uses gloves, ever. The thin crust pizza taste ok and sometimes the wings too, but when you pay attention to what's going on it makes you kind of sick. It's a small place so it's not like they are hiding anything.

Very good pizza, always fresh and hot, authentic taste. Order is always accurate. Pick up or…read moredelivery available.

Brings back nostalgia from 1970s For me " Always very good Pizza Wonderful staff " Thanks Nicole…read more& Bob " see ya again soon "

Horrible people. Below average food. Got called out on Facebook for a pizza that looked less than…read moredesirable, rather than apologizing or offering to make it right, they decide to blame the customer for his "photo skills". And then they go online and leave 1 star reviews to an establishment they've never been to! Petty owners, bad food. Go literally anywhere else. I suggest Langels or Arrenellos.

i have been a loyal customer for 50 years, i am probably one of the oldest customers here. this…read moreplace used to be Pizza Go on 169th, then King of Pizza on 169th, then Key Pizza on 169th next to Drift Inn Liquors, Stanley Family were the owners then, then Key Pizza moved to the old KFC building on Kennedy ave. I have eaten this pizza for a long time and I will tell you that the place has changed ownership many times but the taste is still the same today as in the past in 1975, I used to order the stuffed crust sausage and ground pepperoni back in 1977 and used to eat it on on the stairs of the old Morton High School building steps on marshall st. on a Friday night as i remember back in August cause it was 85 degrees at night, ill never forget my cat snowball came out to visit me at the Morton building stairs, we lived across the street and I shared my pizza with my cat snowball, we ate the delicious stuffed crust and both went home together and cut through the neighbors yard, a memory ill have forever, my cat also loved Key pizza, enough of the nostalgia, lets fast forward to 2025 and the pizza tastes the same, original recipes and ingredients, thanks for keeping this Hessville Icon alive.

This place has always been a great pizza place for a family gathering. I like the pepperoni pizzaread more

We Love Bartons Pizza!! We usually order the family size…read morechunk sausage & pepperoni pizza special. The workers are always so friendly and the pizza is always delicious. We highly recommend this place and check out their daily specials.

2025 And Bartons has reverted to average lackluster cheaped…read moreout on ingredients Bait and switch! You were supposed to be the chosen one! Rip off

First time here , I wanted to try something new I usually go to Casey's or Jets if I'm out that way…read morebut I went to this place and got the capri special, first off I didn't even taste the meat I saw pepperoni and sausage but didn't taste it all I could taste was the overwhelming watery flavor of the greenpeppers and onions overtaking my pizza , the crust was subpar it tasted like there was no sauce just hella cheese. I only got a small which was overly priced at $22 dollars and I will not be back for more . It's better pizza for this ridiculous price .

Very erratic hours here. Door and internet shows hours until 10p. Just tried visiting and all…read morechairs are up and told dining room is closed at 9:10p. Boo!

I was wondering what to eat and came across this joint. I had a good feeling about it…read more My significant other and I walked inside and unfortunately table service wasn't offered. I looked at the menu on the wall. There was a sign that stated 4% Higher with CRedit CArD . I looked at the menu the arrow pointed to. I went to the counter to order. The PIZZA section stated Our Pizzas are Hand Tossed to give you that Personal Touch! We went with a SMALL Cheese Pizza for $10.92. From the FRIED FOODS section, we got Cheese Curds for $6.24. From the same section, we got Mushrooms for $6.24. From the SIDE ORDERS section, we got Garlic Bread for $3.12. We sat at a table while we waited. Our order was ready fast. I was given a free menu, so that was cool. I was excited to try everything. All we had to do was get back to our place. We were given a free red sauce and a free ranch. The Cheese Pizza was beautiful. Every bite was delicious. The Cheese Curds were decent. With the red sauce, they were better. With the ranch, they were awesome. The Mushrooms were okay. With the red sauce, they were a little better. With the ranch, they were tasty. The Garlic Bread had a nice flavor. I enjoyed it. The service was great. I didn't have any issues. Overall, this joint was a successful stop. I'm glad I tried it out. Date of visit: 06/06/2025

Love the Wednesday pizza discount pricing. So much so cheese on their yummy pizza. Always friendly…read moreservice too.