We Love Bartons Pizza!! We usually order the family size chunk sausage & pepperoni pizza special. The workers are always so friendly and the pizza is always delicious. We highly recommend this place and check out their daily specials. read more

2025 And Bartons has reverted to average lackluster cheaped out on ingredients Bait and switch! You were supposed to be the chosen one! Rip off read more

Been going to this Barton's here for several years! Nothing but great experiences for over 30 years! Don't go as much as I would like only because I deliver pizza last 8 years for over 20 places so free can't be beat! But as far as this Barton's for quality and price you're not going to beat that anywhere and they always got good specials all the time!!! read more

As good as your pizza is, the people who work at the Hammond location are even better: always friendly, and happy to see you. Never a bad experience that keeps me coming back and I am sure a lot of other customers too! read more

I went to Barton's last year and ordered a Large sausage, Mushroom and Pepperoni pizza. I took a few bites and thought my goodness! This tastes exactly like Leanardo's Pizza used to taste......later one of the workers confirmed that their Uncle Leanardo taught them how to make pizza. I was blown away that my taste buds knew that it was Leanardo's Pizza. So if you miss Leanardo's Pizza the classic Leanardo's then you have to Come to Barton's Pizza because it's the same pizza. It's really a take out restaurant but I think they have a few tables and an arcade game you can play if you like. read more

Hometown food from a local spot that's a mom n pop shop I will always eat there great service

First of all, this is my favorite Northwest Indiana pizza. I have tried all of the staples in the region and I always go back to Barton's. I just wanted to pep up the store for their awesome service tonight. Being the Super Bowl, I fully expected a delivery time of 1.5-2hours. I placed my order at 6pm. I was told "we will get it to you as soon as we can". It got here at 6:52. I am seriously impressed by this on one of the busiest nights of the year for a pizza place. read more

Barton's has been an average locally owned staple in the NWI pizza scene for decades. Staff is always reasonably friendly when I come to pick up my order.  The crust is thin on the bottom but has a nice holdable edge, not that pizza on a cracker nonsense that many local joints serve. The sausage is crumbled. That doesn't seem like a big deal but if you're not expecting tiny ground sausage it can be a bit odd. But power through the hesitation and you will be rewarded! In fact, you will wonder why everyone doesn't serve ground sausage. Is it amazing groundbreaking not-to-be-missed pizza? No. But Barton's is a much-loved staple in our pizza rotation. Give it a try if you're in the market for decent pizza at a decent price. read more

Barton's Pizzeria - the menu - Pizza Near Me - Hammond, Indiana

I ordered a pizza and some pretzel balls and the food was amazing. Even after driving 25 minutes home, the food was still warm. Barton's Pizza is one of my favorite pizza's ever, please open up somewhere near Crown Point!! The crumble sausage is probably the best in the area and the crust is so amazing. Hands down Barton's is in my top 5 all time favorite pizzas!! read more

Timeless in the Region area. Any crust with a crunch really does it for me. Great for ordering for large groups or family!!

Never. Again. Highland/Griffith location. Worst customer service. Don't dare tell them they were wrong when you don't get what you paid for. Don't bother to call. They're beyond rude, will tell you you're wrong and just hang up on you. Seems like their standard excuse for bad behavior, getting your order wrong is "We're busy. It's dinner rush. It was a simple mistake, you should drive all the way back to pick up what we failed to give you, not complain that we ruined your dinner because you had to come back to fix our mistake. Not our fault your pizza is cold now because you had to fix our mistake." Never. Again. After more than 40 years of giving them business? Nope. read more

Customer service is a joke. I ordered again against my better judgements and won't make that mistake again. I can't eat jalapeños and ordered the beef sandwich pizza. 40 with tip. Open it and it's covered in jalapeños. I call and tell them, their reply is "sorry I can't do anything about that". Long day of work and yet to eat. Guess I'll eat tomorrow. I just wanted a replacement but now I want my money back. Never eat their, you're not valued by then at all. Ty for the wonderful experience bartons. read more

If this review were only about the quality of the pizza, I would give 4 starts. Barton's pizza is very good. My favorite topping here is ground beef with extra cheese. The beef is baked under the cheese and makes for a very meaty, cheesy pizza that tastes very good and filling, although a bit greasy and sloppy. It is possible to get a gigantic pizza here that will quite comfortably feed 4 large hungry people, and 5-6 mortals. The downside with Barton's is the delivery. It takes a long time, and although I hate to say negative things about a person, in my latest experience the delivery driver presented absolutely the worst appearance imaginable for a person's appetite... and I'm not usually squeamish or shallow. I do not wish to judge, so I will leave it at that. Next time I want a Barton's pizza I will go pick it up. read more

I tried to order pizza and the employees were rude and obnoxious. Supposed owner called me back and she was also extremely rude and refused to even listen to my side of the story. I get going to bat for your employees, but when your employees are wrong then you need to hear the customer out. I will never go there again (she "banned" me) and I will make sure everyone I know never buys food from there again. Do not call yourself a Christian outfit when you treat others like this. I work in customer service and I be damned if I spoke to customers the way Nicole or her employees did. read more

Have not had a pizza here in YEARS, as i live 2 hours south, but i was thinking about it and will have it again soon! Loved it when it was served at the GRAPEVINE Lounge in Calumet City read more

They used to have the best pizza the crust was like French bread......I've been ordering from them sense they had a north Hammond location 30 years ago.....I think somebody bought it cause I order a pizza from them and the crust changed...it was a plain flat crust and the pizza had no flavor...so I stopped ordering from them.... read more

I ordered two jumbo pizzas for a friends Christmas party that we were going to $51 and pizzas we get the pizzas delivered the kids start eating some of the cheese we start eating some of the sausage and then we noticed that the whole center in on the 1/2 is completely burnt so I called the Store back I speak to a kid named Brandon I asked him if there is a way I can text him the picture so I was able to text him the picture he says he needs to call the owner and have the owner get back to me when he gets a hold of her now I'm thinking OK how long is this going to take till he gets a hold of her because I need a pizza that's not burnt the food was delivered I was quoted at time of 45-60 the pizza didn't get there until 1 hr 30 mins later & it was burnt I was very frustrated so the owner called me back she said it would take over an hour for them to get me a new pizza because they were super busy but I've already paid for my pizza & it's over two hours ago my pizza should've been a priority so they can get it to me and she said I'm just going to refund you your money so The driver came and refunded me my money. I won't ever return to that place I don't know if they have new owners new management maybe even no managers if their employees have to call the owner then they wanted to take an imprint of my credit card which I said no so that's why I paid with cash they said they've had a lot of fraud there well you're not gonna take an imprint of my card because when you run my card you only get the last four numbers on the receipt not my whole card. But to sum it all up owners rude employees don't know what to do they're kind of like a lost read more

Barton's Pizzeria - Burnt crappy pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hammond, Indiana

Consistently good since I was a kid! Excellent pizza and cheesy bread. Always reasonably priced. Region staple!

Poor customer service whoever answered the phone last time I called was very rude, pizza isn't that good either crumbled sausage ? No thanks. read more

Living in Chicago this is my go to for pizza when visiting the region. We always get a sausage pizza and it never disappoints, it's so good I can't bring myself to try anything else. Even reheated my taste buds tingle with excitement. My husband who is from Michigan thinks it's the best he's had since moving to Chicago 20 years ago. My only complaint is they don't deliver to Chicago. haha. read more

I tired the Beef supreme after seeing it in the local paer about beefs of NWI. The sandwich had plenty of beef on it with tons of cheese and pizza sauce.Very tasty indeed. Lol have not tried a pizza from Barton's yet but will soon. read more

Love Barton's. They have the best dough which makes it the best crust. From childhood to adulthood this pizza rocks!

Pizza here is alright. Prices are great, and if you only want a couple of slices they are made fresh not sitting on a turn style under a heat lamp gas station style like some other small pizzerias. Inside is small but they have pinball. Friendly staff is always a plus too. read more

my family and i use to order here every once in a while the prices were good and just recently we were celebrating an engagement and thought it would be a cute way to surprise the family with the pizza saying "she said yes" when we called to ask if they did such thing the worker was very rude , mean and shut it down very quickly. This would of been our first time back here since the new owners, but needless to say from the attitude of there help state line has a new favorite customer! read more

Order taker did not even repeat the order, got the order completely wrong and when I called to complain the manager wanted the old pizza back... Absolutely ridiculous not my fault you cannot take an order correctly. I am also a manager and a pizza place and this would not be acceptable at all. You should have simply corrected the order and sent it out and apologized. No apology and no sincerity. Horrible service. read more